House of Commons Hansard #165 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was medical.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Youth Criminal Justice Act Third reading of Bill C-231. The bill amends the Youth Criminal Justice Act to expand opportunities for young people with problematic substance use to access treatment during police referrals, court proceedings, sentencing and supervision, supporting rehabilitation and reintegration. Members across parties support the measure, while noting that effective implementation depends on timely access to treatment services. The House adds the alternate title “For the Friends of David Law” and passes the bill. 5800 words, 40 minutes.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation Motion Members debate the government’s time-allocation motion on Bill C-41, which would address MAID for cases where mental illness is the sole condition and permit advance requests. Conservatives, Bloc and Green members call for fuller scrutiny and question safeguards, including consent at the time of administration. Justice Minister Sean Fraser argues prior studies support moving ahead to recognize patients’ agency and reduce suffering. 5200 words, 30 minutes.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act Second reading of Bill C-41. The bill would permanently exclude mental illness as the sole basis for MAID, establish advance requests for people with qualifying conditions who may later lose decision-making capacity, and improve reporting. Supporters emphasize autonomy and dignity, while critics question consent, safeguards and oversight, and argue the advance-request provisions need separate, fuller debate. The House also debates provincial roles and whether the bill’s consideration is being rushed. 35000 words, 4 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives criticize Liberal spending and borrowing, linking them to inflation and affordability as families struggle with food, housing and jobs. They object to funding for Brazil’s forests, question rising immigration levels, and accuse the government of misleading Stellantis workers over a plant sale. They also raise concerns about Telesat ethics and attacks on faith communities.
The Liberals promote budget 2026 as a plan for growth and affordability, highlighting expanded groceries and essentials benefits, worker and caregiver supports, and housing and homelessness investments. They defend their fiscal position, immigration policies and climate investments, while emphasizing efforts to protect Stellantis jobs and uphold ethics rules.
The Bloc condemns the Liberals’ climate record, citing COP criticism, the push to sell gas at COP and plans for Arctic oil drilling. It also challenges immigration targets, warning of inadequate capacity and threats to Quebec’s political weight.
The Greens warn Parks Canada cuts threaten ecosystem protection, migratory bird habitat, visitor safety and wildfire prevention in Gulf Islands National Park.
The NDP calls for better decorum in the House during Question Period.

Adjournment Debates

Canada Health Infoway governance Matt Strauss presses Health Minister to say whether she fired Canada Health Infoway CEO Michael Green, and asks who is conducting an audit of the organization. Wade Grant says an independent review and audit are under way, but does not answer either question directly.
Budget deficits and borrowing Jacob Mantle says Budget 2026 masks rising debt and borrowing behind declining deficit projections, and asks why the Liberals keep changing their fiscal targets. Wade Grant defends the budget, saying it maintains fiscal discipline, meets the government’s fiscal anchors and makes strategic investments. Mantle disputes the government’s accounting approach.
Pipeline cost-benefit analysis Elizabeth May presses Wade Grant for a cost-benefit analysis of the proposed Pacific link pipeline, arguing public funds should not support a project that increases emissions and undermines climate targets. Grant defends the government’s broader approach to clean energy, major projects, jobs and environmental protections. May reiterates that Canada is far off its Paris Agreement emissions commitments.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:05 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, just before I address the question, though I have some concern about some confusion that I have seen play out in the debate, I believe members who have expressed different points of view in this debate have done so only with the best of intentions, following their deeply held convictions. I think that is an appropriate place to have debates where people feel strongly about these issues.

On the item that the member mentioned, of course some of the safeguards that we put in place ensure, where there is a revocation of consent, that ends the validity of an advance directive. However, if there is ambiguity as to whether that consent continues, in the view of either of the medical professionals who are mandated under the Criminal Code, it would be put on hold and the process would demand a reassessment at a subsequent point in time.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:05 p.m.

Conservative

Tamara Jansen Conservative Cloverdale—Langley City, BC

Mr. Speaker, it is absolutely shameful that the Liberal government is shutting down debate on a bill that deals with life and death.

Let us think about this for a minute. The Liberals had all summer, and now it has been nearly three weeks since Bill C-41 was introduced. We still have not seen the government's own analysis of how this bill could affect Canadians' charter rights and yet, they are already shutting down debate. This bill would allow someone to be euthanized years after making a request, when they can no longer consent and can no longer tell us if they have changed their mind, and other people who do not know them will be making that final decision for them. We are talking about ending the life of someone who can no longer speak for themselves.

