Vote #549 on December 4th, 2012
Bill
C-45 A second Act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on March 29, 2012 and other measures
Vote topic
That Bill C-45, in Clause 302, be amended by replacing lines 4 to 8 on page 271 with the following:
“9. (1) Except in instances where a province is pursuing any of the legitimate objectives referred to in Article 404 of the Agreement, namely public security and safety, public order, protection of human, animal or plant life or health, protection of the environment, consumer protection, protection of the health, safety and well-being of workers, and affirmative action programs for disadvantaged groups, the Governor in Council may, by order, for the purpose of suspending benefits of equivalent effect or imposing retaliatory measures of equivalent effect in respect of a province under Article 1709 of the Agreement, do any”
Result
- Yes 125
- No 146
- Green Liberal Bloc NDP
- Conservative
Bloc
- Yes André Bellavance
- Yes Jean-François Fortin
- Didn't vote Maria Mourani
- Yes Louis Plamondon
Conservative
- Didn't vote Diane Ablonczy
- No Eve Adams
- No Mark Adler
- No Leona Aglukkaq
- No Dan Albas
- No Harold Albrecht
- No Chris Alexander
- No Mike Allen
- No Dean Allison
- No Stella Ambler
- No Rona Ambrose
- No Rob Anders
- No David Anderson
- No Scott Armstrong
- Didn't vote Keith Ashfield
- No Jay Aspin
- No John Baird
- No Joyce Bateman
- No Leon Benoit
- No Candice Bergen
- No Maxime Bernier
- No James Bezan
- No Steven Blaney
- No Kelly Block
- Didn't vote Ray Boughen
- Didn't vote Peter Braid
- No Garry Breitkreuz
- No Gord Brown
- No Patrick Brown
- No Lois Brown
- No Rod Bruinooge
- No Brad Butt
- No Paul Calandra
- No Blaine Calkins
- No Ron Cannan
- No John Carmichael
- No Colin Carrie
- No Corneliu Chisu
- No Michael Chong
- No Rob Clarke
- No Tony Clement
- No Joe Daniel
- No Patricia Davidson
- Didn't vote Bob Dechert
- No Dean Del Mastro
- Didn't vote Barry Devolin
- No Earl Dreeshen
- No John Duncan
- No Rick Dykstra
- No Julian Fantino
- Didn't vote Ed Fast
- No Kerry-Lynne Findlay
- No Diane Finley
- No Jim Flaherty
- No Steven Fletcher
- No Royal Galipeau
- Didn't vote Cheryl Gallant
- No Parm Gill
- No Shelly Glover
- No Robert Goguen
- No Gary Goodyear
- No Bal Gosal
- No Jacques Gourde
- No Nina Grewal
- Didn't vote Stephen Harper
- No Dick Harris
- No Laurie Hawn
- No Bryan Hayes
- No Russ Hiebert
- No Jim Hillyer
- Didn't vote Randy Hoback
- No Ed Holder
- No Roxanne James
- Didn't vote Brian Jean
- No Randy Kamp
- No Gerald Keddy
- No Jason Kenney
- Didn't vote Peter Kent
- No Greg Kerr
- Didn't vote Ed Komarnicki
- No Daryl Kramp
- No Mike Lake
- No Guy Lauzon
- No Denis Lebel
- Didn't vote Ryan Leef
- No Kellie Leitch
- No Pierre Lemieux
- No Chungsen Leung
- No Wladyslaw Lizon
- No Ben Lobb
- No Tom Lukiwski
- No James Lunney
- No Peter MacKay
- No Dave MacKenzie
- No Colin Mayes
- No Phil McColeman
- No Cathy McLeod
- Didn't vote Costas Menegakis
- No Ted Menzies
- No Rob Merrifield
- No Larry Miller
- No Rob Moore
- No James Moore
- No Rob Nicholson
- No Rick Norlock
- No Deepak Obhrai
- No Gordon O'Connor
- No Joe Oliver
- No Tilly O'Neill-Gordon
- No Ted Opitz
- No Christian Paradis
- No LaVar Payne
- No Peter Penashue
- No Pierre Poilievre
- No Joe Preston
- No Lisa Raitt
- No James Rajotte
- No Brent Rathgeber
- Didn't vote Scott Reid
- No Michelle Rempel
- No Blake Richards
- No Greg Rickford
- No Gerry Ritz
- No Andrew Saxton
- Didn't vote Andrew Scheer
- No Gary Schellenberger
- No Kyle Seeback
- No Gail Shea
- No Bev Shipley
- No Devinder Shory
- No Joy Smith
