Evidence of meeting #53 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was product.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Chung  President and Chief Executive Officer, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Denoncourt  Analyst in source reduction, Équiterre
Hatch  Chief Executive Officer, Electronic Products Association Canada
Holtby  Vice-President, Government Relations, Automotive Industries Association of Canada
Bester  Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project
Abar  President, Microland
Chu Cheng  Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you, Mr. Groleau.

Mr. Ma, the floor is yours for five minutes.

Michael Ma Liberal Markham—Unionville, ON

Thank you, Chair.

My question is for Mr. Abar.

A core objective of Bill C-267 is to establish a national framework that sets standards around the minimum useful life of essential home appliances. Throughout this study, questions have been raised regarding who should determine these minimum standards and what methodology should be used.

Drawing upon your experience in the electronics repair industry, what technical and operational considerations should inform the determination of minimum useful life standards, and how can these standards be established in a way that balances consumer protection with the practical realities of manufacturing and repair?

12:40 p.m.

President, Microland

Matthew Abar

Thank you for the question.

In our experience in dealing with different manufacturers and different products, the minimum standards—and I think that's the way they've done it in Quebec—vary by product category. Different products are used differently. A TV sits on your wall. It doesn't really move and it's not really touched, so it can perhaps have a longer lifespan than something that has more feedback, is used in your hands and is moved around a lot.

It varies by product category, and who should set those standards, we think, are independent engineering boards, professional engineers outside of both the manufacturer and the consumer sides of things. One of the reasons why we suggested that, and one that I mentioned, is to have repair shops like ours consulted in this, because we deal with both sides. We see what the consumers are looking for and what consumers are demanding of their products, and we also see what manufacturers are capable of providing and willing to provide, and what resources are available to them to provide those services in Canada.

Michael Ma Liberal Markham—Unionville, ON

Thank you.

In your published writing, you've highlighted how returned and decommissioned electronic products can serve as an alternative supply chain for replacement parts. One of our essential concerns in Bill C-267 is ensuring that products remain economically repairable throughout their expected useful lives, even after manufacturers discontinue particular components—like how we used to see used car parts sold as spare parts.

How can a national framework best ensure the long-term availability of replacement parts, while giving manufacturers and independent repair businesses sufficient flexibility to develop cost-effective solutions to parts shortages?

12:40 p.m.

President, Microland

Matthew Abar

That's a very good question. Something we deal with a lot, especially once units go out of the warranty period, is the availability of parts. Being able to continue to provide services to consumers after the units have come out of warranty is difficult. It's very variable by manufacturer. Often we see manufacturers supporting parts seven or eight years after the warranty has expired and units came out, while others basically stop once the warranty period is over or once they start stop selling them.

On having a minimum standard, we would support having a minimum period, let's say, after the warranty period where parts continue to be supplied.

One of the activities we do, as you read, is harvest old, discarded and recycled electronics to build a parts supply. We distribute those parts to other service centres throughout the country, but you never know what's coming in. You can't plan a service industry for the country just around recycled parts, so we do need the manufacturers' support in making sure there's a minimum period of time where they still have to supply parts.

Michael Ma Liberal Markham—Unionville, ON

I applaud you for doing so, because seeing these parts and products sitting in garbage dumps is not good for the economy and not good for the environment.

Thank you very much for that.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Mr. Ma.

Mr. Barsalou‑Duval, you have the floor for two minutes and thirty seconds.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I would like to use my time to give notice of the following motion:

That, pursuant to Standing Order 108(2), the INDU committee examine the consequences for the Quebec and Canadian steel industry—which is already severely affected by 50% U.S. tariffs—of the Prime Minister's announced intention to conclude a free trade agreement with Turkey, as well as the impact such an agreement would have on the federal government's contingency measures, given that countries without a free trade agreement are permitted to import 20% of their 2024 volumes duty-free, whereas countries with an agreement are permitted 75%. That, for this study, which shall consist of at least two (2) meetings, the committee invite the following witnesses to appear: a. The Department of Finance; b. The Canada Border Services Agency; c. Catherine Cobden, President of the Canadian Steel Producers Association (CSPA); d. Marty Warren, National Director of the United Steelworkers (USW); e. Nicolas Lapierre, Director of the Quebec section of the Métallos union; f. Paul Bird, President of the Montreal Port Authority; g. Stéphane Brochu, President of ArcelorMittal Long Products Canada; That the committee report its findings to the House and request a government response.

