Vote #54 on March 5th, 2008

Bill

C-253 An Act to amend the Income Tax Act (deductibility of RESP contributions)

Vote topic

That Bill C-253, in Clause 2, be amended by replacing lines 8 and 9 on page 2 with the following:

“( b) the RESP lifetime limit minus the total of all contributions made by the taxpayer into a registered education savings plan in previous taxation years, to a maximum of $5,000.”

See context in the Debates.

Result

Yes 156
Bloc NDP Liberal
No 122
Conservative
Paired 4

Conservative

No Jim Abbott
No Diane Ablonczy
No Harold Albrecht
No Mike Allen
No Dean Allison
No Rona Ambrose
No Rob Anders
No David Anderson
No John Baird
No Dave Batters
No Leon Benoit
Didn't vote Maxime Bernier
No James Bezan
No Jean-Pierre Blackburn
No Steven Blaney
No Sylvie Boucher
No Garry Breitkreuz
No Gord Brown
No Patrick Brown
No Rod Bruinooge
No Blaine Calkins
No Ron Cannan
No Lawrence Cannon
No Colin Carrie
No Rick Casson
No Michael Chong
No Tony Clement
No Joe Comuzzi
No John Cummins
No Patricia Davidson
No Stockwell Day
No Dean Del Mastro
No Barry Devolin
No Norman Doyle
No Rick Dykstra
No David Emerson
No Ken Epp
No Ed Fast
No Diane Finley
No Brian Fitzpatrick
Didn't vote Jim Flaherty
No Steven Fletcher
No Royal Galipeau
No Cheryl Gallant
No Peter Goldring
No Gary Goodyear
No Jacques Gourde
No Nina Grewal
No Helena Guergis
No Art Hanger
No Stephen Harper
No Dick Harris
No Luc Harvey
No Laurie Hawn
No Loyola Hearn
No Russ Hiebert
No Jay Hill
No Betty Hinton
No Rahim Jaffer
No Brian Jean
No Randy Kamp
No Gerald Keddy
No Jason Kenney
No Wajid Khan
No Ed Komarnicki
No Daryl Kramp
No Mike Lake
No Guy Lauzon
No Denis Lebel
No Pierre Lemieux
No Tom Lukiwski
No Gary Lunn
No James Lunney
No Peter MacKay
No Dave MacKenzie
No Fabian Manning
No Inky Mark
No Colin Mayes
No Ted Menzies
No Rob Merrifield
No Larry Miller
No Bob Mills
No Rob Moore
No James Moore
No Rob Nicholson
No Rick Norlock
No Deepak Obhrai
No Gordon O'Connor
No Bev Oda
Paired Brian Pallister
No Christian Paradis
No Daniel Petit
No Pierre Poilievre
No Jim Prentice
No Joe Preston
No James Rajotte
No Scott Reid
No Lee Richardson
No Gerry Ritz
No Andrew Scheer
No Gary Schellenberger
No Bev Shipley
No Carol Skelton
Paired Joy Smith
No Monte Solberg
No Kevin Sorenson
No Bruce Stanton
No Brian Storseth
No Chuck Strahl
No David Sweet
No Myron Thompson
No Greg Thompson
No David Tilson
No Vic Toews
No Bradley Trost
No Merv Tweed
No Dave Van Kesteren
No Peter Van Loan
No Maurice Vellacott
No Josée Verner
No Mike Wallace
No Mark Warawa
No Chris Warkentin
No Jeff Watson
No John Williams
No Lynne Yelich

NDP

Didn't vote Charlie Angus
Yes Alex Atamanenko
Yes Catherine Bell
Yes Dennis Bevington
Yes Dawn Black
Didn't vote Bill Blaikie
Yes Chris Charlton
Yes Olivia Chow
Yes David Christopherson
Yes Joe Comartin
Didn't vote Jean Crowder
Yes Nathan Cullen
Yes Libby Davies
Yes Paul Dewar
Yes Yvon Godin
Didn't vote Peter Julian
Yes Jack Layton
Yes Wayne Marston
Yes Pat Martin
Yes Tony Martin
Yes Brian Masse
Yes Irene Mathyssen
Yes Alexa McDonough
Yes Thomas Mulcair
Yes Peggy Nash
Yes Penny Priddy
Yes Denise Savoie
Yes Bill Siksay
Yes Peter Stoffer
Yes Judy Wasylycia-Leis

