House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supply June 1st, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to have this opportunity, as brief as it is, to ask the hon. minister a question and put a comment or two forward.

It seemed to me at least, unless I was getting the wrong impression, that he was bragging during his presentation about the 270,000 women who are now covered under EI for the first time with the changes brought forward by the government. He was bragging about the new eligibility criteria. He was quoting statistics.

I refer to a working mother in my riding I recently heard from. This lady works as a permanent part time employee with the school district as a bus driver. Recently she had to take a six week medical leave of her duties and applied for medical benefits through employment insurance. After waiting several weeks she finally received her cards to fill out. Shortly after a letter from HRDC arrived informing her she did not qualify for any benefits. She did not have enough hours. A claimant needs 700 hours in a 52 week period and her total number of hours was only 648.

Her concern is, and I agree, that she is paying for insurance that she is ineligible to collect. Legislation does not take into account consideration of this scenario and there are no exceptions to the rules.

This woman is not alone. I think these people see EI as simply another tax. When some individuals call EI premiums a payroll tax, that is exactly what it is. It is especially true when those individuals are ineligible to collect benefits. To take those premiums off their pay, as small as it is, is unethical when they are in a situation where they have this additional tax, and it is simply a tax because they cannot get any benefits. We already have the highest tax in the G-7.

I wonder if the hon. minister would care to comment and refer his comments to the situation with this working mother and the fact that while on medical leave she was unable to get any benefits despite the fact that she pays her premiums like all other working Canadians.

Charitable Contributions June 1st, 1998

Madam Speaker, I see we only have a minute or two left in Private Members' Business. There is not a lot of time to adequately address Motion No. 318 put forward by my hon. colleague from Fraser Valley.

I find it absolutely unbelievable, not only to members on this side of the House, but indeed to all the people across Canada who are watching at home today that we would even have to have this debate, that we would even have to have this motion put forward by my hon. colleague from Fraser Valley. I certainly applaud his initiative to bring this matter forward.

We are talking about the issue of levelling the playing field at a minimum. The motion as my hon. colleague pointed out says “no less than”. That is a key phrase in the motion itself. It says that in the opinion of this House the government should bring in legislation making the tax deduction for contributions to charitable organizations no less than the tax deduction for contributions to political parties.

In reply or rebuttal, the hon. member from the governing Liberal Party who just spoke is missing the point. He said that if this were to go ahead and we levelled the playing field and treated both exactly the same, that anybody wanting to make a donation to a charity of more than $1,150 in any given year would get no additional tax credit. He is quite correct if we did it exactly the same, but that is not what the motion says. The motion very clearly says no less than.

In the excellent presentation that my hon. colleague from Fraser Valley made in speaking to his private members' motion, and the need to bring this type of legislation forward, he threw out the challenge not only to government members but to members from all the political parties to suggest some options. He said to look at alternatives.

One of the options I would like to discuss is the option of eliminating the tax credit for political parties and reassigning the benefit from that to charities. That type of tax reform would certainly be supported by a lot more Canadians than the present system. The small donors, the average donor, the person who can only donate $50 to any given entity be it a charity or a political party, those are the people we need to target. We need to ensure that it is not a case where $100 to a political party gets a $75 tax credit but $100 to a charity only gets a $17 tax credit. That is the issue. That is the driving force behind this motion and the reason why I am certainly speaking in support of it.

Conditional Sentencing May 26th, 1998

How many? Why did she not tell us how many? She commented during her remarks that there have been more than 18,000 times since September 3, 1996 that conditional sentencing has been used by our courts. But she did not say how many times it was used in cases of rape, how many times in cases of drug trafficking. How many times? How many of the 18,000 were for rape? How many were for violent offences? How many were for drug trafficking? Because if it is one, then it is one damn well too many.

For this government to say it will leave it up to the courts, leave it to the judges to decide or it will appeal, there can be no doubt that the Liberal Party of Canada and the government is made up mostly of lawyers. They want to perpetuate this type of nonsense. They want to keep the courts busy. They just want to keep appealing it instead of correcting the problem. Even if there is one person who does not serve time in jail, and I am not talking about four star hotels where they can flex their muscles and exercise, I am talking about putting them to work, I am talking about real justice and punishment that will deter these people from doing it again.

The parliamentary secretary in her comments said, and I wrote this down maybe not word for word but something close, that the government is willing to work with the provinces to monitor and see whether further changes are needed. To monitor. That is about all bloody well good this government is for, to monitor. It certainly is not intent on making any meaningful justice changes, any meaningful justice reform.

