House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Canada Labour Code May 12th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is unfortunate that every time I get up to speak to important bills it is just before question period. We know that once again my presentation will undoubtedly be interrupted by that frivolous use of an hour of House time.

It is a pleasure to rise today to speak once again to Bill C-19, the labour legislation that is before the House, and specifically to the Group No. 6 amendments.

Motions Nos. 18 and 20 by the official opposition deal with the fact that we are concerned the only provisions for preventing rail or shipping disruptions at the Vancouver port deal specifically with grain.

One might wonder why as the agriculture critic of the official opposition and a grain farmer for close to 20 years in the real world I would be speaking to expand it and why I would not be speaking in favour of this amendment.

While I do favour the fact that it is a small step in the right direction to have a process in place to ensure that the grain continues to flow through the ports, to meet our international commitments and to ultimately reach our foreign customers, the fact remains that it is specific to one commodity. I do not think even farmers would feel that is fair. There are many agricultural commodities other than grain that we ship abroad and on which we have important commitments to our foreign customers. It is very important that those commodities reach our customers.

One can readily see that while a lot of farmers including many in my riding, I am sure, support the particular clause in the legislation they are concerned with fairness and equity. They wonder why they are singled out. There has certainly been a history of rail and shipping disruptions at the ports that have cost the country and specifically farmers very dearly in the past. It has cost them hundreds of thousands of dollars in demurrage charges as ships sit waiting to be loaded. That is ultimately reflected in the final payment that farmers receive from the Canadian Wheat Board.

As a young farmer trying to eke out an existence in the Peace River country I too from time to time was very angry when I would view the ships waiting in the harbour for days and weeks. I knew the mounting demurrage charges. I wanted to jump in my pick-up truck, tear off the 1,000 miles south to Vancouver and load the ships myself. I know many other young and older farmers felt the same way. They would have liked to have just gone down and loaded the bloody grain themselves rather than see it sitting on the wharf and not being shipped.

I see my time is up so I will continue after question period.

Division No. 137 May 12th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. If I am not mistaken, I believe right now we are supposed to be debating Group No. 3 amendments at report stage of this very important bill, not talking about what happened in the last parliament.

Dna Identification Act May 11th, 1998

Madam Speaker, it is a pleasure for me to address the amendment in Group No. 3 to Bill C-3. At the outset I would like to state that this particular amendment addresses two real concerns that I hear constantly from Canadians as I travel across Canada and throughout my riding.

One is the whole issue of the privacy of the individual; the privacy of individual Canadian citizens. The second issue concerns sufficient deterrence to dissuade Canadians who might break the law in some fashion. In this particular case we are talking about those who might reveal information contained in DNA sampling. We want to make the threshold of the penalty sufficiently high enough to ensure that people will be dissuaded from releasing that type of information.

Very clearly, as my hon. colleague for Surrey North just noted, during testimony when the justice committee was reviewing Bill C-3 there were a number of concerns brought forward by witnesses dealing with these two fundamental issues. One concern is privacy. How will the DNA samples be protected to ensure they will not be used in a manner in which they are not intended to be used? We have seen cases in the past dealing with income tax and other issues whereby government agencies obtained certain information about Canadian citizens which was ultimately leaked into the public arena. A growing concern for Canadian citizens is their fundamental right to privacy. One of the major stumbling blocks in this DNA legislation is the need to convince Canadians that it will be used appropriately and properly and that the legislation is in place to protect the well-being of society, because there is an inherent distrust.

I would suggest that with the advent of things like Bill C-68, the gun registration, there is a growing inherent distrust of government on the part of the average Canadian citizen. There are some good reasons for that. Citizens have seen some of their fundamental rights continuously eroded, continuously chipped away by big government. Big government knows best. Big government is going to look after us from the cradle to the grave. We had some speeches on this very point in the preceding debate on Bill C-26.

We have to ensure that the concerns about the right to privacy are adequately addressed. How are we going to ensure that? Simply put, as my hon. colleague from Surrey North just said, deterrence has to be sufficient. Any individual who would break the law and reveal that information has to be dissuaded from doing it. We want to have the penalties sufficient to deter them from doing it. I often refer to the system not as a criminal justice system unfortunately but as a legal system. Too often we see in our criminal justice system that it is not meeting the needs of the average Canadian.

