Thank you, Mr. Herntier.
Mr. Swick, do you have any recommendations for developing a national framework?
Evidence of meeting #50 for Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was apprenticeship.
A recording is available from Parliament.
Liberal
Natilien Joseph Liberal Longueuil—Saint-Hubert, QC
Thank you, Mr. Herntier.
Mr. Swick, do you have any recommendations for developing a national framework?
Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council
We must have a national advisory committee for it, and it has to be made up of stakeholders like me, with more people from industry who can speak to this. Then have it coordinate efforts with CCDA to make sure they understand what we're trying to do. We can help with that; we're here to help. We just want to make sure that this happens the way it's supposed to happen and that we can actually have a mobile workforce.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey
Thank you, Mr. Joseph.
Ms. Larouche, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.
Bloc
Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.
We do take a lot of notes on what's being said.
Now, we must remain vigilant with respect to certain aspects of the bill. The sponsor of the bill himself, speaking before this committee, discussed the varying standards across different skilled trades, noting that some of them might be less stringent. He emphasized the need to ensure that the bill does not lead to a race to the bottom or lower standards nationwide. I believe you touched on this briefly in your opening remarks.
Do you share this concern about a race to the bottom, Mr. Herntier and Mr. Swick?
I see you nodding. You may begin, Mr. Swick.
Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council
Yes, I agree with that. We cannot lower the bar just to make it a national project. We have to make sure we're at the highest standard, because we have to achieve the highest ability in everything. We need to raise the industry standards; we can't lower them.
I agree with your statements 100%. If we're doing this, we have to make sure we take the time to do it right. It has to be done appropriately, and it has to keep that high standard we've achieved ourselves through the IBEW.
Also, if there are standards that are higher than ours, we should exceed them. We need to be better than that. We have to make sure we are at the highest standards for whatever we're trying to achieve here.
Thank you.
President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers
Yes, I think that if there's a higher standard, let's achieve that. For mobility, it's not just about the technical training. We also need to harmonize the safety training standards across the country. One safety certification, say, in Saskatchewan, is not recognized once you get over to Ontario. Safety training has to be levelled out across the board, and everybody needs to be on the same playing field.
Bloc
Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC
Obviously, this is a concern that was also raised by witnesses from Quebec, among others, who said that Quebec has standards. They, too, had that fear. Stay tuned.
Liberal
Conservative
Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB
Good morning. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you to both of you for being here.
It took me a while, as I was learning about this area, to figure out what was meant by this concern that we have both shortages of work and shortages of workers, or that those two seemingly contradictory concerns can actually coexist. It fits in with this reality that doing the work is necessarily part of the training and that there's some unevenness to the availability of work, especially within a particular geographical area.
If there aren't opportunities to learn by doing the work, then we're going to have a shortage of workers. We can, then, have situations where people are sitting and not working for periods of time, but then there aren't enough workers when workers are actually required.
Would you say that we should be concerned, as policy-makers, with both of those concerns—a shortage of workers and a shortage of work—and that we need to be tackling these problems together?
President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers
Absolutely. With the shortage of work, individuals can't get the hours that are required. Then a shortage of work is definitely going to lead to a shortage of workers when major infrastructure projects do come about.
Conservative
Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council
This is construction. It happens all the time. You work yourself out of a job. That's just what it is. You go to a job, you work yourself out of the job, and you go to the next one. That's the reason you have to make sure you have enough work in that geographical area. That's why mobility is so important, especially apprenticeship mobility. You're not going to get that person to the next level if you can't have a national mobility piece.
If you're building a data centre in Edmonton and need 1,000 skilled trades workers, then you're not getting them all from Edmonton. You have to actually take from the pot—move people and incentivize them to go to that area to work. That's just how it is in construction. It's been like that forever, and it's never going to change, because individual areas have the work at that moment in time, but then, when the job's done, you move on.
We work ourselves out of employment every day. That's what construction people do. Then we move on to the next project. That's why it's so imperative that we get this mobility piece right. Also, it's not just for journeypersons; it has to be for the apprentices too.
Thank you.
Conservative
Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB
Yes, I totally agree that we need to strengthen mobility across the board, including for apprentices. We're going to continue to highlight that and bring forward amendments to that effect.
I want to ask you about labour mobility in general. This is something we've been working on. We have high youth unemployment. We also have regions of the country or places where there is a need for workers, but there's a geography element to that. It's obviously challenging to relocate, even for shorter periods of time.
What do you think we can do as policy-makers to make it easier for young people, or people of any age, to consider exploring opportunities in other regions? What are the barriers you see that make it harder for them to do that?
President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers
In terms of exploring opportunities in other areas, cost is definitely a big one for the youth, or when you're starting off in any particular trade. To reference Manitoba again, you're starting off at 40% of what a Red Seal electrician makes. Currently, you're starting off at about $20 an hour. It's pretty tough to have somebody from Alberta relocating to Manitoba to work for $20 an hour without some sort of subsidy or wage bump.
Conservative
Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB
Yes, it's the costs.
One thing I hear about when I'm talking to young people is concern over housing and transportation. Maybe you're open to moving to a new area, but how are you going to get to where you need to go in an unfamiliar place? That's why one of the policies we've proposed in relation to youth unemployment is support for building homes where the jobs are, including incentives for employers offering workforce housing.
What's typically done in the context of areas you work in to help those moving for work, so they can have their housing and transportation needs addressed?
Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council
Depending on the construction project, they'll put a living-out allowance on it. If you're coming from another jurisdiction, they incentivize you with a living-out allowance. How much they'll give you is dictated by the project. It's usually so much a day, and it's tax-free. It's so you can purchase or get rental facilities and stuff like that while you're there.
Conservative
Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB
Is that tax-free? Is it not considered a taxable benefit?
October 22nd, 2026 / 11:45 a.m.
Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council
I'm pretty sure it's a non-taxable benefit.
Conservative
Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB
All right.
Is that typically available for apprentices as well?
Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council
Yes. It would be for anybody on that particular job, because it's job-based.
Conservative
Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB
It usually means you're on your own for logistics, but you're getting the money that's supposed to help facilitate your finding the place you need.
Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council
Yes. It's above what your paycheque is. Your paycheque is your paycheque. Your living-out allowance is above that, so it takes care of your means when you're in that area. However, you're on your own.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey
I've never seen that perspective before—you go to work to work yourself out of a job.
Conservative
Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB
Yes. We don't do that enough here, Chair, I guess.