House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was tax.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Liberal MP for LaSalle—Émard (Québec)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 48% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Taxation December 5th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, dealing with the last part of the member's question, I would like to thank all members of the finance committee for the report which came out today. I say to the chairman and the members who wrote the majority report, it appears to be a very good document, very constructive and worthwhile.

Although I have not had the opportunity to read the minority reports in full, I would like to mention to the Bloc finance critic that-

I would like to thank the financial critics from the Reform Party. I am sure the work they have done will be of the same quality as in the past.

The hon. member said that the Reform Party does not intend to cut health transfers. Let me simply-

Taxation December 5th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, under those circumstances it is quite clear that I will have to change my definition of an extremist.

Whether it be a $4 billion tax cut or whether it be as the Reform has suggested a $15 billion to $20 billion tax cut, the fact is that one has to pay for it. The issue is not whether one would like to see a tax cut. There is nobody in this House who would not like to see a tax cut. The question is: What programs would have to be cut, would have to be given up, in order to pay for that tax cut?

The government is not prepared to see health care impaired. The government is not prepared to see old age pensions impaired. This government is going to stand behind the basic social fabric of the nation and under those circumstances, we will stay the course.

Canada Pension Plan December 5th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, as the hon. member knows, we have brought in selective tax benefits for Canadians in all of our budgets and we intend to continue in that vein.

The hon. member put his finger on it when he said that if there are going to be further tax cuts they will have to be accompanied by cuts in social spending. I congratulate the Reform Party for at least having outlined those areas where it believes ongoing cuts in spending should be made. I encourage the Reform Party to speak to their other extreme right wing cousins, those in the Conservative Party, and ask them to outline where they would make the cuts.

Canada Pension Plan December 5th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, there is no linkage between CPP premiums and EI premiums any more than there is between CPP premiums and other payroll taxes such as imposed by the provinces, workers compensation, health or education levies. In fact, each has to stand on its own feet.

The member's question is very pertinent. One would really hope that the joint stewardship of the CPP between the federal government and the provincial and territorial governments will lead all

parties to deal with the immediate need for financial stability of the plan.

I am, I must say, quite optimistic that we will arrive at a solution. I would prefer to have done it by January 1. We may go beyond that but I believe there is goodwill on all sides to arrive at a solution.

Taxation December 5th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, unfortunately it is the member opposite who does not understand the tax system.

The change we made to the system means that, when someone leaves the country, it is quite likely the tax is not due, since the item in question was never sold; so there is no capital gains tax. We want to be sure that, when the item or shares are sold, the tax will be paid by someone who is now a non-resident. So we insist on a debenture.

Unfortunately, the situation is clear enough for the member to perhaps have some difficulty understanding it.

Taxation December 5th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, I repeat what I said last week. When taxes are due, they must be paid. If, for one reason or another, a tax due is not paid and the tax is duly levied, interest accumulates.

Canadian Airlines December 4th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, when one looks at the taxation of any entity, one has to take a look at the full range of taxes: payroll taxes, corporate taxes, excise taxes and anything else. The taxes levied on Canadian transporters are quite competitive and do not in any way inhibit their situation.

Furthermore, on international routes, the federal government does not impose undue taxation. What the hon. member might want to do is to take a look at the level of provincial taxation.

Employment Insurance December 3rd, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the unemployment insurance account is being treated by this government exactly as it was under the previous government. In fact, the innovations brought in by the previous government were the recommendations of the auditor general.

As the hon. member knows, since we have taken office we have in each and every year brought unemployment insurance premiums down. In fact, in the last two years we have brought them down by $1.8 billion. Also, as the hon. member knows, the fact is that when the Conservative government was in power each and every year that it took office it increased those premiums.

The real question that the whole country wants to know is how is the Progressive Conservative Party going to pay for the massive tax cut it has recommended. Is the Conservative Party going to do as Reform and cut health care? Is it going to do as Reform and cut equalization payments?

What social programs is the Conservative Party going to cut in order to pay for its tax reduction? The leader of the Conservative Party owes the Canadian people an answer. When is he going to have the courage to provide it?

Taxation December 3rd, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the Canada pension plan, which the Reform Party would seek to destroy, is depended on by more women than men. It is an essential part of their retirement. The Reform Party would take it away.

Health care, which the Reform Party will cut, is important to Canadian women. Why is the Reform Party threatening to take it away? Equalization payments in Atlantic Canada, Manitoba and Saskatchewan are important for the public services that they supply to women.

The Reform Party has the nerve to stand up here and say that they would defend the basic public services on which women depend. The facts speak for themselves. This party is a 14th century party raising headlines in the 8th century. That is what we are dealing with.

Taxation December 3rd, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the one million families referred to by the hon. member would end up paying for that tax reduction in lowered services if they lived in one of the equalization receiving provinces. When a party cuts equalization, it is saying that Canadians who live in those provinces are not entitled to the same level of public services.

The hon. member says that his party will put $4 billion into health care which is simply not the truth. The fact is it would take $4 billion out of health care at the very beginning. Then it would ask Canadians to trust that it would put it back, but Canadians will not do that.

On the issue of millionaires, I would like to thank you, Mr. Speaker, for defending the member for Calgary Centre against the attacks from one of his own.