The system is failing. A large part of that is because there is inadequate punishment for crimes. We need some minimal sentences. We need some sentences that truly deter those who would break the law.

We have seen in the last couple of years farmers receive more punishment for trucking a load of grain across the U.S. border and selling their own product without getting the necessary Canadian Wheat Board permits than someone who commits rape, someone who preys on the most vulnerable in our society, the women and children. It is disgusting that people can get away with conditional sentencing. Those people are not deterred whatsoever from committing heinous crimes against the most vulnerable members of society.

This Liberal government continues to do nothing to address the issue of conditional sentencing and the need for minimal sentences to deter these individuals. This is absolutely appalling.

We have contained in Group No. 3 a proposal that deserves serious consideration. We want to increase this penalty from two years to five years to make it sufficient to hopefully deter anyone from doing such things and, perhaps more important, to ensure Canadians can have confidence that the government is serious about preventing this information from getting out.

These Group No. 3 amendments deserve serious consideration and I urge all members to do exactly that.

Canada Grain Act May 11th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure for me to speak to the amendments in Group No. 2, put forward by my hon. colleague from the Progressive Conservative Party.

I note at the outset that these amendments, Motions Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 6, as put forward by my hon. colleague from the fifth party, clearly outline the need for voluntary participation in this levy that is going to be imposed on producers of special crops in western Canada.

When the commodity groups appeared before the standing committee on agriculture almost unanimously their one greatest concern was the fact that, despite the premise that the levy or the check-off would be voluntary, the fact is that it is mandatory upfront.

I just want to explain this to everyone watching the debate today so they clearly understand what this means. When the producer hauls a truckload of the designated special crops to the delivery point, the levy of 38 cents per $100 will be deducted regardless of whether he or she opts out of the check-off; in other words, does not want to participate in the insurance plan.

As my hon. colleague from the Conservative Party just said, very clearly this is a form of negative option billing. In this case the producer has no option but to have that levy deducted from his or her paycheque.

At the start of the year he or she can apply to the agent, the Canadian Grain Commission, which is going to be administering this fund, stating that they do not want to participate and they want their levy money returned to them following the completion of the crop year.

The way the bill is constituted, they then have to keep track of how much would be deducted off of each and every truckload and each and every designated commodity because they may grow more than one of the special crops. They have to keep track of that and then at the end of the year or at a designated time set up by the agent apply for a refund.

There was some concern expressed at committee, both for the need to have this voluntary upfront and if it does have to be this negative option billing process that the producer should only have to let his or her views be known once. In other words, if they wanted to opt out they should not have the administrative burden of keeping track throughout the year and tallying it all up at the end of the year, similar to how they now have to keep track of the GST and apply for a refund.

Without fail, when the producer groups appeared before the committee they said this was their greatest concern. Did the government listen? Unfortunately, no.

Amendments that I had put forward on behalf of the official opposition at committee were voted down by the Liberals on the standing committee for agriculture. The amendments that I introduced at committee were virtually identical to the ones put forward by my hon. colleague now at report stage. Appearing before the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food on April 21 were eight commodity groups: the Alberta Pulse Growers Commission, the Manitoba Pulse Growers Association, the Saskatchewan Canola Growers, the Saskatchewan Farmer Consultations for SCRIP, the Saskatchewan Pulse Growers, the Western Barley Growers, the Western Canadian Marketers and Processors Association and the Western Canadian Wheat Growers Association.

If memory serves me correctly, with the possible exception of the Western Canadian Marketers and Processors, all of the witnesses appearing expressed the same concern about the way in which this levy would be collected. In other words, there would be an additional administrative burden placed on farmers. They would not be able to opt out, in a one-time opting out, whereby they could say “I have looked at this. I have studied it. I understand that the government is moving to endeavour to have insurance for all of the special crops buyers and dealers to ensure that in the event one of them were to go bankrupt the producer, if he or she had speciality crops in storage with that particular dealer, would be covered”. Why is the industry interested in making some changes in this area? As we have heard, there is a concern out there that there are a number of unlicensed small dealers, small buyers, and that farmers in some cases may be unaware they are not protected. In other words, these dealers, these buyers of the speciality crops, are possibly unlicensed and therefore have not put up a bond to protect the producer, to protect the farmer, in the event of bankruptcy.

