Evidence of meeting #50 for Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was apprenticeship.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Herntier  President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers
Swick  Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Noon

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

It won't compromise anything, because it will be at that higher level. They have to recognize it.

Noon

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

Yes. I agree 100%.

Noon

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

They've already done studies on which ones they would need for each of the trades. There's a handful of tickets you need to get on to a job. Get them first, and then everything else could be site-specific training.

Noon

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

Do you have anything to add, Warren?

Noon

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

If we're sticking with working at heights, fall arrests and stuff like that, there are areas where you could get on a boom lift that will take you 125 feet in the air, and you actually don't even need any sort of certification for it as long as you're deemed competent.

Noon

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

That's crazy.

Thank you very much.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Ms. Falk.

We'll go to Mr. Saini for five minutes.

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you, witnesses.

When this legislation, Bill C-266, was introduced, one of the statements I heard was that if we don't do anything, this is going to impede our economy by close to $210 billion annually, because people can't go from place to place. If they do, they have to start from the beginning.

I would like to hear your viewpoint on that. This is for both of you.

Noon

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

I'm not sure about that number.

If we don't do something, obviously, they won't be able to fulfill the jobs, and people won't be able to continue their training, because it will be jurisdictionally based at best. It is true that you would have to start over in certain jurisdictions, when you go there, to get your technical training and such like that.

As I said, I'm not sure of the number, but yes, we definitely need to do this.

Thank you.

Noon

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

To echo Chris, if we can't get the guys to the job, they can't get the hours and they can't advance, and if we can't man the jobs up, the work isn't going to happen.

Noon

Liberal

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Warren, in your opening statement, you said as long as Bill C-266 does not jeopardize collective bargaining or diminish the Red Seal....

Can you elaborate a bit further on that? Do you think there's a risk of that happening if we go forward with Bill C-266?

Noon

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

For the Red Seal, the designation is something that's been fought for for years. If the idea is to increase mobility and allow people to work across the country by lowering the training standards on the safety of individuals, then Bill C-266 isn't of interest. If all you're going to do is start creating puppy mills through training centres and firing these guys out the door as fast as you can just to man up labour needs, then we're looking at it the wrong way.

We need to harmonize training at the highest point we can and stay there.

Noon

Liberal

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Bill C-266 is basically a framework, I understand, whereby the federal government, in collaboration with the provincial governments, territorial governments, indigenous communities and unions, will come up with standards that need to be applied across Canada. I think that's the best thing we can do, because as a Canadian, I should have the opportunity to choose whether I want to work in British Columbia, Quebec or Newfoundland. The barriers should not be restricting my ability to live the life I want to live.

Noon

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

Absolutely. If I can drive there and not need a passport to get there, I should be able to work there.

Noon

Liberal

Gurbux Saini Liberal Fleetwood—Port Kells, BC

Chris, you mentioned that the rate of failure is around 47% because we don't have standards across Canada. If Bill C-266 can accomplish those by working together with unions and the provincial and territorial governments, do you think we can improve on that and make it part of a successful society?

12:05 p.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

That was the recommendation for the advisory committee. We would have to make sure that it goes to the advisory committee and we get the parties at the table to make sure that they understand what's happening.

You could probably go back over the last 10 years to see what the success rate for the Red Seal exam has been on the first time. It's been abysmal at best. When I look at that and say we're still using the same system, where maybe only half of the people are passing the first time, and meanwhile, they're all....

It doesn't make sense that someone has actually passed all of their technical training in trade school—they've passed and done all their hours—and all they have to do is write this final exam, and they can't pass it. It makes zero sense, because they should have all of the knowledge and abilities they need to pass that test when they get there.

There is a failure somewhere. We need to align everybody and say this is not acceptable anymore. If we're going to raise the bar everywhere, we have to raise the bar on this. We need to see 70%, 80% and 90% success rates when they're coming out, because, technically, they've done their trade. They've done everything. All they're doing is waiting to write that last piece of paper, and they can't do it. It makes zero sense.

That's why we have to make sure that the proper people are at the table through the trades. We have to make sure that we have the CCDA involved. We have to make sure that all of the provinces are aligned. We have to ask how this works, so we can make sure that we can push these outcomes out for more success. That's what we have to do.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Mr. Saini.

Ms. Larouche, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

I'd like to thank both witnesses again for being with us today.

Earlier, I was talking about the risks associated with lowering standards. I will continue by talking about certain reservations or fears that have been expressed here, particularly by witnesses from Quebec. They said that, in trying to harmonize things, there might be a risk of duplication. Let me explain.

As we know, and as we've mentioned, not all provinces have the same rules. Quality and safety standards come to mind, obviously, working conditions and insurance, for example. In short, it wouldn't be simple. There might be some duplication. In Quebec, we have a unique model. There is the CCQ, the Commission de la construction du Québec, Québec emploi, sectoral organizations, and so on. They all work together.

Mr. Swick, Mr. Herntier, are you concerned that this bill will duplicate what already exists? We also know that there are already agreements between certain provinces, so is there a risk of duplication?

12:05 p.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

In some instances there might be some duplication, but the way the system is right now, it's broken. There is no duplication because there's no mechanism, if we're talking to the apprentices, to have them slot in to the new province appropriately with the trade school training that they've done in other provinces, or even to recognize their hours of training.

We have to make sure that we go back to the very basics. If there are duplications, we can—through the committee and through the bill—actually work that out to make sure that there are no duplications or see where the provinces are aligned. Without going through the steps and processes to find out where those duplications lie.... I think we have to do that. You have to take that advisory committee and find out where the duplications are.

If there are any, eliminate them. We don't need to have any more red tape on any of this stuff. We just have to make sure that everything goes through smoothly. It has to be aligned. Once we do that first step, then we can actually go to the jurisdictions and say, now we can piecemeal certain things out and make it so that there's not that duplication, if that makes sense.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

You have 10 seconds left, Ms. Larouche.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

Mr. Herntier, do you have anything to add in a few seconds about the risk of duplication?

12:05 p.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

I agree with Chris that the advisory committee would have to take a look at everything to source out any duplications. Along with everybody on the advisory committee, there should be educators on there from institutions that are training this every day.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Madame Larouche.

Thank you to the witnesses for appearing before the committee and providing excellent testimony on the world that is.

Do I have it right, Mr. Reynolds, that it's the world of apprenticeship Red Seal and the obstacles that I think governments collectively allow to be created when they shouldn't be? Thank you. Your evidence was very clear and practical from a real perspective.

Thank you, witnesses.

We have one administrative matter, because we do not have a second panel today. I believe there was agreement with the instructions to draft a report. The analysts needed a timeline for when we will stop accepting briefs on this study.

Are members comfortable with today being the last day? I understand there's some agreement.

An hon. member

Maybe tomorrow.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

The committee can choose.