Vote #388 on June 13th, 2012

C-38 An Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on March 29, 2012 and other measures

That Bill C-38 be amended by deleting Clause 446.

See context in the Debates.

• Yes 72
• No 172
• Bloc NDP
• Green Liberal Conservative

• Yes André Bellavance
• Yes Jean-François Fortin
• Yes Maria Mourani
• Didn't vote Louis Plamondon

• No Diane Ablonczy
• No Eve Adams
• No Mark Adler
• No Leona Aglukkaq
• No Dan Albas
• No Harold Albrecht
• No Chris Alexander
• No Mike Allen
• No Dean Allison
• No Stella Ambler
• No Rona Ambrose
• No Rob Anders
• No David Anderson
• No Scott Armstrong
• No Keith Ashfield
• No Jay Aspin
• No John Baird
• No Joyce Bateman
• No Leon Benoit
• No Candice Bergen
• No Maxime Bernier
• No James Bezan
• No Steven Blaney
• No Kelly Block
• No Ray Boughen
• No Peter Braid
• No Garry Breitkreuz
• No Patrick Brown
• No Lois Brown
• No Gord Brown
• No Rod Bruinooge
• No Brad Butt
• Didn't vote Paul Calandra
• No Blaine Calkins
• No Ron Cannan
• No John Carmichael
• No Colin Carrie
• No Corneliu Chisu
• No Michael Chong
• No Rob Clarke
• No Tony Clement
• Didn't vote Joe Daniel
• No Patricia Davidson
• No Bob Dechert
• No Dean Del Mastro
• Didn't vote Barry Devolin
• No Earl Dreeshen
• No John Duncan
• Didn't vote Rick Dykstra
• No Julian Fantino
• No Ed Fast
• No Kerry-Lynne Findlay
• No Diane Finley
• No Jim Flaherty
• No Steven Fletcher
• No Royal Galipeau
• No Cheryl Gallant
• No Parm Gill
• No Shelly Glover
• No Robert Goguen
• No Gary Goodyear
• Didn't vote Bal Gosal
• No Jacques Gourde
• No Nina Grewal
• No Stephen Harper
• No Dick Harris
• No Laurie Hawn
• Didn't vote Bryan Hayes
• No Russ Hiebert
• No Jim Hillyer
• No Randy Hoback
• No Ed Holder
• Didn't vote Roxanne James
• No Brian Jean
• No Randy Kamp
• No Gerald Keddy
• Didn't vote Jason Kenney
• No Peter Kent
• No Greg Kerr
• No Ed Komarnicki
• No Daryl Kramp
• No Mike Lake
• No Guy Lauzon
• No Denis Lebel
• No Ryan Leef
• Didn't vote Kellie Leitch
• No Pierre Lemieux
• Didn't vote Chungsen Leung
• No Wladyslaw Lizon
• No Ben Lobb
• No Tom Lukiwski
• No James Lunney
• No Peter MacKay
• No Dave MacKenzie
• No Colin Mayes
• No Phil McColeman
• No Cathy McLeod
• No Costas Menegakis
• No Ted Menzies
• No Rob Merrifield
• No Larry Miller
• No Rob Moore
• Didn't vote James Moore
• No Rob Nicholson
• Didn't vote Rick Norlock
• No Deepak Obhrai
• No Gordon O'Connor
• No Bev Oda
• Didn't vote Joe Oliver
• No Tilly O'Neill-Gordon
• No Ted Opitz
• No Christian Paradis
• No LaVar Payne
• No Peter Penashue
• No Pierre Poilievre
• No Joe Preston
• No Lisa Raitt
• No James Rajotte
• No Brent Rathgeber
• No Scott Reid
• No Michelle Rempel
• No Blake Richards
• No Greg Rickford
• Didn't vote Gerry Ritz
• Didn't vote Andrew Saxton
• Didn't vote Andrew Scheer
• No Gary Schellenberger
• No Kyle Seeback
• No Gail Shea
• Didn't vote Bev Shipley
• No Devinder Shory
• No Joy Smith
• No Robert Sopuck
• No Kevin Sorenson
• No Bruce Stanton
• Didn't vote Brian Storseth
• No Mark Strahl
• No David Sweet
• No David Tilson
• No Lawrence Toet
• No Vic Toews
• No Bradley Trost
• No Bernard Trottier
• No Susan Truppe
• No Merv Tweed
• Didn't vote Tim Uppal
• Didn't vote Bernard Valcourt
• No Dave Van Kesteren
• No Peter Van Loan
• No Maurice Vellacott
• No Mike Wallace
• No Mark Warawa
• No Chris Warkentin
• No Jeff Watson
• No John Weston
• No Rodney Weston
• No David Wilks
• No John Williamson
• No Alice Wong
• No Stephen Woodworth
• No Lynne Yelich
• No Terence Young
• No Wai Young
• No Bob Zimmer