Bloc

Yes Guy André
Yes Gérard Asselin
Yes Claude Bachand
Yes Vivian Barbot
Yes André Bellavance
Yes Bernard Bigras
Yes Raynald Blais
Yes France Bonsant
Yes Robert Bouchard
Yes Diane Bourgeois
Yes Paule Brunelle
Yes Serge Cardin
Yes Robert Carrier
Yes Paul Crête
Yes Claude DeBellefeuille
Yes Nicole Demers
Yes Johanne Deschamps
Yes Gilles Duceppe
Yes Meili Faille
Yes Carole Freeman
Yes Christiane Gagnon
Paired Roger Gaudet
Yes Raymond Gravel
Yes Monique Guay
Yes Michel Guimond
Yes Maka Kotto
Yes Jean-Yves Laforest
Yes Mario Laframboise
Paired Francine Lalonde
Yes Carole Lavallée
Yes Marc Lemay
Yes Yves Lessard
Yes Yvon Lévesque
Yes Marcel Lussier
Yes Luc Malo
Yes Serge Ménard
Yes Réal Ménard
Yes Maria Mourani
Yes Richard Nadeau
Yes Christian Ouellet
Yes Pierre Paquette
Yes Gilles-A. Perron
Yes Pauline Picard
Yes Louis Plamondon
Yes Jean-Yves Roy
Yes Thierry St-Cyr
Yes Caroline St-Hilaire
Yes Ève-Mary Thaï Thi Lac
Yes Robert Vincent

Liberal

Yes Omar Alghabra
Yes Larry Bagnell
Yes Navdeep Bains
Yes Sue Barnes
Yes Colleen Beaumier
Yes Mauril Bélanger
Yes Don Bell
Yes Carolyn Bennett
Yes Maurizio Bevilacqua
Yes Raymond Bonin
Yes Ken Boshcoff
Yes Scott Brison
Yes Bonnie Brown
Didn't vote Gerry Byrne
Yes John Cannis
Didn't vote Brenda Chamberlain
Yes Raymond Chan
Didn't vote Denis Coderre
Yes Irwin Cotler
Yes Roy Cullen
Yes Rodger Cuzner
Yes Jean-Claude D'Amours
Yes Sukh Dhaliwal
Yes Ruby Dhalla
Didn't vote Stéphane Dion
Didn't vote Ujjal Dosanjh
Yes Ken Dryden
Yes Wayne Easter
Didn't vote Mark Eyking
Yes Raymonde Folco
Yes Hedy Fry
Yes John Godfrey
Yes Ralph Goodale
Didn't vote Bill Graham
Yes Albina Guarnieri
Yes Mark Holland
Yes Charles Hubbard
Yes Michael Ignatieff
Yes Marlene Jennings
Yes Susan Kadis
Didn't vote Nancy Karetak-Lindell
Yes Jim Karygiannis
Yes Tina Keeper
Yes Dominic LeBlanc
Yes Derek Lee
Yes Lawrence MacAulay
Yes Gurbax Malhi
Yes John Maloney
Yes Diane Marleau
Didn't vote Paul Martin
Yes Keith Martin
Yes Bill Matthews
Yes John McCallum
Yes David McGuinty
Yes Joe McGuire
Yes John McKay
Yes Dan McTeague
Didn't vote Gary Merasty
Didn't vote Peter Milliken
Yes Maria Minna
Yes Brian Murphy
Yes Shawn Murphy
Yes Anita Neville
Didn't vote Stephen Owen
Yes Massimo Pacetti
Yes Bernard Patry
Yes Glen Pearson
Didn't vote Jim Peterson
Yes Marcel Proulx
Yes Yasmin Ratansi
Yes Karen Redman
Yes Geoff Regan
Didn't vote Lucienne Robillard
Yes Pablo Rodriguez
Yes Anthony Rota
Yes Todd Russell
Yes Michael Savage
Yes Francis Scarpaleggia
Yes Andy Scott
Yes Judy Sgro
Yes Mario Silva
Yes Raymond Simard
Yes Scott Simms
Yes Lloyd St. Amand
Yes Brent St. Denis
Yes Paul Steckle
Didn't vote Belinda Stronach
Yes Paul Szabo
Yes Andrew Telegdi
Yes Lui Temelkovski
Yes Robert Thibault
Yes Alan Tonks
Yes Garth Turner
Yes Roger Valley
Didn't vote Joe Volpe
Didn't vote Tom Wappel
Didn't vote Bryon Wilfert
Yes Borys Wrzesnewskyj
Didn't vote Paul Zed

Independent

Yes André Arthur
Didn't vote Bill Casey
Yes Louise Thibault
Yes Blair Wilson