House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Canadian Wheat Board Act June 10th, 1998

That is because you are one.

Canadian Wheat Board Act June 10th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I do not know how anybody could keep their comments short after listening to that socialist rant from the hon. member.

For any of the farmers who happen to be watching the debate tonight, and I am sure there are some, that type of nonsense is the very thing that people have struggled with and fought against to ensure their freedoms throughout history. Throughout history people have had to struggle and fight to get freedoms because of that type of attitude. That is the simple fact of the matter.

Because my time is short I will just address one issue, the issue of dual marketing, the issue of freedom of choice, the issue of a voluntary wheat board.

Why is it that Ontario farmers have a fully elected board of farmers to run the Ontario Wheat Marketing Board? They have a fully elected board, not two-thirds. They are going to be able to market their grain directly out of the country themselves. They will not have to go through the Canadian Wheat Board.

Why is it that what is fair and right and works in Ontario for some reason cannot work in western Canada?

Canadian Wheat Board Act June 10th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I would request that you instruct the Liberal members opposite to try to hold it down a little. I would be interested in hearing what the member for Brandon—Souris is saying as he adds to the debate on my subamendments.

Canadian Wheat Board Act June 10th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, despite the late hour it is a pleasure to rise tonight to address the Senate amendments to Bill C-4, an act to amend the Canadian Wheat Board Act and to make consequential amendments to other acts.

Before I get into the thrust of the Senate amendments I would like to address the process by which we find ourselves at this point this evening. I feel very strongly that it is a faulty process. We have seen that despite the pleas of western Canadian grain farmers upon which the bill will impact tremendously their concerns have largely gone unheeded by the government. The process by which the legislation has moved through parliament is very faulty.

If we look back to the early days of the 36th Parliament we find a commitment by the hon. minister for the Canadian Wheat Board and Natural Resources to bring forward the bill very early in the new mandate following the last election, and he did so. I think the bill came in, in early October. With the new process it moved directly to committee stage rather than having second reading debate, despite the fact that the majority of the opposition members in the House of Commons received a substantial amount of correspondence from western Canadian grain farmers about their concerns with the legislation. Despite that the government moved it directly to committee.

That process in itself is supposedly to allow more time at committee, more time in which to consider substantive amendments, more time in which to receive witnesses' testimony, more time in which members of all the various parties can cross-examine witnesses at committee stage. Yet what we found was an accelerated process even at committee.

The government with its majority on the standing committee for agriculture moved the bill very rapidly through the committee stage and back to the House for report stage. Sensing this, the opposition parties held back their amendments rather than put them forward at committee stage and see them voted down with very little attention paid to them and put forward at report stage.

Unbeknownst to us what we saw, unfortunately for western Canadian farmers, was that the government moved very quickly once it came back to the House for report stage and brought in time allocation to shut down further debate despite the fact that we had not had substantive debate at committee.

We see a process that is deeply flawed and the government is not listening to concerns of farmers. Despite the fact that there were some 48 amendments brought by the four opposition parties at report stage in the House of Commons, of which about 30 were from the official opposition, they were voted down. They received very little time in debate because of the government's move to bring in time allocation.

We saw very substantive amendments such as Motion No. 1 which would have amended the preamble to the bill to ensure that the newly structured Canadian Wheat Board would act and govern itself in the best interest of farmers. We saw amendments such as the one put forward that would have removed references to the president as a member of the board of directors so that the board of directors would have the power to hire and fire the president and CEO rather than that power resting with the minister as it currently does in the bill.

We saw amendments to make the 15 member board of directors fully elected rather than the existing 10 of 15 elected with the other 5 appointed by the minister voted down by the government. The list goes on. Substantive amendments were brought forward not only by the official opposition, by the Reform Party, but by all opposition parties. It was noted at the time during the abbreviated debate that probably nowhere else in the history of agricultural legislation had a government managed to anger everyone across the full spectrum dealing with the Canadian Wheat Board.

We saw people from every aspect who were deeply upset with the legislation and the fact that the government was not listening to the concerns of farmers and forging ahead with it despite their wish to see amendments brought forward. The amendments that were put forward by the opposition were in direct reply to the concerns we heard expressed both at committee and in correspondence and direct communication with farm groups.

