Evidence of meeting #46 for Foreign Affairs and International Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was institutions.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Martin-Brûlé  Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual
Adam Chapnick  Professor, Defence Studies, Canadian Forces College, As an Individual
Jennifer Welsh  Director of the Max Bell School of Public Policy and Distinguished James McGill Professor, McGill University, As an Individual
Pouliot  Professor, Université de Montréal, As an Individual
Audet  Professor, Canadian Observatory on Crises and Humanitarian Action, Université du Québec à Montréal, As an Individual
Robert Wolfe  Professor Emeritus, School of Policy Studies, Queen's University, As an Individual

11:35 a.m.

Conservative

Jacob Mantle Conservative York—Durham, ON

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to all of our witnesses for appearing and providing their valuable testimony.

Professor Welsh, the last time you were at this committee, you provided some testimony about foreign policy review. You were lamenting the fact that the last foreign policy review took place in 2005. We are now in the longest gap between policy reviews since the Second World War: 11 years of the current government and 18 months of the current Prime Minister. Where is the foreign policy review?

11:35 a.m.

Director of the Max Bell School of Public Policy and Distinguished James McGill Professor, McGill University, As an Individual

Dr. Jennifer Welsh

It's an excellent question. I'm asking the same question.

My understanding is that the government is preparing a series of reviews for this autumn, including a national security policy and strategy, and also a foreign policy strategy. I would agree with the assumption in your question that it's extremely important for us at this moment, with the global changes we are seeing, to articulate for Canadians any new directions in our foreign policy.

From what I understand about those documents, there is a strong focus on ensuring that Canada has strategic autonomy in an era of geopolitical rivalry and a changing relationship with the United States, but I think what this committee is looking at with respect to international institutions is an important piece of the puzzle. I would say that while I have heard a great deal from this government about trade and defence, and I agree that our trade and defence relationships need to be improved upon and expanded, we have not heard as much about our political diplomacy or something that none of us have yet really drilled down on in this conversation: global development.

We have talked about the UN system in this conversation, but Canada holds very important positions in bodies like the World Bank, where its executive director seat represents not just Canada but also others. We can, as part of a new foreign policy strategy, also discuss the ways in which we are going to innovate international institutions and global development. I hope very much to see that in any new strategy that comes out this fall.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Jacob Mantle Conservative York—Durham, ON

Thank you very much for that, Professor Welsh.

Professor Chapnick, you spoke about the government's approach to international institutions, foreign policy and foreign trade. I want to describe for you one of the problems I see with the current approach and get your thoughts on it.

On the one hand, the Prime Minister speaks about a rules-based system, whether that's for trade or foreign policy. On the other hand, I see Canada breaking those rules on a regular basis. For example, we have imposed trade restrictions on our free trade partners when it comes to steel goods, and we have imposed even harsher restrictions on countries with which we do not have free trade agreements on steel goods, none of which was done in conformity with our WTO or free trade obligations.

The Prime Minister talks about an uncertain world and the need for liberal democracies to co-operate, but then he signs agreements and stands on a podium with authoritarians and dictators. We saw that just last week in Turkey. We've heard discussion about the U.A.E., Saudi Arabia and, of course, China. When I look at variable geometry, it seems to me to simply be a justification for hypocrisy.

What are your thoughts?

Prof. Adam Chapnick

First and foremost, I think diplomacy is ugly and will always be ugly, because we share some interests with countries and don't share them others. It's rare that we're fully aligned. Seeing elements of what you're calling hypocrisy is a given in diplomacy, in general.

I prefer, personally, that we simply not have as much rhetoric. I'm comfortable with actions that you would call hypocritical, because we may not have security interests with some countries. As John Diefenbaker said in the 1950s or early 1960s when dealing with China, they may be communists, but they can't kill us with a loaf of bread. Therefore, we can sell them bread. They can't do anything to us with that loaf of bread.

That's partly how diplomacy works.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Jacob Mantle Conservative York—Durham, ON

Thank you for that.

One of the themes I was picking up from your comments and those of others is that we should stay in these organizations, not walk away from them.

The trouble I have with that—I'm running out of time—is this: Why should we stay in organizations that have proven themselves to be incapable of reform? You talked about the WTO, but you didn't mention the fact that the WTO has an appellate body that is creating new obligations, or that you have countries self-selecting as developing countries. Korea is not a developing country anymore, yet it benefits from that.

Why should we stay in organizations that can't reform themselves?

Prof. Adam Chapnick

That's a very fair question.

The WTO—

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Unfortunately, that answer will have to wait for the next round or the next opportunity.

I go next to MP Abdelhaq Sari.

