Mr. Speaker, medical assistance in dying in Canada is now a disaster. In 2024, 16,499 Canadians died by MAID, which was 5.1% of all deaths in Canada in 2024. That is one in 20 Canadians dying by medical assistance in dying. It is an unthinkable number. Compared to other countries, Canada has the highest mortality rate by MAID, followed by the Netherlands and Belgium. How did we get here? We were not supposed to.
In the 2015 Carter versus Attorney General decision, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that Canada's prohibition on physician-assisted suicide violated section 7 of the charter. Attempting suicide has not been a crime in Canada since 1972, but counselling or aiding suicide is still an offence under section 241 of the Criminal Code and carries a maximum penalty of 14 years. In the Carter decision, the Supreme Court held that a blanket prohibition on physician-assisted suicide is contrary to the charter's right to life, liberty and security of a person. The court ruled that medical assistance in dying is permitted for competent adults, and I stress “competent”, who are experiencing enduring and intolerable suffering from a grievous incurable condition, which was the second stipulation. Again, the key phrase was “competent adults”.
Competence requires consent. There are two basic elements to competence. A person must be the age of majority, otherwise they cannot consent, and they must be of sound mind. That is the key. That is why it was so outrageous that the Liberals sought to expand, at some point, MAID to teenagers, and equally repugnant was their attempt to expand MAID to those whose sole underlying condition was mental illness. How can someone who is not of sound mind consent to die? How could we entertain such cruelty that we would administer a lethal injection to someone who may not be able to consent to a lethal injection?
I am blessed in my role as shadow minister for civil liberties. I have a unique perspective on civil liberties, having been born and lived the first eight years of my life in the communist Soviet Union. Section 7, the right to life, liberty and security, is perhaps the most precious right in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. What else could be more important than life, liberty and security of a person? These are the most primal instincts we have as human beings, and I will not second-guess the Supreme Court in Carter. I agree that a consenting individual of sound mind should be able to say, under the right circumstances, “I don't want to suffer anymore. I don't want to lose my dignity. I don't want to subject my loved ones to pain.” It is their life, their liberty and their security, which is often interpreted as a right to their own body, but that is because it is their decision. It is their decision because they are competent to make such a decision and they can grant consent, but if a person is not an adult, or is suffering from mental illness, then how can they grant consent? If there is no consent, then it is no longer medical assistance in dying.
What MAID turned into in Canada is not what it was meant to be. In response to the Carter decision, Canada legalized MAID in 2016, which is for adults who are able to consent and who are experiencing intolerable suffering from a terminal condition that is irreversible. At the time, the law required that death was reasonably foreseeable. That requirement of death being reasonably foreseeable was struck down by the courts, forcing Parliament to expand eligibility further, except the Liberals were liberal, and eligibility was considered for people whose sole underlying condition was mental illness. Thankfully, through Bill C-7, the Criminal Code was amended to include a two-year prohibition on availability of MAID for individuals whose sole underlying condition was mental illness. Then, twice more, in 2023 and 2024, the mental illness exclusion was extended again, moving the deadline to March 2027.
Conservatives have always been on the right side of this question. We fought tooth and nail against the expansion of MAID to teenagers. We fought tooth and nail against MAID for those whose sole medical condition was mental illness, and now we have finally won. We can think about how much worry the emotional roller coaster of the Liberals has put so many families through, worrying that a loved one may not be able to hold on and, god forbid, take their own life.
We have a mental health epidemic in our country. CAMH estimates that 20% of Canadians are suffering from mental illness. That is significantly higher than the global average and puts us in the top tier of countries experiencing mental illness. Twenty-six per cent of Canadians aged 16 to 21 report suffering from poor mental health. That is a catastrophe.
I still maintain that it was our pandemic response, the fact that Canada, and my province of Ontario, had the longest lockdown in the world, that sparked this mental health epidemic that we cannot seem to get out of. I was the only one in this building to publicly oppose the lockdown of 2020-21, albeit that I was in the provincial legislature at the time.
The Liberals wanted to expand MAID to people suffering from mental illness. Thankfully, with this legislation, Bill C-41, they are rolling it back. There are material concerns with respect to the second portion of the bill, which is advance requests, but on mental illness, the Liberals could have just voted for Conservative bills.
They could have voted for Bill C-218, brought by the Conservative member for Cloverdale—Langley City. Her bill would have permanently blocked the expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole medical condition is mental illness, but they voted against it.
What happened to MAID in Canada? In my province, Ontario, patients can wait for more than two years to get an appointment with a psychiatrist. There are cities such as Kingston, where at some point it was three years to get an appointment with a psychiatrist, but they could get track 2 MAID in as little as 90 days. In some cases, for track 1 MAID, there was no wait time at all. This is not what the Supreme Court had in mind in Carter.
We hear horror stories of veterans being told that they are eligible for MAID when all they asked for was basic disability benefits and mental health supports. People are known to be considering MAID in food banks. That is the Prime Minister's economy.
This is why I support my friend's bill, Bill C-260, by the Conservative member for Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan. Bill C-260 would preclude anyone who is not a health care practitioner from offering MAID.
We have a MAID factory in this country, not as an act of compassion, as it was meant to be, but as a standard operating procedure that is not health care or compassion. We have a crisis in mental health and addictions. Imagine the result of this crisis perpetuating itself and extending onto MAID.
We need to rethink the entire MAID regime. I pray for the lives that will be saved because MAID will not be available to individuals whose sole condition is mental illness.
Let us invest in mental health treatment and supports. Let us invest in more doctors, nurses and hospital beds. Let us not allow people who cannot consent to MAID to consent to MAID.