I believe, Mr. Chair—unless I am mistaken—that I cannot debate the motion or explain it at this time, given that it is merely a notice. Am I mistaken?

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Have you given a copy of the motion to other members of the committee, Mr. Barsalou‑Duval?

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

No, the motion has not yet been circulated. I understand that it's also not part of the subject under discussion on today's agenda, since we are discussing Bill C‑267. Therefore, I don't believe it can be debated, unless there is unanimity around the table to proceed. However, I could circulate it, if there is an opportunity to do so.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Yes, I need to look into that first. However, the motion cannot be moved at this time because of the subject we are discussing, but you can still move it later. You can hand this to the clerk and give adequate notice, and we can hold the debate later if it's something you wish to move.

Xavier Barsalou-Duval Bloc Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères, QC

Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Is that all?

All right, thank you.

Ms. Begum, the floor will be yours for five minutes.

Doly Begum Liberal Scarborough Southwest, ON

Thank you very much, Chair.

I want to first take the opportunity to go to Ms. Wai Chu Cheng. I feel that I owe her a thank you because I know she's coming to the border of my riding in a week or two with the repair café at the Hub on Eglinton.

I know that our community really appreciates the work that you and all the volunteers have done throughout the years.

One of the things that really stuck to me when you talked was about the fact that in just one event, you had 150 items repaired. Over the year, you've had 170 events. It just goes to show the demand that we have from our community, especially with average-income and low-income families, who really want to be able to use their products for the long term.

It's not just that. I think everyone has that desire. We've seen data in the past, and people have that desire—over 75%. When we look at the number of people who are actually getting it done, it's quite low compared to how many people want to get their electronics and other appliances repaired, but they don't have the ability. You are filling a gap.

We have many of you—and other witnesses here as well—who are looking for manufacturers. We have Matthew Abar and Keldon Bester here today in person.

I think it really goes to show the demand and the need for this framework and this legislation, which will allow us to have that consultation and have the local voices, the local repair shops' voices, come together to come up with that framework.

First, I wanted to ask Ms. Cheng this.

On your website, you talk about how you're really focused on safety. One of the questions that has been raised for this legislation is, of course, about safety and making sure that we have licensed professionals doing the repair work. Would you be able to touch on that?

I know you've mentioned quite a few examples. Talk a little about how important it is to have that safety component and what you've done to make sure that we are not only focusing on being able to make repairs accessible but also focusing on the professionals who are able to do them.

12:50 p.m.

Executive Director, Repair Café Toronto

Wai Chu Cheng

First of all, I want to mention that what we have achieved is the result of collaboration with a lot of excellent community organizations that care about the community and want to bring a repair service and repair education to their community members. We have been working closely with a lot of community organizations to organize repair cafés, including the one at the mid-Scarborough Hub. They organize the events and we work together to support them in recruiting volunteer fixers.

Regarding your question about safety, at the repair cafés, we have house rules and safety procedures. We include the house rules and safety procedures on our website, and all of our volunteer fixers are required to follow them. For example, when they're working on electrical items, they should be unplugging before they open an item. There are some steps that they share. When a visitor arrives, before they get to see a fixer who will help them, they are reminded that they need to work with us to follow house safety procedures.

Most of the time, we will ask our fixers whether they want to fix certain items or not. Our fixers have the right to reject. If they don't feel comfortable with certain items, they don't have to work on them. For example, we generally reject items that are powered by gas, like gas-powered lawnmowers. We don't open them. We actually don't accept them. We also don't accept heating items made before 1997, because there might be asbestos in them. We reject them if anyone brings them to an event.