The government wants to implement this process. It will mean more regulation. All dealers and buyers will have to be licensed, for which of course there will be a licence fee, and all of them will have to be insured.

We heard from a number of producers about this. The problem is that once again we see big government making decisions for the producers. Instead of the old adage “buyer beware”, possibly we could have “seller beware” and allow the producer to make a conscious choice. Perhaps he or she could derive a bit more money, a few more dollars per pound or per bushel or per tonne, whatever the case may be, for their product if they were to take the risk of selling that product to an unlicensed, uninsured, unprotected buyer or dealer.

If there was a substantial amount money involved the producer might not want to take the risk. For example, they may be shipping carloads of a commodity. We could be talking about hundreds of thousands of dollars. If they did not want to take that risk, they would then ensure that they sold their product or had it in storage with a dealer or buyer who was insured, who was bonded, so they would be protected in the unlikely event that the particular company were to go broke. I say unlikely because the instances of these corporations, these dealers, going broke is very, very rare.

Unfortunately there is a real lack of evidence as to whether this process, this check-off to ensure that all dealers and buyers are insured and licensed, is going to be a great boon for the special crops industry. Certainly the government would like everyone to believe that this is going to promote the industry. However there is no real evidence that this will happen.

In some quarters there has been some evidence to suggest that it will provide a disincentive for good business practices by these dealers. Presently if a sizeable bond has to be put up, there is an incentive built in to ensure they operate in as efficient and effective manner as possible and to ensure that they do everything to keep from going bankrupt. If they go bankrupt, of course they will lose the sizeable bond they put up. Now they will be working with an insurance fund where the farmers are paying for the insurance. They will not be putting up any bond whatsoever. Therefore, it is no wonder dealers and agents are in favour of this legislation.

Canada Grain Act May 11th, 1998

moved:

Motion No. 1

That Bill C-26, in Clause 7, be amended by replacing line 42 on page 5 with the following:

“Special Crops Board referred”

Motion No. 5

That Bill C-26, in Clause 7, be amended by replacing line 24 on page 6 with the following:

“Crops Board may be entitled”

Motion No. 7

That Bill C-26, in Clause 7, be amended by replacing line 10 on page 7 with the following:

“49.02 (1) The Minister shall establish a”

Motion No. 8

That Bill C-26, in Clause 7, be amended by replacing lines 11 to 13 on page 7 with the following:

“Board of Directors, referred to as the Special Crops Board, within six months after the coming into force of this section, composed of not more than nine directors appointed by the Minister, chosen from a list provided by officially registered special crops commodity groups, for”

Motion No. 9

That Bill C-26, in Clause 7, be amended by replacing line 16 on page 7 with the following:

“(2) The Special Crops Board”

Motion No. 10

That Bill C-26, in Clause 7, be amended by replacing line 24 on page 7 with the following:

“Special Crops Board shall be”

Motion No. 11

That Bill C-26, in Clause 7, be amended, in the English version only, by replacing line 29 on page 7 with the following:

“the Special Crops Board such”

Madam Speaker, I wish I could say at the outset that it is a pleasure for me to rise to speak to Bill C-26 this morning.

Despite the pleas of opposition members during second reading debate on March 27 to the government to actually listen to producers, to farmers, to the special crops producers themselves when this bill was being considered at committee, the government failed to implement the very amendments that the producer groups wanted almost unanimously. I speak primarily about the issue of the negative option billing.

The way Bill C-26 is presently constituted, the check-off or the levy from producers' cheques when they haul in a load of special crops will be mandatory despite what the government says and despite the fact that producers wanted it to be voluntary. It is only voluntary by nature of negative option billing. In other words, the producer must at the beginning of the crop year state that he or she does not want their levy to be put into the pool to provide for the insurance of the buyers and then keep track of how much is collected off their crops during the year and submit those receipts at the end of the year.

There was an amendment at committee stage put forward by the government and the parliamentary secretary implied that the producer would now only have to apply once during the year in order to opt out. I do not see that in the way the amendment is written. It is a small step in the right direction in that it clarifies that the Canadian Grain Commission, acting as the agent for this fund, must reimburse the producer if he or she opts out.

