Evidence of meeting #50 for Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was apprenticeship.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Herntier  President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers
Swick  Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

The Chair (Robert Morrissey (Egmont, Lib.)) Liberal Bobby Morrissey

I call this meeting to order.

Welcome to meeting number 50 of the Standing Committee on Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities.

Pursuant to the order of reference received on Wednesday, September 23, the committee is meeting on Bill C-266, an act to establish a national framework respecting skilled trades and labour mobility.

Before I begin, we'll review a couple of points. For all those participating in this meeting who require translation, please keep your earpiece on and choose the language that you are comfortable participating in. Ensure that you have that, for the benefit of those members who are speaking in either French or English, so you understand what they are saying, out of respect to all witnesses and committee members.

Nobody is appearing virtually this morning.

If there is a breakdown in the translation, please get my attention, and we'll suspend while it is corrected.

Please direct all questions through the chair. Wait until I recognize you by name before proceeding.

For the benefit of the committee, I would like to give a clarification. Due to unfortunate circumstances, all the witnesses for the second hour are now unable to appear. At this moment, we will begin the first hour with the two witnesses we have. The committee can choose how it proceeds after that.

I would like to welcome both witnesses, who are with us in the room.

From the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, we have Warren Herntier, president of Local 2085. From the National Electrical Trade Council, we have Chris Swick, executive director.

Each of you will have up to five minutes for an opening statement, and then we'll go into the question rounds for the rest of the first hour.

We'll begin with you, Mr. Herntier.

Warren Herntier President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Good morning, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for allowing me to come before you today to present my views on Bill C-266.

I am a Red Seal electrician with over 30 years of experience in the electrical industry. I currently serve as president and training director for the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 2085. I also serve on Manitoba's Apprenticeship and Certification Board, which plays an important role in supporting employer and employee participation in the apprenticeship system, and on advising the minister on apprenticeship training requirements and the evolving labour market needs for skilled tradespeople throughout Manitoba.

For the past eight years, I have been heavily involved in apprenticeship training. Although the interprovincial exam is based on the Red Seal occupational standard, there are many differences from province to province. For example, technical training weeks across Canada range from as few as 28 weeks to up to 40 weeks.

I do agree with removing unnecessary barriers that prevent qualified tradespeople from pursuing employment across our great country, but not if it means diminishing the value of the Red Seal designation, which we have fought so hard to achieve. Apprentices are not interchangeable with journeypersons and therefore should be treated separately.

Bill C-266 must allow provinces the ability to enforce in their own jurisdiction compulsory certification, electrical codes, licensing and supervision ratios. A few recommendations I'd like to bring forth include verbiage that the framework cannot diminish the Red Seal occupational standards, the recognition that collective bargaining rights are protections and not mobility barriers, and allowing labour and apprenticeship training representatives to participate in the development and implementation.

IBEW Local 2085 believes that there should be realistic avenues for qualified tradespeople to practise their trade in Canada. It is the responsibility of the committee to differentiate between unnecessary red tape and actual training and certification processes that provide protection to the employees and the general public.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Mr. Herntier.

We'll now go to Mr. Swick for up to five minutes.

Chris Swick Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Good morning, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to share the National Electrical Trade Council's perspective on Bill C-266.

My name is Chris Swick, and I'm the executive director for NETCO.

NETCO serves as a national voice on Red Seal and apprenticeship matters for both the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, representing approximately 90 local unions and 70,000 members across Canada, and the Canadian Electrical Contractors Association, representing approximately 8,000 electrical contractors.

Regarding NETCO's position on Bill C-266, NETCO fully supports the intent of Bill C-266 and the establishment of a national framework to improve skilled trades labour mobility across Canada. We recognize the importance of reducing barriers, improving credential recognition and ensuring that skilled workers can move to where their expertise is needed.

However, we believe the legislation is an opportunity to go considerably further. True labour mobility must begin with apprenticeship training, not simply the recognition of credentials after the individual becomes a certified journeyperson. In Canada's electrical industry, significant inconsistencies remain between provincial apprenticeship systems, particularly in technical training hours, curriculum development, practical training and the recognition of completed apprenticeship levels.

As an example of the lack of national apprenticeship harmonization, depending on the jurisdiction and applicable trade requirements, total apprenticeship hours can range from approximately 7,200 to 9,800 hours. Technical training can range from approximately 960 hours to 1,800 hours. These are not minor differences.

