I need to interrupt the member. The time has elapsed for debate.
Questions and comments, the hon. member for Oxford.
Sean Fraser Liberal
Second reading (House), as of Nov. 16, 2026
Subscribe to a feed (what's a feed?) of speeches and votes in the House related to Bill C-41.
This is from the published bill.
This enactment amends the Criminal Code to, among other things,
(a) clarify that a person cannot receive medical assistance in dying on the basis of a mental illness; and
(b) create exemptions from the offences of culpable homicide and administering a noxious thing, in order to permit a medical practitioner or a nurse practitioner to provide medical assistance in dying to a person who has lost the capacity to consent to the procedure if the person made an advance request to receive medical assistance in dying when they had that capacity and if
(i) the person is eligible to receive medical assistance in dying and the medical practitioner or nurse practitioner ensures that the applicable safeguards are complied with,
(ii) the person prepared their advance request in accordance with the applicable criteria, including that the person was diagnosed, before the request was signed, with a serious and incurable illness or disease that was reasonably expected to lead to an irreversible loss of the capacity to consent to receiving medical assistance in dying, and
(iii) the province in which the person would receive medical assistance in dying has in force a provincial legislative regime that identifies the repository in which advance requests are stored and that includes rules in relation to, among other things, making, storing, withdrawing and amending or replacing advance requests.
The enactment also amends An Act to amend the Criminal Code (medical assistance in dying) so that the exclusion from eligibility to receive medical assistance in dying in relation to a mental illness remains in force.
Finally, the enactment makes related amendments to other Acts.
All sorts of information on this bill is available at LEGISinfo, an excellent resource from Parliament. You can also read the full text of the bill.
Bill numbers are reused for different bills each new session. Perhaps you were looking for one of these other C-41s:
This is a computer-generated summary of the speeches below. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.
Bill C-41 would maintain the exclusion of medical assistance in dying where mental illness is the sole underlying condition and establish a framework for advance requests by adults with capacity-limiting illnesses, subject to safeguards and provincial or territorial legislation.
Liberal
Conservative
NDP
Bloc
Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders
The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec
I need to interrupt the member. The time has elapsed for debate.
Questions and comments, the hon. member for Oxford.
Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders
November 4th, 2026 / 6:25 p.m.
Conservative
Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON
Mr. Speaker, I think we all agree on the mental illness component of the bill, and my colleague highlighted that there have been great discussions and great studies at committees, both at the Senate and in this chamber. However, on advance requests, there have been no studies, no debates and no conversations that we have seen in the House, and it seems that the government is rushing through something that should not be rushed, especially when it comes to matters of life or death.
Can the member stand up and tell us why the government is trying to ram something through instead of working with us, passing the mental illness component to satisfy the time restriction we have of March 2027 and listening to experts before it puts policy forward?
Emmanuella Lambropoulos Liberal Saint-Laurent, QC
Mr. Speaker, of course, the minister consulted with Canadians. Someone who suffers from Alzheimer's disease suffers tremendously, especially toward the end of their life. They lose capacity in many functions in their body, and it is only fair that they get the right to decide to die with dignity if they so choose.
Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC
Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask my colleague about people living with mental health issues.
It is all well and good if certain psychedelic drugs, taken in low doses, may eventually cure these individuals. Under no circumstances should medical assistance in dying become a way out for those who are unable to access care. When I talk to my colleague from Montcalm, who is an expert on this issue, he tells me that this is not at all intended for such people. They would never be granted access to end-of-life care. Rather, we are talking about people who have been struggling with mental health issues for 20 years, who have tried every available treatment and consulted every possible specialist.
What the court has told the government and us, as legislators, is that we must respect the rights and freedoms of people who, after decades of trying everything, have found no relief. We must recognize that mental illness is a health condition, just like physical illness, and respect the rights and freedoms guaranteed to these individuals under the charter.
Is there not a risk that the bill, as it stands, could be challenged before the Supreme Court, forcing the government and legislators to go back to the drawing board in a few years' time?
Emmanuella Lambropoulos Liberal Saint-Laurent, QC
Mr. Speaker, based on our discussions in caucus, the proposed bill was not necessarily intended only for people who have been living with a mental illness for 20 years. We also know that our health care system is stretched to the limit. I think that doctors need to make informed decisions and verify whether a condition has truly persisted for 20 years.
I think that some people are going to die before their chosen time simply because we lack the supports needed to implement this kind of legislation.
Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders
November 4th, 2026 / 6:30 p.m.
Winnipeg North Manitoba
Liberal
Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons
Mr. Speaker, I am hoping that throughout the debate this evening, we will hear more discussion on home care services, hospice care and palliative care. These are all essential services, and we need to look at ways to continue to expand and support them. Much of this is provincial responsibility, but it is important to recognize that the legislation would have an impact on different levels of government in terms of their responsibility. That is one of the reasons it is critical that we work collaboratively with other jurisdictions.
I wonder if the member could provide her thoughts in regard to the issue of hospice care in particular.
