Evidence of meeting #46 for Foreign Affairs and International Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was institutions.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Martin-Brûlé  Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual
Adam Chapnick  Professor, Defence Studies, Canadian Forces College, As an Individual
Jennifer Welsh  Director of the Max Bell School of Public Policy and Distinguished James McGill Professor, McGill University, As an Individual
Pouliot  Professor, Université de Montréal, As an Individual
Audet  Professor, Canadian Observatory on Crises and Humanitarian Action, Université du Québec à Montréal, As an Individual
Robert Wolfe  Professor Emeritus, School of Policy Studies, Queen's University, As an Individual

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

Thank you to all the witnesses for being here this morning.

I appreciate the time, Mr. Chair.

I'd like to start off with our professor from McGill, Dr. Welsh. I really appreciate your testimony and how you opened.

I picked up on one concept that you raised, which was that after World War II, a lot of countries were left out of the highest echelons of the decision-making order. Do you have any suggestions for how we can repair that and adjust to the current moment we're in today?

11:25 a.m.

Director of the Max Bell School of Public Policy and Distinguished James McGill Professor, McGill University, As an Individual

Dr. Jennifer Welsh

I think it's really important that at this moment, when our institutions are being discussed as objects of reform, we do not pursue that reform with clubs that we are used to collaborating with only.

I see our first tier of variable geometry in this new government as being inclusive of Europe, Japan, South Korea and now, increasingly, India, but forgetting that our universal multilateral system has a much wider membership, and that part of the problem with our institutions today is not just their alleged ineffectiveness but also their alleged illegitimacy in terms of their representation and the way they have operated.

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

Certainly. Even the outgoing Secretary-General has spoken about this, hasn't he?

11:25 a.m.

Director of the Max Bell School of Public Policy and Distinguished James McGill Professor, McGill University, As an Individual

Dr. Jennifer Welsh

Yes, exactly.

Professor Chapnick mentioned the approach of China and some of our adversaries to these institutions. I think it's really important that committee members understand that those countries have a very deliberate strategy of engaging countries from the global south in their vision of how international institutions should operate.

That's why we should sit up and take note that the various votes in the General Assembly with respect to Ukraine were perhaps not as overwhelmingly condemning of Russia as we might have expected, because of some of these dynamics over time.

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

Certainly. I appreciate what you referred to.

Dr. Chapnick, I'll ask you further questions on this particular point.

You talked about the influence of China and how there's been a withdrawal of the major western powers. You are cautioning us to be aware and to not cede space to China so it can then enter and influence the international institutions, such as the UN and others.

Would you like to elaborate further on that?

Prof. Adam Chapnick

My basic argument is that one of our greatest allies got very frustrated with the World Health Organization and has all but abandoned it. That space will be filled. The World Health Organization will not shrivel up and die. The space will be filled, and it will be filled by a country with similar power.

As a result, from a Canadian point of view, the last thing we should do is leave as well. We need to try, with our allies, to fill in as much of that space as possible and leave it available for other allies if and when they want to come back. That's the same for every organization out there.

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

With the withdrawal of the United States, which we would expect to continue until January 2029, how do we, as you're saying, fill in that space? Do you have any concrete suggestions?

Prof. Adam Chapnick

My concrete suggestion is that, number one, we do not make it worse and we do not also cut back our commitment based on the argument that if our allies aren't involved anyway, the organization is not worth our time. That would be step one.

Step two would be encouraging our allies to do the same and similarly not back off. I don't think Canada is large enough to solve the problem, but we can stop it from becoming worse, and we can leverage our partners and allies to preserve as much as we can for as long as we can.

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

How do you see the posture of us and our like-minded partners on that particular point? What's our current posture?

Prof. Adam Chapnick

Our current posture is consistent with the idea that multilateral organizations and institutions matter, but if we are reducing our diplomatic capacity, it's much harder to put that posture into action.

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

Do you have any suggestions for reforms of the Security Council or other instances of the like as they relate to the post-World War II era and where we are today?

Prof. Adam Chapnick

Here's where I might differ from some members. I don't think reforming the United Nations Security Council is worth Canada's time. I don't think the reform will work. We already have limited resources, and in the grand scheme, if three of the five veto powers are our allies, I don't imagine that any institution that comes to replace the UN Security Council would give us a better deal than that.

That is not where I would put my time.

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

I appreciate that.

In terms of the recent increase in contributions to NATO, we have done that because of the realities within Ukraine and the region. Do you see a need for us to also be mindful of other international organizations' priorities as we have prioritized the military?

This is my last 20 seconds.

Prof. Adam Chapnick

I think we've increased to NATO, in part for military reasons, but it was really for diplomatic reasons. We made a promise to our allies, and we didn't meet it for years. In fact, we almost bragged about not meeting it at times.

If we want credibility with our partners, we have to keep our word.

Sameer Zuberi Liberal Pierrefonds—Dollard, QC

I appreciate that. That's certainly not the case today, but thank you for your testimony.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you very much.

