House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was children.

Last in Parliament October 2000, as Reform MP for Calgary Centre (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 1997, with 40% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supply February 11th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I appreciated the comments of the hon. member for Durham. I know that in his professional life he worked a lot in financial situations and accounting and that he is well respected in that field.

I particularly appreciated his comments on the impacts of bracket creep. I was reminded as he was speaking about a recent report from the C.D. Howe Institute that talks about how Canada's personal income tax system has not been adjusted properly for inflation since 1985. As a result more taxpayer income has become effectively subject to tax. For Canadian families this means higher taxes on the average of about $1,000 per family due to bracket creep. I certainly concur with his comments. Now that we are moving into the days of surplus, is it the member's priority that we address this with the surplus money?

We may be saying there are no tax increases but in effect with bracket creep real tax increases are taking place.

Homelessness February 10th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the Liberal government has created a class of working poor in Canada. Many angry Canadians rallied on the Hill today and their message was loud and clear.

Liberal economics are putting Canadian families and individuals out on the street. When will this government admit that it is wrong to tax a family making far less than $20,000 a year? When will this government stop draining our social system of its resources, preventing Canadians from helping those who need help the most?

The Liberal government does not hesitate to give out millions of dollars to Canada's largest corporations but laughs when it comes to relieving the pressure on those in real need.

The Prime Minister has talked to the imaginary homeless but some real homeless people are outside still waiting to talk to him. The Prime Minister's absence was noted and so is the government's inability to implement economic and social programs that will allow every Canadian to have a home.

For a country so rich in resources, only the regressive policies of this Liberal government prevent every Canadian from having their needs met.

Questions On The Order Paper February 3rd, 1999

In all agencies and departments of the federal government in the last three fiscal years, ( a ) how many grants, contributions and/or contracts have been given or committed to the Canadian Coalition for the rights of Children and/or its provincial subsidiaries; ( b ) what are the amounts given, by department, in order that a non-governmental organization (NGO) report on Canada's compliance with the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child as part of Canada's five-year report to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child might be produced; ( c ) what is the amount and purpose of any other grants, contributions or contracts given to the coalition by department(s) which contributed funding, and by type of grant; ( d ) when were the above grants, contributions or contracts given; ( e ) what other organizations were considered to receive funding to produce an NGO report on Canada's compliance with the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child as part of Canada's five-year report to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child; ( f ) which other organizations actually received funding; ( g ) when was such funding given; ( h ) what were the amounts of the funding given, by department; ( i ) what were the criteria used to distribute funding to different interested organizations; and ( j ) what documents have been produced by the coalition and these other organizations that may have received funding?

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I appreciated the comments of my hon. colleague. I am not an expert in this area but I have high regard for our military and the great men and women who serve our country so admirably. It is a point of pride for all Canadians but particularly Canadian men and women on the frontlines in the armed forces.

The hon. member did not touch on one area. I wonder if he would be willing to comment on it. We often see our military called into service and action on the national scene in natural disasters such as the recent snowstorm in Toronto. There is even reference now to the Y2K issues and leaves being cancelled. Everybody appreciates their efforts and there are all kinds of accolades when it is over for the photo ops.

I am concerned about what the member revealed today on the treatment of these honoured individuals when it comes to pay, compensation and respect for the service they give and what will happen if we jeopardize the service these people provide to Canadians at home when we are facing natural disasters. I wonder if he could comment on that.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I would be glad to respond to that question. Probably one of the best ways to respond to that question is to refer to a recent report by the Fraser Forum which states that this study reveals that fully 48% of the yearly income of the average Canadian family is consumed by taxes visible and hidden. Canada's various levels of government claim to spend their tax revenues for the good of Canadian families but ultimately that revenue comes from families.

I would suggest to the member, in response to his question, that it is not social engineering. Families know their own needs much better than the government does and their administrative costs are much smaller. We would be far wiser to leave the money in their hands.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to speak in the prebudget debate. There are a few points that I would like to bring to the attention of the House.

I would like to begin by saying that there are a number of voices across Canada that are calling for fair family taxation and these voices continue to increase every year. Meanwhile, we see a finance minister who has continued to ignore the voices of these families. In fact the changes he has proposed have actually made the situation worse.

