Vote #20 on December 5th, 2007

Vote topic

That, in the opinion of the House, the government should amend Section 7 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms to extend property rights to Canadians.

See context in the Debates.

Result

Yes 118
Conservative
No 138
Bloc NDP Liberal

Conservative

Yes Jim Abbott
Yes Diane Ablonczy
Yes Harold Albrecht
Yes Mike Allen
Yes Dean Allison
Yes Rona Ambrose
Yes Rob Anders
Yes David Anderson
Didn't vote John Baird
Yes Dave Batters
Yes Leon Benoit
Yes Maxime Bernier
Yes James Bezan
Yes Jean-Pierre Blackburn
Yes Steven Blaney
Yes Sylvie Boucher
Yes Garry Breitkreuz
Yes Patrick Brown
Yes Gord Brown
Yes Rod Bruinooge
Yes Blaine Calkins
Yes Ron Cannan
Yes Lawrence Cannon
Yes Colin Carrie
Yes Rick Casson
Didn't vote Michael Chong
Yes Tony Clement
Yes Joe Comuzzi
Yes John Cummins
Yes Patricia Davidson
Yes Stockwell Day
Yes Dean Del Mastro
Yes Barry Devolin
Didn't vote Norman Doyle
Yes Rick Dykstra
Yes David Emerson
Yes Ken Epp
Yes Ed Fast
Yes Diane Finley
Yes Brian Fitzpatrick
Yes Jim Flaherty
Yes Steven Fletcher
Yes Royal Galipeau
Yes Cheryl Gallant
Yes Peter Goldring
Didn't vote Gary Goodyear
Yes Jacques Gourde
Yes Nina Grewal
Yes Helena Guergis
Yes Art Hanger
Yes Stephen Harper
Yes Dick Harris
Yes Luc Harvey
Yes Laurie Hawn
Yes Loyola Hearn
Yes Russ Hiebert
Yes Jay Hill
Didn't vote Betty Hinton
Yes Rahim Jaffer
Yes Brian Jean
Yes Randy Kamp
Yes Gerald Keddy
Yes Jason Kenney
Didn't vote Wajid Khan
Yes Ed Komarnicki
Yes Daryl Kramp
Yes Mike Lake
Yes Guy Lauzon
Yes Denis Lebel
Yes Pierre Lemieux
Yes Tom Lukiwski
Yes Gary Lunn
Yes James Lunney
Yes Peter MacKay
Yes Dave MacKenzie
Yes Fabian Manning
Yes Inky Mark
Yes Colin Mayes
Yes Ted Menzies
Yes Rob Merrifield
Yes Larry Miller
Yes Bob Mills
Yes James Moore
Yes Rob Moore
Yes Rob Nicholson
Yes Rick Norlock
Yes Deepak Obhrai
Yes Gordon O'Connor
Yes Bev Oda
Yes Brian Pallister
Yes Christian Paradis
Yes Daniel Petit
Yes Pierre Poilievre
Yes Jim Prentice
Yes Joe Preston
Yes James Rajotte
Yes Scott Reid
Didn't vote Lee Richardson
Yes Gerry Ritz
Yes Andrew Scheer
Yes Gary Schellenberger
Yes Bev Shipley
Yes Carol Skelton
Didn't vote Joy Smith
Yes Monte Solberg
Yes Kevin Sorenson
Didn't vote Bruce Stanton
Yes Brian Storseth
Didn't vote Chuck Strahl
Yes David Sweet
Yes Myron Thompson
Yes Greg Thompson
Yes David Tilson
Yes Vic Toews
Yes Bradley Trost
Yes Merv Tweed
Yes Dave Van Kesteren
Yes Peter Van Loan
Yes Maurice Vellacott
Yes Josée Verner
Didn't vote Mike Wallace
Yes Mark Warawa
Yes Chris Warkentin
Yes Jeff Watson
Didn't vote John Williams
Yes Lynne Yelich

NDP

No Charlie Angus
No Alex Atamanenko
No Catherine Bell
No Dennis Bevington
No Dawn Black
No Bill Blaikie
No Chris Charlton
No Olivia Chow
No David Christopherson
No Joe Comartin
No Jean Crowder
Didn't vote Nathan Cullen
No Libby Davies
No Paul Dewar
No Yvon Godin
No Peter Julian
No Jack Layton
No Wayne Marston
No Tony Martin
No Pat Martin
No Brian Masse
No Irene Mathyssen
No Alexa McDonough
No Thomas Mulcair
No Peggy Nash
No Penny Priddy
No Denise Savoie
No Bill Siksay
No Peter Stoffer
No Judy Wasylycia-Leis