Atlantic Canada has demonstrated what greater co-operation can achieve through the Atlantic apprenticeship harmonization initiative involving New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador. However, comparable harmonization has not been achieved nationally.

We recognize that apprenticeship training and education fall primarily under provincial and territorial jurisdictions. That should not prevent governments, industry, labour organizations and training institutions from working together to establish consistent national expectations for apprenticeships' learning outcomes.

A national occupational standard should mean more than a common examination at the end of the apprenticeship. It should provide a consistent foundation for the education and training that leads to that examination.

NETCO was also concerned about Red Seal examination performance and apprenticeship completion outcomes across Canada. Greater attention must be given to how differences in technical training, curriculum alignment and practical expertise affect apprentices' preparedness. Apprentices working primarily in residential construction may have limited exposure to industrial motor controls and other specialized systems. Conversely, an apprentice in heavy industrial environments may have limited exposure to certain residential applications. This is why consistent, comprehensive technical training aligned with the Red Seal occupational standard is so important. Wherever apprentices live and whatever electrical work they perform, they should have access to the knowledge and the competencies needed to succeed on their Red Seal examination and become well-rounded, nationally qualified electricians.

Building on recent federal progress, NETCO welcomes the recent federal efforts to improve apprenticeship mobility and reduce administrative barriers. In particular, we are encouraged by the proposal for a single apprenticeship identification number referenced in the federal government's spring economic statement. With appropriate privacy protection and intergovernmental co-operation, such an identifier could help apprenticeship authorities track training progress, recognize completed requirements and support apprenticeship moving between jurisdictions. It could also help identify where skilled workers are available and where labour shortages are emerging.

NETCO recommends that the national framework established under Bill C-266 include the following measures. One, establish a national apprenticeship harmonization advisory committee; two, strengthen national alignment with the Red Seal occupational standard; three, improve interprovincial recognition and apprenticeship training; four, review Red Seal examination and apprenticeship completion outcomes; and five, advance the national apprenticeship identification system.

I look forward to taking your questions.

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Mr. Swick.

I'm sure we have members of this committee who have a lot of interest in the points you raise.

We'll begin with Mr. Reynolds for six minutes.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for coming here today. I know both of these gentlemen quite well, so I'm going to be a little less formal than I usually am.

I wanted to take a minute to paint a bit of a picture of what apprenticeship looks like in Canada. If you were to compare it to any profession—say a teacher, a lawyer or something like that—and you decided to go to Dalhousie University on the east coast and take the first two years of your professional training, and then you decided you wanted to move to British Columbia and finish your training program, that's accredited. You can take your schooling anywhere in the country and the accreditation will follow you.

Keeping that in mind, does apprenticeship work that way?

I'll ask you, Warren.

11:10 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

In the grand scheme of things, it should work that way, but it depends on the jurisdiction they're moving to. I'm seeing a lot of apprentices still living at home. If mom and dad decide to move across the country, they don't really have a choice. If they were a third-level apprentice in Manitoba, they could move to the next province and be knocked down. Then they'd only be a second-level apprentice.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

In some cases, they may even have to start all over again. Is that correct?

11:10 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

That can happen as well.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

Who is currently responsible for apprenticeship certification in the country?

I'll ask you, Chris.

11:10 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

The apprentice certification for journeypersons is the Red Seal examination. It differs among the provinces. Certain provinces have exams you can write to stay within your province and continue your practice as a journeyperson electrician. If you want to have mobility, you need to have the Red Seal examination passed and completed. That is the federal standard governed by CCDA, the Canadian Council of Directors of Apprenticeship.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

Okay. If you're a Red Seal tradesperson, you can work anywhere in the country.

Can an apprentice do that?

Chris.

11:10 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

To the member's question, to echo what Warren said, no, they cannot. There's no mechanism right now where you can slot an apprentice in from one province to the next.

I go back to the Red Seal occupational standards. That's what the governance is. It's for us to take a look at how to write that exam. Through the CCDA, they take that. Each of the provinces takes a look at it. They make up their own curriculum based on the Red Seal occupational standards. Those learning outcomes have to match. Right now, they're not matching.

I talked earlier about the Atlantic harmonization. Through that, they've matched it all for that particular group. When you get to Quebec, their system is totally different. You do all your training up front. Then you get put to work and complete your hours. We can't slot them into a system where you need to have all your training up front, because, in other provinces, you do one block of training, go to work and come back for the next block of training.

