Evidence of meeting #50 for Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was apprenticeship.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Herntier  President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers
Swick  Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

11:20 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

Although labour mobility for apprentices is an issue, one of the bigger issues that I know we're facing in Manitoba is the availability of training space. There are a lot of individuals who end up leaving the trade because they can't take their next level of technical training and further their career.

Currently, in the school that I'm the director of, we have roughly 200 people on an interest list to come to school, while we can comfortably put forth 34 apprentices every year. It's not a matter of interest and wanting to get into the trade. There's plenty of interest. It's a matter of actually being able to train these young individuals to get out there and join the skilled trades.

Louis Villeneuve Liberal Brome—Missisquoi, QC

Mr. Swick, I invite you to answer the question.

11:20 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

To echo that as well, there's a call for proposals that came out for the UTIP stream, which was for infrastructure. That's going to help us build that capacity to get those training centres up and running, so that we can actually cut down on those wait-lists.

Another thing that was brought out, too, through a call for proposal, was job readiness training and how that works. In the past, we've seen that individuals will strike companies to do a preapprenticeship style of training for the trades, but there's no pathway to a job. When you have the partnership link, as we do through the IBEW and our signatory contractors, we can put these job readiness programs on to have those youth come in, take the training so that they're ready to go day one on the job, with all the tickets and credentials they need to help the contractors, so they're not inflating what their costs are. That's taken out of that. Then, when they get to the job, they're effective on day one.

Through those pathways, as long as you have the proper link so that a person gets the certificates that are required in the beginning, then they get their registered training agreement. That is the next most important thing. You have to have a registered training agreement, and then after that you get placed with a contractor so you can fulfill that work commitment for four months or whatever it is—hopefully, forever. If you have that alignment, everything works very smoothly. As soon as you break down one of those three things, then things don't work as smoothly.

We're seeing that, with us and the way our structure is, we actually have that. Through the union sectors and the other trade unions, they would have the exact same thing: You do the job training, get them their tickets, and make sure that they get placed with that contractor and have the registered training agreement.

Why do I keep saying, “registered training agreement”? It is because there are compulsory trades across Canada, and it's illegal to work in the trades unless you have a registered training agreement. We have all kinds of people saying that they're an electrical helper, this, that and the other thing, and you technically can't do that. If we're going to build capacity for the trades, we have to make sure that they follow the mechanisms, that they have that registered training agreement with the province or the authority having jurisdiction, and that they then move on to get their work placement. After they get their work placement, then they can start doing the trade school aspect.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Mr. Villeneuve.

Ms. Larouche, you have the floor for six minutes.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

Mr. Herntier and Mr. Swick, thank you very much for being with us.

Here today, we are all seeking to address these issues in the most constructive way possible. Obviously, we are all aware of certain labour shortages in some sectors. We're all looking for solutions to ensure, in some cases, better collaboration to allow for a certain degree of mobility among skilled workers. However, as was pointed out—I believe it was you, Mr. Swick—the issue of labour and labour training falls under the jurisdiction of the provinces and Quebec.

We've heard from witnesses here from Quebec who clearly explained that we have a rather unique model—that of vocational training centres—which works well. However, of course, there are needs. In fact, I’ll soon be attending a training camp myself at the vocational training centre in my region, in Granby, to get a sense of what it's like and how young people are trained.

Mr. Herntier, you said that, in your case, it wasn't so much an issue of labour mobility as it was of training. It really comes down to being able to train more workers. Did I understand correctly that this is about having access to training programs?

The spring economic update 2026 promised funding as part of the team Canada strong initiative. Witnesses from Quebec told us that they were still waiting for these funds and that the funds would enable them to develop new training programs and find solutions to train more young people.

How could this funding, which was promised to you in the latest economic update and that would be transferred to you, help you meet your training needs? How crucial is it to receive that money?

Mr. Swick, you may begin.

11:25 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

The interesting piece with Quebec is that a lot of times they're excluded from the applications. Because of the way the funding model between the federal government and Quebec is, it actually doesn't work the same way for the call for proposals that we have in the other provinces.

Being able to put in the call for proposals for that infrastructure brick and mortar was instrumental to us, because we actually see where our training centres need to be upgraded. We see where we need to do the expansions, and we see the need to have more classroom space. We can put instructors to this, but we don't have the resources and the infrastructure right now to do it. When you build a new building, you have to have all the equipment, so they can do the technical training and things like that.

What's been brought down now in the spring economic statement is actually going to help us. The way that we have the infrastructure equipment stream that's out there right now with the 70-30, that's going to help. It's actually better, because it was 50-50 before, and now it's 70-30. It's a bit of extra help to make sure that we can equip those training centres so they can do the practical and technical training for that.