Bloc

No Guy André
No Gérard Asselin
No Claude Bachand
No Vivian Barbot
Didn't vote André Bellavance
Didn't vote Bernard Bigras
No Raynald Blais
No France Bonsant
No Robert Bouchard
No Diane Bourgeois
No Paule Brunelle
No Serge Cardin
No Robert Carrier
No Paul Crête
Didn't vote Claude DeBellefeuille
Didn't vote Nicole Demers
No Johanne Deschamps
No Gilles Duceppe
No Meili Faille
No Carole Freeman
No Christiane Gagnon
No Roger Gaudet
Didn't vote Raymond Gravel
No Monique Guay
No Michel Guimond
No Maka Kotto
No Jean-Yves Laforest
No Mario Laframboise
Didn't vote Francine Lalonde
No Carole Lavallée
Didn't vote Marc Lemay
No Yves Lessard
Didn't vote Yvon Lévesque
No Marcel Lussier
No Luc Malo
No Réal Ménard
No Serge Ménard
No Maria Mourani
No Richard Nadeau
No Christian Ouellet
No Pierre Paquette
Didn't vote Gilles-A. Perron
No Pauline Picard
No Louis Plamondon
Didn't vote Jean-Yves Roy
No Thierry St-Cyr
No Caroline St-Hilaire
No Ève-Mary Thaï Thi Lac
No Robert Vincent

Liberal

No Omar Alghabra
No Larry Bagnell
No Navdeep Bains
No Sue Barnes
No Colleen Beaumier
No Mauril Bélanger
No Don Bell
No Carolyn Bennett
No Maurizio Bevilacqua
Didn't vote Raymond Bonin
No Ken Boshcoff
No Scott Brison
No Bonnie Brown
No Gerry Byrne
No John Cannis
Didn't vote Brenda Chamberlain
No Raymond Chan
No Denis Coderre
No Irwin Cotler
No Roy Cullen
No Rodger Cuzner
No Jean-Claude D'Amours
No Sukh Dhaliwal
No Ruby Dhalla
Didn't vote Stéphane Dion
No Ujjal Dosanjh
No Ken Dryden
No Wayne Easter
No Mark Eyking
Didn't vote Raymonde Folco
No Hedy Fry
No John Godfrey
Didn't vote Ralph Goodale
Didn't vote Bill Graham
Didn't vote Albina Guarnieri
No Mark Holland
Yes Charles Hubbard
Didn't vote Michael Ignatieff
Didn't vote Marlene Jennings
No Susan Kadis
No Nancy Karetak-Lindell
No Jim Karygiannis
No Tina Keeper
No Dominic LeBlanc
Didn't vote Derek Lee
Didn't vote Lawrence MacAulay
No Gurbax Malhi
No John Maloney
No Diane Marleau
Didn't vote Paul Martin
Yes Keith Martin
Didn't vote Bill Matthews
No John McCallum
No David McGuinty
No Joe McGuire
No John McKay
No Dan McTeague
Didn't vote Gary Merasty
Didn't vote Peter Milliken
Didn't vote Maria Minna
Didn't vote Brian Murphy
No Shawn Murphy
No Anita Neville
Didn't vote Stephen Owen
No Massimo Pacetti
No Bernard Patry
No Glen Pearson
Didn't vote Jim Peterson
Didn't vote Marcel Proulx
Didn't vote Yasmin Ratansi
No Karen Redman
No Geoff Regan
No Lucienne Robillard
Didn't vote Pablo Rodriguez
No Anthony Rota
No Todd Russell
Didn't vote Michael Savage
No Francis Scarpaleggia
No Andy Scott
Didn't vote Judy Sgro
No Mario Silva
No Raymond Simard
No Scott Simms
No Lloyd St. Amand
No Brent St. Denis
Didn't vote Paul Steckle
Didn't vote Belinda Stronach
No Paul Szabo
No Andrew Telegdi
No Lui Temelkovski
No Robert Thibault
No Alan Tonks
Didn't vote Garth Turner
No Roger Valley
No Joe Volpe
Didn't vote Tom Wappel
No Bryon Wilfert
Didn't vote Blair Wilson
No Borys Wrzesnewskyj
No Paul Zed

Independent

Yes André Arthur
Yes Bill Casey
No Louise Thibault