During the presentation of the member for Brandon—Souris on Monday evening when Bill C-4 was before the House he expressed his opinion that the Reform Party and I had contradicted ourselves by criticizing the Senate amendments.

We have to look at what these amendments are to accomplish. The official opposition as well as all opposition members as soon as Bill C-4 went from the House of Commons to the Senate encouraged the Senate to hold hearings in western Canada to hear directly from western Canadian farmers about their concerns with the legislation. The Senate to its credit did that.

When I was criticizing the Senate for the end result I was not criticizing the fact that it undertook the process of at least going out to hear from farmers. Unfortunately it did not listen to them and bring forward the amendments that farmers are deeply seeking.

I come back to the single biggest flaw in the legislation over and over again. It is the lack of freedom of choice. Under Bill C-4 farmers will continue to be heavily fined or even thrown in jail if they cross the U.S. border to market their grain. This is unlike options that will soon be available to Ontario grain producers.

One must question why the double standard. Reformers have been doing that consistently and certainly western Canadian farmers have been doing that consistently. Why is there one set of rules for Ontario grain farmers and a totally different one for western grain farmers?

This fundamental flaw with this legislation and with the operation of the Canadian Wheat Board will result in the divisiveness continuing. The elections this bill will put in place for those 10 producer positions on the board of directors will end up simply in a battle between producers who are pro single desk selling, favour the present mandatory system, the status quo, and those producers who favour greater freedom of choice, democracy and a fully voluntary wheat board.

We will end up having elections whereby farmers probably will be casting their ballots not for the candidate they believe brings the greatest skills and expertise to managing a $6 billion a year enterprise but rather for a single issue. Are they in favour of maintaining the single desk selling structure of the Canadian Wheat Board or are they in favour of greater freedom of choice and looking at options that will allow farmers to market some or all their grain outside of the Canadian Wheat Board? I think it is unfortunate that farmers will have to make that choice when they go to the ballot boxes, likely this fall, and vote for these 10 producer positions.

The standing Senate committee on agriculture and forestry tabled its report on Bill C-4 on Thursday, May 21 after spending thousands of taxpayer dollars travelling across western Canada to hear what farmers thought of the legislation. I have referred to that and I actually applaud the Senate's initiative to get that feedback.

It became very clear throughout the hearings, even to some senators, that the majority of farmers were unhappy with the legislation. Farmers told senators they wanted more marketing options outside the Canadian Wheat Board and that the inclusion clause allowing for more grains to come under the Canadian Wheat Board's jurisdiction had to go.

While some farmers were optimistic that the Senate would propose substantial changes to reflect this testimony, the Senate proved yet again that it is simply a puppet controlled by the government.

I intend later in my presentation to move some subamendments to the five Senate amendments.

Of the Senate amendments brought forward the first amendment is consequential to the second and the second will really require that the minister consult with the board of directors on the appointment of the president and CEO. The minister still retains the power to arbitrarily appoint the president for the first year after the changes come into effect.

We believe, and we made these amendments when the bill was before the House before, that it should be the board of directors with total control of appointing or ultimately have the power to fire the CEO and president if that person is not doing their job.

I will be proposing a subamendment to this that would turn this thing around and ensure that it is the board of directors that has that power and that it must consult with the minister before it appoints the CEO, not the other way around.

The third Senate amendment deals with the auditor general. This too was an amendment brought forward by the Reform Party to open up the Canadian Wheat Board to audits by the auditor general and to the Access to Information Act.

We have repeatedly demanded that the Canadian Wheat Board open its books to the auditor general. We applaud this as a tentative first step. Here too there are some great deficiencies in what actually has taken place with the way this amendment is worded. This amendment does not stipulate that the auditor general must make his findings public. A report made simply to the minister is ineffective and inadequate. This is a one time opportunity. No further audits are stipulated. In addition, the amendment does not specify which year or years of the Canadian Wheat Board operations the auditor general is to audit. Conceivably the focus of the audit could be 20 years ago and nothing more recent.