The unfortunate part, and I'm not 100% familiar with the structure for Quebec, is that they are excluded from all of that because of the way the funding model goes from the federal government to the Quebec government. I would suggest that if the Quebec government was looking at it, they should be looking at the same things in their own metric, through their own province, to say how they would do that.

Similarly, when you look at the federal transfer dollars that went to Ontario for the skills development fund, they already started to do this with the job readiness training, which has been done for five years. It has been proven 100% successful through the IBEW in job placements, so we already ticked that box to make sure that we have people going on to the job site and fulfilling their career.

We have individuals right now who are actually journeypersons who started in that program, and they have proven to be huge success stories. They then started doing the infrastructure, because they noticed the infrastructure was lacking in Ontario. I'm glad to see the federal government is looking at the other provinces to help assist them as well, because the federal transfer dollars don't work the same way in all the provinces, because they're allowed to dictate where they go. It just happened that Ontario decided to do it through a skills development fund, because they've seen the need to have more skilled tradespeople in the workforce, but they also had to have the infrastructure to do that.

Thank you.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

Mr. Herntier, do you have anything to add about these needs and these amounts? How might this help improve the training offerings? I think it was you who mentioned that this issue related to workforce training was a major challenge.

11:25 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

In terms of the announcement last week with the UTIP brick and mortar funding, that is one thing in Manitoba we will definitely be looking at. I've worked with Chris for about a year now, trying to get this grant pushed forward. Without access to something like this, there's probably very little chance that we'd be expanding to be able to train more people for the skilled trade workforce.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

So what's missing to truly meet this need?

11:25 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

What's missing for us is that in our own pocket we don't have the financial ability to actually purchase or build a new building. With our current location, it isn't feasible to expand on the building we currently have.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Ms. Larouche.

Ms. Falk, you have five minutes.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

I'd like to thank both of the witnesses for taking the time to be here and also for what their backgrounds are. I've said this before: Tradespeople are the people who build. When we talk about the need for infrastructure in this country, that means we need people who can do the work.

You know, it's an interesting conversation for me. I come from a part of the country that is very focused on energy, oil and gas, and agriculture. Those are all things that are very hands-on and that tradespeople are needed for. It was very common, actually, when I was in high school, that the question wasn't, “What university are you going to?” but, “Oh, are you going to SIAST or are you going to NAIT? Are you going to SAIT? What trade are you taking?” That's just our culture. The value that it brings to community and also to family is great.

I know we've been hearing repeatedly from the Liberals that we need trades workers, that there's this shortage. This committee actually did a study in 2018—so, a while ago—on experiential learning. At that time, we heard from witnesses—for example, the Independent Contractors and Businesses Association of British Columbia—that there were shortages of “pipe fitters, sheet metal workers, electricians, and plumbers”. That was 10 years ago. There's an importance, I think, in putting an emphasis on our needing trades workers to do this work. I would also think that we need the ability to have work, so that when someone is doing their apprenticeship, part of it is a hands-on process. You need to be able to actually go out and do the work, train the skill, see the skill and be taught.

I'm wondering whether you would agree that we need to see more projects happening in this country in order to help fulfill our lagging number of tradespeople.

That's for either of you, if you want to answer.

11:30 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

This is a reason that, when individuals say there's a lack of skilled tradespeople, we have to look at the jurisdictional measures that this has been perceived in. What I mean by that is that certain areas will have certain projects going on. There might be a major hospital going on. This is why mobility is so important. If there's a major project happening, such as a hospital being built in, let's say, Niagara Falls, it's going to take a lot of electricians. There might not be that same work happening in Hamilton, Kitchener, London or wherever. They might not have the same amount of work there, so those guys are not working. To be able to mobilize that workforce to do that job and incentivize those guys to go and do that job makes so much sense, because then you're not overcompensating and not putting too many people into the skilled trades. It's similar for province-to-province.

11:30 a.m.

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

Sure.

Well, I would say, because I border Alberta, that there are contingents of east coasters from Nova Scotia and Newfoundland who literally come out, commute that far, to be able to provide for their families. I think it's actually incumbent on provinces, but also the federal government, to ensure that the policies that they are putting in place are attracting investment. There's nothing I want to see more than for those workers in, say, Newfoundland and Labrador to be able to stay home and work in the community that they were raised in and that they're raising their families in. I think it's an important conversation to have. Yes, mobility absolutely is an issue, but we also have to look at the policies that are being implemented by every level of government and how they're affecting the regions. I mean, it would be very great if we didn't need to rely on mobility and had every area of our country working, the skilled trades being able to fulfill that.

