House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Petitions September 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I have a petition to present today signed by over 200 of the constituents of Prince George—Peace River. They note that on the same day that the Canadian Radio Television-Telecommunications Commission refused to license four religious broadcasters it did indeed license the pornographic Playboy channel television service.

The petitioners believe that Canadians have a constitutional right to freedom of religion, conscience and expression. Therefore they call upon parliament to review the mandate of CRTC and direct the CRTC to administer a new policy which will encourage the licensing of religious broadcasters.

Supply September 22nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I will certainly share with him my thoughts in that regard and he will be better off.

The reality is that legislation like Bill C-68 and its forerunners are step by step and incrementally discourage gun ownership in Canada today. That is what it amounts to.

It is the same as any other law passed in this place that make it more and more onerous on private citizens to own certain property. The more laws and the more difficult we make it for people to own something, obviously there will be less and less people who own it.

This legislation, as its forerunners, goes even further than that. The government can arbitrarily decide that certain makes, models and types of firearms are suddenly on the prohibited list. No one on that side has ever adequately explained how that does not constitute confiscation of private property. That is exactly what it is. At least the people in rural Canada and the people of Prince George—Peace River know that is exactly what it is.

Supply September 22nd, 1998

With an axe. He is a very brave individual.

The reality is that many lives would be saved. Earlier on in the debate individuals across the way were talking about how it does not matter how much it costs if we just save one life. I heard that statement across the way. It does not matter how much it costs as long as we save one life. What I was talking about was saving lives as well. Not every individual should probably carry a firearm in every situation. However, the reality is that people who travel outdoors and know how to responsibly use firearms because they have been trained or have been raised with firearms should carry firearms to protect themselves. There would be less incidents like the one I referred to.

Supply September 22nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, first I would like to know how the individual across the way who posed the question killed the three foot rattlesnake. With a shovel? I am not sure.

Supply September 22nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure for me to rise today to address the motion put forward by my colleague concerning gun registration, specifically Bill C-68 which was about to be enacted in a couple of short weeks. It actually will not be fully put into place until December 1. That is what we have been told in the last few days.

I recognize that 10 minutes is a very short time to address such an important issue. When I say important issue, I really want to target the majority of my comments today specifically to my riding and more generally to the difference in how this issue is viewed by people residing in urban centres and by rural people.

Regarding the whole issue of “gun control” as my colleague from the fifth party just mentioned, the reality is that we who are questioning Bill C-68 are not talking about no gun control. It is not a question of gun control versus no gun control. We already have some of the most stringent gun control legislation and laws in the western world in place in Canada. My colleague from Esquimalt—Juan de Fuca talked about that very eloquently.

What I want to do in the short time I have is to try to educate some of our urban brethren as to what really constitutes the difference on how this issue is viewed by rural residents in Canada and those in the more urban centres, specifically some of the vast urban centres and the crime problems in places like Toronto, Vancouver and Montreal.

I noticed that in the debate today a number of members of parliament in representing their views have used specific instances on both sides of the argument. I want to talk very briefly about one tragic incident that happened in my riding. The hon. member for Hamilton—Wentworth who just spoke from the government side used a very tragic instance from his recollection where an individual used a firearm.

I have one on the other side of this issue. I would like to quote from the text of the Vancouver

Province

newspaper that carried the account of this tragic incident on August 17, 1997, just a little over a year ago.

Her husband died a hero—that much Angela Kitchen knows.

But the sudden nature of Ray Kitchen's death and the random way fate struck didn't make any sense to her yesterday.

One minute, the Fort Nelson father was stopping for a swim with his daughter and her friend on a hot day. The next minute, hearing the cries of a mauled woman trying to protect her son from a rampaging black bear, Kitchen was throwing himself into a situation that, as an outdoorsman, he knew could mean death.

The bear tore him apart. He died, as did the woman he ran to help.

“Someone mentioned that he died a hero. I'm really proud of him for that”, a tearful Angela Kitchen said yesterday. “It's just so hard”.

