Evidence of meeting #52 for Status of Women in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was young.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Dunn  Associate Professor and Director, Law and Technology Institute, Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, As an Individual
Parent  Cofounder and Executive Director, Le Centre pour l’intelligence émotionnelle en ligne
Tamil Kendall  Director, Partnership for Women's Health Research Canada
Attard-Frost  Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Alberta, As an Individual
Sestock  National President, Canadian Federation of University Women
Gillespie  Executive Director, Equal Voice Foundation
Ruddick  Coordinator, Election Tracking and Research, Equal Voice Foundation

6:35 p.m.

Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Alberta, As an Individual

Blair Attard-Frost

I'm sorry. I thought you were directing that to the Equal Voice folks—my apologies.

There are a few main things. The first piece of it has to do with what's being covered by Bill C-16. Right now, we're covering only the distribution of deepfakes, but we should also be looking at criminalizing the creation and possession of deepfakes, as a preventative measure against further distribution. A couple of ways could be to specify this to be creation and possession with intent to distribute for cases of threats or blackmail, or negligent or wilful possession after consent has been withdrawn.

Just yesterday, the Government of Alberta announced their own deepfake legislation. That includes provisions around creation and revocation of consent, so there's very much a precedent for that kind of approach in Canada, as well as internationally. South Korea has built a really robust legislative framework around deepfakes.

I think we should also be expanding the scope of imagery covered by the law to cover non-consensually sexualized uses of one's likeness, rather than the definition set out in Bill C-16, which covers only imagery that is “likely to be mistaken for a visual recording of that person.” As people in the previous session talked about, there are many ways that this kind of definition can shift the legal burden onto victims and create a lot of lack of clarity in how the law is interpreted.

With regard to Bill C-34, we can also amend that to require providers of generative AI services to demonstrate in some way that their systems have been tested and safeguarded against hateful and non-consensual sexual uses prior to deployment, rather than the current status quo in Bill C-34, which is to create a digital safety plan, but it's not clear if the provider is going to be following that.

6:35 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you very much, Ms. Attard‑Frost. I am sorry to interrupt you. I am not trying to pick on you. Thank you very much for your understanding.

Ms. DeRidder, you have five minutes.

6:35 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Unfortunately, I have to use a bit of my time to put a motion on notice. I hope I have enough time left to ask a question.

My motion—Elly, this one's for you—is as follows:

That, given that 90% of end of life caregivers are women, the committee undertake a study of at least four meetings on the adequacy and flexibility of Employment Insurance caregiver benefits for Canadians providing end of life care to a family member; the committee examine options to make caregiver benefits more flexible and responsive to the unpredictable nature of end of life illness; this study include witness testimony deemed appropriate by the committee and that upon conclusion of this study, the committee report its findings and recommendations to the House.

For you, Ms. Gillespie, we've had a lot of discussion today around attacks, with AI specifically used, on women in politics and women in leadership roles. I personally have had a few AI-generated attacks circulating on the Internet, and I can understand that it is quite harmful. You get that sinking feeling in your stomach when you see one, and then you think to yourself, “Oh, that's terrible.”

I can recognize that it is quite harmful for women in leadership roles. What are your recommendations to protect women in leadership roles against these AI-generated attacks?

6:35 p.m.

Executive Director, Equal Voice Foundation

Laurel Gillespie

Before we can come up with any real, viable solutions and start to really address it as a more global issue, we need to look at the hard-core data: the frequency, the severity and where these things are being manifested from.

One thing that women and those who are gender-diverse can do is support one another and even call out the men. I'm sorry, men in the room. We need to call you out to be allies to this cause and to provoke and stimulate change so that we don't see the occurrences that we do.

The reporting mechanisms also have to be in place.

I'm sorry to hear that you've experienced this. I'm also curious to know what was done about it. Was it documented? Is there some place you can go to say how often this is occurring and to what severity?

6:40 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

At the end of the day, one thing that you mentioned is to just start talking about it. I'm sure many of us in the room have had these ads happen specifically to us. I think that opening the conversation is really important. That's why I chose to start with that myself.

I agree that we need data, for sure, to recognize how often this is happening to women in leadership roles.

Ms. Attard-Frost, AI is being used more and more to make decisions that affect people's education and careers. In your opinion, what should remain a human decision when AI is involved, and how do we make sure that there's accountability for the decisions? Specifically, what tools are used in generative forms to keep a human in the loop?

6:40 p.m.

Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Alberta, As an Individual

Blair Attard-Frost

What tools should be used to keep a human in the loop and ensure that we have accountability? It really depends on the context. In general, we are going to need some form of regulatory oversight, and that's going to differ from use case to use case.