When consulted by opposition MPs about this amendment the auditor general's office wrote a letter to the minister for the Canadian Wheat Board outlining his concerns with this amendment. Legal counsel at the auditor general's office were uncertain how this amendment would actually fit into the mandate and legislation governing the operations of the auditor general. The letter expressed concern that the apparent intent of the amendment as drafted would not provide a great deal of value for the money.

I too will be presenting a subamendment which will if passed ensure that the auditor general has an ongoing role to play in auditing the Canadian Wheat Board and ensure that he has the greatest amount of flexibility in how he conducts those audits, and ensure further that he reports as he should and as he does in other cases to parliament and not simply to the corporation and to the minister responsible.

The last two amendments the Senate brought forward deal with the exclusion and inclusion clauses. The fourth amendment is with the exclusion and the fifth the inclusion, and they are consequential with one another. Here too what we see is the Senate has merely reverted to basically the status quo and added one small hurdle where the minister would have to consult and hold a plebiscite were he to include any new grains.

We have already heard over and over again how farmers feel about this prospect, as slim as it might be, that there would be additional inclusion of other commodities under the Canadian Wheat Board's mandate. It is simply unacceptable. Once again I will be moving a subamendment.

I could go on to talk about some recommendations that the Senate made in addition to these amendments, but I do not have the time. Therefore I will get to my subamendments.

The recommendations are not binding whatsoever on the government or on the minister. That is a great flaw as well. I think some of the recommendations have some merit and I have said that publicly. But they are merely that, recommendations. They are not amendments. Farmers in particular in western Canada should clearly understand that. The recommendations dealing with the electoral process for dividing up the election of the directors is on a geographic basis and the amendments dealing with the contingency fund cap are just recommendations. They may or may not be acted on.

That brings me to moving my subamendments. I move:

That the motion be amended by deleting all the words after the word “That” and substituting the following: “a message be sent to the Senate to acquaint their honours that this House agrees to amendments number 1 and 4, made by the Senate to Bill C-4, an act to amend the Canadian Wheat Board Act, and this House agrees with the principles set out in amendments number 2, 3 and 5, but would propose the following amendment:

Amendment 2 be amended by replacing all the words in section 3.09(1) with the words “The president is appointed by the governor in council on the recommendation of the board of the directors and holds office during pleasure for the term that the board of directors may determine.” and by replacing the word “Minister” in section 3.09(2) and 3.09(2)(a) with the word “board” and replace the word “board” in section 3.09(2)(a) with the word “Minister”;

Amendment 3 be amended by replacing all the words in the first paragraph with the words “Within two years after the day this section comes into force, the Auditor General of Canada shall commence auditing the accounts, financial transactions, information management systems and management practices of the corporation for such fiscal years as the auditor general considers appropriate and reports of those audits shall be made to the corporation, the minister and parliament”; and

Amendment 5 is amended by adding to section 5 the following: “(c) producer participation in the Canadian Wheat Board is voluntary”.

In other words, amendment No. 5 would not pass and it would not be allowed under any circumstances to include more commodities under the Canadian Wheat Board until such time as the Canadian Wheat Board is voluntary.

Petitions June 10th, 1998

He should know better.

Petitions June 10th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 36(6) it is my pleasure to introduce a petition signed by 125 residents of the small northern town of Fort Nelson in my riding.

The petitioners assert that registering legal firearms will do absolutely nothing to stop the criminal misuse of guns. They therefore request that parliament repeal Bill C-68 and redirect the hundreds of millions of tax dollars being wasted on the licensing and registering of responsible law-abiding gun owners and their firearms toward proven cost effective methods of fighting crime.

Canada Grain Act June 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure for me to rise again today at this time to address Bill C-26, an act to amend the Canada Grain Act and the Agriculture and Agri-Food Administrative Monetary Penalties Act and to repeal the Grain Futures Act.

Before I get into exactly what Bill C-26 does and why the official opposition is opposed to this legislation, I wish to express my appreciation to all members involved in the decision that took place last Thursday when Bill C-26 was last before the House.

I was unavoidably committed elsewhere on that day. At first it appeared that I would not be able to have a final chance to address this particular legislation, but with unanimous agreement from all the parties it was decided to bring the bill back today and that allows me the opportunity to speak. I appreciate that decision, particularly on the part of the government.