The only substantive amendment made at committee stage that was passed, just to bring the viewers at home and the industry up to speed, was that the Liberal dominated agricultural standing committee dropped the possible future inclusion of the six standard grains: wheat, barley, oats, rye, flax and canola.

There was some concern in the industry in western Canada that at some time in the future this levy on special crops could be expanded to the standard grains. Fortunately the government saw the wisdom of clarifying that and actually excluded them. Unfortunately the government did not show the same wisdom when we were debating Bill C-4, the changes to the Canadian Wheat Board Act. It should have done that to exclude any grains other than barley and wheat which are presently under the control of the Canadian Wheat Board.

What does Bill C-26 do? It establishes a system of licensing and insuring special crops dealers and buyers. It moves from the present system whereby the buyers and the dealers have to put up a securities bond to cover the unfortunate eventuality of bankruptcy or receivership to protect the producers. It moves away from the present system of putting up bonds to a system of licensing and insurance.

This bill has been hailed by the government as the greatest thing since sliced bread in the context of what is good for the special crops producers, but there is absolutely no evidence that moving to this new system of licensing and insuring will actually expand the special crops industry.

As well, Bill C-26 makes some changes to the Agriculture and Agri-Food Administrative Monetary Penalties Act. The present enforcement mechanisms in the act are much too limited in scope. Most of the mechanisms are too harsh and costly to impose. In many cases, if there are minor infractions, there is a limit to what the Canadian Grain Commission can do. I think this is a step in the right direction and certainly one that we would support.

As well, Bill C-26 would repeal the 59 year old Grain Futures Act, clearing the way for the Manitoba Securities Commission to assume responsibility for regulating the Winnipeg commodity exchange. I think that, as well, is a step in the right direction and certainly something we would support.

As usual, there are a number of things contained in the bill which the opposition supports. However, I must say at the outset of the debate today that while my Reform colleagues and I, acting as agriculture critics for the official opposition, gave tentative support pending committee stage at second reading, we will withdraw that support and oppose this bill unless the amendments that we have before us in Groups Nos. 1 and 2 today are passed.

What do our motions in Group No. 1 actually do? We feel there is a need for a board of directors made up primarily of farmers versus the advisory board that is presently constituted in Bill C-26. The bill, as presently laid out, allows the minister to appoint an advisory board to assist him with the management of this levy fund and the insurance that will flow from it.

What we have said, what producers have said and what witnesses who appeared before the standing committees have said is that they want to see farmers in control of the fund. They do not want to see it in the control of the administrators, the bureaucrats with the Canadian Grain Commission. They do not want to see it being controlled by possible patronage appointees put forward by the hon. Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food.

Because it is farmers' money, producers' money, that is being taken off their cheques and funnelled into the fund they want to see that controlled by farmers.

We have put forward a group of amendments. First, Motion No. 7 states that the minister must, not may, bring forward a board of directors made up of farmers. Second, these producers would be chosen from names submitted by special grains commodities groups. In other words, farmers would choose those people, put the list forward, and the minister would choose them.

We certainly have seen with the appointment of a past Liberal MP, Ron Fewchuk, the type of political appointment that we do not want to see on this board. There are many other examples. I just use the one that echoes the concern of producers.

With the motions contained in Group No. 1 we see that the people on the advisory board will not have a lot of power. We have seen that with the Canadian Wheat Board. Even if the minister appoints this advisory board made up of nine members, the majority of whom must be producers as it states in the act currently, we heard from producers that they are concerned about not having much power. They are only in an advisory capacity. Certainly we have seen that with the Canadian Wheat Board. That is one reason, because of a lot of pressure from western Canadian grain farmers, that the wheat board is moving toward a board of directors made up primarily of producers, of farmers.

With this group of amendments we want to see the same thing for this special crops advisory board. We want to see it become a managerial board of directors that would have some real power to look after farmers' money drawn from a check-off from their cheques and used to assure grain buyers and grain dealers. It is the farmers' money. Why should they not have control of that rather than bureaucrats or government appointees?

That is basically the thrust of Reform's motions contained in Group No. 1. I certainly urge all members to seriously consider these amendments.