You have five minutes.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

Many thanks to the witnesses for the testimonies we are hearing today, and especially for the way in which we are receiving the relevance of their answers. They are giving us a rather interesting angle to the understanding of the subject of the day.

Ms. Martin‑Brûlé, in your opening remarks, you spoke about several things. I want to talk about your work on gender guidelines in relation to the UN, or the United Nations.

I would like to give you a little more time to talk about this and to talk about your work on intelligence in peacekeeping, which you also wrote about in 2022, and your work on the Canadian Armed Forces, in 2023. You did two jobs, as I understand it. I would like to know how Canada is leveraging this expertise as part of the reform we are talking about today. Can you tell us a little more about this?

11:45 a.m.

Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual

Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé

Yes, I worked with the UN as a consultant to develop the first guidelines on peacekeeping-intelligence and gender issues. The question was whether gender was a cross-cutting issue in how women and men operate on peace missions, to better understand their actions.

The UN developed this new intelligence policy on Canadian missions. It was a word that was very taboo at the UN until 2017. It was renegotiated in 2019. There is also a hyphen in the English name peacekeeping-intelligence to show that it is not national intelligence, but information sharing between allied countries within a peace mission.

I was tasked with seeing how women and men could intervene differently in war zones. I then did the same for the Canadian government to see how to take gender into account in the Canadian context.

Your question is about mobilizing Canadian expertise. In my opinion, there has been no such mobilization. This is a bit what I want to put forward as well. I happen to be Canadian, but Norway and Sweden asked me to teach in their countries.

I haven't given any classes here. I also haven't trained our armed forces on gender and intelligence. In my opinion, too often we have extraordinary experts in Canada who are underutilized by Canada. We are called upon by Ireland, Norway and Sweden. It is very difficult to demonstrate the value of our expertise within the Canadian government. That has been the case for me, in my career, but it is true for many other experts. We have, I would say, very experienced people who have had extraordinary experiences. Moreover, we have Jennifer Welsh by video conference, who has extraordinary experience at the UN. We are a small ecosystem, but in the case of several other experts, I don't know if we are called on enough.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

I would like to come back to another subject that preoccupies me as well. That is the matter of governance in general and the lack of agility of several international bodies or organizations. People say they have become very bureaucratic and slow.

The question is for you, but also for Ms. Jennifer Welsh. To have some agility or to review the situation, what specific and priority reforms should really be prioritized now to solve this problem or remedy it a little?

11:45 a.m.

Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual

Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé

We must distinguish between visible and invisible processes and, in fact, all informal relationships at the UN, which Jennifer Welsh also mentioned. Canada should prioritize being at the table and being present. Even our Prime Minister, Mark Carney, said it: If we're not at the table, we're on the menu. This is too often the case in several UN committees.

Before thinking about reforms, we should begin to understand the mechanisms and the influence we can have. The influence can be twofold. It can be the influence of the official mission of the UN committee or the deployed agency. We could also consider the influence of peace operations on the ground. However, there are also very significant benefits to be gained from our allies: Being there and being present allows us to learn more about them and about other ways of doing things. That's not taken into account enough.

There is also the fact that, on the ground, there are several ways to see the legitimacy of an action. It's about seeing that the UN is a tool and better understanding how the tool works both formally and informally. It's also important to be part of the processes.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Ms. Welsh, you have the floor.

11:45 a.m.

Director of the Max Bell School of Public Policy and Distinguished James McGill Professor, McGill University, As an Individual

Dr. Jennifer Welsh

Thank you for the question. Let me make two comments.

I think it's critical at the moment that Canada look at the entire UN80 reform agenda, which can look very large and overwhelming, identify with precision the two or three areas of UN reform that it thinks are critical to its own interests and values, and lead with ideas in a coalition to reform those parts of the UN that we believe are going to survive and be even more important.

Member states are going to need a World Food Programme, no matter what happens in the competition between China and the United States. Member states are going to need a functioning global migration organization like UNHCR. How do we, as Canada, in collaboration with countries from the global north and global south, pragmatically put forward a reform agenda for two or three parts of the UN system that we think are critical to maintain and keep alive? That is what I would be doing in GAC right now.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you very much.

Next is MP Brunelle-Duceppe, for two and a half minutes, please.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Ms. Martin‑Brûlé, in your opening remarks, you talked about the Elsie initiative. You said that there were three levers that appeared to be the foundation of the program. Can you share your expertise with the committee?

11:50 a.m.

Full Professor, Bishop's University, As an Individual

Sarah-Myriam Martin-Brûlé

Thank you for this question on the Elsie initiative.