Bill C-26 will accomplish three distinctly different objectives. First, in repealing the Grain Futures Act, Bill C-26 paves the way for the Manitoba government to regulate the Winnipeg Commodity Exchange rather than having the exchange fall under federal jurisdiction, the Canadian Grain Commission to be specific, which it does at present.

It is my understanding that the exchange wants to offer trading of non-grain contracts, especially hogs, and the repeal of the Grain Futures Act will facilitate that.

As I noted previously during second reading and at report stage, having the province of Manitoba assume responsibility through the Manitoba Securities Commission to regulate the Winnipeg Commodity Exchange is a positive step and one which we support.

Second, Bill C-26 will bring the Canada Grain Act under the umbrella of the Agriculture and Agri-Food Administrative Monetary Penalties Act, thereby permitting fines for violations of the Canada Grain Act and its regulations to be levied by the Canadian Grain Commission. Because this legislation has a wider range of enforcement options which will allow greater flexibility, we view this as a positive step and therefore one which we support.

This brings me to the third item which Bill C-26 accomplishes.

Because this government once more has failed to listen to the farmers and their representatives who appeared before the standing committee on agriculture, we find ourselves in opposition.

Bill C-26 began with the establishment of the special crops rural initiative program committee. This SCRIP committee is made up of producers and processors from the three prairie provinces and is assisted by a representative from the Canadian Grain Commission.

Since 1993 the committee has consulted with stakeholders and in April of 1996 it drafted a report called the “Special Crops Rural Initiative Program” upon which this bill is loosely based.

Many of the recommendations made by the SCRIP committee are not included in Bill C-26, but will be laid out in regulations which do not undergo scrutiny by parliament.

While it would be impractical to set out specifics such as levy rates and deductibles in legislation, it would be more reassuring for farmers if certain limits were set out. For example, the legislation could have ensured that the levy rate not exceed 1% of the gross value of the grain sale proceeds. This would provide comfort in the years to come that the levy would not simply skyrocket to an unreasonable level.

The government likes to wax poetic about the success of the consultative process through SCRIP, but we saw very early on that SCRIP recommendations were overruled by the Canadian Grain Commission when the levy was set at a higher level than recommended by the committee. That is a rather ominous start and a cause for concern for farmers of special crops.

The farmers who will be affected by this bill will be those producing beans, buckwheat, corn, fababeans, lentils, mustard seed, peas, safflower seed, soybeans, sunflower seed and triticale.

The production of those products or commodities is on the increase all across western Canada. As a farmer myself, as someone who has farmed close to 20 years in the Peace River country, I can tell members that farmers are increasingly looking at these special crops as a way in which to diversify, as a way in which to try to spread their risk and as a way in which to try to increase their profitability.

That is why there is a great concern about this bill and how it is being brought in, and more specifically, how the levy will be structured and administered.

As for the licensing insurance scheme created under this legislation, there is an alarming lack of competition. Even the parliamentary secretary confirmed that the Canadian Grain Commission developed this bill. So there is indeed a high level of self-interest since the commission will also administer the plan.

At present buyers and dealers are free to shop around for the best price on their bond. I brought this issue up when the bill was before the committee and representatives of the Canadian Grain Commission were appearing as witnesses. Under the present system there is a certain competitiveness. The dealers, if they are licensed and are required to put up a bond, can shop around amongst the various agencies in order to purchase that bond. Under this new system they will not have that option. They will not have that freedom of choice.

As well, special crops producers are free to shop around for the best price for their product. In doing so they have to recognize the potential risk if they choose to deal with an unlicensed, unbonded dealer. If the buyer was to go into bankruptcy prior to them receiving payment for their delivery, they obviously would not be covered. That option is available to the producer. If he or she can see that there is a potential for a higher return for the product, they may indeed be willing to accept that risk.

All dealers will be licensed and insured with the Canadian Grain Commission acting as the agent and the Canadian Export Development Corporation becoming the single insurer.

