Evidence of meeting #47 for Foreign Affairs and International Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was institutions.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Steil  Director General, Strategy, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
MacKenzie  Director General, International Organizations and Human Rights Bureau, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Larose  Director General, International Security Policy and Strategic Affairs Bureau, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Dufour  Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual
Slaughter  Incoming Dean, School of Public Policy, London School of Economics, As an Individual
Robertson  Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

Thank you.

My questions will be for you, Mr. Robertson.

I want to go a little further with respect to some of your testimony. You mentioned the need for an independent review of UNRWA meeting certain requirements. Could you delineate, if you can, specific milestones that you would insist on UNRWA achieving before being satisfied that aid was going to the appropriate places?

5:55 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

Absolutely. In June 2026, USAID, an enforcement arm of the United States government's office of international trade, referred 101 staff members at UNRWA for investigation because of their links to listed terrorist organizations or to the October 7 Hamas-led terror attack in Israel.

The educational materials, specifically as highlighted by IMPACT-se, that contain the glorification of terror and inciting and hateful rhetoric continue to be utilized in UNRWA schools throughout UNRWA's mandated region. I think we need to start there.

We cannot be investing as a nation in an organization that has failed to reform at the most basic level, to remove those linked to terror from its staff, and that continues to educate the next generation of citizens within its mandated area with materials that are highly problematic, hateful and encouraging of terror.

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

Just to confirm your testimony, UN Watch, your organization and other organizations have absolute proof of hatred and antisemitic subjects being taught through UNRWA. Is that correct?

5:55 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

Yes. The continued use of these problematic materials in certain UN schools is very well documented. I would refer you to the IMPACT-se report that I mentioned in my opening remarks. The links to terror, I believe, are justified by USAID's recommendation this previous summer.

These are not things that are abstract. These are things that are very real. There are 50 recommendations made in the Colonna report. Those recommendations deal specifically with these problems, and yet these problems persist. The question is, why is Canada continuing to invest in a UN agency that has demonstrated it is incapable of reform?

6 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

Thank you.

The next question isn't specific to your organization, and if you don't want to comment, I understand.

Of course, Canada has recognized the Palestinian state, tied on expectations of democratic governance and elections, which have not materialized. Would you like to comment on the fact that the Government of Canada recognized Palestine, based on the fact that—

6 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

If we can pause for a second, how is that connected to international organizations?

6 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

It's been recognized through the United Nations and other multilateral as well as international organizations—

6 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Your question dealt with Canada recognizing a state. How is that connected to international organizations?

6 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

It did that with other countries. There's international recognition. This is an international.... We are dealing literally by definition with multi-nations together recognizing each other. It's hard for me to say that water is wet.

6 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

No, no. You talked about a bilateral issue, Canada recognizing.... I just want to make sure folks keep to the topic. Thank you.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

I think this is very much a topic at the United Nations, at NATO and at various international organizations.

6 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Please continue.

6 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

I think that we see a pattern when we look at Canada's recognition of a Palestinian state and Canada's continued support for UNRWA. Canada's continued support for UNRWA, by GAC's own releases, was contingent on its reform, which GAC alleged it was monitoring closely, yet we haven't seen those reforms undertaken, just as we haven't seen the Palestinian state meet some of the conditions on which recognition was predicated.

I think this is a theme when it comes to international institutions, in that if Canada wants to play a leading role in strengthening these institutions, we need to hold them accountable when they fail to meet the reforms that are expected of them in order for them to continue to receive our funding in the same way that we must hold the international actors accountable when they fail to meet the prerequisites for things like recognition of statehood.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

I don't think anyone denies that there is a humanitarian crisis going on in Gaza right now. Do you have any concerns that the money that's being flowed into Gaza is not going to a humanitarian crisis but to other areas that we would be concerned about?

6 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

I think that the links between UNRWA and listed terrorist organizations, as have been demonstrated by the reports and as have been demonstrated by USAID, certainly raise concerns over what is being done with the donations that UNRWA receives.

This isn't about whether or not there's a humanitarian crisis or whether or not Canada should support the victims of humanitarian crises around the world. This is about whether or not Canada should continue to invest in a UN agency that has demonstrated that it is incapable of reforms that were recommended by a UN-authorized independent review.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Clarke, ON

Are there ways that UNRWA could demonstrate to your organization and other organizations, such as UN Watch, that monies are actually addressing the humanitarian crisis?

6 p.m.

Director, Research and Advocacy, B'nai Brith Canada

Richard Robertson

I think that by undertaking to meaningfully complete the 50 recommendations made in the Colonna report and by being open to having a third party attest to the satisfactory completion of those 50 recommendations, UNRWA would go a long way towards re-establishing its credibility within the international realm, but we simply haven't seen that. It's been two years.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you.