I see I am about out of time. That is unfortunate. The member for Scarborough—Rouge River says that they wanted to rely on the judges when they passed Bill C-41 to draw the line because there is always an exception to the rule. That is what he said. Yes there are always exceptions to the rule. I can say that less than two months after these conditional sentencing provisions came into effect in September 1996 I raised the issue of how it was being inappropriately used in cases of rape.

There was a young mother whose ex common law spouse broke into her home and raped her on the kitchen floor. He was found guilty and convicted but the judge did not give him any time in jail. One of the conditions he imposed upon this criminal was that he felt it would be better for the mother and the children if this individual continued to pay his child support. That was one of the conditions. That is what conditional sentencing does. It imposes these harsh conditions on rapists.

I want to thank the hon. House leader of the Progressive Conservative Party and my hon. colleague from Surrey North for their participation in the debate. I want to say to everyone watching this debate at home tonight that I and the victims of these crimes are absolutely appalled at the parliamentary secretary's callous disregard for meaningful justice reform.

Conditional Sentencing May 26th, 1998

She says it is.

I would like her to come to my riding and other ridings in the country and say to the victims that it is fearmongering when criminals who have brutally raped them walk out of court and do not face any time in jail.

Conditional Sentencing May 26th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, once again I must say it is a sad day in this House of Commons that this government has shown itself to be completely unresponsive to the general public about this issue, unresponsive to the victims of crime and unresponsive to the cries of those victims for real justice.

I see the parliamentary secretary sitting across the way shaking her head. I heard her say in response to some of the examples my hon. colleague from Surrey North cited that it is fearmongering.

Conditional Sentencing May 26th, 1998

moved:

That, in the opinion of this House, the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights be instructed, in accordance with Standing Order 68(4)( b ), to prepare and bring in a bill to prevent the use of conditional sentencing in cases where someone is convicted of any sexual offence, drug trafficking, or any other violent crime.

Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise this evening to elaborate on my Motion No. 383. It is very appropriate, almost ironically so, that the one day allotted for my private member's motion concerning conditional sentencing happened to fall on this Reform supply day. In its role as official opposition the Reform moved a supply motion that was debated by all parties in the House. We debated conditional sentencing, the Young Offenders Act and other aspects of the failed legal system which is presently masquerading as a justice system in Canada.

It is unfortunate that Motion No. 383 is limited to simple elaboration. The committee responsible for determining which private members' motions are votable and worthy of three hours of debate in this House did not feel inclined to allow all members of this House to explore the issue further. Naturally I am extremely disappointed in that decision as this motion is non-partisan in nature. It is simply a mechanism I proposed to remedy a legislative error.

The granting of conditional sentences to violent and sexual offenders is indeed an error. It was never the intent of this House in the last parliament to have Bill C-41, which instituted the concept of conditional sentencing, apply to those types of crimes. That is one of the issues that was being debated virtually all day in the House. Even the justice minister at the time publicly stated that was never the intent.

Through this motion I wanted to right that wrong by using the resources and co-operation of the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights. This motion does not propose something concretely unpalatable to any members of this House. It is a first step in drafting a reasonable remedy to the ambiguity of conditional sentencing.

I believe certain members of the private members' business committee did not understand that intent. During my presentation the chair of the committee asked “And just how many more prisons would have to be built if your motion were passed?” In case any members of the House are asking themselves that same question, I caution that they do not understand the motion. I emphasize that the prison population will not suddenly expand to phenomenal proportions if conditional sentencing were disallowed for violent and sexual offenders and drug traffickers.

Conditional sentencing is a recent development. It has not been responsible for significantly reducing the prison population throughout the years. It did not take effect until September 3, 1996, so the answer is no. There will be no sudden overwhelming need to build more prisons. I fear the chair of the committee missed the entire point of my motion when she asked that question.

Conditional sentences have created confusion and ambiguity in the legal system across the country. It is ironic that when Bill C-41 was before the House the justice minister at the time said the bill would improve the process of sentencing and criminal law. I ask government members to listen carefully to his words which so specifically describe the intent of Bill C-41: “In this bill, parliament is given the opportunity to declare the key purposes of sentencing, to put before judges a list of factors to be taken into account, to provide direction, to encourage uniformity so that the purpose of the process can be properly understood and so that it might be rendered more predictable than it is at present.

