Evidence of meeting #46 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was gas.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Committee Researcher
Baiton  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers
Jenkins  Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy
Bowen  Vice-President, Asset Planning and Delivery, Manitoba Hydro
Walker  Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual
Belliveau  Program Manager, Energy Transition, Environmental Defence Canada
Stirling  Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society
Levin  Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

Noon

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

I want to shift gears a bit. With respect to affordability from a household perspective and energy, Statistics Canada found that almost 14% of Newfoundland and Labrador households were spending at least 10% of their after-tax income on home energy, compared to 5.6% nationally—and 10% is considered to be energy poverty. For families in colder regions, affordability is already a serious concern. From the producer side, how do industrial carbon pricing costs affect the cost of supplying home heating fuel?

To what extent can those costs ultimately impact consumers, especially in a place like Newfoundland and Labrador, where 30% of our homes are heated by home heating fuel?

Noon

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

I would just restate that it's a virtuous circle. If we get all the pillars right, if we get the investment capital and the regulatory and fiscal frameworks in place, and if we can start building, then it's going to benefit us not only by protecting our national sovereignty, our economic security and our energy security but also by helping with the economy.

Noon

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

Thank you.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

You have 10 seconds.

Noon

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

It's fine.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thanks, Ms. Anstey.

Our final speaker is Mr. St-Pierre.

You have the floor for five minutes.

Noon

Liberal

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Mr. Jenkins, there was the Churchill Falls announcement that was made this summer, which my colleague Claude worked very hard on. It promises a lot of benefits for my province of Quebec and also for the riding of Long Range Mountains, which my Conservative colleagues are probably very excited about, because it's one of the largest clean energy projects in North American history. We're talking about two gigawatts of wind energy for the Innu community in Labrador and Quebec.

I'm curious: What is Indigenous Clean Energy's perspective on this massive clean energy project?

Noon

Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy

James Jenkins

Our perspective is that Quebec has had a strategy of trying to catalyze renewables for some time, and that has involved directly working with indigenous partners, in this case the Innu Nation, and we're very excited to see that come to fruition.

Again, these are the kinds of efforts that take place more at the provincial level and the utility level, but there are some levers that the federal government can use in this in terms of things like ITCs and some focused grants that allow groups like the Innu Nation to have the capacity to participate in a meaningful way.

It's one of many excellent examples of indigenous leadership in the space. That's our perspective on it as one that's taking place across the country. Quebec's approach to it has been somewhat different from that of many other regions, and this may be an example of it paying off.

Noon

Liberal

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

That's great. Thank you.

I'm going to pick on my colleague from Winnipeg South. There's a really good project out of Manitoba run by Raven Indigenous Capital Partners.

Mr. Jenkins, you might be familiar with Jeff Cyr and his work in Manitoba with Aki Energy. They've installed geothermal energy in first nations communities to decarbonize the communities with what are called outcomes-based contracts.

I'd be curious, Mr. Jenkins, if you could comment on that type of model and how we can use energy efficiency to improve indigenous energy security and self-sufficiency. If you can quickly comment on those types of projects and how they are beneficial to first nations communities, that would be great.

Noon

Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy

James Jenkins

I'm happy to do that.

Often, capital isn't the issue for things like renewables or transmission, because they're highly bankable and electricity contracts are fairly risk-free compared to many other investments. Energy efficiency has been a tougher nut to crack, especially when it comes to indigenous energy efficiency. The Raven Capital model of allowing a long-term return on investment could be a way to replicate that at a more national scale. We are calling for ways to work with the federal government and other potential sources of capital to make that a reality for more communities.

There are a few other examples. We're strongly advocating for communities to enter into these partnerships with capital-based firms like Raven Capital and others. Our vision would be to replicate that on a national scale to make it available to many indigenous communities.

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Quickly, can you give us another practical example of a model of energy self-sufficiency for first nations communities, something concrete that we can wrap our heads around?

12:05 p.m.

Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy

James Jenkins

Pikwàkanagàn is currently looking at something similar north of Ottawa in Ontario that would include community-level new builds and retrofits. That's typically what the model looks like. There usually has to be some support from the public sector and some capital in place so that the model can take place over a longer term. There are a few other examples like that, where they're essentially project-ready but it is a deep retrofit that has that benefit for the entire community.

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

That's perfect.

I have one last quick question to throw in here.

What policy tools can our government adopt to help scale energy efficiency and clean energy projects in first nations communities?

12:05 p.m.

Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy

James Jenkins

One policy tool would be to look at more flexible capital programs, as you mentioned. That seems to be the nearest opportunity because we're seeing some boutique examples of that taking place. Another could be grants. We've seen some jurisdictions have subsidies for energy efficiency. The U.S. had very large subsidies in place that recently sunsetted. That could be one way to unlock some potential, but again, the near term seems to be more flexibility around these capital programs.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Mr. St-Pierre.

Thank you, colleagues, for good questions and comments.

I give a big thank you to our witnesses for appearing before us today.

I want to thank Mr. St-Pierre and Mr. Patzer for inserting some Manitoba content. I thought of intervening, but I didn't need to because they were there for—

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

It was not as good as the Calgary content.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

—the keystone province of Manitoba.

Colleagues, we're going to pause for seven minutes while we prepare for the next panel.

Again, thank you to our witnesses.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Colleagues, welcome back. We're back in session, and we will resume the meeting.

I'd like to welcome all of our witnesses. They are all appearing virtually today. As an individual, we have Thomas Walker, director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, and professor of finance, Concordia University. From Environmental Defence Canada, we have Emilia Belliveau, program manager, energy transition, and Julia Levin, associate director, national climate. From Friends of Science Society, we have Michelle Stirling, who is the communications manager.

Welcome to all of you.

All witnesses appearing virtually have conducted a mandatory onboarding test.

Let me make just a few comments for the benefit of our new witnesses: Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. I remind you that all comments should be addressed through the chair. You will each have five minutes for your opening remarks, after which we'll open the floor for questions.

We're going to start with you, Mr. Walker. You have the floor for five minutes.

Thomas Walker Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual

Thank you.

Mr. Chair and honourable members of the committee, thank you for inviting me today.

My name is Dr. Thomas Walker. I'm a professor of finance and director of the L. Jacques Ménard BMO centre for capital markets at Concordia University. I also serve on the scientific committee and as co-lead of the Volt-Age sustainable electrification program. Additionally, I serve as director at the institute for sustainable finance at Queen's University.

Earlier in this study, witnesses told this committee that doubling Canada's electricity grid by 2050 will cost between $1 trillion and $2 trillion. Governments and taxpayers cannot pay for this alone. The vast majority must come from private institutional investors, such as pension funds, insurers and banks. My written brief outlines four financial pillars to mobilize that private capital, which I will summarize today.

Pillar one focuses on the de-risking of private capital through blended finance, public-private partnerships and indigenous equity. Blended finance means using targeted public money to absorb early project risks so that pension funds can meet their fiduciary duties and invest at scale.

In March 2026, Parliament expanded the Canada Infrastructure Bank's capital envelope to $45 billion. Deploying that balance sheet for first-loss loan guarantees, revenue insurance and public-private partnerships lowers the risk for private lenders. Lower risk means lower interest rates and lower electricity bills for Canadian families.

A prime example of de-risking is indigenous equity financing. As the first—

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Mr. Chair, if I may, the pace needs to be slowed down if we want to keep the interpreters alive until this afternoon.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Mr. Walker, I hope you heard that. Could you go at a slower pace? We've stopped your time, so you haven't lost any during this pause.

Please continue.

12:15 p.m.

Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual

Thomas Walker

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

A prime example of de-risking is indigenous equity financing. As the First Nations Major Projects Coalition testified, backing loans with Canada's AAA credit rating solves the high borrowing costs that historically locked indigenous communities out of energy projects. Currently, an indigenous community seeking to finance a major project stake in a project has to navigate a maze of federal and provincial agencies. Offering these guarantees under a single agency would reduce delays and duplicate paperwork and turn first nations into true equity partners.

Pillar two calls for domestic securitization sovereignty. Securitization is when banks bundle thousands of individual loans for heat pumps, solar panels or large infrastructure investments into tradable bonds, freeing up cash to make new loans. While the word “securitization” may remind people of the 2008 financial crisis, infrastructure securitization is completely different. Data from Moody's shows that public-private infrastructure loans have a 10-year default rate of just 3.9%, and recovery rates of over 80%.

As a member of this committee recently noted, American banks actively resell clean energy loans, while Canadian banks remain hesitant. Meanwhile, China mobilizes over $400 billion annually in green bonds and securitized assets. Canada must build its own domestic green securitization framework so that foreign platforms can never dictate which Canadian energy project gets financed.

Pillar three applies lessons from Germany and Europe on grid diversification and demand-side management. Having grown up in Germany myself, I saw first-hand how phasing out nuclear baseload power too early exposed German companies and households to price shocks, suggesting that Canada should draw on all energy sources to remain well diversified in its power generation.

We also need grid hardening against extreme weather events to lower utilities' insurance premiums and maintain credit ratings. Moreover, we should deploy capital towards demand-side management. Here, Germany's state development bank—the KfW—presents a world-class model, using automated digital approvals to fund energy efficiency retrofits that effectively cut winter peak demand.