Reformers have called for fairer tax treatment for families right from the beginning. I want to add to our voice the voices of many current think tanks and study groups that have reported on the impact of the current government's taxation policies on the family.

Let us consider what two recent independent studies discovered.

A recent 1998 Compas poll commissioned by Southam News and the National Foundation for Family Research and Education found that 90% of respondents felt that taxes being too high for parents with children is a more serious stress now than a generation ago; 82% of Canadians felt it should be a priority for the government to change the tax law to make it easier for parents with young children to afford to have one parent at home; and 78% felt that not enough respect for the efforts parents put into raising children is now more serious than a decade ago. Those are high percentages.

Even the December report from the Canadian Council on Social Development, which was titled The Progress of Canada's Children: 1998 Highlights called for reform of the tax system to make it more equitable for low and moderate family income earners.

There is another unique group of voices that is coming together to raise the volume on the call to fairness and family taxation. This new group, The Family Tax Coalition, is made up of 10 national family organizations, academics and financial experts.

Let me read their recommendations. These are national groups with tens of thousands of members right across Canada. This is their very simple set of recommendations that they have lobbied for independently for years, but have now come together as the family tax coalition. They state:

Tax concessions for the care of dependent children should be distributed equitably to all Canadian families.... Given this discrimination, most dual-income families with dependent children share common ground with single-income families. Tax fairness for all families must include these measures:

  1. Base taxation on family income, through either income splitting or joint filing;

  2. Convert the child care expense deduction into a refundable child tax credit for all children;

  3. Make the spousal exemption equal to the existing personal exemption;

  4. Give homemakers access to an independent RRSP.

Those were their four recommendations.

I would like to speak about the first one. One of their key recommendations for fair family taxation is the conversion of the child care expense deduction that we currently have into a refundable, and I emphasize the word refundable, child tax credit for all children.

Let me explain the refundable child tax credit option that Reform has long endorsed and championed. What this means is that when income tax is calculated there is a certain amount of tax payable. The refundable tax credit would be subtracted directly from the tax payable so that the hard dollars taken out of pockets would be decreased. This would be a direct advantage in hard dollars to every person who is paying tax.

What about the person who is not paying tax or has no taxable income? Because it is a refundable tax credit—and this is an important concept for people to grasp—it would be paid to the family that did not have any taxable income. In that way, it is equitable to all families. All families are given the credit. In certain cases where there is no tax payable, they would receive the refund.

Then the parents can determine what is the best option for the rearing of their children, whether it be institutionalized daycare or a grandparent or one parent staying at home. It recognizes that parents are the best ones to make the decision for their children rather than being biased in one direction or another by discriminatory tax policies.

All the voices of this coalition are consistent with that of Reform. The Reform Party has called for the current child care expense deduction program which rewards only third party child care to be replaced with the child care expense credit I have spoken about. It would provide a consistent benefit to all parents regardless of the type of child care chosen.

The key here is to let the parents decide. Leave the money with the taxpayer and let the parents decide. Reform has called for this for many years. Why? Because it is fair and it is what families want. The volume is getting louder.

Based on last year, the finance minister is determined not to listen. What did he do in the last budget? He increased the tax deduction incentive for receipted third party daycare. Again, he told those who care for their own children in their own home or with the help of an extended family member that there is no value in that. This is very troubling at a time when people are becoming increasingly aware of how valuable family health is and the parental attachment to society's health.

The family tax coalition also called for the spousal exemption to be equal to the personal exemption. Today it is not. The spousal exemption is substantially lower. The current tax treatment sends a message that a stay at home spouse is less than a whole person.

This is why Reform has long called for equalization of the spousal exemption to the same level as the personal exemption. Year after year the call has fallen on the seemingly deaf ears of the finance minister. Will he continue to treat single income earner families unfairly and knowingly endorse a system that has the single income family paying almost a third more in income tax?

Unfortunately, it seems to me that this government is more inclined to fund child advocates who, after receiving funding for their programs, seldom seem to recognize that children live within families and that helping families through tax relief and equitable tax treatment helps the children.

In a recent Compas poll 92% of the respondents said that families with children today are under more stress than families of 50 years ago and 89% felt that divorce and family breakdown is now more serious.