There was a suggestion by the government that sometime in the future one or both of these tasks could be contracted to the private sector. I do not think I will hold my breath. Without such a goal outlined in legislation I see no real hope that the Canadian Grain Commission will be willing to release its grip on the plan so that it can eventually be transferred to the private sector. It is the farmers' money and they should run the insurance plan, not the bureaucrats. We have learned time and time again that the bureaucracy is not very good at running programs and plans such as this, where the expertise, capabilities and resources already exist in the private sector.

While Bill C-26 does provide some positive developments for producers of special crops, it also reminds me of a runaway train that is increasingly getting beyond the control of the farmers.

I would like to digress for a moment and refer the viewing audience at home to some other examples of legislation where this government has increasingly shown open disdain to listen to farmers, the people who will be affected by this legislation. In some ways there is a trend here. There is a similarity with Bill C-19. the labour legislation.

We had a number of producers and farm groups who suggested that because Bill C-19 takes a small step forward under section 87.7 in ensuring that the standard grains will continue to flow, even in the case of a pending labour disruption at the ports, and that ships will continue to be loaded that we should support Bill C-19. But the point we have repeatedly made is, why is it that this government will not listen to farmers and amend legislation? Why is it that it will not listen to opposition members and amend legislation to improve it? We have to settle for second best. We have to make do. We have to simply say that there is some good in the legislation.

In defence of the government, there is some good in the majority of legislation that goes through this House. The government is not bringing forward legislation just because it has nothing else to do. I am sure that it is bringing it forward with the best of intentions. However, the fact remains that almost all legislation, certainly all the legislation that I can think of that goes through this House, could be improved if only the government and its members were willing to listen, and in this case listen to the farmers.

It also reminds me of legislation that is going to come back before the House next week, Bill C-4, the amendments to the Canadian Wheat Board Act. Here again the government has shown a tendency not to listen to the farmers and act upon their recommendations.

Let us look at what we had to give up to get this plan.

Farmers will be forced to pay for the insurance plan up front whether or not they want to participate. They will then have to write to ask for their hard earned money to be returned to them. It is like a tax in that sense. If they are lucky they will get a refund at the end of the year. It is modelled on negative option billing which I recall the government repeatedly hailed as an unfair way in which to do business.

Criticism of this aspect of Bill C-26 was abundant during witness testimony when the legislation was considered by the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food. During the month of April besides the Canadian Grain Commission we heard from representatives of the Manitoba Pulse Growers Association, Saskatchewan Farmer Consultations for SCRIP, the Western Canadian Marketers and Processors Association, the Western Canadian Wheat Growers Association, the Alberta Pulse Growers Association, the Saskatchewan Pulse Growers Association and the Western Barley Growers Association.

We had an opportunity to appear before the committee even though the time was shortened and the bill was hastened through the process. There was not a lot of time to hear from them about their presentations or for members, be they government or opposition, to cross-examine the witnesses to probe deeper into their concerns about the pending legislation. We had the opportunity to have a substantial number of farm groups appear before the committee.

We were very fortunate to have had the opportunity to hear from all these witnesses. It is one of the best tools of parliamentarians to accurately determine the will of the people. As a result of their opinions the Reform Party moved a number of amendments at both committee stage and report stage to reflect that feedback.

Unfortunately, as I have said, it appears the government does not value the opinion of farmers and defeated our amendments that would have made Bill C-26 an improved piece of legislation in the opinion of special crops producers.

In the time that I have remaining I would like to go over a few of the amendments the government has chosen to defeat. At committee stage some Liberal government amendments to the bill were put forward and passed which Reform supported. If I recall correctly they were supported by all the parties. Some of them were technical in nature. One amendment to clause 7 was to ensure that a producer's contribution to the insurance plan would be reimbursed after withdrawal from the plan in a more timely manner at the end of the season.

We heard repeatedly from farm representatives about negative option billing where everybody is in the levy. They cannot opt out as it were. They cannot say up front “No, do not collect this. Every time I haul a load of one of the designated crops to the elevator I do not want that taken off my cheque”. They cannot do that. It is taken off anyway. They were also concerned that they would have to keep track of it throughout the year.

I note even with the amendment that it is unclear at this point just exactly how it will operate and how cumbersome the administration will be for individual farmers. That concern was pretty unanimous in the farm representations we heard.