• No Elizabeth May

• No Peter Goldring
• No Bruce Hyer

• Didn't vote Scott Andrews
• No Mauril Bélanger
• No Carolyn Bennett
• No Scott Brison
• No Gerry Byrne
• Didn't vote Sean Casey
• No Denis Coderre
• No Irwin Cotler
• Didn't vote Rodger Cuzner
• Didn't vote Stéphane Dion
• Didn't vote Kirsty Duncan
• Didn't vote Wayne Easter
• No Mark Eyking
• No Judy Foote
• No Hedy Fry
• No Marc Garneau
• Didn't vote Ralph Goodale
• No Ted Hsu
• Didn't vote Jim Karygiannis
• No Kevin Lamoureux
• Didn't vote Dominic LeBlanc
• No Lawrence MacAulay
• No John McCallum
• No David McGuinty
• No John McKay
• No Joyce Murray
• No Massimo Pacetti
• No Bob Rae
• No Geoff Regan
• No Francis Scarpaleggia
• Didn't vote Judy Sgro
• No Scott Simms
• No Lise St-Denis
• No Justin Trudeau
• No Frank Valeriote

• Didn't vote Malcolm Allen
• Didn't vote Charlie Angus
• Yes Niki Ashton
• Yes Alex Atamanenko
• Yes Robert Aubin
• Yes Paulina Ayala
• Yes Tyrone Benskin
• Yes Dennis Bevington
• Yes Denis Blanchette
• Yes Lysane Blanchette-Lamothe
• Didn't vote Françoise Boivin
• Yes Charmaine Borg
• Didn't vote Alexandre Boulerice
• Didn't vote Marjolaine Boutin-Sweet
• Yes Tarik Brahmi
• Yes Ruth Ellen Brosseau
• Didn't vote Guy Caron
• Yes Andrew Cash
• Yes Chris Charlton
• Yes Sylvain Chicoine
• Yes Robert Chisholm
• Didn't vote François Choquette
• Yes Olivia Chow
• Didn't vote David Christopherson
• Yes Ryan Cleary
• Yes Joe Comartin
• Yes Raymond Côté
• Yes Jean Crowder
• Didn't vote Nathan Cullen
• Yes Libby Davies
• Yes Don Davies
• Yes Anne-Marie Day
• Yes Paul Dewar
• Yes Pierre Dionne Labelle
• Yes Fin Donnelly
• Didn't vote Rosane Doré Lefebvre
• Yes Matthew Dubé
• Didn't vote Linda Duncan
• Yes Pierre-Luc Dusseault
• Didn't vote Mylène Freeman
• Yes Randall Garrison
• Didn't vote Réjean Genest
• Didn't vote Jonathan Genest-Jourdain
• Yes Alain Giguère
• Didn't vote Yvon Godin
• Yes Claude Gravelle
• Didn't vote Sadia Groguhé
• Didn't vote Dan Harris
• Yes Jack Harris
• Yes Sana Hassainia
• Yes Carol Hughes
• Yes Pierre Jacob
• Yes Peter Julian
• Yes Matthew Kellway
• Yes François Lapointe
• Yes Jean-François Larose
• Yes Alexandrine Latendresse
• Yes Hélène Laverdière
• Yes Hélène LeBlanc
• Yes Megan Leslie
• Didn't vote Laurin Liu
• Yes Hoang Mai
• Yes Wayne Marston
• Didn't vote Pat Martin
• Didn't vote Brian Masse
• Yes Irene Mathyssen
• Yes Élaine Michaud
• Yes Christine Moore
• Yes Isabelle Morin
• Yes Dany Morin
• Didn't vote Marie-Claude Morin
• Yes Marc-André Morin
• Didn't vote Thomas Mulcair
• Yes Pierre Nantel
• Yes Peggy Nash
• Didn't vote Jamie Nicholls
• Yes José Nunez-Melo
• Yes Annick Papillon
• Didn't vote Claude Patry
• Didn't vote Ève Péclet
• Yes Manon Perreault
• Didn't vote François Pilon
• Yes Anne Minh-Thu Quach
• Yes John Rafferty
• Yes Mathieu Ravignat
• Didn't vote Francine Raynault
• Yes Jean Rousseau
• Didn't vote Romeo Saganash
• Yes Jasbir Sandhu
• Didn't vote Denise Savoie
• Yes Craig Scott
• Didn't vote Djaouida Sellah
• Yes Jinny Sims
• Yes Rathika Sitsabaiesan
• Yes Kennedy Stewart
• Didn't vote Peter Stoffer
• Yes Mike Sullivan
• Yes Glenn Thibeault
• Yes Philip Toone
• Yes Jonathan Tremblay
• Didn't vote Nycole Turmel