Evidence of meeting #52 for Status of Women in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was young.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Dunn  Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual
Parent  Cofounder and Executive Director, Le Centre pour l’intelligence émotionnelle en ligne
Tamil Kendall  Director, Partnership for Women's Health Research Canada
Attard-Frost  Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Alberta, As an Individual
Sestock  National President, Canadian Federation of University Women
Gillespie  Executive Director, Equal Voice Foundation
Ruddick  Coordinator, Election Tracking and Research, Equal Voice Foundation

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

That's excellent.

Now I have a question for Dr. Kendall.

It's about getting disaggregated data on women's health so that women will get improved health care, especially in a lot of areas that are not well understood. Menopause was one of the studies we just finished, for example.

What do we need to do, as a government, to get that data happening?

5:30 p.m.

Director, Partnership for Women's Health Research Canada

Dr. Tamil Kendall

There's a need for increased investment in women's health research. We know, now, that only 7% of the CIHR budget is dedicated to women's health research, in terms of publicly funded research that is female-specific. We need to have these commitments to SGBA-plus monitored and reported on in health data. As I said, we need to ensure that women's health experts, like the ones in my network, are the ones designing and feeding data into the AI systems that are generating applications for use in women and 2SLGBTQI people.

Those are some of the places to start.

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

I believe that is my time.

5:30 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Yes, Ms. Gladu. You had three seconds left. Thank you very much.

Ms. Larouche, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

Thank you again, Ms. Parent, Ms. Dunn and Ms. Kendall, for being part of the first panel of witnesses in this first hour of the meeting.

I will finish what I was about to say at the end of my first intervention, Ms. Kendall.

You have partly answered that question. We understand the links between the lack of research and the need to make greater use of artificial intelligence. As you said, it can be extremely relevant, for example, in analyzing medical imaging more accurately to detect cancer. You also said that it can be extremely useful to support research.

I will now go back to the question I was going to ask you. In fact, 61% of women and gender-diverse people have experienced cyber-violence because of their gender identity. Beyond research, the analysis of medical imaging and women's physical health, what about mental health? What more could be done, for example, to provide more services needed by victims of cyber-violence and deepfakes?

Time is running out, so I invite you to answer in 30 seconds. I see Ms. Dunn nodding, so she may have something to add. Ms. Parent seems to want to add something as well.

Obviously, we have to think about supporting these victims.

5:30 p.m.

Director, Partnership for Women's Health Research Canada

Dr. Tamil Kendall

I would defer to Dr. Dunn on this topic.

5:30 p.m.

Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual

Suzie Dunn

The mental health aspects are really challenging. Young people are facing a lot of digital issues. One of the responses is to say, “Let's have them not engage with these tools. We're not going to have them use technology, and we're not going to have them use social media.” However, if we're taking them away from these spaces that might be causing these harms, what else are we offering? Especially for this generation, there are very few third spaces for young people to spend their time in. There aren't a lot of options for them beyond these digital social spaces, especially as their worlds become more closed. Children don't have the freedom they used to have.

Creating more opportunities for young people to engage in things outside of digital spaces is very important, but so is having health practitioners who really understand social media, digital spaces and AI in such a way that young people can get non-judgmental supports when they are facing mental health distresses from these types of technologies.

In some of the research I did with the DIY digital safety project—

5:30 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, Ms. Dunn. I have the unpleasant task of interrupting you.

Anna, you have the floor for five minutes.

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you very much for being here today. I know that this is the second time for some of you. Welcome back to Ottawa.

The first question I'm going to ask, on behalf of my colleague, is for Dr. Kendall.

Do you believe we need a national data framework for health data in Canada, yes or no?

5:30 p.m.

Director, Partnership for Women's Health Research Canada

5:30 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

That was good. See, I'm not that tough.

My next question is for Suzie Dunn.

As the shadow minister for seniors, I'm very conscientious of the numerous and vile scams that are perpetrated upon our older—I like to call us “mature”—Canadians. Generative AI being able to mimic the voices and faces of loved ones has opened the door to an even more extreme form of these scams. In my view, how do we educate our older population, our mature population, on looking out for these scams?

How do we hold the technical companies responsible to ensure that they're monitoring it? Right now, we're looking at a billion dollars' worth of scams in the senior population. What are your suggestions to help prevent this?

5:35 p.m.

Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual

Suzie Dunn

The senior population is very difficult to reach. I think education campaigns targeted at them are a real challenge. There are often some simple tools that can be used. One is having a code word with family, such as always knowing that if your daughter ever calls you to ask you for money, she's going to say “pineapple” if she really needs it. It's so that they know these types of things. I find the elderly are some of the most difficult.

Some of the incentives that I think are important are both with the social media companies and with banks. If we required banks to reimburse people for some of the money that is lost in scams—as you see in other countries like the United Kingdom—I think banks would be very incentivized to educate their customers. There might be other avenues that we can look at, both to incentivize change and to ensure that the losses they face are lesser. It's having banking regulations for when you see odd patterns of behaviour where people are taking out cash or these types of things.

The education piece is very difficult. Many of these scams occur in patterns in the same way that we see sexual extortion scams occur. They'll use the same accounts and the same images. Having accountability for this being one of the harms that social media companies need to mitigate when we see repeat offenders....