Another Liberal amendment was basically an exclusion amendment which we certainly supported and applauded. A concern was expressed by a number of farm groups representing western producers of special crops. Even the Canadian Grain Commission said that at some point in the future perhaps this levy, this insurance and licensing scheme, could be expanded to include the six standard grains: wheat, oats, barley, rye, canola and flax. A lot of concern about that was expressed by farmers.

When the government brought forward this amendment to very clearly state that those grains would be excluded we supported it.

As well motions were put forward by the other parties. What we heard really came down to two main contentions with respect to the legislation.

We heard that farmers were concerned about the way in which the levy would be collected. They were concerned that like the GST it would be foisted on them. They would have to keep track of it as they went along. Then, if they did not want to have their crops insured with the dealer, they would have to keep track of the levy, which is 38 cents per $100 of sales, how much over the year had been taken off their cheques, and then apply for it. This would create additional bookkeeping they were not too interested in.

They were also concerned about the lack of freedom of choice. They felt once more that government was intervening in the marketplace, in their freedoms as business people, and that if they wanted to accept the risk of selling their product to an unlicensed, unbonded and uninsured dealer or buyer it should be their choice. Once more they saw government intervening and telling them the way in which they should run their business.

We brought forward a number of amendments at report stage to address this last issue. The farmers were also concerned that the advisory committee the minister would be required to set up to advise on the administration of the insurance plan would have no power. Under the legislation it does not have any power despite the fact that all administration costs and the costs of the insurance would be borne entirely by farmers through the levy.

They were telling us the advisory board should be a board of directors that would administer and oversee the insurance plan and decide themselves. It would be farmers looking after their own money since it is their money and dealing with it as best they could.

The official opposition brought forward amendments dealing with all those concerns and the government chose to defeat them. In light of the fact that the government consistently ignores the concerns and desires of western producers and western Canadian farmers, whether it is Bill C-4, Bill C-19 or Bill C-26, the official opposition, the Reform Party of Canada, cannot support Bill C-26 even though as I said earlier there is a lot of good in it. The government will not amend or improve the legislation. Shame on the government. We cannot support it.

Judges Act June 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, as always it is a pleasure to rise to speak. It strikes me as somewhat unfortunate, as it seems that the four or five times I have spoken this spring my presentations have been interrupted by that one hour question period. Today continues what has been set as a tradition for my presentations.

I remark at the outset in reply to the government House leader who just spoke about legislation we have to deal with and he hoped we would not have to have evening sittings. I think that is certainly the hope of everyone.

The reality is, if the option is that the opposition just cease being opposition and we rubber stamp everything that the government has brought forward in order that we can get all this legislation, this heavy load as he called it, through, that is not going to happen. If it requires that we sit well into the evening over the next couple of weeks, then that is what we will be doing in order to represent the concerns of Canadians who live and work out in the real world. They have some very deep concerns with the legislation the government wants to ram through the House of Commons.

When we adjourned the debate just prior to question period I was in the midst of talking about Bill C-37, specifically about Motion No. 2. We are at report stage of Bill C-37, an act to amend the Judges Act. Motion No. 2, which was brought forward by my colleague from Crowfoot, deals with accountability and having the reports of future recommendations by the commission that will be set up under Bill C-37 to consider judges' compensation, wages and benefits packages brought before the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights.

What I was getting at is that this is really an issue of accountability, of bringing an element of public scrutiny to these reports. In this way the general public can have some input through their opposition members of parliament at the standing committee as to what they feel is fair compensation for our nation's judges.

What bothers Canadians most about the issue of an 8.3% increase in salary for judges? I suspect that probably what bothers them most is some of the rulings that they see from some of the judges. I want to be very clear in saying that it is some of the judges, not all of them. A lot of them are making judgments and rulings that are defensible to the general public. Certainly increasingly it seems that there is one underlying theme running through a lot of the judgments that come down from our courts.

Earlier in talking to report stage Motion No. 1 of Bill C-37 I referred to three specific cases that are fairly well known in my riding of Prince George—Peace River, the Feeney, Solomon and Baldwin cases and ultimately the judgments that were rendered with those cases. My concern is I do not feel that in a lot of the cases where the judges are actually legislating or making law rather than fairly interpreting the law that their decisions are supported by the general public.