We will go next to MP Brunelle-Duceppe.

You have the floor for six minutes.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I'm going to have a lengthy preamble because I want to talk about credibility. If we want Canada to contribute to the effectiveness of major international institutions, we must first know whether Canada is credible in its bilateral relations.

Here's a little reading for you today. On October 26, 2025, “the violence in and around El Fasher reached a devastating peak following months of siege and escalating attacks” by the Rapid Support Forces, or RSF, at war with the Sudanese army. That statement was signed by Germany, Denmark, Ireland, France, Norway, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Sierra Leone, Sweden, the European Union and Canada. That's the same date as today.

Experts from the United Nations, or UN, considered that this offensive by the FSR to take the last major city in Darfur still under the army's control had the characteristics of a genocide.

We know that the United Arab Emirates is considered the main supporter of the FSR and by supplies them with vehicles, fuel, weapons and military equipment. However, today and tomorrow, Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, or MBZ, and his entourage will be welcomed with great pomp by the Prime Minister.

We want Canada to take part in strengthening major international institutions. However, when somewhat Orwellian situations occur, as we are experiencing today, on the one hand we denounce, and on the other, we welcome the main ally of a force that is currently accused of committing genocidal acts. I ask myself this: What does this say about Canada's credibility and what does it mean when Canada says that it would like to strengthen….

Ms. Martin‑Brûlé, can you answer this big question? There will be easier ones afterward.

11:30 a.m.

Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual

Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé

I think it's possible to distinguish between the Canadian government's tentative political aspirations and having partnerships or partners that can be a little uncomfortable. You talked about the United Arab Emirates or Saudi Arabia. There is also a new agreement with Türkiye.

We cannot afford to be friends only with the democracies that suit us. That has been said by many experts besides myself. We are in a system with a plurality of interests and priorities. It would be difficult for us—and it would be a very lonely mission—to only align with certain types of democracies. I am thinking, politically, of democracies with other priorities.

Turning back to Canada's credibility in international institutions, I think we need to look at it from another angle, and that's where Canada can play a role. Someone mentioned that major powers such as China are investing over the long term, for example, in several key UN committees that are less visible, but very significant in terms of scope.

I think that we shouldn't focus on the visibility of the investment, be that the number of troops deployed or even the magnitude of the financial resources used. China has positioned itself in several committees that set the UN's rules; that is something we could learn from. Canada can go where it can play a role, in places that are less influential, but that have an impact on the decision-making process and on the rules that are established.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

I understand, but what you're saying is that we can't be friends solely with like-minded democracies. However, there is still a certain boundary that must not be crossed. When we see a joint statement issued by Mr. Carney and Mr. Erdoğan, stating that Canada and Türkiye share values like respect for the rule of law, respect for human rights and freedom of expression, there is still a line that has been crossed when we know what sort of person Mr. Erdoğan is. Incidentally, I invite everyone who can to listen to the podcast on OHdio about Mr. Erdoğan. Isn't there something a little Orwellian there, as I was saying? Maybe we're rewriting something.

We can trade, I understand that. However, when we go so far as to receive Mohamed bin Zayed with great fanfare, isn't there a sense of unease about the Carney government's new foreign policy at the moment?

11:35 a.m.

Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual

Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé

Certainly. You alluded to unease, but I think it's important to keep the lines of communication open. For example, the last thing we should do is close embassies or to turn a blind eye or deaf ear to regimes that make us uncomfortable in our democracy. I don't think the two can coexist in an ideal manner. That's not possible. However, it seems to me that it is vital to maintain channels of communication.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

I agree, as long as we don't go too far. That's my opinion, but I think a lot of people share it.

You talked about the possibility of drawing inspiration from what others are doing better. You mentioned Germany and Switzerland.

11:35 a.m.

Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual

Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé

There's also Japan. There are several other examples, such as Sweden.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

That's right. Could you tell the committee about what others are doing better?

11:35 a.m.

Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual

Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé

Germany has the ZIF, which recruits, trains and deploys civilian experts and runs structured programs to support international careers. I was saying that it was a deliberate way of placing German nationals in international institutions, and this is an example of that. For its part, Sweden relies on the Folke Bernadotte Academy. And so does Switzerland. Japan takes a complementary approach through the UN Triangular Partnership Programme. It helps to train military contingents from other countries, notably in Africa, but in more technical fields, such as military engineering, for example. These are examples, more broadly, of countries choosing to guide and train experts, mobilize those who are already there and train the next generation, to help these experts access international careers.

A distinction needs to be made. Our diplomats represent and defend Canada's position, that's one thing. Canadians recruited as international civil servants serve their organization while being independent, but I think they can reflect Canadian values. We could be much more intentional and create a group of experts so that we can better distribute, support and listen within our Canadian government and our talent pool.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you very much.

We go next to MP Jacob Mantle.

You have five minutes.