Evidence of meeting #9 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was meetings.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Walshe  Associate Head, Canadian Centre for Cyber Security, Communications Security Establishment
Arbour  Director General, Telecommunications and Internet Policy Branch, Department of Industry
Gibson  Director, Cyber Protection Policy Division, Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness
Couillard  Director General, Cyber Partnerships, Canadian Centre for Cyber Security, Communications Security Establishment
MacSween  Director General, National Cyber Security Directorate, Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you for those great questions, Ms. Acan.

Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Ms. Walshe, we had Ms. Gibson in the previous panel, and she said that the government was well aware of the jurisdictional overlap with provincial cybersecurity authorities when it was drafting Bill C‑8.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Mrs. DeBellefeuille, sorry to interrupt you, but you mustn't refer to information that was provided in camera.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

That's right. My apologies.

Ms. Walshe, Bill C‑8 will probably lead to interference in certain provincial and territorial responsibilities. Our party came to the same realization in relation to agreements between Hydro‑Québec and the U.S.

You play a central role in protecting government information, and you said at the outset, in your presentation, that the government could not tackle cyber-threats on its own. It has to be a team effort, bringing together businesses, provinces and territories.

Under Bill C‑8, how do you plan to share information with your provincial and territorial partners?

12:30 p.m.

Associate Head, Canadian Centre for Cyber Security, Communications Security Establishment

Bridget Walshe

Thank you for your question. I'm going to answer in English.

We have very strong working relationships with our counterparts in all the provinces and territories. For example, we meet regularly with those responsible for cybersecurity. We have a working group that meets in person at least once a year to exchange information on cybersecurity issues, and in fact we have discussed Bill C-8 and Bill C-26, the predecessor, with our counterparts and have really heard from them about the fact that....

Hydro-Québec is a good example, because they are subject to regulation within Quebec and they are subject to regulation within the U.S. because of the transborder energy they sell. They would also be subject to regulation under Bill C-8. We really have a good connection with them to understand their concerns with new regulation and the processes involved.

Also, we work regularly, on a day-to-day basis, when it comes to cyber-threats. We work very closely with all critical infrastructure providers and provinces and territories to share threat information.

For example, if we hear about a cyber-incident impacting Canadian critical infrastructure, while we don't have mandatory reporting requirements today, we receive voluntary reports. We take that information, understand it, and distill what we can share. We share that information with critical infrastructure partners and with the provinces and territories so that everyone is able to take that information and use it to defend their own networks.

I might turn to my colleague Dan Couillard to share a little more detail about our interactions with the provinces and territories.

Daniel Couillard Director General, Cyber Partnerships, Canadian Centre for Cyber Security, Communications Security Establishment

Since the Canadian centre for cyber security was created, we have worked extensively on our relationships with the provinces and territories. As my colleague mentioned, incidents are reported to us, and that's been the case since the centre opened.

In 2024‑25, more than 1,400 cybersecurity incidents were reported to the centre. In every case, we worked with other jurisdictions. We shared information. Many cases involved regulated entities with cross-border operations in the U.S., Canada or the provinces. We are familiar with those situations, and we've been examining them for a number of years now.

Under Bill C‑8, it will be mandatory to report certain incidents. The idea behind the approach is that the more information we have, the better equipped we are to identify the threat and notify the targeted entity, as well as other entities in the sector. They can then work proactively to protect themselves, while protecting other sectors as well. As we know, Canada's critical infrastructure sectors are highly interconnected, so timely responses are key. We are familiar with all that, and with Bill C‑8, we'll be able to gather and share that wealth of information.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Bill C‑8 sets out penalties. In light of the jurisdictional overlap, I was wondering whether Hydro-Québec, for instance, would be subject to a double penalty if it violated Bill C‑8.

12:30 p.m.

Director, Cyber Protection Policy Division, Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness

Kelly-Anne Gibson

Bill C-8 was created in a way that lets us rely on the existing regulator for the entities. The reason we did that was that those regulators already know their business, so they're already very familiar with working in a regulatory environment where there is another provincial regulator and where they can deconflict.

I can't speak to how they would deconflict or whether there could be a case of a double AMP or something of that nature. However, what I can say is that we would rely on the existing regulators, who are already used to managing provincial and federal regulation in those industries to promote compliance in those industries.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Mrs. DeBellefeuille.

Over to you, Mr. Gill, for five minutes.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the witnesses for being here today.

My line of questioning is going to be on freedom of speech and expression.

The Canadian Constitution Foundation has raised concern about the civil liberties implications of Bill C-8 in proposed section 15.2, which would give the minister the ability to make decisions to kick someone off the Internet.

What safeguards are in place to prevent the government from using cybersecurity as a pretext for silencing speech?

12:35 p.m.

Director General, Telecommunications and Internet Policy Branch, Department of Industry

Andre Arbour

I certainly appreciate the importance of the subject raised. There are protections at the outset, during the use of the authority and after the fact. For instance, the policy objective specifies the protection of the Canadian telecommunications system as the overarching scope of action, so individual speech has no bearing on the ability of Bell Canada or Rogers to maintain its network or the reliability of its services. There is no relation there.