“What are those purposes and principles? They are spelled out clearly and in plain language in the statute. The sentence would reflect the seriousness of the offence. There would be similar sentences for comparable crimes. Those who contravene the criminal law must face punishment”.

Those were the words of the justice minister in June 1995. He said that Bill C-41 was to assist the courts in making the sentencing process more reliable and more consistent with the intentions of parliament.

Now fast forward to January 1998, more than a year after Bill C-41 provisions took effect. The current justice minister publicly stated: “There have been some circumstances in which I believe conditional sentences were used when it was not the intention of parliament to have them used and those should be appealed”. She added that conditional sentencing was never intended to apply to violent or sexual offenders. While Bill C-41 was supposed to clear up ambiguity in sentencing she said she prefers to allow the appeal courts to address the inappropriate use of conditional sentencing.

Needless to say, this is entirely opposite to the promises of consistency and reliability for the courts in using Bill C-41 as a guide which were given by the former justice minister in 1995. Since its implementation conditional sentencing has been used in cases of rape, assault, drug trafficking and other violent offences. Canadians are alarmed at this application of the Criminal Code and communities feel threatened. The punishment certainly does not fit the crime. This is not a tough on crime perspective. This is just the simple facts of the wrongful use of conditional sentencing.

Rapists, violent offenders and those who attempt to exploit children and the weak through a profitable drug trade should face jail time. In Grande Prairie, Alberta a judge released a man on a conditional sentence after he fired a .22 calibre sawed-off rifle at his wife but he missed. He received an 18 month conditional sentence to be served in the community.

In a B.C. case a man who confessed to sexually assaulting his babysitter once a week for three years from the time she was 11 was excused from serving any time in jail.

In Nova Scotia a convicted wife beater received a conditional sentence. In Ontario another man pleaded guilty to carrying a pellet rifle while assaulting and forcibly confining his estranged wife in her Mississauga home while his children watched. His punishment was an 18 month conditional sentence through which he was to live with his parents and stay at least a kilometre away from his wife and children, despite the fact that his wife believes he will return to kill her some day and the children remain fearful of even seeing their father.

A B.C. man was convicted of two counts of indecent assault and three counts of gross indecency. The victim was a child he helped raise from the age of three months and the sexual assaults began when she was three and ended when she was thirteen. This man was spared jail time on a conditional sentence.

In another B.C. case a man who threatened, raped and sodomized a 38-year old woman with the handle of racquetball racquet received a conditional sentence exempting him from serving two years in jail. The sentence was appealed and the offender eventually received a sentence of two years in jail less time served; in other words, just a few months in jail for that horrendous crime. The appeal itself was a drain of resources.

We are not talking about fearmongering here. We are talking about legal precedents. These are just a few of the examples of phenomena occurring with increased frequency. In any of these cases I find it impossible to believe that any reasonable and feeling human could consider that these offenders should not go to jail for their crimes. The victims of these criminals deserve better. It sends the message that despite the pain and suffering resulting from the violent trauma they have endured society does not feel it is worthy of punishment for the offender.

Imagine how this must feel to the victims of these crimes. Many victims have compared an inadequate sentence to enduring the attack all over again. Unfortunately in some cases an inadequate sentence may actually mean the attack will occur again. This is certainly a very real possibility for victims of domestic violence and sexual crimes.

A woman whose husband, ex-husband or boyfriend has beaten or raped her and is released on a conditional sentence lives every day in fear of that happening.

Since he is not in jail he is able to strike again. As we have seen, once these offenders are obsessed with the intent to harm their victim the restrictions imposed under conditional sentencing are not much deterrence, little deterrence if any at all.

The two fundamental reasons for sentencing are punishment and deterrence. Fair and just sentences are required to denounce unlawful conduct, deter offenders and others from committing criminal offences, separate offenders from society when necessary, provide reparations for damages and promote a sense of responsibility in offenders and an acknowledgement of the harm done to victims and the community.

What deterrence is there for a convicted drug trafficker granted a conditional sentence? The trafficker has already shown a preference for profit over the welfare of children and other users. What part of a conditional sentence could possibly convince that person to give up their trade? They are immediately back out on the streets on a conditional sentence. The best source of income they know is to continue pushing drugs. There is certainly no deterrence. As for fair punishment, is a ticket to freedom justifiable for an individual motivated by greed through the physically harmful exploitation of others? I ask that question to the government.