Generally, the approach that we're taking already, through things like Bill C-34, has indicated that it makes a lot of sense to address individual use cases that might be harmful and build regulatory regimes around them or adapt existing regulatory structures. We're now applying the existing privacy law and regulatory infrastructure that we have to address privacy risks related to automated processing of consumer data, for example.

It's really hard to give a sweeping answer to that, because these kinds of regulatory questions are so tied to context, accountability and oversight. It looks a little bit different in every context, a little bit different in every use case. That has to do with the risk profile of each use case as well as existing regulatory regimes in various sectors and application areas.

6:40 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Thank you very much for that. I agree. It was a multi-faceted question, but thank you for answering how you did.

When we examine the impact on women and gender-diverse individuals, how do we distinguish between problems caused by technology and problems that already exist in society?

6:40 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

I'm sorry, Kelly. That's all the time you have.

Ms. Begum, you have the floor for five minutes.

Doly Begum Liberal Scarborough Southwest, ON

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

First, I'm not regularly on this committee, but this is fascinating. I sit on the justice committee. Of course, Bill C-34 is one of those ones that I think are so relevant to the conversation here.

It's been really inspiring to listen to all of you. Thank you for the work that you all do, all our witnesses who are here today. Thank you for taking the time to come and share all the concerns you have and for the work you've done in the past, which I know from your bios. I'm sure all the committee members would appreciate any recommendations you may have that you want to add to our study and share going forward as well, if you want to send those.

I would like to start with Linda Sestock.

I know you've done a lot of work in gender bias in AI algorithms and women's participation in STEM. With some of the recommendations that you've made, would you like to share those—and our analysts could also listen to this as well—in terms of some of the ways we can incentivize more women's participation?

Then we can make policies that allow us going forward, in the future, to face a world where AI policies are made by women or gender-diverse people who understand, experience and reflect their realities.

6:40 p.m.

National President, Canadian Federation of University Women

Linda Sestock

Thank you very much for that question. It's a good question.

Money is a big factor that's going to be needed. There are a lot of women entrepreneurs. We're talking about how women are affected, but there are many women who are working in fields that involve AI. I think it's our duty to make sure that investments are going towards women as entrepreneurs as well, so that they have a voice at the table.

We have another thing too. It's very important that we audit the work in the AI systems out there and make sure that they're inclusive for everybody, including gender-diverse and disabled people. It's very important. It's been shown over time that a lot of women look at business in a different way and involve more of a human touch to it—no offence to the gentleman in the room.

It's important that investment be made at the school level, and also that when women are out in the workforce and starting their businesses, we're there to support them.

Doly Begum Liberal Scarborough Southwest, ON

Thank you very much for that.

I have a few more minutes left, and I want to go to Professor Blair Attard-Frost. Thank you again for being here.

Some of the things that you spoke about were weaknesses that we have in terms of governance and industries that are focusing on what benefits them versus marginalized communities. Recently when one of my nieces was watching something, I was passing by and just listening in. I thought it was just this harmless YouTube cartoon she was watching. It was fascinating to see all the biases—and not just biases. There was discrimination in how some women looked and different types of Islamophobia. There was anti-Black racism. I mean, it was just the way people were stereotypically put in different situations, and it really dawned on me that this four- or five-year-old was being exposed to something like this. Sometimes we don't really monitor what's being watched in those situations.

Are there recommendations that you would want us to look at that may not touch Bill C-34? I know we're trying to tackle some of those as well to make sure that youth and children's safety is number one, but if there is something that you think we're doing well, I would love to hear it, as well as if there's something you would recommend that we should focus on.

6:45 p.m.

Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Alberta, As an Individual

Blair Attard-Frost

Thank you for a really good question.

Echoing what others have said in this session and in the previous one, there's this really big challenge around literacy and education, going back to the notion that bias doesn't begin in the actual tech product. The technology begins in kindergarten through grade 12 and continues in post-secondary and into the workforce, so if we really want to address bias in a systematic way, we have to be thinking about the entire spectrum of social life where bias can enter into how these systems eventually get built.

Part of that is through education. Part of it is through having a responsible media ecosystem. Part of it is through talking with children and educating children and having some oversight over what our children are looking at.

6:45 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

I am sorry for interrupting, Ms. Attard‑Frost. That is all the time we have for this committee meeting.

I would like to thank all our guests here today. It was very informative.

Is it the will of the committee to adjourn?

A voice

Absolutely.

6:45 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

The meeting is adjourned. Have a good evening.