5:35 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Coming from the banking world, I will tell you that accounts are monitored on a regular basis, and activities will trigger a message. Sometimes, when you're talking to a senior and asking why they are withdrawing $10,000 and whether they know it's a danger to them once they leave the branch if somebody's watching, the idea that they need this money to protect a loved one is so ingrained that they're not going to listen to you.

Anyway, you mentioned freedom for children. I kind of listened to that because human trafficking is becoming a huge issue in this country. The perpetrators are using fake pictures and selling these children, to put it bluntly. I recently did an undercover stint with our local police department. I was shocked, totally shocked. What can we do once those pictures of that individual are on the Internet or wherever, in AI? How can we hold these companies responsible to ensure that those pictures don't get out?

5:35 p.m.

Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual

Suzie Dunn

There's a great type of technology called image hashing. The Canadian Centre for Child Protection does this for sexual images of children. You can create a numeric code of an image. Then, if an image is repeatedly shared on a particular website, it can just be taken down. They use this to find child sexual abuse material. There might be ways to try to create other forms of laws or services, where you could include other child-trafficking images that might not necessarily be child sexual abuse material and use that same type of technology to try to identify and remove those images online. It can be very difficult once they've proliferated, especially if they are popular amongst people who might be collecting certain types of images. What we see amongst child abusers is that they'll often be collecting certain types of images. However, there is technology to help locate and pre-emptively remove those images.

5:35 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

I'm going to ask you for your personal opinion. Do you feel that these perpetrators should be put behind bars?

5:35 p.m.

Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual

Suzie Dunn

Do you mean the people who are trafficking children?

5:35 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Yes.

5:35 p.m.

Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual

5:35 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Thank you.

5:35 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

That was the last word, Mrs. Roberts.

Ms. Parent, I can see you wanted to speak. I am really sorry, but Mrs. Roberts’ speaking time has run out.

Ms. Chi, you have the floor for five minutes.

Chi Nguyen Liberal Spadina—Harbourfront, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I would like to thank the witnesses for being here today.

I will start with Ms. Parent.

I'm sorry, but I have to switch to English.

In your opening remarks, you talked a bit about that pendulum—the signals young people are getting that AI is here so they need to use it, but then they should live in shame about it because it's terrible and terrifying. I just got an email from my school board letting me know some students are making images and deepfakes of staff and teachers. There is a lot for young people to unpack.

I was wondering if you could help us describe what it means to do this well and responsibly. What could that look like as we think about what young people need to navigate life online?

5:40 p.m.

Cofounder and Executive Director, Le Centre pour l’intelligence émotionnelle en ligne

Emmanuelle Parent

To be non-judgmental, we need to trust young people's intelligence and engage with them as adults in the conversation. Young people see adults using their phones and playing video games. They often become very defensive if you tell them that they, as young people, use artificial intelligence and TikTok a lot. So, the idea is to talk to them using the pronoun ‘we', in other words, to join in the conversation as adults.

We should also always point out that we recognize the benefits of device use before discussing the risks. We must also ensure that young people have a say in consultations so that they feel their voices are heard on issues that affect them. I would add that we must not neglect media literacy. When young people have a better understanding of how artificial intelligence works, it helps to develop their critical thinking and influences how they react if they ever find themselves in situations such as the one you have just described in relation to your school.

I also believe that another way to help young people with digital technology is to focus on what happens outside the digital world. When we facilitate their access to free health care services that are available at their school, or when they do not have to pay their own dentist bills, they are less likely to ask ChatGPT what to do if their left molar is hurting. So, having these services available to young people can also promote their well-being.

Chi Nguyen Liberal Spadina—Harbourfront, ON

Thank you very much, Ms. Parent.

Ms. Dunn, one of the things you noted in your remarks was the idea of victim-centred legal responses. Could you tell us what that might look like?

5:40 p.m.

Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual

Suzie Dunn

Victim-centred responses differ, depending on the type of harm a person is experiencing. One of the challenges we face is this: We'll rush to a criminal response to a particular type of harm, but a criminal response isn't necessarily the solution a person is looking for. Intimate image cases are the ideal example. They don't want to go through a criminal trial, necessarily. They just want the content taken down.

In the same way, one of the challenges government faces.... Think about AI companies. What consultation is being done? Who's being spoken to? You'll bring in experts like us, and we'll provide the information we have from our experiences talking with and working with victims. As you create regulation, talk to victims: “Is this actually providing you with the solution you want?” It's also about looking at the data. Are people using this law?

The B.C. law is an extraordinary example. They have the Civil Resolution Tribunal. It's accessible. It's low cost. You don't need a lawyer. There have been hundreds of cases there, and it's only been around for a year or two. However, in provinces like Nova Scotia, where you have to hire a lawyer to get your civil rights implemented, we don't have any cases. There have been some settlements that have occurred.

Laws aren't helpful unless people use them and unless they're providing us with the remedies we need. This is why we need to see research on how satisfied victims are with the responses.

Chi Nguyen Liberal Spadina—Harbourfront, ON

Thank you.

One of the items you talked about was the right to deletion. In Bill C-36, the protecting privacy and consumer data act, we are looking to do just that: create the right to deletion.

Is there any guidance you have on making sure we get that right in order to fight back against deepfakes?