I'm sorry. We're over time.

MP Fortier, you have six minutes.

6 p.m.

Liberal

Mona Fortier Liberal Ottawa—Vanier—Gloucester, ON

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

I'd like to thank all the witnesses for being here today.

Professor Dufour, thank you for joining us. I'm pleased that you are working with my alma mater. It's wonderful to see you in the national capital region.

In your opening remarks, you spoke about the issue of effectiveness, among other things. I'd like you to elaborate on that concept in the context you described, namely that Canada could do more, given that it has stepped back somewhat from multilateral engagement.

You also referred to two points that Professor Sarah‑Myriam Martin‑Brûlé raised with the committee earlier this week about mobilizing Canadian expertise and linguistic capacity. It makes me smile to hear these points raised again. Could you expand on both of them, particularly in terms of how they could strengthen Canada's multilateral presence and effectiveness?

6:05 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

Canada is a middle power, as we know. We therefore have little choice but to practise multilateralism. We cannot operate through power politics. We must work within a multilateral framework and, ideally, one that reflects Professor Slaughter's 10 principles of multilateralism. We're still a long way from that, but I hope we're headed in that direction.

We're living through a major crisis. Some would say we've been in a permanent state of crisis since 1945. Multilateralism certainly has its flaws, but it has also accomplished many remarkable things. We're clearly reaching the end of a cycle, and some form of redefinition is coming. The question is, to what extent? Will every organization be redefined? Probably not. Some organizations function quite well. Generally speaking, the more technical the organization is, the better it functions. The more political the sphere, however, the more difficult it is to achieve effective results.

Why should Canada play a larger role? To what extent would that make the system more effective and efficient? Historically, Canada has proposed the creation of a wide range of institutions and initiatives that ultimately materialized, even when they didn't directly reflect Canada's own interests. That's why I believe Canada must be a key player. When Canada proposed that the UN create the blue helmets, it was not acting out of self-interest but in the interest of international peace. In the 1990s, Canada was the first country to advance the idea of creating a world trade organization to replace the GATT, the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade. European countries later took up the idea and tabled a formal proposal. That organization did not necessarily serve Canada's immediate needs, but we recognized that multilateral trade negotiations had stalled and therefore came up with that idea.

I believe Canada is a country capable of proposing solutions that are not inherently partisan. Of course, we won't advocate measures that run counter to our values or our fundamental interests. However, Canada is a country grounded in the rule of law, inclusion and fairness. It promotes fundamental values that matter deeply to humanity. I therefore believe it's important for Canada to play a role in the redefinition that's now under way. We will only fully recognize that redefinition once it's been completed.

Mona Fortier Liberal Ottawa—Vanier—Gloucester, ON

In the context of redefining some organizations that function reasonably well and others that require reform, do you see opportunities to create new mechanisms? Based on your experience and expertise, is there anything we should be proposing as a new institution or a new way of doing things?

6:05 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

It generally takes a major collapse before new institutions can be created. It has to be a major shock or crisis, like the First World War and the Second World War. Both of those events led to major institutions being established. The World Trade Organization, or WTO, emerged from a shock. There was the shock created by the arrival of newly independent developing countries in the 1960s and 1970s. There was also the shock of the collapse of the Soviet Union in the late 1980s and early 1990s and the creation of numerous new states. Shocks are what give rise to new organizations.

That said, we are currently experiencing an enormous shock: invasions, a pandemic, a tariff war, and the world's leading power questioning institutions and established practices. We're therefore living through a shock that's serving as somewhat of a wake-up call.

We've been talking about reforming the WTO for a long time because we know it needs it. Is it finally time to recognize that we may need to reconsider some principles we once thought were firmly entrenched? At the WTO, decisions are adopted by consensus, but should we rethink that approach? Member states continually challenge this principle. At the same time, they remain attached to it, particularly developing countries, because it gives them a voice equal to that of other countries, even though they may not have the financial resources they wish they had. That may therefore be one area where reform efforts should be focused. In international trade, we often speak of the most-favoured-nation principle and non-discriminatory trade. We're now beginning to ask whether those principles may need to evolve.

Most importantly, trade can no longer be developed in isolation. That much is certain. International trade is my area of expertise, so I tend to speak about it a great deal, but we can't talk about trade without also talking about labour law, respect for fundamental labour standards and the inclusion of women—

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you, Professor Dufour.

6:10 p.m.

Full Professor and Research Chair on Sustainable, Responsible, and Inclusive Trade Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Geneviève Dufour

My apologies. That was a rather long answer. I'm a university professor.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Mr. Brunelle‑Duceppe, you have six minutes.