That feels really interesting, because I think the language around deepfakes is really tricky to get precise. I don't have it in front of me, but the language in that bill is whether it's a reasonable representation of another person. I can't remember what the exact language is.
When we look at deepfakes, it's not as though the harm is that you're creating a perfect replica of someone who is nude or engaged in sexual activity. It's the idea that we should have some control over the way our voices, our faces and our bodies are represented online. One of the concerns I have with the language in that bill is that it might be interpreted as if the image doesn't look entirely real and if the person has a third eye on their forehead or a unicorn horn or something else like this, you'll know that it's not a real person. I think there are some concerns with the language of the act regarding how it will be interpreted by the courts.
We'll have to see, once cases come through, because there's so much you can do with deepfakes, and it's not just that a deepfake looks exactly like a real person. It's the fact that it's a misrepresentation of ourselves. I think much of the focus has been on sexual deepfakes, but this goes beyond sexual deepfakes. Think about the harms that occur to people when their images and their faces are co-opted. We see this amongst politicians who have had deepfakes where they're saying things that they didn't say. It's causing confusion and disruption. There has been this focus on sexual deepfakes, but we might need to think more broadly about what rights we have to our images and our voices.
I think there is a gap in the law regarding creation. I'm not sure if criminalization is the perfect answer, but if you look at children's content, we criminalize the creation, the access and the possession—all of these things. With sexual deepfakes, it's still permissible to create that content. I think there are some questions about that. If we're not actually stopping it at the creation point, the only thing we're dealing with is post-distribution, when the harm has already occurred. I think there are interesting legal questions around what the legalities are around creation. Do we need to think beyond just sexual deepfakes, then, and ask how we can protect people from their faces and their voices being co-opted more broadly?