First, one has to understand the obstacles. Canada supported the development of a methodology called measuring opportunities for women in peace operations, or MOWIP, which was developed with DCAF, or the Geneva Centre for Security Sector Governance, and Cornell University. The method examines 10 barriers to women's participation, including selection criteria and family responsibilities, and combines anonymous surveys, interviews and political and institutional analyses. What is known as MOWIP has made it possible to replace assumptions with scientific data and to target necessary reforms as well.

Next, the focus turned to funding the solutions. The Elsie initiative fund was created in 2019 to support the targeted changes, i.e., adapted infrastructure, equipment, training, selection procedures and deployment incentives.

The results were tangible. By the end of 2025, more than $21 million U.S. had been approved for 28 projects. In addition, seven infrastructure projects had been completed, 445 trained women were registered on the deployment lists and 7 units promoting high female participation had been deployed. This is another example where Canada helped develop a methodology and had a concrete influence through standards as well.

In 2023, Canada contributed to the adoption of nine documents amending the standards for equipment, lodging and medical support for UN contingents. In January 2026, with Australia and Bangladesh, it also contributed to the recognition and reimbursement of certain feminine hygiene products. As such, with the Elsie Initiative, Canada didn't just fund the change, it helped change the rules that make it possible.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

You have 30 seconds.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Mr. Chapnick, earlier, you said that when it comes to bilateral relations, it's hypocritical to do business with certain regimes that are dubious, so to speak. However, when a head of state who is considered the main ally of a genocidal force in Africa is received with great fanfare, isn't there a limit?

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Just a second. There's no translation.

Okay. I'm assured by the technical folks that it is working now. You may restart your question.

Thank you.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Isn't there still a red line that shouldn't be crossed? Yes, we can have diplomatic relations, but it's the manner in which these bilateral relations are expressed that sometimes crosses over the line a little. Don't you find it a little indecent to receive with great pomp, on the very date when genocidal acts were denounced, the person who is considered the greatest ally of the forces committing these acts? Isn't there something incoherent in that?

Prof. Adam Chapnick

I'm sorry to have to answer you in English. My French isn't good enough.

I think there are lines. I think, typically, though, those lines should be drawn based on concrete actions rather than words. If we're going to be hypocritical through words, the public can see sometimes that the words are necessary to appease in order to pursue other interests that are deemed critical, and that if we're going to draw lines, they should come much more in terms of actions.

We are going to do work with unsavoury regimes in the current climate. We have no choice. If the hypocrisy comes from saying a nice thing, and that's the only hypocrisy, I'm comfortable with that in the current environment, where we don't have the luxury of being all that picky about who we do business with.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you very much.

We go next to MP Ziad Aboultaif for five minutes.

11:50 a.m.

Conservative

Ziad Aboultaif Conservative Edmonton Manning, AB

Thanks, Chair.

Thanks to the witnesses for appearing.

I heard the term “variable geometry” twice, I believe, from you, Dr. Welsh, and from Professor Chapnick. Within the context of this, you mentioned that Canada should be looking for new partners and looking into these institutions and how effective the system can be. There's no doubt that we have a lack of transparency in this case and a lack of clarity on the strategy of the government. We don't know where the government is going with this.

I have a question for both of you, starting with Dr. Welsh. Where are these partners? Who are they? Is Canada really looking for these partners to be able to continue on that mission?

Thank you.

11:55 a.m.

Director of the Max Bell School of Public Policy and Distinguished James McGill Professor, McGill University, As an Individual

Dr. Jennifer Welsh

In what I've been able to learn, I think there are a few examples of where we can see variable geometry at work. One that the government has talked about a lot is the coalition of the willing on Ukraine, which is broader than the formal alliance of NATO. It is a coalition of countries coming together to coordinate their policy. Another example is the expansion of the trans-Pacific trade partnership towards the U.K. and Europe, which is something outside of the WTO but is a new kind of trading relationship.

I think the direction of your question is correct. When we pull these coalitions together, we need to clearly understand their purpose and their parameters but also how they relate to the existing architecture we have. I personally would like to see variable geometry extended to issues around, for example, global health security, and to cross the north-south divide. I also think, for example, there could be variable geometry among countries with critical mineral resources. South Africa and Canada right now lead a mining organization and could work together to set standards-based critical minerals agreements that would bring about transparency and better governance.

I'd like to see us expand what that means but also clarify how it relates to the existing institutions we have, so that we're not left with the impression as Canadians that everything is broken, because not everything is broken. We have to reform and improve what we have but creatively create new arrangements where they're needed.

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

Ziad Aboultaif Conservative Edmonton Manning, AB

Dr. Chapnick, go ahead, please.