The savage attack Thursday night also left the woman's son and a 28 year old Calgary man injured.

It occurred as Patti Reed McConnell, 37, and her two children, Kelly, 13, and Kristin, 7, were out walking at Liard Hot Springs Provincial Park, 310 kilometres northwest of Fort Nelson. The family were on their way to Alaska from their home in Paris, Texas to start a new life in a land McConnell had fallen in love with.

It goes on to describe the incident in more detail.

More deaths were averted in this tragic incident. How were they averted? Because one individual at that scene had a firearm. It happened to be an American tourist that was stopping in this location, Liard Hot Springs. I am very familiar with this area. When I do my summer tour of my riding, and the riding goes all the way to the Yukon, I travel up the Alaska highway. I stop and talk to the lodge owners along the way. Most MPs on both sides of the House visit their ridings during the summer and they converse with their constituents.

I have often stopped at this hot springs. This was not the first incident of a bear attack or of bear sightings at this hot springs. At this hot springs there is a boardwalk of some 100 yards in length which carries people from the parking lot to the hot springs itself where people bathe.

What happened when this bear attacked those people? Someone had to run back along the boardwalk and find someone who happened to have a firearm in their recreational vehicle. I am not sure whether it was a motorhome or a fifth wheel trailer. An American tourist happened to have a firearm which was stored separately as the storage laws require. They rummaged around and got the ammunition out. This was an elderly gentleman who fortunately gave it to a younger person and said “Take my firearm and go and save some people”. This person rushed back down the walkway and shot the bear with one shot. Unfortunately for Patti Reed McConnell and for Ray Kitchen, my constituent from Fort Nelson, it was too late.

The point I am trying to make is that there is a vast world of difference between ridings such as mine, Prince George—Peace River, and this whole issue of gun control, gun registration and gun storage because what we are relating this to is the people in Toronto who do not understand guns. They do not ever want to understand guns. They do not want to own a gun. They do not understand why anyone would want to own a gun because they have never been in situations like McConnell's and Kitchen's. They have never been placed in those situations.

I was born and raised in Fort St. John in northeastern British Columbia and was a hunter as a young lad. I was raised with and had a strong respect for firearms and know how to handle them, and I can say that I do not understand people like that either. Therein lies the problem. The people in the big urban centres do not understand this issue from the point of view of rural residents. To me that is the fundamental issue.

Reform members throughout this debate, going right back to the time when we were first here, first elected in any numbers back in the fall of 1993, have tried to bring what we believe is some common sense to this issue. We have tried to represent not just the people who have legitimate concerns about safety and the illegal use of firearms in the cities of Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver, Edmonton and Calgary for that matter, but also to represent the very legitimate concerns of law-abiding firearms owners in the rural areas of our country, people who already fervently believe that we have enough gun legislation in this country.

In fact many would argue that we had enough under the old Bill C-17, Kim Campbell's gun legislation that ranges back to the time of the Progressive Conservative government. They would argue that we did not need parts of that legislation or it should not be applied the same in Toronto as it is at Liard Hot Springs in northeastern British Columbia.

Let us take a look at this motion. “That this House condemns the government for its refusal to replace Bill C-68, the Firearms Act, with legislation targeting the criminal misuse of firearms”. I will stop there and not go on to read the rest of it. The rest has certainly been adequately covered by many of my colleagues. Targeting the criminal misuse of firearms.

I want to read again into the record what I said when I introduced a private members' bill to show what Reformers have been actively endeavouring to do since we came to the House. On December 5, 1994, almost four years ago, when I introduced Private Member's Bill C-293 I said:

Today it is my pleasure to introduce the bill to the House. It will increase the minimum mandatory sentence for the use of a gun in the commission of a crime to five years.

Canadians are demanding stiffer sentences for the criminal misuse of firearms but the recently proposed four-year mandatory sentence of the justice minister is only restricted to 10 offences and is not consecutive.

