House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Extradition Act October 9th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I find it quite appalling that the parliamentary secretary, who knows the rules very well in this place, would use a bogus point of order to endeavour to ask two questions in a row when other people were standing and wanted to pose questions and comments to my hon. colleague from Calgary West.

I enjoyed very much the member's comments and dissertation on extradition. He raised a very important issue and that is, exactly how bad does it have to get as far as senators hiding out in other lands before we will consider that to be a criminal offence in this country?

Solicitor General Of Canada October 9th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, before we break for Thanksgiving, one final question to the solicitor general.

He said he had confidential information about the business arrangement between Karlheinz Schreiber and Elmer MacKay, a business relationship that even Elmer MacKay's son did not know about.

Obviously the member for Palliser did not make this up. How did the solicitor general know? Exactly who told him?

Royal Canadian Mounted Police October 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, let us talk about essential services. The memo further states that all policing overtime and standby is now suspended but it is critical for smaller communities where understaffed detachments have been providing 24-hour coverage by being on standby. What about undercover drug investigations and stakeouts?

Criminals do not operate on a 37.5 hour work week. How can the solicitor general guarantee safe homes in B.C. when instead of criminals, his government is taking the police off the streets?

Royal Canadian Mounted Police October 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the RCMP in British Columbia is facing a financial crisis.

According to an internal document written by Assistant Commissioner Johnston, all coastal patrol vessels are to remain tied up at the docks, all aircraft are to be grounded and only those transfers absolutely essential for the delivery of minimum police services will be approved.

Is this the Liberals' idea of fighting crime in B.C.? What are the people of B.C. supposed to do? Hope that all the crimes occur outside police stations?

Charitable Contributions October 1st, 1998

Madam Speaker, it is a pleasure for me to rise this afternoon and briefly address Motion No. 318 placed before the House by my colleague from Fraser Valley.

Motion No. 318 states:

That, in the opinion of this House, the government should bring in legislation making the tax deduction for contributions to charitable organizations no less than the tax deduction for contributions to political parties.

If we were to flip that motion around and stand it on its head, it would really state that gifts to political parties should not be given more favourable treatment than donations to charities. That is how we need to look at this motion. The intent is clear. It is to level the playing field between donations to political parties and those which accrued to charities.

I compare this motion to the Reform blue book policy that deals with political donations. There has been some concern expressed about that and why my esteemed colleague would bring forward a motion that on the surface would seem to be contrary to Reform's blue book policy.

Reform policy in the blue book under the heading of electoral reform states: “The Reform Party opposes any assistance to political parties and political lobbies from public funds including—” and it lists a number of things. In that list is tax credits for contributions to federal political parties. That is the policy of the Reform Party. Certainly it is a policy that my Reform colleague adheres to, as do I. If we were ever to become government, or when we become government, we will enact that as well as a number of other policies.

In the meantime, it has become painfully clear to charities that this government does not intend to address the inequity between the donations to political parties and those to charities by removing the tax incentive to donate to political parties, as the Reform Party would do.

Therefore my colleague took it on himself to bring forward Motion No. 318 which would level the playing field between the two and treat them the same. Unfortunately we see that in some cases people who are looking at making a donation might be encouraged to make a donation to political party rather than to the charity of their choice. It is very unfortunate that they might tempted to do that because the tax incentive is so much greater.

How unfair is the present system? It was noted in the debate last spring that for a $100 dollar contribution to a political party a donor will receive a $75 federal tax credit. For a $100 donation we have a 75% tax credit. For a $100 gift to a charity the donor will receive a $17 federal charitable donation tax credit. That is $17 versus $75.

To receive a tax credit of $500 for a donation to a federal political party an individual would have to give $1,150, and to receive that same $500 tax credit a donation to a registered charity would have to be in the amount of $1,807.90. Clearly a gross inequity exists. My colleague is attempting to address that by putting forward Motion No. 318.

I think it would interest the viewing public at this point in the debate to ask what are we talking about here. How many charities are we talking about? There are roughly 80,000 registered charities in Canada and in 1996, 5,451,860 donors gave approximately $4 billion. We are talking about a substantial industry, as it were, in the sense of charitable organizations. They employ a lot of people and they certainly do lots of good work.

I see the Chair is telling me I have one minute left. I must have spoken on this issue previously. I thank the Chair for the correction.

On such an important motion I could go on at great length but I will sum up by stating the obvious. This motion is votable. It is not too often that members of this place have a great opportunity to right an injustice.

When we come to vote on Motion No. 318 we can seize the opportunity and vote to level the playing field and treat both these things the same. I urge all members of the House to do exactly that.

Charitable Contributions October 1st, 1998

Madam Speaker, how did I manage that? I have never spoken to this bill.

Criminal Records Act September 29th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, there have been consultations among the parties and I believe you will find unanimous consent for the following motion.

I move:

That following the conclusion of debate on Bill C-284, standing in the name of the member for Calgary Centre, the question be deemed put, a recorded division requested and deferred to the completion of Government Orders on Tuesday, October 6.

Aboriginal Affairs September 28th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, let us really clarify this issue. The letter in question was not written in 1995, as the hon. minister would like us to believe, it was August 24 of this year. That is about a month ago, not a long time ago.

I ask the Minister of Health again. Did the leak take place from his office or did it take place from the office of the Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development?

Aboriginal Affairs September 28th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the revelations of the Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development were very enlightening to the House today. She just stated that it is her belief that the leak took place in the office of the Minister of Health.

Leona Freed took the minister at her word when she said awhile ago that her government could be trusted by the aboriginal people. Look what happened.

I ask the Minister of Health, since it has been revealed that the leak took place in his department, what is he doing about it?

Canada Pension Plan September 25th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, even after giving the hon. member two chances to answer the question, he still failed to answer the question.

Management style is not the issue. The chief actuary is supposed to be independent. Finance officials wanted him to compromise that independence.

I ask again, and this time we would really like the answer, which has nothing to do with management styles, isn't the real reason he was fired because he refused to sell out to finance department officials?