Stress on families is high. Often financial stress is a key factor in family breakdown. What is the biggest budget item for the Canadian family? You guessed it, Madam Speaker. Taxation is the biggest item in the family budget. According to Statistics Canada, personal taxes make up the largest share of the household budget. It is greater than shelter. It is greater than transportation. It is far greater than food.

The C.D. Howe Institute report “Giving Mom and Dad a Break: Returning fairness to families in Canada's tax and transfer system” of November 1988 points out another way the finance minister ensures that he gets the most from families who pay the least.

Allow me to quote from the institute's report. “The take portion of Canada's tax system, the revenue raising part, assesses tax on an individual basis, while the give portion, the many spending programs associated with the income tax, calculates benefits on a family basis. Is this inconsistency defensible?”

The point here is that this government and the finance minister are determined to maximize taxes from families and minimize benefits.

I will wrap up with a few final comments.

The tax policy sends a message about what the government thinks is important. It is long overdue for the tax policy of this government to serve to strengthen families rather than to undermine them. In order to achieve fairer family taxation within Canada's tax system, the government must make these changes in the next budget.

Supply February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I think the issue of trying to determine which material is appropriate and which material is not really is splitting hairs. What we are really debating today is this case and the details of this case. We know what material was involved in this case. The ruling on this case is what has incensed Canadians, I am glad to see, right across this country. It is the details and the material that was so offensive to so many of us that necessitated us to take some action, and I am glad to say members on all sides of the House to take some action, to eliminate or to address this material in a proactive manner.

Supply February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I think I clearly understand the crux of the issue here. The member opposite said that we are all concerned about the grievous effect of child pornography. But then he said that is not the issue. He said the issue has to do with process. I would submit to the House that the issue is the grievous effect. The issue is the victims, the children. The issue is the negative impact on our communities. The issue is all the Canadians who are tarnished by this kind of ruling in our supreme court. The issue is for the House to do everything possible.

We have an opportunity today to send a message to all Canadians and to the courts that the crux of this issue is victims and we are not going to stand for it any more in this country.

Supply February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I want to continue from where I left off, but I also think it is appropriate to include some of the revelations we gained from the question period.

I will start with the comments of the justice minister, who said that we need to let the current process sort of work itself out. However, it is important for us all to note, those watching and listening today as well as members opposite, that section 33, the notwithstanding clause, is part of the process. It was there to be used for situations exactly like this where judicial rulings are clearly outside the intent of the legislation. It is part of the process and we have an opportunity in the House today to use that part of the process to protect children.

I thought the other interesting revelation from question period was that the justice minister commented that the current legislation is still working in other parts of Canada. Our question is: What about B.C.? We have children in B.C. We have concerned people in B.C. The pay the same high Canadian taxes that we all do. They are entitled to the same protection that we all are. They are also Canadians. Do we put them at risk and not implement this part of the process? Does that make sense? No, it does not make sense.

The whole issue of trusting the judicial process to address this tragic situation is wrong.

I point to one of my own bills in the House which deals with the pardons that are given to known sexual offenders of children. In this country over 12,000 pardons have been given to sexual offenders. Of that 12,000 over 700 of them have been caught—and there are many others who have not been caught—a second time, even after the pardon. About 400 of those were repeat offenders of children. They were convicted once and they were pardoned. Their records were hidden from the public. They were convicted again, a second time. They were caught a second time.

These are the kinds of things that give a lot of Canadians concern. Without implementing the notwithstanding clause and allowing this type of grievous material to be in the hands of Canadians is of grave concern to all of us.

I close with the argument that championing freedoms and putting the most vulnerable at risk is a mistake. When we cross over the line and put the vulnerable at risk in the cause of freedom we have gone too far. The notwithstanding clause allows us to fix it today. I appeal to every member of the House to vote in support of the motion on the floor today. Let us send a strong endorsement to all Canadians.

Child Pornography February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, Canadians are tired of legalise when children are suffering.

I am having a flashback to the hepatitis C vote. I am concerned that the same thing is happening here again today. Many Liberals want to vote in support of this shutdown of child pornography.

My question is again addressed to the Prime Minister. When will this Prime Minister allow his backbenchers and his party to vote with a free conscience on this motion?