Surely, if there was ever a bill that deserves careful scrutiny, this is it. Instead, the Liberals are rushing it through, without even giving MPs the information we need to do our jobs. How can the government possibly justify shutting down debate on Canadians' fundamental rights when it has not even given Parliament its own charter analysis?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:10 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, with enormous respect to all members of this House, the motivation to move forward is born out of the strong desire to give agency to people who are losing capacity to make decisions for themselves, so we no longer condemn people to a death that is certain and that will involve, by definition, intolerable suffering.

I would remind the member, as well, that what we are talking about here is not a new health care regime, but a change to Canada's criminal laws. The alternative to supporting this legislation is to maintain the fact that medical practitioners who abide by provincial standards and who follow, to the letter, the requirements of health laws developed by provincial governments, are to be treated as criminals. I do not think that is the right path forward. We should protect them from criminal liability and extend compassion to those who are suffering.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:10 p.m.

Bloc

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Mr. Speaker, it is always very disturbing when the government decides to muzzle the House of Commons, stifle debate and silence people who are genuinely interested in having their say on a topic as delicate and divisive as the one addressed by Bill C‑41.

I am at a loss for words to describe how I feel about the government employing this manoeuvre, especially on such a sensitive topic. I understand that the government wants to move forward quickly, and I understand that it wants to avoid the possibility of ideological filibustering by the Conservatives, but a public conversation is called for. I think that the government is wrong to impose time allocation on this debate.

I would like to know whether my colleague, the Minister of Justice, is comfortable with the fact that the government is going to unilaterally make a decision that called for a public conversation. It should have engaged in a discussion with the people, elected officials and experts, rather than use a time allocation motion to do as it pleases, with no regard for democracy.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:10 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, at the risk of stating the obvious, I take a different view.

I think there has been ample opportunity through various debates in Parliament, through the joint study by various committees of Parliament, and through debate that has taken place so far in this chamber and that will take place subsequently, during the committee study of this bill. We stand on firm ground to understand the reasons that underpin the suggested path forward.

It is also not lost on me that we are dealing with a set of circumstances in which if we do not adopt this law expeditiously, we are going to come up against a mandated timeline that exists in the Criminal Code with another issue for which there is a greater consensus. That, of course, is dealing with circumstances involving mental illness as a sole underlying medical condition.

I welcome differing points of view. I have heard many of them in my personal engagement and the engagement in my department. I think there has been ample opportunity in the House to air different positions—

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:10 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker John Nater

Questions and comments, the hon. member for Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:10 p.m.

Conservative

Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK

Mr. Speaker, it is very difficult to take anything the minister is saying seriously.

If the Liberals truly cared about the well-being of Canadians, especially those who, once this deadline passes, would be prevented from accessing medical assistance in dying based on mental illness as the sole condition, they would have voted for Bill C-218. Instead, they stood in this place, and they voted against it. They could have voted for Bill C-218, and they could have brought forward advance directive policy if they had wanted to.

Honestly, how can we even take seriously that the Liberals actually care about the well-being of Canadians when they should have voted for Bill C-218?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:10 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, one point of difference is that regardless of another member's position, I do my best to take it seriously, even when I do not agree.

With respect to Bill C-218, it was motivated by strong convictions and good intentions. That bill had a challenge with some of the wording, which we took issue with, that dealt with neurological conditions that could have excluded people who are currently eligible. Even in the face of that, which we may have been able to work through, we wanted to benefit from the deep policy expertise and lengthy study that went into the preparation of Bill C-41.

Also, based on our engagement on multiple issues, we wanted to move forward with a bill that included both the indeterminate exclusion of the mental illness issue as well as the steps we put in place to deal with advance directives.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:15 p.m.

Green

Elizabeth May Green Saanich—Gulf Islands, BC

Mr. Speaker, the hon. Minister of Justice will not be surprised to hear that I object to pushing this bill through quickly. He will probably recall from many previous debates such as this that I always oppose pushing bills through quickly.

This one has some particular concerns that are doubled by my experience of this new version of what is still, apparently, called a Liberal government, which says that once we push it through quickly at this stage, we are also likely to have it pushed through quickly in committee. We are also likely to not have enough witnesses, study or amendments at committee with adequate time to study.

My pleading with the minister is this. I think the official opposition has a good point, that this bill could be split in two, but I still have problems with the first part of the bill, as do Canadian civil liberties organizations. We need to have proper and full debate.

Also, while I have the floor, I object to the idea that there is a patchwork here. In the first versions of medical assistance in dying, when Jody Wilson-Raybould and Jane Philpott brought it forward, it was the same law across the country.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:15 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, I would remind the member that I have great respect for her, as always, and appreciate her point of view in this instance and in others as well.

On the issue she raised with respect to a patchwork, I would remind the House that we are amending the Criminal Code, which necessitates a conversation about very specific safeguards that we want to insist are in place, which would delve into provincial governments' authorities should we do it in a way that would be uniform in nature across the country from day one, particularly the requirement that a repository is created in order to avoid criminal liability under the bill.