I hear this increasingly from my constituents and I think the Feeney case is a classic example. It does not seem to matter any longer whether an accused is innocent or guilty. What seems to matter is whether it is legal or illegal. The courts seem to be more concerned about technicalities rather than guilt or innocence. There is something sadly lacking in our legal system which is masquerading as a justice system today.

We will not be supporting this bill. We do not feel that the Canadian public at this time will defend an 8.3% increase in judges' salaries when they cannot understand or support a lot of the decisions that these same judges are making.

Judges Act June 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to speak to Motion No. 2 put forward by my hon. colleague from Crowfoot.

It deals with the issue of accountability. That is where this amendment is going. It drives home the point that the commission to be set up under Bill C-37 to review the benefit packages and the pay of judges should be scrutinized. If this amendment were passed the commission would come before the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights. That is what this amendment accomplishes. I do not see the problem with that.

A Liberal member stated earlier that in her opinion she felt this amendment was redundant since the committees in exercising their independence already have the ability to call witnesses on virtually any subject that falls under their domain. As one of my Calgary colleagues indicated during his brief and brilliant presentation, everyone, certainly those in parliament, knows the simple fact that the government has a majority position in the standing committees.

The minister of a particular department to which a standing committee is connected basically sets the agenda through their parliamentary secretary who sits on that committee. Those are the facts.

We can pretend these committees are basically independent but it is simply not the facts. The facts would indicate the cabinet and the minister responsible for that portfolio set the agenda.

Clearly in this case the Minister of Justice and her parliamentary secretary and their appointed chairman of the standing committee all desire that this report from the commission not be reviewed by the standing committee. They crack the whip as they do in the House of Commons. They get all the government members on the standing committee to stand and they simply would not bring that forward to be scrutinized.

That is the point of this amendment because if this amendment were passed there would be no choice in the matter. The commission's report would have to come before the standing committee and there would be public scrutiny through the committee.

When looking at Bill C-37 and this 8.3% increase in salary that it will bestow on our judges, what is the view of the people in the real world? What would they think about this piece of legislation?

As has been clearly laid out by a number of my colleagues, when we look the tough times a lot of people are having to make ends meet today, they would certainly question the need for judges who on average are making $140,000 a year to receive a retroactive pay increase of 8.3% at this time.

This is something the average person has no control over. This is something that will ultimately result in higher taxes. The money has to come from somewhere. Where will it come from? It will come out of the pockets of taxpayers and therefore this type of increase should be defensible. It should be scrutinized by the general public through the standing committee, which this amendment calls for. I see my time has expired. I always I get interrupted by question period.

Judges Act June 3rd, 1998

Madam Speaker, I wish I could say that it is a pleasure for me to rise today to address the report stage of Bill C-37, but I must confess that following my comments and the comments of others when it was before the House for second reading, I had hoped the government might rethink this legislation instead of bringing it back.

Today I am here to speak to Motion No. 1, which was put forward by my colleague from the Bloc Quebecois. The motion would amend Bill C-37 by deleting clause 5. We have heard previous speakers address this particular clause because it is controversial. I certainly feel that it is controversial insofar as it deals specifically with an increase in judges' salaries. It is duly noted that judges, on average, make about $140,000 a year. This will amount to an 8.3% increase over the next couple of years.

When I rose to speak to Bill C-37 the last time it was before the House I noted that it was April 1. I thought it was perhaps a cruel April Fool's joke which had been foisted upon the Canadian public by the government of this country at a time when Canadians were increasingly concerned about judgments that were being brought down by the justices of Canada. Rather than debating some of the judgments, which I feel quite confident do not carry the judgment of the Canadian people, we find ourselves today, as we did on April 1, discussing a very substantial salary increase, amongst other things, in Bill C-37.

As other speakers from the opposition have noted, I support the motion put forward by the hon. member of the Bloc Quebecois to entirely delete clause 5, which would increase judges' salaries, at least at this particular time. As I did at second reading, I would draw the comparison for the viewing public at home between the salary increases for judges and the more recent salary increases that were granted to our RCMP officers. Those increases amounted to a mere 2%, which was retroactive to January 1, and a subsequent 1% increase on April 1, which, ironically, was the day we were debating the second reading stage of this bill. Another .75% will become due to the Mounties on October 1.

