There is no difference.
House of Commons photoWon his last election, in 2006, with 48% of the vote.
Unemployment Insurance Fund March 27th, 1996
There is no difference.
Unemployment Insurance Fund March 27th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, I can only repeat once again that UI premiums have been used to absorb the deficit, which amounted to about $6 billion. Today, the surplus does not exceed $1 billion.
It is obvious that the funds were not used for any purpose other than to make up the deficit we had inherited.
Now, the deficit, I mean the hon. member-
Unemployment Insurance Fund March 27th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, when we came to power, the UI fund was running a deficit in excess of $6 billion. By the end of 1995, this deficit had turned into a surplus of approximately $735 million. It certainly is not more than $1 billion today. We have made it very clear that we wanted to build a cushion to protect the workers in times of economic decline.
The hon. member talks about diverting funds and that sort of thing. Look, we do not even have a $1 billion surplus to spend on Canadian workers.
Goods And Services Tax March 27th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, first we are talking about a replacement tax that would make it better for consumers and better for small business.
Second, as with any tax, a subsequent government or this government is capable of dealing with it. There is nothing in any single tax that would so bind a government, either federal or provincial, that it could not deal with it and not deal with its own revenues.
The government is going to do what it said in the red book. It is going to do what was promised on page 22. That is what was promised Canadians. The tax system will be dealt with in a way that will allow Canadian companies to create jobs, allow them to be competitive and allow consumers to have a lower rate. In fact, we are going to do a great deal to make this economy better and better and better.
Goods And Services Tax March 27th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, no. There were a number of times in opposition and previous times in my life when I certainly criticized the GST. In fact, I would criticize the GST today. There are a number of major problems with it. In fact, that is why we want to bring in a replacement tax, precisely to deal with those problems.
Environment March 26th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, we welcome and in fact are actively reviewing the proposals of the standing committee on the environment concerning the base line
study. We will be reporting shortly on how we intend to continue the important work which has already been initiated.
I will give some examples of what we have done. In the 1994 budget we brought in tax deductions to encourage contributions to mine reclamation funds. In 1995 we brought in a tax change to encourage donations of ecologically sensitive land. In the 1996 budget which we just brought down, we acted on the key findings of the environment committee's review to help level the playing field between renewable and non-renewable energy sources by, for instance, providing access to flowthrough financing. I would say that we are very active on it.
I would also like to congratulate the environment committee, its chairman and all members of the House who bring this very important matter to the attention of the government.
Taxation March 26th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, I have answered the question. I said that what we want to do and what the provinces have agree to do is sit down and take a look at the way the provinces and the federal government tax the same taxpayer. We have agreed to co-ordinate.
Perhaps I should remind the leader of the Reform Party that in our first budget there were no increases in personal taxes. In our second budget there were no increases in personal income taxes. In our third budget there were no increases in personal taxes, corporate taxes or excise taxes; there were no increases in taxes at all.
Taxation March 26th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, we have made it very clear that with the provinces we are prepared to sit down and take a look at the whole area of federal-provincial tax co-ordination. We have made it very clear and we will be discussing it at the next meeting.
I find it very difficult to understand how the leader of the Reform Party could stand up not one minute ago and say that one of the
problems is the drastic reductions we have imposed on the provinces when in fact his budget from last year had reductions that made ours look like a peanut hill; they were enormous.
Why will he not be consistent? How can he stand up here one day and say one thing, then stand up the next day and say another? Is there no coherence in the Reform Party at all?
Taxation March 26th, 1996
Mr. Speaker, the leader of the Reform Party has a tendency, I am sure due to a difficulty in the research department, to ask the same question time and time again.
He has asked this question before. I have said to him that at the last meeting of the finance ministers we discussed this very issue and their was complete agreement on the need for co-ordination, that it made no sense for governments to fill in tax room, one on the other in either way. We will continue to co-operate in that way.
Eight provinces have either balanced their budgets or are looking to balance their budgets, absolutely. One of the reasons is that in the transfers to the provinces established by the federal government we have provided a formula for growth.
If the federal government had followed the policies of the Reform Party to slash and eviscerate those transfers, those provinces would not be able to balance their books.
Securities March 25th, 1996
The hon. member knows full well, Mr. Speaker, that we are in favour of harmonization, in terms of securities as well as taxation. That said, the situation is much more complicated and the problem much deeper that a mere matter of co-operation between stock exchanges.
This is not my own observation but rather the observation of the Montreal stock exchange president. In fact, the vast majority of stock brokers operating in Montreal know very well that co-operation is necessary. That is what we want to do, and I do not understand why the Bloc Quebecois is stalled in the sixties. They must stop looking at the future with their rear-view mirror. We must give the people of Quebec and Canada the ability to compete with anyone.