He is merely introducing a minimum sentence of four years for these crimes, and with parole it may be less. Although the tougher sentences in his reaction plan are a step in the right direction, the bill would go even further. It would make the minimum five-year sentence consecutive to any other sentence and would apply to any accomplices who had access to the firearm during the crime or attempted crime whether or not the gun was fired.

Canadians want deterrents and I believe the bill would provide some.

That is concrete action that the Reform Party and indeed many members in a number of parties would like to see. Let us get tough on the criminals who misuse firearms and leave law-abiding firearms owners alone because they are already respecting the law.

Supply September 22nd, 1998

They are not as onerous as ours and they have less crime.

Supply September 22nd, 1998

Yes, we do. We have had it since 1934.

Parliament Of Canada Act June 11th, 1998

Mr. Chairman, dealing with clause 6 of Bill C-47, I was wondering about subclause (6) which deals with the eligibility for this new supplementary severance allowance.

My understanding is that under the existing Members of Parliament Retiring Allowances Act when an MP reaches the age of 55 they qualify for the MP pension. In fact, there is a phase-in period of one year, from 54 to 55, built into the act. When they qualify for the MP pension, they no longer qualify for the standard six-month severance that all members of parliament qualify for, regardless of whether they are in or out of the pension plan.

I wonder if the hon. minister could clarify for us, under clause 6, whether those MPs who are not in the MP pension plan who reach age 55 will qualify for the six-month standard severance, plus the additional supplementary severance allowance at the time they retire, or when they are not re-elected, if they are 55 or over.

Canadian Wheat Board Act June 10th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is 11.10 in the evening and there is a considerable gallery of hecklers across the way who seem to be having grand time contributing little to the debate, I might note, but a lot in the sense of heckling members who are trying to debate a very important western Canadian issue. Despite all this I would like to get back to what my hon. colleague from North Vancouver was asking the member earlier. Why is the government imposing the bill upon western Canadian farmers?

In light of that I am pleased the minister responsible for the Canadian Wheat Board is in the Chamber this evening at 11.10. I would certainly welcome his comments on why they are doing that if he would choose to rise following my colleague's comments.

Canadian Wheat Board Act June 10th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I would like to clear up a couple of misperceptions communicated by the member for Malpeque earlier in the debate.

The first deals with the subamendment I put forward that would grant the auditor general greater flexibility in how he would conduct the audit of the Canadian Wheat Board. The hon. member for Malpeque has suggested that this Senate amendment which calls for this one time audit by the auditor general would satisfy those farmers who are seeking greater transparency and accountability on the part of the Canadian Wheat Board.

He referred to the fact that the very reputable auditing firm Deloitte & Touche currently does the auditing for the Canadian Wheat Board and I recognize that fact. The simple fact that the member does not recognize and never has recognized in all the debates that we have had on this subject is that the auditor general goes far beyond a financial audit. He goes far beyond just counting the beans, as it were, which another auditing firm does, which accountants do.

The hon. member knows that. For him to suggest anything different is ridiculous. One amendment I put forward, the subamendment to the Senate amendments, deals with giving the auditor general far greater flexibility in how he would conduct his audit so that he would look at the actual efficiency of how the Canadian Wheat Board markets wheat and barley in western Canada and also ensure that he reports back to parliament, not simply to the minister and to the board of the directors of the corporation.

I wanted to clear that up and ask for some comments from the hon. member for Elk Island.

As well, the hon. member for Malpeque suggested that this new board of directors that will be comprised of 10 producer representatives of the 15 will have lots of power to control the operation of the Canadian Wheat Board. That is built into the bill, he suggested. He went so far as to reiterate and echo the remarks made by the hon. minister for the Canadian Wheat Board which that minister has often made that the board could always reduce the remuneration of the CEO and thereby have control of the CEO.

I do not know whether the member for Malpeque has ever heard of wrongful dismissal, but if the board of directors were to do that I would suggest that the board of directors would be taken to court by that CEO very quickly because it would be a breach of contract. I am sure that would happen.

I would like the hon. member for Elk Island to comment on that as well.