Emmanuella Lambropoulos Liberal Saint-Laurent, QC
Mr. Speaker, it should always depend on what the person who is suffering wants, especially with a disorder like Alzheimer's. Of course, hospice care and end-of-life care are extremely important, and a person dying should always die with dignity, but at the end of the day, it is ultimately up to them how they choose to end their days of suffering.
James Maloney Liberal Etobicoke—Lakeshore, ON
Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to stand up and speak to Bill C-41 for reasons that will become apparent as I move forward.
MAID is, frankly, one of the more difficult issues that I have had to deal with in my 11 years here as an MP. It is an issue that deals with people at the most vulnerable time in their life, making one of the most difficult decisions they will ever make. We have a great responsibility in getting this right. It is a discussion, of course, that people wish they never had to have, but it is a conversation that is necessary, and that is why this piece of legislation is so important.
MAID provides Canadians with the ability to make a choice about how they wish to live out their last days and to exercise some control over the most inevitable parts of human existence, and it brings comfort to their family members. It is also something that generates a lot of questions and concerns from Canadians, and rightly so.
People across the country are struggling with these personal issues. When family members are ill, sick and dying, they are dealing with medical professionals, and they need to know that this is a top priority for us. I know this because I, like every other member of Parliament in this chamber, have received phone calls and emails from constituents and people sharing these deeply personal stories.
The most recent iteration of the special MAID committee, which I had the honour of sitting on, completed its work in June. I see one of my colleagues across the way. She was on the committee with me, so she understands the great angst that we all experienced in dealing with these deeply personal issues. We heard from witnesses. We listened to testimony. We heard from professionals. We heard from families with lived experience. I think we got it right. It was a tough decision to make, and anybody who thinks that committee did not take its job seriously was not paying attention.
Bill C-41 would get us to where we need to be, in my opinion, and I am honoured to stand up here and speak to it. Firstly, the bill would conclusively halt the scheduled expansion of MAID on the basis of mental illness. Secondly, it would legalize the provision of MAID on the basis of an advance request. An adult diagnosed with a capacity-limiting illness could make a request while they still have the capacity to do so, in anticipation of a future loss of capacity.
I want to speak first about the mental illness decision. As I said, I was on this committee most recently. I was on the committee immediately prior to that, when we reviewed the issue. I was on the committee the first time there was a joint committee. I was also on the justice committee when the legislation was first considered and, ultimately, was introduced.
I have heard from all of the witnesses time and time again. I know how troubling this issue is. I struggled with it myself. Mental illness is a real issue. It is a real medical condition. However, we have to get this right. Until we have concurrence among the medical community, we as legislators would be irresponsible to do anything but introduce this bill and stop the law from coming into effect on March 17 of next year.
All three times, we heard from experts from across the country, people who practise in this area, people who are specialized and have particular knowledge. We heard from family members. The overwhelming majority view was that the system is not ready, the country is not ready, and we cannot responsibly and safely introduce MAID for people whose sole underlying condition is mental illness.
There is no consensus among the doctors. If we cannot get consensus among the doctors on a diagnosis, how can we possibly get consensus among the doctors on whether we should proceed? That is a very important distinction. This is not a value judgment. We have to listen to these experts, but if 10 doctors examine the same patient and cannot agree on the diagnosis, how can we possibly responsibly proceed and allow this to take effect? We cannot. That is where we are today.
An irremediable mental health condition is something the medical community can simply not agree on, full stop. That is why we are here talking about this today. This is not to say that mental illness is not a serious or grievous condition. We all know it is. We have talked about it many times. We all have people in our families who experience these challenges. Nobody makes light of this, I can assure members. It does not matter. It does not mean people cannot be helped. It does not mean there is not help out there for these people in their darkest moment to have something to look forward to. That is why this is so important.
The committee heard from experts about the insufficient mental health services available in this country. Let us call it what it is. We know that. That is something we have to address here. It is something the provinces have to address. It is something that I am proud to say this government, and in fact all parliamentarians as it is not a partisan issue, can agree on and something we have made great strides on.
This first part of the bill is not only important but urgent. If we do not pass it immediately, the law takes effect on March 17, 2027, so I am asking every member of this House to vote in favour of Bill C-41 for that reason and the reasons I have outlined.
The second part of the bill deals with creating a framework for baseline safeguards for the provinces and territories to be able to introduce their own legislation to allow MAID to be provided on the basis of an advance request. An advance request lets a person decide now, after diagnosis of a disease that in the future would strip them of the ability to consent to MAID, to make decisions about their end-of-life care while they still can. This generates great debate too.
The crux of the concern that I have heard is that people lose their ability to make the decision, which means we do not know if they have possibly changed their mind. Here is the thing about that. We know when we are making that decision that that is part of the equation. If I am presented with that scenario, and I know the action is going to be carried out after I have lost my ability to make that decision, I make that decision myself, and I know that going in. That is consent. I think people need to give that serious consideration.
I know my friend across the way is going to raise the issue of a perceived lack of study. It has been studied. I have been on all three iterations of this committee. Members can look at the report from the first one. The matter of advance requests was part of our discussion. We reviewed it thoroughly. We heard from experts. We gave it detailed consideration. This is not something the government just decided to do. This debate has been going on for several years. Not only that, but when this bill gets through the House, it will go to committee and we will have the opportunity to scrutinize it again. Members can rest assured that this will be done responsibly. I have great confidence that that is a fact.