- No Robert Sopuck
- No Kevin Sorenson
- Didn't vote Bruce Stanton
- No Brian Storseth
- No Mark Strahl
- No David Sweet
- No David Tilson
- No Lawrence Toet
- No Vic Toews
- No Bradley Trost
- No Bernard Trottier
- No Susan Truppe
- No Merv Tweed
- No Tim Uppal
- No Bernard Valcourt
- No Dave Van Kesteren
- No Peter Van Loan
- No Maurice Vellacott
- No Mike Wallace
- No Mark Warawa
- No Chris Warkentin
- No Jeff Watson
- No John Weston
- No Rodney Weston
- No David Wilks
- No John Williamson
- No Alice Wong
- No Stephen Woodworth
- No Lynne Yelich
- No Wai Young
- No Terence Young
- No Bob Zimmer
Green
- Yes Elizabeth May
Independent
- No Peter Goldring
- Yes Bruce Hyer
Liberal
- Yes Scott Andrews
- Yes Mauril Bélanger
- Yes Carolyn Bennett
- Yes Scott Brison
- Yes Gerry Byrne
- Yes Sean Casey
- Yes Denis Coderre
- Yes Irwin Cotler
- Yes Rodger Cuzner
- Yes Stéphane Dion
- Yes Kirsty Duncan
- Yes Wayne Easter
- Yes Mark Eyking
- Yes Judy Foote
- Yes Hedy Fry
- Yes Marc Garneau
- Yes Ralph Goodale
- Yes Ted Hsu
- Yes Jim Karygiannis
- Yes Kevin Lamoureux
- Yes Dominic LeBlanc
- Yes Lawrence MacAulay
- Yes John McCallum
- Yes David McGuinty
- Yes John McKay
- Yes Joyce Murray
- Yes Massimo Pacetti
- Yes Bob Rae
- Didn't vote Geoff Regan
- Yes Francis Scarpaleggia
- Yes Judy Sgro
- Yes Scott Simms
- Yes Lise St-Denis
- Didn't vote Justin Trudeau
- Yes Frank Valeriote
NDP
- Didn't vote Malcolm Allen
- Yes Charlie Angus
- Yes Niki Ashton
- Yes Alex Atamanenko
- Didn't vote Robert Aubin
- Yes Paulina Ayala
- Yes Tyrone Benskin
- Didn't vote Dennis Bevington
- Yes Denis Blanchette
- Yes Lysane Blanchette-Lamothe
- Yes Françoise Boivin
- Yes Charmaine Borg
- Yes Alexandre Boulerice
- Yes Marjolaine Boutin-Sweet
- Yes Tarik Brahmi
- Didn't vote Ruth Ellen Brosseau
- Yes Guy Caron
- Yes Andrew Cash
- Yes Chris Charlton
- Yes Sylvain Chicoine
- Yes Robert Chisholm
- Yes François Choquette
- Didn't vote Olivia Chow
- Yes David Christopherson
- Yes Ryan Cleary
- Didn't vote Joe Comartin
- Yes Raymond Côté
- Yes Jean Crowder
- Yes Nathan Cullen
- Yes Libby Davies
- Yes Don Davies
- Yes Anne-Marie Day
- Yes Paul Dewar
- Yes Pierre Dionne Labelle
- Yes Fin Donnelly
- Yes Rosane Doré Lefebvre
- Yes Matthew Dubé
- Yes Linda Duncan
- Yes Pierre-Luc Dusseault
- Yes Mylène Freeman
- Didn't vote Randall Garrison
- Yes Réjean Genest
- Yes Jonathan Genest-Jourdain
- Yes Alain Giguère
- Yes Yvon Godin
- Yes Claude Gravelle
- Yes Sadia Groguhé
- Yes Dan Harris
- Yes Jack Harris
- Yes Sana Hassainia
- Yes Carol Hughes
- Yes Pierre Jacob
- Yes Peter Julian
- Yes Matthew Kellway
- Yes François Lapointe
- Yes Jean-François Larose
- Yes Alexandrine Latendresse
- Didn't vote Hélène Laverdière
- Yes Hélène LeBlanc
- Yes Megan Leslie
- Yes Laurin Liu
- Yes Hoang Mai
- Yes Wayne Marston
- Yes Pat Martin
- Didn't vote Brian Masse
- Yes Irene Mathyssen
- Yes Élaine Michaud
- Didn't vote Christine Moore
- Didn't vote Isabelle Morin
- Didn't vote Marc-André Morin
- Yes Dany Morin
- Yes Marie-Claude Morin
- Yes Thomas Mulcair
- Yes Pierre Nantel
- Yes Peggy Nash
- Yes Jamie Nicholls
- Yes José Nunez-Melo
- Yes Annick Papillon
- Yes Claude Patry
- Yes Ève Péclet
- Yes Manon Perreault
- Yes François Pilon
- Yes Anne Minh-Thu Quach
- Yes John Rafferty
- Yes Mathieu Ravignat
- Yes Francine Raynault
- Yes Jean Rousseau
- Didn't vote Romeo Saganash
- Yes Jasbir Sandhu
- Yes Craig Scott
- Yes Djaouida Sellah
- Yes Jinny Sims
- Yes Rathika Sitsabaiesan
- Yes Kennedy Stewart
- Yes Peter Stoffer
- Yes Mike Sullivan
- Yes Glenn Thibeault
- Yes Philip Toone
- Yes Jonathan Tremblay
- Yes Nycole Turmel