As they move from province to province, there is a differentiation among the learning outcomes. That should never happen, because everything should align with the Red Seal occupational standards. As I alluded to before, one region has 960 hours of technical training and the region next to it has 1,400 hours of technical training. It's impossible for all those outcomes to match and align, because they just don't have enough time to do it. They manipulate to see what their jurisdictional area is and what they will allow for.

This is also the reason we have such high failure rates for the Red Seal exam: Nobody's getting taught the exact same thing. When they go from one province to the next, we try to put them in. We have to take a look at what supplemental training they need in order to get them into that spot. If someone comes from B.C. or Alberta to Ontario, we have to see what learning outcomes they've missed and what we're going to try to put them in. The easiest way for them to do that is to write an exemption exam. It encompasses all that level of trade-school training they have not received. Therefore, if they don't pass the exemption exam, they have to start all over again.

I have 10 years as a training director, and I was on a JAC prior to this. Typically what happens is this: We ask how far along they are in their apprenticeship. They might be better served going back to their province, finishing, getting their journeyperson status and then coming back. Otherwise, they have to start over.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

Ultimately, the Red Seal is standardized across the country. The finish point is the same regardless of what province they're in, but the path to get there differs from province to province.

Is that the way we're set up right now?

11:15 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

My next question is for you, Warren. We've worked many years together on the tools and in the field.

Would you say that apprentices play an integral role on a construction site? Would you say they're pretty important to the whole ecosystem of a construction project?

11:15 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

Yes, I would. Absolutely.

Coming on a construction site is where their journey starts. They're working side by side with a Red Seal electrician who's mentoring them. They need to be on the site from day one. That way, farther down the road, once they achieve their Red Seal, they can mentor their own apprentice. They always need somebody who's going to be right there beside them, thinking mechanically about what the next step will be and what they're going to need next.

If we can't get them on the site early, we're not going to be able to produce quality Red Seal electricians and fill the shortages we're facing.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

Also, who else would clean up after us?

Voices

Oh, oh!

11:15 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

Come on. Electricians don't use brooms. We know that.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Colin Reynolds Conservative Elmwood—Transcona, MB

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Mr. Villeneuve, you have the floor for six minutes.

Louis Villeneuve Liberal Brome—Missisquoi, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I would like to welcome Mr. Herntier and Mr. Swick.

Unlike my colleague Mr. Reynolds, I'm not a construction professional. I represent average Canadians. It wasn't too long ago that I learned which end of my hammer to hold, so that should give you an idea of just how much of a construction guy I'm not.

My questions are for you both. Feel free to interject or add to the other person's answer.

Like the residents of my riding, Brome—Missisquoi, in Quebec, I'm concerned about the housing shortage. In this context, could you provide an overview of how increased mobility among electricians would help accelerate the expansion of the housing supply in Canada?

11:15 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

To the member's question, when we look at the electrical trade, we see that it's a very vast trade. When you're a construction electrician, you're supposed to be able to build everything from a house to a nuclear power plant and everything in between.

What ends up happening is that we specialize in our own fields. If I'm a residential electrician, I will do a lot of residential work, and that's probably the only thing that I'm going to do. With the mobility act, we will be able to move individuals who specialize in residential fields to those other provinces to help with this, and that would help with the housing piece you're talking about.

We can look at the heavy industrial sector and the major job projects that are coming up. Those individuals will basically stay in those projects. They're used to it. Those are the ones who are there. We kind of separate ourselves out after we get our Red Seal ticket.

In the pathway for apprenticeship to get to the Red Seal, we have to know everything. We write that Red Seal exam, but then we're very comfortable on the job sites that we're at. When it comes time and you're doing residential, you'll typically stick to the residential workforce. If you're in heavy industrial, you'll stick to the heavy residential workforce.

That's the reason, too, why we're saying that if you have that single national registration number, you can identify where people are, you can see where that work group is, and you can focus down on what that individual actually does over time. That will help with doing the mobility back and forth between the provinces.

Louis Villeneuve Liberal Brome—Missisquoi, QC

Another topic of interest to me is young people.

How do you think young Canadians who want to take part in apprenticeship programs will have more opportunities to enter the industry of their choice, thanks to the government's efforts to improve labour mobility and encourage people to pursue careers in the skilled trades?