There's further precision that the use of the authority needs to be reasonable relative to the gravity or the nature of the threat that you're trying to combat. There are criteria established by the Supreme Court over many decades, including in the 2019 Vavilov decision, which specifies what reasonableness will be. There are other oversight and reporting requirements, including to NSIRA, NSICOP and then, finally, to Parliament.

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

Okay, thank you for that.

Well, it seems that if this legislation is passed in its current form, unamended, we are going to be giving the Minister of Industry sweeping powers, with virtually no checks or balances. In theory, the minister could wake up one morning, as one of my colleagues referenced, and not be impressed by a post on social media, going further to basically say that it poses a threat to our telecommunications services. Without a warrant, without a trial, without any automatic judicial review, the minister could compel Rogers or Telus to go seek these people's private data.

What do you have to say about that?

12:35 p.m.

Director General, Telecommunications and Internet Policy Branch, Department of Industry

Andre Arbour

I would note the scoping mechanisms that limit any action with respect to the disconnection of services. Furthermore, to the question about personal data, first, the scoping applies to those considerations as well. Again, the personal data or browsing history of individual Canadians is not germane to the underlying maintenance or reliability of the telecommunications infrastructure in question.

There is a further amendment that was adopted with Bill C-26. For greater certainty, it explicitly prohibits the use.... This was already prohibited, but it adds an extra level of clarity so that the order-making powers cannot be used to intercept private communications.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

What measures can be put in place to ensure that this isn't misused, or worse, turned into a political tool for the Liberal government against people or organizations they disagree with?

12:35 p.m.

Director General, Telecommunications and Internet Policy Branch, Department of Industry

Andre Arbour

Ultimately, what the committee decides is the committee's prerogative, so I can't speak on behalf of the committee. I would note that the set of authorities that were introduced with the bill and that were adopted in the previous committee study add protection both at the outset of the scoping.... The concerns that have been raised are already prohibited within the scoping of the law currently. There are also consultation requirements that allow for additional oversight and consideration of the use of those powers. Then, there are notification requirements and reporting requirements, including for the narrow confidential use of authorities, that ensure oversight.

12:40 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

I have a final question.

Multiple civil society groups have raised concerns about federal governments trying to grant themselves the power of intrusion into our private lives in the name of security. Have these organizations been genuinely consulted before the development of this bill?

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

You have about 15 seconds.

12:40 p.m.

Director, Cyber Protection Policy Division, Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness

Kelly-Anne Gibson

The short answer is yes. We have received multiple submissions from civil liberties organizations. I can say for sure that my team looked at them, studied them very carefully and considered them very carefully, including submissions that were made to the committee in the previous Parliament. We studied those very carefully.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you for your questions, Mr. Gill.

It is now Ms. Dandurand's turn for five minutes.

Marianne Dandurand Liberal Compton—Stanstead, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, for the very clear answers. It's all very interesting.

I want to follow up on my fellow member's questions about privacy. Ordinary citizens are very concerned. Can you enlighten us and tell us who exactly the cybersecurity legislation covers?

12:40 p.m.

Director, Cyber Protection Policy Division, Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness

Kelly-Anne Gibson

I can speak to part 2, and then perhaps I can turn to my colleague for part 1.

Part 2 would apply only to designated operators who have been established in schedule 2 of the act. Currently, the way the act is written, schedule 1 lists vital services that we need to protect, and then within those sectors, we would designate, through the regulation-making process, specific operators. The obligations act only upon those designated operators, so those are the owners and operators of critical infrastructure. It's those companies that it would act on.

12:40 p.m.

Director General, Telecommunications and Internet Policy Branch, Department of Industry

Andre Arbour

In short, the proposed act in part 1 applies to telecom service providers such as Bell and Rogers.

Privacy came up because, generally speaking, the networks of telecom providers hold customer data, Canadians' and businesses' data. That is why the powers provided for in Bill C‑8 have a limited scope. The bill includes clarifications such as the one prohibiting personal communications from being intercepted. That is all to make clear that Canadians' personal information is not subject to these powers. Instead, the purpose is to protect networks and critical infrastructure.

Marianne Dandurand Liberal Compton—Stanstead, QC

I understand that the bill, in its current form, in no way applies to people's personal information, but are more safeguards necessary? Since the proposed act does not apply to personal data currently, can we be sure that that won't change in the future?

12:40 p.m.

Director General, Telecommunications and Internet Policy Branch, Department of Industry

Andre Arbour

The powers set out are really aimed at telecom service providers and their networks. Specific powers make it possible to collect information from those providers. The idea is to understand what equipment their networks use. Canadians' personal information is not covered by the measures, which are aimed at protecting the networks in question.

The powers in this part of the bill and their scope are directly tied to the order. Although some situations engage just one aspect of the bill, the part has to be read as a whole in order to better understand the safeguards it contains.