Finally, pillar four focuses on ending greenhushing and on offering reliable climate data to investors. After Bill C-59 passed in 2024, firms producing 95% of Canadian oil sands output struck their public transition data overnight, while greenwashing complaints against Canadian banks jumped by 70%.

As the 2025 institute for sustainable finance study confirmed, legal ambiguity is chilling climate reporting. Even after the more recent Bill C-15, litigation risks and a reverse burden of proof remain as points of concern. Investors cannot fund our energy transition in the dark. They need data and firms willing to disclose them. Parliament should pair our emerging sustainable finance taxonomy with a legal safe harbour for corporate statements made in good faith so that honest businesses can report transition plans without a fear of lawsuits.

Thank you for your time. I welcome your questions.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Mr. Walker.

We go now to Ms. Belliveau and Ms. Levin. You have the floor for five minutes.

Emilia Belliveau Program Manager, Energy Transition, Environmental Defence Canada

Good afternoon, and thank you to the committee for this opportunity to share the perspective of Environmental Defence on Canada's electrification, energy self-sufficiency and domestic energy future.

In general, Environmental Defence welcomes the Government of Canada's recognition that electrification is central to Canada's climate goals and its pursuit of energy and economic sovereignty. Canada's wind energy, solar energy and energy storage sectors will provide the power an electrifying and growing economy needs. However, we are deeply concerned that the strategy as presented risks entrenching Canada's dependence on fossil fuels rather than accelerating our transition away from them.

The discussion paper the government released earlier this year, “Powering Canada Strong: A National Strategy for an Electrified Canadian Economy”, positions natural gas as “strategic” and “essential” to Canada's electricity future. This is wrong on two counts. First, it's wrong as a matter of climate policy, and second, it's wrong as a matter of economics.

Canada's electricity sector is already approximately 80% non-emitting, a global advantage we must build on and not squander. The path forward must prioritize wind, solar, energy storage, demand-side management and grid modernization, not a prolonged reliance on natural gas justified by short-term cost or reliability concerns that can be directly addressed through clean alternatives.

In fact, surging emissions from gas-fired power plants, which have doubled in the last decade to 40 megatonnes in 2024, have already erased half of the gains made by cleaning up Canada's electricity sector by phasing out coal. Natural gas is a fossil fuel, most of which is fracked in Canada. A full life-cycle analysis of the emissions of natural gas, which is how its impact would be best measured, demonstrates that gas can be just as polluting as coal, given the huge volumes leaked in extraction and transit.

The latest data on the cost competitiveness of energy sources demonstrates that gas is more expensive than renewable energy, even when compared with renewables paired with battery storage. This was further supported by the outcomes of recent procurements in Ontario. Adding greenhouse gas abatement technology like carbon capture would only serve to make gas significantly more expensive while almost certainly failing to reduce emissions to near zero, which must be Canada's overarching goal.

Independent analysis from Environment and Climate Change Canada, which commissioned five modelling firms and was presented in October 2024, demonstrates that a near-zero-emissions electricity grid by 2035 is achievable and economically viable across most of Canada. The modelling shows that all scenarios result in substantial emissions reductions under the clean electricity regulations, with collective reductions ranging from 182 to 588 megatonnes of CO2 equivalent between 2025 and 2050 across all five models.

The average cost of abatement across all models is $58 per tonne over the 2025 to 2050 period, which is well within the range of cost-effective climate action and far below the social cost of carbon. All models built grids that respected the policy constraints of the CER without any rupture in the ability to supply energy and capacity. The modelling confirms that the primary driver of cost in achieving near-zero emissions is not the regulations themselves but the pace of transmission build-out and the availability of flexible resources like storage, interties and demand response. The answer to grid reliability concerns is more investment in clean flexibility, not more gas.

The proposed amendments to the clean electricity regulations, as articulated in Canada's discussion paper, represent a dangerous and unacceptable rollback of Canada's most important regulatory tool for grid decarbonization. If the government moves forward with these changes, it will undermine the regulatory certainty needed for clean energy investment, delay the transition away from fossil fuels and create serious stranded asset risk while damaging Canada's international climate credibility.

Canada has a diverse electricity supply mix, including one of the best hydro power resources in the world. Canada has other abundant clean energy resources, from solar to offshore wind and geothermal. Coupled with existing clean energy resources, they can be used to deliver the goal of a net-zero electricity grid. In fact, few other countries are better positioned to achieve this goal than Canada.

Once again, thank you for this opportunity. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Ms. Belliveau.

We'll move on to Ms. Stirling for five minutes.