The sentences handed down in these cases and many others across Canada have created even more of a backlog in our justice system, as the legal wrangling ensues and appeal after appeal is initiated.

Keeping in mind what the former justice minister said about Bill C-41, making the sentencing process easier for the courts, and keeping in mind what the current justice minister said about leaving the subject of conditional sentencing up to appeal courts, listen to what the appeal courts have to say about conditional sentencing and parliament's role in it. An Ontario appeal court judge stated: “The new sentencing direction set by parliament requires that the courts give these provisions a large and liberal construction and wherever possible the court should resort to the community sentence option”.

“Parliament clearly envisioned that a conditional sentence would be available even in cases of crimes of violence that are not punishable by a minimum term of imprisonment. Parliament also contemplated that the conditional sentence would be available even where, absent appropriate controls, there may be some risk of reoffending”.

So much for the certainty in sentencing the justice minister claimed to have come with Bill C-41. So much for the current justice minister's belief that parliament did not intend for conditional sentences to be granted for violent and sexual offenders.

What we really have is a wide ranging legal interpretation of parliament's intent and tremendous ambiguity. My motion is a method to remedy this situation by instating more specifications in the Criminal Code on conditional sentencing. The B.C. court of appeal agrees. In a August 1997 decision the B.C. court of appeal ruled that violent offenders are entitled to serve time in the community under conditional sentences: “If parliament had intended to exclude certain offences from consideration under section 742.1, it could have done so in clear language”.

That is plainly and clearly an invitation for this House to enact clear language and to provide more certainty for conditional sentencing under section 742.1 of the Criminal Code. I believe we and this government have an obligation to do so.

Let us not get into blame and partisan finger pointing. Let us just fix it. We owe that to Canadians and we owe that to the victims of crime. Canadian courts are already bogged down in legalities and appeals. If it truly was the intention of Bill C-41 to relieve the confusion, we must ensure the conditional sentencing is not a further source of backlog in the courts.

Since parliament is responsible for initiating this ambiguity, parliament must also rectify the situation. This motion was to send a clear message that we have a flexible and responsive democracy. It is my hope that even though my motion has not been deemed votable other similar initiatives such as the motion debated by my hon. colleagues today, or even a legislative initiative by the government, will ultimately right this injustice.

Division No. 158 May 25th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, he had his opportunity to speak. Now he is heckling me, trying to throw me off track when I am trying to drive home the message to the viewing public that there are fallacies contained in his prepared speech that probably came out of the minister's office or the Prime Minister's office and was handed to him a few minutes before he walked into the Chamber.

He stood and read it. If he really wants to debate the millennium fund and how much support it has, then why do we not have a debate about that instead of him standing and reading a prepared speech?

The fact is that the millennium fund is going to be a disgrace. It is going to be a failure. Why? The reason is simple. We pointed it out during the budget debate. I am sure the pages watching this debate today will be interested in this because, once again, what we see is that the Liberal government wants to differentiate between Canadians. It wants to set up two classes, just as it has on the hepatitis C issue. It wants to have two classes of victims. It will compensate some of the people. The government says it is a caring government, that it will compensate the post-1986 victims. The ones between 1986 and 1990 will be compensated, but the ones before will not be compensated.

The hon. member across the way who just spoke was bragging about how the millennium fund will help 100,000 students. Is that not great? But the fact of the matter is that there 1.6 million post-secondary students: 400,000 are full time students and the rest are part time students. Do the math. The students are doing the math: 100,000 out of 400,000.

Once again this Liberal government wants to differentiate. Which will be the lucky quarter of the full time students who will get the scholarships? The government will decide which of those young students will get the scholarships. If they belong to the Young Liberals of Canada they might get a scholarship. Somehow the government is going to differentiate and decide who gets the scholarships.

That is not totally true. The hon. member who spoke before me said that there is going to be one student on the board. I am sure the government can find one Liberal student, but after this maybe not.

The fact is, there is no budget surplus to help Canadians in a unified way because of the false accounting practices of this government. That is the fact. This millennium fund is the latest example of that. The finance minister has put $2.5 billion into the 1998 budget. He has built it in, but he has not spent the money yet. The money will be spent down the road.

The auditor general on March 18 responded to a threatening letter from finance officials by saying “I believe the change will open the door for governments to influence reporting results by simply announcing intentions in their budgets and then deciding what to include in the deficit or surplus after the end of the year once preliminary numbers are known”.