As I mentioned, we've been running repair cafés for the last 13 years, and we have been really careful about safety. I think we can always do better, but we have a lot of fixers who are very experienced as well.

Also, as I mentioned, we often refer products if we find that visitors can get better or specialized help from professionals at business repair shops. Without hesitation, our fixers will refer them to repair shops. On our website, we have put together a directory of repair shops as a resource to share with our community members. We are not doing all of the repairs, as you know.

I'm sorry. I hope I answered your question.

Doly Begum Liberal Scarborough Southwest, ON

Yes. Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Ms. Begum.

Colleagues, there are just a few minutes left, so I'm going to take the opportunity to ask the final question.

Mr. Bester, I was trying to understand throughout your testimony, working with the analyst and looking at the Competition Act as it currently exists.... I believe it was section 75. I'm wondering if you could offer some clarity.

The way it seems to read to me is that there is currently a provision in the act that would allow for a “person”—that's the language the act uses—to have a legal recourse for the right to repair. If I go to Joe's mechanic shop and Joe has my GM and says, “I'm sorry. We can't fix it. We don't have access to the information”, the Competition Act, as it's written in section 75, would permit me or the mechanic to make a complaint to the tribunal that we are not being given access by the manufacturer to the information necessary for the repair. Am I reading that correctly? That's number one.

Number two, I understand the argument I think you've made, which is that, yes, the legal provision exists, but that's an onerous process and you have to go through this tribunal every single time. If that is the case, are we seeing everyday Canadians making use of that provision in section 75 to demand the right to repair as it pertains to the auto sector?

12:55 p.m.

Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project

Keldon Bester

It's an excellent question. Bear with me.

When it comes to the enforcement of the Competition Act, for a very long time, it was predominantly the Competition Bureau that brought the vast majority of cases. The private access route, more often than not, is taken by a business as opposed to an individual, and the standard for them to bring a case was quite high. You basically had to be going out of business and then decide to take on a bunch of legal fees, which was not a particularly attractive path. In 2023 and 2024, they opened the path to private access and also included, correctly, as you note, the provisions around refusal to deal around repair and diagnostic information.

This is a great example of the value of upfront standards and a framework as opposed to an investigatory and adjudicative tool. It is true that you could bring that case either to the Competition Bureau in the form of a complaint or to the Competition Tribunal, but the fact that it originates from the Competition Act means that it would have to actually have an impact on competition to then begin the process of either investigation or litigation. Again, we are talking about something that, to date, even with the expanded access, only a select number of Canadian businesses have engaged in.

I'd be happy to elaborate on that further—

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Yes. If I—

12:55 p.m.

Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project

Keldon Bester

—but it is not a tool for the everyday Canadian today.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

If I'm understanding you correctly, an argument that could be made by the manufacturers is, essentially, that there's no competitive issue here because nobody else is doing it either.

October 27th, 2026 / 12:55 p.m.

Executive Director, Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project

Keldon Bester

It could also be we're so small, we're not a dominant player, there's not a substantial lessening, and so on and so forth. Again, it's a great tool, but it exists for a very particular purpose that an individual walking up to the desk really can't achieve.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

That's very interesting. I appreciate that clarity.

Maybe it serves as a bit of a foundation for us moving forward, as we try to understand this more broadly, as something that can be pointed to that exists but, as you say, is primarily not a consumer-friendly or upfront way to deal with this.

Thank you for that.

Colleagues, I appreciate another very good meeting and conversation.

I would like to thank all the witnesses who are here today.

As a reminder, the deadline for amendments has been moved, per our decision earlier today, to four o'clock on Thursday.

There is no meeting this Thursday. We will do subcommittee business instead, and I will speak with members of the Bloc, the Liberals and the Conservatives to work through that. On Tuesday, we will meet to begin clause-by-clause on the bill. On the following Thursday, as a result of the tabling of the federal budget, there will be no meeting. We'll have some further direction of where we go after that.

With that colleagues, thanks very much. Enjoy the rest of your day. We will see you again next week.

The meeting is adjourned.