More specifically, on the issue of splitting the bill and the time allocated for debate, we have seen substantial debate play out on these issues across Canada, in Parliament, not only during the present debate but during previous studies as well.

At its core, I am uncomfortable delaying further the implementation of these rules knowing that there are people who are suffering and who deserve to have their agency recognized at a time when there is a deadly disease taking their capacity.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:15 p.m.

Conservative

Connie Cody Conservative Cambridge, ON

Mr. Speaker, under the bill, a Canadian whose death is not reasonably foreseeable can be assessed for MAID in a very short time. They can sign up for an advance request, fast-tracking their request for death instead of fast-tracking it to care. Currently, this leads provinces to deliver advance requests through their own health systems, and those are the same systems in which Canadians are already waiting half a year, a year or two years for surgery. People who might be able to recover very quickly are suffering more of an impact from the weight of the health care system.

Before someone signs up for MAID to actually die, what assurances would the government give to make sure they receive the care they need in ample time?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:15 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, I take issue with the characterization of this being about fast-tracking people's death. I keep in mind that we are dealing with sets of circumstances that involve, by definition in the legislation, intolerable suffering that is recognized by multiple medical assessors, where there is an irremediable condition. We are trying to respect the wishes of people, people I have sat down with who have told me what it is like to watch their parents lose who they were and become violent toward their children and their caregivers and then to have themselves be diagnosed with the same condition.

In those circumstances, it is my judgment, and the position of the government, that we should not characterize this as fast-tracking someone's death. I find that to be without taste. Instead, we should recognize that they deserve agency over the quality of life that they should enjoy as they deal with the worst possible diagnosis.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:15 p.m.

Bloc

Rhéal Fortin Bloc Rivière-du-Nord, QC

Mr. Speaker, I have a question for the minister about his proposal to fast-track this bill.

I believe, like him, like all of his Liberal colleagues, the Bloc Québécois, the Conservatives and everyone else, that this is an important bill. We do not all agree on everything about the bill, but we all agree that this bill is very important.

Is democracy no longer important for the minister? In my opinion, the more important we consider an issue to be, the more we must use the best tools at our disposal and the more our work should be guided by fundamental values. That is the case here with this important bill.

How can the minister justify the fact that he is now disregarding the rules of democracy, cutting short debate and fast-tracking a bill that he said himself was very important?

Faster is not always better.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:20 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my Bloc Québécois colleague, but I disagree, given the circumstances surrounding this debate. Parliament has conducted a few studies on these issues, we have debated them in the House and the Senate, and the government has produced many reports.

Now it is time to implement the changes, which are informed by the expertise of medical professionals and which reflect the need to address this disease for those who suffer from it.

We have had many opportunities to debate this issue in public, in the chamber in this instance and in various parliamentary studies over the past number of years. In my view, we have the information we need to make decisions and have provided opportunity for various perspectives to be put forward on these important issues.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:20 p.m.

Conservative

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

Mr. Speaker, the time allocation motion is nothing short of outrageous. We have had one day of debate on a bill that significantly expands MAID with the introduction of advance requests. The last time advance requests were meaningfully studied was back in 2018, when the Council of Canadian Academies' expert panel recommended against them. Since then, there has been no meaningful consultation and no meaningful study.

The minister spoke of the special joint committee. I sat on that special joint committee. At best, the committee did a cursory review of advance requests. Advance requests raise profound legal, ethical and practical issues and present significant risks, including the very real risk that MAID could be administered against a patient's wishes, absent contemporaneous consent.

Given all of that, how can the minister possibly justify shutting down debate?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:20 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, one element of the question was directed at a central issue. It is about respecting a patient's wishes. We clearly hold a different view. We wish to move forward with a regime that provides for advance requests. In fact, the legislation would not create the regime in provincial health systems but would simply decriminalize the practice where there is a provincial regime in place. The reason we want to move forward is about giving agency and respecting the patient's request.

To do otherwise would be to condemn them to experience a death that is intolerable, in the level of suffering they would experience, with a known result and a continued deterioration. We want to do what we can to give agency to those individuals. We have, at a government level, with the Department of Health, and as a Parliament, been able to study these and related issues. The time to move forward is now.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:20 p.m.

Liberal

Doly Begum Liberal Scarborough Southwest, ON

Mr. Speaker, in my time here, just over the last month, I have heard from my constituents on this very important bill. We have heard many personal and deeply emotional stories throughout this debate. I would like to give the minister an opportunity to share some of his experiences. What has he heard, and why is it so important to move forward efficiently and effectively with this legislation?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:20 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, the stories capture the human element behind these very difficult debates, and I appreciate the member giving me this opportunity. Perhaps one that stands out for me more than others was from a member of my community. He is a stand-up citizen whose partner is a wonderful and beloved artist in our community. He shared with me the experience of living through a terrible set of circumstances when his mother was diagnosed with a condition that caused her to forget her family, that caused her to become unknown and a very different version of herself, which was hard not only on her as a patient but of course on the family as well. Upon being diagnosed with the same condition, he expressed to me a strong desire to ensure that he had the ability to not make his family go through what he went through.