The facts are very clear. The government is trying to separate students. It is trying to pit student against student. Very clearly during the last election campaign, and we are nearing the first anniversary of this new government since the June 2 election a year ago, we laid out our plan on how we would help all students. We did not hear anything back then about a millennium fund. This is something that the government has come up with to pit student against student. It will help a quarter of them. What about the other three-quarters who are seeing tuition costs rising?

The fact is, these students cannot afford huge increases in the cost of obtaining their education. The Liberal government with its millennium fund is effectively bringing down a subsidy for people like Bill Gates because of the huge brain drain of our brightest young students. They get their education here and end up going to work for companies like Microsoft. The richest man in the world is getting a subsidy courtesy of the Liberal government because it has refused to address fundamental issues like high taxes that drive our young people away from our country to seek employment in the United States where taxes are more reasonable.

That is a fundamental issue that this government is not addressing and the government refuses to address it.

Division No. 158 May 25th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I had fully expected to have my speech interrupted by question period. That seems to be my lot in life, to rise just before the start of QP. However, with this sudden unexpected turn of events that is not going to happen today and I will speak earlier than I had originally intended.

There are a couple of fundamental issues which I wish to address in speaking to Bill C-36, and specifically the amendments put forward in Group No. 1 by the Bloc Quebecois.

First of all, the very fundamental issue that we are dealing with in this very shortened debate that we are going to have today is the issue of time allocation. The Liberals, once again, have cut off debate for the 41st time since 1994. It is despicable. I think there is rising resentment across the country due to the fact that there is no democracy in this Chamber, the very place that is supposed to be the heart of democracy.

Perhaps the government has done this because it has decided that it wants a longer summer break. Perhaps the backbenchers put pressure on cabinet and on the Prime Minister to ensure they get a long enough time to flip burgers and go to barbecues in their ridings. While that is important work for an MP, no doubt, the fact is that the main thrust should be to debate legislation in this Chamber.

We have seen this so many times in the past. When the opposition parties start to really get to this government and start to hold it accountable on important national issues like its complete failure to address the reform of the Young Offenders Act or the issue of compensation for all victims of hepatitis C, what does this government do? It runs for cover by invoking time allocation, by bringing down closure to cut off debate. In this case what we see is the cutting off of debate on a whole long list of amendments to this very important bill. The Group No. 1 amendments alone constitute over a dozen motions. How can these types of motions be adequately addressed when debate has been limited?

Not only do they want to cut off debate, they are heckling and directing inappropriate comments at opposition speakers who stand here today wanting to hold this government accountable to the people of Canada. They direct those comments at us to distract us from the little time that we are allowed to speak on this bill.

This group of amendments specifically deals with the millennium fund. I listened in somewhat stony silence as the hon. member opposite—

Mackenzie-Papineau Battalion May 12th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I rise this evening on a matter of equity for all Canadian farmers.

On February 19 and on subsequent occasions in the House I asked the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food why he has not extended disaster relief to farmers in the Peace River region of British Columbia and Alberta who do not qualify under the disaster financial assistance arrangements.

These farmers have endured two devastating years of crop losses due to excess moisture. These arrangements are known as the DFAA. Farmers in the maritimes who suffered last summer under the worst draught in a decade have also been denied disaster relief by the federal government.

Throughout the past two years we have seen special disaster relief programs set up outside the DFAA on four different occasions. The precedent has been set. The federal government has shown that compassion and compensation are available outside the DFAA criteria.

For the Saguenay and the Red River floods special subsidiary programs were established outside the DFAA for farmers suffering losses. More recently the federal government shelled out an extra $50 million again outside the DFAA for part time Quebec farmers with losses resulting from this January's ice storm. Then again in March the minister of agriculture proudly proclaimed an additional $20 million in federal funds outside the DFAA for part time Ontario farmers with losses from the ice storm. These were farmers who do not qualify and did not qualify under the regular DFAA rules.

Let me point out that in each of these four cases farmers were deserving of the special arrangements that were made to get them through the devastation caused by these disasters. What is difficult to understand, however, is that the government will not apply the same rules and compassion to all disaster besieged farmers. They have done it not once, not twice or three times but four times.

The federal government has indicated that when the DFAA is not sufficient, when it does not adequately provide financial disaster relief to farmers, the rules can be changed and special programs can be established.