The starting salary for a third year constable will go from $50,500 to a little better than $52,000. These are the people who every day put their lives on the line to protect society, yet we find that in the eyes of this particular government they only warrant a small increase. The judges, who increasingly are returning violent convicted criminals back to the streets, will enjoy this 8.3% increase over the next two years.

As a number of my colleagues have indicated, I want to put it on the record that I am not casting aspersions upon all justices. That is not the case. We had somewhat of a heated debate on April 1 when certain members of the government felt that the official opposition, the Reform Party, in citing certain examples of judgements that have come down were doing exactly that. I want to say at the outset that is not the case.

It has been indicated by a number of my colleagues in the Reform Party that many of the judges in Canada today, both at the provincial and federal level, do great work. They bring down many judgments which carry the confidence of the Canadian people. However, unfortunately, a lot of them do not.

In referring to this issue today I would like to mention three cases that happened either in my riding of Prince George—Peace River or very near to it.

The first case I would like to cite is what has become known as the Feeney case. Michael Feeney was convicted of second degree murder in the bludgeoning death of 85 year old Frank Boyle in his home in Likely, B.C. in June of 1991. Likely is a small community just outside Williams Lake, which is outside my riding. Ironically, the lawyer who took the case to the supreme court is a lawyer from Prince George, which is in my riding, so I am fairly familiar with the case.

This unfortunate victim was smashed in the head five times with a crowbar and his truck and $400 in cash was missing. RCMP officers, following up on a tip that Feeney had been seen near the victim's stolen truck, went to Feeney's trailer to investigate. They entered his trailer and found his shirt splattered with blood. Subsequently they arrested Mr. Feeney.

However, the supreme court judges ruled that the police did not have reasonable grounds to arrest Feeney when they entered the trailer without a warrant. All evidence gained as a result of the arrest and the subsequent search which was conducted with a warrant were ruled inadmissible. It was a majority decision. It was not unanimous. The evidence included the bloodied shirt and his fingerprints, matching prints which were found on the victim's refrigerator, money hidden under a mattress and cigarettes similar to those found in the victim's house. I would suggest that it is going to very difficult for the crown counsel to obtain a conviction, if it ever goes to retrial, without the use of this evidence.

I will draw to the House's attention another case which was known as the Sullivan case. This happened in the city of Prince George. Wayne Richard Sullivan of Prince George was found non-criminally responsible by reason of a mental disorder in the January 1992 shooting death of his wife and the sexual assault at gunpoint of another woman. After a night of drinking, Sullivan proposed a threesome between himself, his wife and the other woman. His proposal was rejected. He then shot his wife in the temple, pointed the gun at the second woman and ordered her to remove her clothing.

The trial judge instructed the jury on the law relating to mental illness and criminal responsibility. The B.C. court of appeal judges ruled that the judge was correct in his instruction. The verdict of December 11, 1993 meant that Sullivan was confined in a secure mental facility, but subsequently would be released once it was determined he was no longer mentally disordered. Sullivan's punishment was a conditional release.

That judgment has raised a lot of concern not only in the community of Prince George, but in communities across our country. I raise it today as another example of how the judgments brought down by our justices certainly do not at all relate to what average citizens in our communities would feel is right, fair and just.

The last case I would bring forward today is the Baldwin murder. Here we have a case of an elderly gent in the city of Dawson Creek located in the southern end of my riding of Prince George—Peace River. The elderly gentleman was set upon in a park by six local teenagers and kicked and beaten to death. Six local teenagers were charged in the murder of James Baldwin. Mr. Baldwin, a homeless person, had set up camp in the park less than a dozen metres from where his body was found.

I guess I am already out of time, unfortunately. The point I am trying to make is that all of these judgments reinforce the view of the general public that there is something seriously wrong with our justice system. In fact they do not even refer to it as a justice system any more, but a legal system.

It is pretty hard to defend an 8.3% increase when people see these types of judgments coming down.