They are amendments not just put forward by the official opposition. We heard from a lot of producer groups concern on the part of farmers. They did not want to see this check-off used because it is mandatory up front, as I already laid out at the start of my remarks. They did not want to see that check-off used in a way that they might feel is detrimental. They want to see it managed as effectively and as efficiently as possible. The only way they can see that happening is if farmers control the fund.

Agriculture May 8th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, as the minister just said, there is a lot of rhetoric about this issue and most of the rhetoric is coming from the minister himself.

The fact is that the United States has threatened to rewrite NAFTA to cap our sales because it believes that the compulsory nature of the Canadian Wheat Board allows the Canadian Wheat Board to dump unfairly priced wheat into the United States.

We need to know what exactly the government will do to protect the future of wheat sales going to the U.S. Will the government do something or will it just continue to spout rhetoric?

Canada Labour Code May 7th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am sure the viewing audience at home this afternoon appreciates that explanation. It is sort of similar to groundhog day. As long as there is a shadow showing you are considered to be in the Chamber and participating in the debate.

I appreciate the comments of the hon. Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Labour. She has been present throughout the day, diligently taking notes, I am sure, as individual members of the opposition have actually addressed the amendments that have been put forward.

As I address this amendment that deals with democracy, a fundamental premise for the entire nation, and the fact that the will of the majority is supreme, I am reminded of the dilemma that faced our nation during the most recent Quebec referendum and how the official opposition and opposition members tried to get the Prime Minister of the country and the government of the day to state what they considered to be a strong enough no vote. Was it 50% plus one, or was it something else? The Prime Minister never clearly said what he would consider to be a strong no vote or a legitimate yes vote. Was it 50% plus one or not?

In the legislation we see that the government, when it suits its needs, is quite prepared to accept 35%. That is a problem. What we are saying is that if it is the will of a group of employees, then a secret ballot should be held. If it is the clear will of the majority of those employees that a union should represent their interests, then that is the way it should be. But if it is the will of the majority of those employees that they do not wish to be represented by a particular union that is trying to organize in their particular industry, then that should also be the determining factor in whether or not that union is actually certified.

I have some personal experience in this. One of the jobs I had as a young man many, many years ago was working for a company in the oil and gas industry in northeastern British Columbia, in the region of the country that I come from. At that time the company was called West Coast Transmission. It was in the business of transporting natural gas through a series of pipelines through northeastern British Columbia down to Vancouver and points south. There was quite a debate during my time of employment with that company about whether the needs of the employees of West Coast Transmission could be better met through representation by a union. It never actually came to a vote because it was very clear that the majority of those employees, after some very careful deliberation, ascertained that it was not in their best interests and they did not wish to be represented by a union.

There is a company in the small village of Taylor, which is in my riding, just south of my hometown of Fort St. John. It is a pulp and paper company that is non-unionized. Those employees felt they did not need the representation of a union.

Very clearly, with respect to this particular amendment, we see a need that democracy should reign supreme when it is time for workers to decide on who will or will not represent their best interests.

Canada Labour Code May 7th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, just so that everyone, not only those in the Chamber but the viewers at home watching the proceedings on television this afternoon clearly understand, do the House rules stipulate that when there is a quorum call the individuals have to be seated in the Chamber, or is it enough just to poke your head in the curtains that surround the Chamber?

Canada Labour Code May 7th, 1998

A member opposite is saying that we had to get something as insignificant as question period out of the way of my presentation. It is too bad it had to be interrupted. I am sure I would agree with the hon. member. The key, despite all the heckling from the opposite side, is that it is question period.

As we well know, after having been here close to five years, it certainly is not answer period. I think the people watching on television understand that now.

When I was interrupted by question period I was speaking about the need for democracy and specifically the need for democracy in Bill C-19. I was using a bit of a comparison about how even in this Chamber sometimes we do not see democracy.

In my remarks I was trying to assist those watching the debate at home to understand what all of these quorum calls mean. When there is government legislation before the House, the responsibility rests with the government to have its members present to listen to the debate, to the amendments, to the rationale behind them and to participate in the debate as well.

Canada Labour Code May 7th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure for me to resume my presentation after the interruption for question period.