Warren, do you have any comments on this?

11:30 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

Well, you're right. For an apprentice to advance, there needs to be work so that they can get their hours in the field. In Manitoba, we partnered with the plumbers and pipefitters, along with First Peoples Development Inc., and tried to artificially create work. In northern Manitoba, there are a number of people who do start in the trades but can't get past the first level because there's not enough work.

11:30 a.m.

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

It's because there are no projects and work to fulfill the needed requirement of the experiential learning that they need to do.

11:30 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

Absolutely. We'd put forth a proposal we called “getting past first”. We were going to duplicate training centres up in northern Manitoba, put them through that and then actually dispatch from Winnipeg fully set-up service vans. We put in a budget of about five million dollars' worth of equipment. They were going to basically retrofit all the northern communities with new state-of-the-art LED lighting, new heating and new panels, but the federal government told us it was too much money and not worth it.

11:35 a.m.

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Bobby Morrissey

Thank you, Ms. Falk.

Mr. Joseph has the floor for five minutes.

Natilien Joseph Liberal Longueuil—Saint-Hubert, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Mr. Swick, thank you for being here. We're going to talk about next steps.

What do you see as the key opportunities to continue to improve the mobility of skilled trades workers in Canada, moving forward?

11:35 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

Everything starts at apprenticeship. You can't be a journeyperson unless you're an apprentice. You have to get your hours. In order to get your hours, you have to do work. Work is based on the jurisdiction that has that factory, that data centre or whatever. You actually have to be able to mobilize. If we can't mobilize the apprentices through the Red Seal program and through the mechanisms we have, then to me that is a catastrophic failure.

I think what we have to do is we have to go back to the CCDA. I know it's a voluntary committee, but we have to say that you need to be more aligned with the Red Seal occupational standard. To use an example, in Ontario over 25 colleges do electrical training. Not a single one of them is doing the exact same technical training. They're all doing it differently.

There are two colleges right now through the IBEW that are mirrored, because we're the ones who help write the lesson plans and the curriculum so that they can do that. We've tried to mirror our stuff with Atlantic harmonization. We're also working with Saskatchewan right now. At the end of it, NETCO was prepared to take all the RSOS and look at what's happening in all the provinces and where those little supplemental trainings are. When an apprentice through the IBEW goes from one spot to the next, through our joint apprenticeship committees we will be able to place them so that they don't lose time and they keep their hours where they need to be.

We need to see that happening all across the industry. That has to happen not just with the IBEW but with the industry as a whole. We need to make sure that CCDA gets on board with this, so that we can make sure it actually is a true standardized and harmonized system across Canada.

Thank you.

Natilien Joseph Liberal Longueuil—Saint-Hubert, QC

On that note, let's talk about initiatives. Normally, there are specific initiatives or sectors that we should focus on. Can you tell us a bit about these initiatives and sectors?

11:35 a.m.

Executive Director, National Electrical Trade Council

Chris Swick

Again, I'd go back to making sure there's an alignment with all the provinces through the CCDA. I go to the CCDA meetings. I'm going to see if I can do a presentation just to make sure they understand where NETCO and the IBEW stand on how we can actually mobilize the apprentices in the workforce to make sure that the outcome is sufficient.

When I look at the completion rates for the Red Seal exam for the electricians, it's 53%, so we failed 47% of the people. We set them up for failure. We need to stop doing that. We need to set people up for success. We have to make sure that everything is actually identical to the way you're supposed to be teaching and all the learning outcomes are the same. If your jurisdictional area is heavy in industrial stuff, then you do supplemental training to teach them after the fact, so that they can get that, but the basis has to be the same across Canada so that they can write that exam. Then we actually have a true national workforce that can mobilize anywhere.

Natilien Joseph Liberal Longueuil—Saint-Hubert, QC

Thank you, Mr. Swick.

Mr. Herntier, let's talk about the mutual recognition of diplomas among the provinces. The federal government has a role to play in this regard, but what is that role?

11:35 a.m.

President, Local 2085, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers

Warren Herntier

I have to echo what my colleague here said. The RSOS has to be reviewed and an actual training standard developed from it. The number of technical training hours needs to match from coast to coast. The number of hours in the field needs to match. Whether we're going to do 7,200 hours of work and technical training or we're going to do 8,000 hours, it needs to be the same in every province. The curriculum needs to match.

There are provinces out there where, when you attend level one technical training, you don't even pick up a tool. It's all out of the book. I realize that you do learn out in the field how to use the tools, but a classroom setting is a perfect situation to get these young individuals comfortable with them.