Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. This is not an easy subject to discuss. We are talking about some of the most vulnerable Canadians in our country: people living with mental illness, people suffering from serious medical conditions and families facing some of the most difficult decisions imaginable. The decisions we make in the House will have real, irreversible consequences for these Canadians. That is why we have a responsibility to get it right and to treat the bill with care.
Bill C-41 proposes two very different changes to Canada's laws on medical assistance in dying. The first would permanently exclude mental illness as the sole underlying medical condition for MAID. The second would allow certain Canadians to make advance requests for MAID, which could be carried out after they have lost the ability to provide informed consent. I strongly support the first part of the legislation. However, the second part raises very serious concerns about consent, patient autonomy and the protection of vulnerable Canadians. I believe that these two issues deserve to be considered separately.
Mental illness affects families in every community across this country, including right at home in Hamilton East—Stoney Creek. Whether someone is struggling with depression, post-traumatic stress disorder or other serious mental health conditions, their suffering is very real. However, what troubles me deeply is the idea that someone struggling with their mental health could see medically assisted death presented as an alternative to getting the treatment and support they desperately need. Canadians struggling with mental illness need treatment, resources, support and, above all, hope.
Unfortunately, we have already seen deeply troubling examples of MAID's being proposed to Canadians who are simply trying to get help. In 2022, Canadians learned that a Veterans Affairs employee had inappropriately discussed medical assistance in dying with veterans. One veteran seeking treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury reported that MAID was brought up during his dealings with Veterans Affairs. He was not asking for assistance in dying; he was asking for help. A subsequent Veterans Affairs investigation confirmed four inappropriate MAID discussions. I find it absolutely heartbreaking that even one veteran had to experience something like this. When a veteran reaches out for help, our response should be to provide that help, not to suggest ending their life.
This issue also extends beyond our veterans. In 2023, a woman named Kathrin Mentler went to the Vancouver General Hospital while experiencing a serious mental health crisis. She was struggling with depression and suicidal thoughts. According to her account, during her assessment, a physician asked her whether she had considered medical assistance in dying. The health authority later characterized the discussion is part of a clinical risk assessment rather than an offer of MAID. Regardless of how that conversation was intended, we must recognize the distress it caused someone who had come looking for help. Imagine the courage it takes for someone struggling with suicidal thoughts to reach out and ask for help. Now imagine how devastating it would be to hear MAID raised during that conversation.
When someone is struggling, our job is not to give up on them. Our job is to help them get better. That means improving access to psychiatrists, psychologists, counselling, crisis intervention and long-term mental health support. It means making sure Canadians are not left waiting months to receive treatment when they need help today. That is why I support permanently excluding mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID.
That brings me to the second part of the bill, and this is where I have very serious concerns. Bill C-41 would allow someone diagnosed with a qualifying serious and incurable illness such as Alzheimer's disease to make an advance request for MAID. That request could potentially be carried out after the person has lost the mental capacity to consent. I understand why this is being proposed. I understand that there are Canadians who fear losing their independence, their memories and eventually the ability to make decisions themselves. I recognize that this bill includes eligibility requirements, medical assessments and safeguards, as well as requirements for provincial or territorial legislation, but the existence of safeguards would not mean every ethical question has been answered.
Should consent that was given months or years in advance remain valid when the individual is no longer mentally capable of consenting? There is something particularly concerning about this legislation. Bill C-41 establishes no federal maximum time limit between the signing of the advance request and when it could eventually be carried out. That means a request signed 10, 15 or even 20 years earlier could potentially still be considered, provided the patient meets the eligibility criteria and applicable provincial requirements. Members can think about what that means.
Imagine someone diagnosed with early onset Alzheimer's disease at the age of 50. They make an advance request fearing what their future might look like, but 15 years later, their condition has progressed and they can no longer provide informed consent. Should a decision made 15 years earlier be enough to authorize ending that person's life today? How can we know their wishes have not changed? How can we know the life they are living today is the life they imagined when they signed that request?
People change. Their circumstances change. Their perspectives change. Someone diagnosed with dementia may initially fear that their life will no longer be worth living once their condition progresses, but years later, despite their cognitive decline, they may still experience happiness, comfort, connection and, most importantly, love. How can we be certain that the decision they made years earlier is still the decision they would make today? We are talking about an irreversible decision, and it deserves extreme caution.
Another major concern is the responsibility this legislation would place on medical professionals. Ultimately, it would not be members of Parliament administering these advance requests. It would be doctors and nurse practitioners. I recognize that the bill would protect medical professionals from being compelled to participate, but for those who do, the responsibility is enormous. How does a medical professional determine whether someone who can no longer communicate clearly is experiencing intolerable suffering? How do they distinguish between an involuntary reaction and an attempt to resist?
The bill says that, if a patient clearly demonstrates refusal or resistance, the doctor cannot proceed with MAID, but what happens when their behaviour is unclear? The legislation requires a delay of at least 30 days when the medical professional is uncertain whether the patient is refusing or resisting, but what would waiting 30 days necessarily resolve? Will that resolve that uncertainty? How can we expect doctors and nurse practitioners to interpret someone's final wishes when that individual can no longer provide informed consent?
These are enormous ethical and professional responsibilities. Before Parliament moves forward, we must hear directly from those who would be responsible for administering the legislation. We need to consult doctors, nurses, psychiatrists, palliative care specialists and those who work directly with patients experiencing cognitive decline. We need to understand whether they believe these safeguards are sufficient. We need to understand the consequences if an irreversible mistake were to be made. We cannot simply pass legislation in Ottawa and leave medical professionals to wrestle with these questions on their own.
That is why I believe these two parts of Bill C-41 must be separated. We should move forward with permanently excluding mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID, but advance requests deserve their own legislation, their own debate and a thorough examination. There should be no rush when the consequences are irreversible.
I want to finish with this: Behind every discussion about medical assistance in dying is a real person, a father, a mother, a son, a daughter, a grandparent, someone who is loved, someone whose life matters, someone who may be facing the darkest and most frightening chapter of their life. I think about the veteran struggling with PTSD who simply wants treatment.
We must never allow the lack of resources, the lack of treatment or the lack of support to leave vulnerable Canadians feeling that death is their only option. We must be a country that offers hope to those who are struggling, care to those who are suffering and protection to those who are vulnerable. That is the responsibility we have been entrusted with, and that is the responsibility we must uphold.
I urge the Liberals to consider making these two issues their own separate bills, so we can give both the attention they deserve.