House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was tax.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Liberal MP for LaSalle—Émard (Québec)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 48% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Securities March 25th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, first of all, I never used the word "invade". I talked about co-operation, about creating partnerships and working together. In fact, the hon. member is right when he talks about the premium paid by American investors and the U.S. capital markets. There is a threat not only to Canadian but also to European stock exchanges.

That is why we must work together, we must co-operate. The idea is not to invade, but there is no doubt that it costs a great deal of money to send prospectuses to 10 provinces. We must find a way, as suggested by the Montreal business community, to co-operate to give the Canadian financial community a strong bargaining position.

Goods And Services Tax March 25th, 1996

Why is the Reform Party deliberately trying to distort very clear statements that have been made in the past and a position that is rock hard?

Is it because the Reform Party is embarrassed by its own internal contradictions? Is it because the Reform Party does not know which way to turn? Is it because the Reform Party has lost virtually every item of its agenda? Is it because the Reform Party is no longer relevant to the Canadian political scene?

Goods And Services Tax March 25th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the Deputy Prime Minister has always said that she would replace the GST with another tax. That is it. The words in the red book are very clear in black and white.

Goods And Services Tax March 25th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, we have been having discussions with a number of provinces which essentially recognize that it would be good for their small and medium sized business communities and their consumers if the GST were replaced with a new single tax.

We can go back and forth as the member plays games. Is the Reform Party adopting a fourth position? Is it reneging on the

position it stated in the finance committee that it sought to have a single tax and that it recognized that it would be a very difficult negotiation?

What is the Reform Party's position? Are you in favour of a single tax?

Goods And Services Tax March 25th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, let me repeat once again that, in 1990, the leader of the Reform Party said very clearly, when he was trying to get the member for Beaver River elected, that he was going to rip the GST out, to get rid of it. One year later, he wanted to keep it. Now, his position is exactly the same as ours in the red book, in that he wants to replace the GST with a harmonized tax. It took him three years to get to where we have been since the very beginning.

[English]

The Reform Party can go through this charade time after time on what the government's position is. The government's position has been very clear. The difficulty the Reform Party has is that it is caught by its own contradictions year after year on the GST, on social programs, on the commitment to bring in a new budget, on how fast it would reduce the deficit, on medicare and on virtually everything.

There is no consistent philosophy from Reform Party members. They only have one objective which is to confuse. The only people they confuse are themselves.

Goods And Services Tax March 25th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the position of Liberals throughout the campaign and the position of the government have been very clear. It was stated in the red book on page 22. It is conceivable that members of the Reform Party have not read the red book. I would suggest they do so as it would give them very good insight into what the country is all about.

In 1990 the leader of the Reform Party said that he would rip the GST out. Was he speaking for the Reform Party? Was he speaking for the Reform when he said it could not be repealed immediately because it would increase the deficit? Was he speaking for the Reform Party when he commended the government on its attempt to harmonize the tax with the provinces?

Goods And Services Tax March 19th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the decision any individual government chooses to take on any individual tax is obviously up to that government at that time. It is very clear that consumers and small and medium size businesses want us to harmonize it.

It seems to be clear that the Reform Party thought it wanted us to harmonize it but obviously, given the tremendous unity which exists within the Reform Party, it is quite hard to determine what in fact its real position is on anything.

Goods And Services Tax March 19th, 1996

The most recent statement, prior to questions in this House, that I had anything to do with in terms of the GST said, and I quote from the red book: "A Liberal government will replace the GST with a system that promotes federal-provincial co-operation and harmonization". That is the most recent thing I have had to say on the GST.

Goods And Services Tax March 19th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, Monte Solberg's flying circus rides again.

Goods And Services Tax March 18th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the hon. member has "mythd" the point. There is no possibility of a supertax. What we are seeking is a harmonized tax.

Obviously if there was a transfer from one segment of society to another, any province would have the ability to right that and to shift it back. There is all kinds of flexibility built in there.

I simply quote the Reform Party again from the finance committee. This is in context: "We commend the government on its attempt to harmonize the tax with the provinces".