These human experiences have become all too common in my conversations with people who now treat this legislation as an opportunity to minimize the suffering they experience as well as the suffering their families are required to live through.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:20 p.m.

Conservative

Alex Ruff Conservative Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound, ON

Mr. Speaker, my question to the Minister of Justice is very simple. We understand there is a legal timeline or deadline with respect to the part of the bill that deals with the exclusion of MAID for mental illness alone. Is there a legal requirement or deadline tied to advance requests, yes or no?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:20 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, the motivation we have to deal with the advance request issue is to prevent the extraordinary human suffering that exists every day. I wish to extend protections to people who are living with a diagnosis today where there is intolerable suffering of an irremediable nature so that they know what is coming, which would give them an opportunity to transition from this life in a way that minimizes the pain and suffering they and their families live through.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:25 p.m.

Bloc

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Mr. Speaker, I agree with what my colleague from Rivière-du-Nord said earlier.

These are such important issues, because they affect our society so profoundly and will change it drastically, change our approach to dealing with illness at the end of life.

These are extremely sensitive and extremely important issues, and we need to take our time and debate them thoroughly. The government cannot simply say that it is the government and that it has enough information to make a decision, so it does not need Parliament anymore because it is going to move forward and do whatever it wants.

Other aspects of this bill are very important. There is the issue of mental illness, which we have not finished debating. Yes, Quebec has already taken the lead on advance requests since 2023, but there are still other matters we should debate and discuss.

It is truly troubling to see this minister, who is generally known for working collaboratively with others, show up today with a time allocation motion on such a delicate and sensitive issue, when our constituents are asking us to explore it and debate it further to clarify these points, which, I repeat, are extremely sensitive.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:25 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague that these issues are important. I take a different point of view as to the opportunity that parliamentarians have had or will have to put their perspectives on the record, to vote with their conscience and to represent the folks who have elected them to serve in this particular chamber. We are not dismissing different points of view. In fact, taking together considerations from different parties, different perspectives and different communities of expertise and advocacy is how we arrived at the conclusion we did.

We have had eight hours of debate in this chamber. We will have an opportunity at committee to hear more. We are standing on the shoulders of studies, both joint studies between the Senate and Parliament, as well as previous debates that included proposed amendments on these issues. We believe we have identified the path forward. I welcome continued consideration of this through the parliamentary process that remains.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:25 p.m.

Conservative

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

Mr. Speaker, it took the government two years to discuss and debate changing two words in Canada's national anthem. The bill before us, which deals with life or death, was introduced by the minister on October 27, just 20 days ago. In the past 20 days, for one full week Parliament was not sitting. Today the minister is asking us to shut down debate and shut down any further discussion. He is refusing to split the bill, with no discussion whatsoever on a matter as important as life or death.

Why the urgency? Why not split the bill? Why not discuss it further? Why not debate it further? Why not hear from stakeholders across the country? Why not hear from Canadians? Why rush it through the House at warp speed?

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

12:25 p.m.

Liberal

Sean Fraser Liberal Central Nova, NS

Mr. Speaker, a repeated theme from members of the Conservative Party has been to split the bill. Although unanimity would be preferred, it is not the goal. Preventing the real suffering people are living through is the goal.

As we have this debate in Parliament, there are people living with deadly diagnoses that have or will steal their capacity to make decisions for themselves and result in a certain and painful death characterized by intolerable suffering. We have an opportunity to prevent the suffering that many vulnerable Canadians and their families will live through.

In addition, it makes sense to study multiple issues together when dealing with the same community of advocates and experts who will have perspectives on the two issues that are the central themes of this bill.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation MotionMedical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 16th, 2026 / 12:25 p.m.

Conservative

Ellis Ross Conservative Skeena—Bulkley Valley, BC

Mr. Speaker, we are talking about two issues here. One is about accessing MAID for mental health, which everybody agrees with. That could have been approved through Bill C-218. The minister talks about there being an issue with it. It could have been amended and would be a done deal.

We are talking about advance consent. Parliamentarians are expected to debate this within eight hours, but the minister keeps going back to studies that were done 10 years ago. Our job as MPs is to represent the people's wishes and feelings. Eight hours is not enough time.

Does the minister agree that Parliament's job is to assess and debate important bills like this one, which deal with life and death?