For Peace River and maritime farmers the DFAA is insufficient to meet their needs. The minister of agriculture has stated in the House that these farmers have been treated exactly the same for coverage as farmers in other areas. This is simply not true. Until Peace River and maritime farmers receive the same kind of subsidiary assistance programs as their counterparts have in the Saguenay region, Manitoba, Quebec and Ontario, this injustice will continue.

These are the simple facts. In trying to justify his inequitable treatment of these farmers the minister has also indicated to the House that special subsidiary programs have not been put in place, particularly in Alberta and B.C., simply because those provinces have not asked for it. He made this ridiculous excuse even though the $50 million special subsidiary Quebec program was established unilaterally by the federal government without the co-operation of the Quebec government.

I was pleased to see recently that the Alberta minister of agriculture, the hon. Ed Stelmach, called his bluff. He formally asked the federal agricultural minister that a special subsidiary program be established for Alberta farmers in the Peace River region.

I have just learned that Minister Stelmach's request has been denied. I am unaware of what excuse the minister of agriculture used other than maybe his compassion does not exist west of Manitoba.

The truth is that the government is making up the rules as it goes along. If it is to design special subsidiary programs to address Quebec and Ontario farmers who do not qualify under the regular DFAA rules, it should change the criteria for western and eastern farmers as well.

Canada Labour Code May 12th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, before question period I was speaking from a farmer's perspective to Motions Nos. 18, 20, 22 and 23.

I was trying to speak from a farmer's perspective, having farmed for close to 20 years in the British Columbia Peace River region, growing grain, grass seed and oilseed. I was remarking on how angry farmers become when they see the shipments of grain which are supposed to be freely flowing through the ports on to ships for shipment to our foreign markets, our overseas customers, delayed and held up in some cases for extended periods of time and the resultant cost that ultimately the farmers and the country pay.

I have heard from quite a number of farmers who grow these crops, the six standard grains, wheat, barley, oats, rye, flax and canola which I am assuming are included under this definition of exclusion from any possible strike action at the ports. They are quite concerned because they want to see this bill proceed so that they do receive that protection.

The end result is that we are going to be enshrining inequity and unfairness with the passage of Bill C-19 as it is presently written. That is why the official opposition has put forward Motions Nos. 22 and 23. It is to drop the inclusion pertaining simply to the standard grain crops. We feel that it discriminates.

I have not heard the answer from the government benches on whether specialty crops would be included under this protection. A lot of farmers are growing so-called specialty crops. Lentils, peas, fava beans, sunflower, safflower, these types of crops are being grown on increasing acreage across the land. In particular I am speaking about western Canada. I wonder if they are protected under this same clause. I do not think so. I think this clause simply pertains to the standard grains.

As we expand these markets for these specialty crops the bill is going to discriminate against some producers and thereby pit farmer against farmer when there are strikes or lockouts at the ports.

Motions Nos. 18 and 20 put forward by Reform have been open to attack, in particular from members of the fourth party, the NDP, saying they are unfair because they pertain to expansion of this restriction of strikes to protect the national economy.

In other words, if it can be shown that a strike or lockout has a profound impact on the national economy, it would not be allowed. Because of that, members of the NDP have suggested that we are being unfair to the unions and that no strikes would be allowed.

In fairness to their arguments, we cannot consider Motions Nos. 18, 20, 22 and 23 in isolation. We must consider them in tandem with the Group No. 8 motions, which have not yet been debated. These deal with Reform's proposal for final offer selection arbitration.

To make my point I refer to Hansard and quote the hon. member for Winnipeg Centre on February 10, 1998:

In the province of Manitoba where I am from we actually had final offer selection legislation for a number of years.

The actual fact is in Manitoba FOS was used very sparingly. In fact, the Manitoba labour relations board received only 97 applications in all the time that it was legislation in that province. Of those 97 applications only 7 were ever ruled on by an FOS selector or arbitrator. Four went to the union package and three were in favour of the company in those rulings. In the vast majority of cases, 72 in all, the application was withdrawn because the parties returned to the bargaining table and found a satisfactory resolution by more convention means.

The point I am making is that by his very admission, the hon. member from the New Democratic Party is saying that final offer selection works. In 72 of those cases the parties returned to the bargaining table and ultimately reached a satisfactory resolution to their dispute. The process worked. I add that as further confirmation that the Reform amendments to this legislation deserve serious consideration by all parties. When it comes time to vote on these motions, I urge all members to consider that and vote accordingly.