Under Bill C-41, in order to qualify or make the decision for an advance request, the requester must be an adult, 18 years old or older; live in Canada and be eligible for publicly funded health care; have a diagnosis of an incurable, capacity-limiting disease; and have the capacity to make the decision about their own health care. I emphasize that again.
The advance request must be drafted with the assistance of a physician or a nurse practitioner and in consultation with an expert in this disease. The request reflects the person's voluntary and informed decision. I cannot put enough emphasis on this. It is an informed decision, when one has the ability and the capacity to make that decision. Is that not what we want? I say the answer to that is yes.
I know I am running out of time. I think this legislation would put our country where it needs to be. I feel very strongly about it. It is an issue I have been committed to for many years now, and I am very proud to be standing here in support of this bill.
Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders
November 4th, 2026 / 6:40 p.m.
Conservative
Rosemarie Falk Conservative Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, SK
Mr. Speaker, I felt the weightiness of what the member across the way spoke about. I also felt the weightiness in his voice as he delivered his remarks. I want to thank him for that, for taking this so seriously.
In the majority of his remarks, he spoke about mental illness. He did say this is not a partisan issue, but I wonder why the Liberals voted against Bill C-218. This would have immediately moved on, and we would have been well under way to ensuring that the mental illness component would be looked at right away. How come they voted against that?
James Maloney Liberal Etobicoke—Lakeshore, ON
Mr. Speaker, that is a great question. The simple answer is that the language used in that bill did not accurately reflect the language used in the Criminal Code, and we have to get this right.
The member is right; I feel strongly about this. Mental disease and mental illness are two different things from a legal perspective, and this piece of legislation addresses that with the language that is appropriate and would get us the result we need. Not voting for that bill was not a reflection of my attitude or anybody else's attitude, but as I said during my remarks, I want to get this right. I do not want to have to do this again.
Alexis Deschênes Bloc Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, QC
Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his contribution to this debate. I would like him to tell us more about excluding MAID altogether as an option for people whose sole medical condition is a mental illness. Even if we asked 10 different doctors, each of them might well come up with a different diagnosis. I get a sense that this can happen with any diagnosis.
By closing the door on medical assistance in dying for people living with a mental illness, are we not moving too quickly and failing to take seriously a health condition that can cause immense suffering?
James Maloney Liberal Etobicoke—Lakeshore, ON
Mr. Speaker, I alluded to that as well. Let me give an example. If an individual is diagnosed with terminal cancer and that person goes to see 10 physicians, all 10 of them are going to agree on that diagnosis. Some of them may disagree on life expectancy, some might disagree on the type of treatment, but they would agree on the core issue, which qualifies the individual to apply for MAID. A mental illness is entirely different. In my previous life, I dealt with this quite a bit.
If somebody with a mental illness goes to 10 doctors, six of them might say yes, there is a serious mental illness; two of them might say no, there is no mental illness; and the other two might just say yes, there is, but it is going to get better. How in that scenario can a person possibly be granted access to MAID? Four of those doctors are saying they do not know whether the illness is irremediable. That is the difference. Until we can get that right, until we can design a system that those people do not slip through, I will never be comfortable supporting it.
Lisa Hepfner Liberal Hamilton Mountain, ON
Mr. Speaker, I just have a comment. I want to thank my colleague for all the years of work he has put into this issue. As we heard in his speech, he has put everything he has into this issue. He studied it for years on end, and those were difficult conversations. Those were difficult committees to sit on.
I have heard stories from my friend over the years. I know he has put a lot into it and it has taken a lot out of him. I want to thank him for his service.
James Maloney Liberal Etobicoke—Lakeshore, ON
Mr. Speaker, that was very kind. I do not need thanks. I am just grateful to be in a position to do this, as any one of us would be. I mean, we all sit on committees. We all participate in different activities here every day. I can say without hesitation that this was the most weighty issue and process I have ever been through, but I am proud I was there to participate in all of it.
Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders
November 4th, 2026 / 6:45 p.m.
Conservative
Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON
Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with my great colleague from Cloverdale—Langley City.
In hearing the debates and discussions, I would say we all know this is a tough topic to talk about. It is an issue that affects everyone deeply. I am not here to change anyone's mind; I am here to raise concerns that I see on this issue.
I want to start by first sharing a story with the House. In 2014, my uncle was admitted to the hospital and then was moved to the ICU. He was not breathing on his own and had internal bleeding. The doctors said to us that his time was up and that he was not going to make it. We were told to make the funeral arrangements. My cousin and I went to the funeral home, booked the funeral, blew his picture up for the ceremony and called our family in the U.K. We were by his side for what we thought were his last moments.
The doctor then asked us if the family was done spending time with the patient, and we said no. She said she wanted us to witness his transition into his new life. My aunt asked what the doctor meant by “new life”. The doctor said he was not going to make it. He had internal bleeding in his brain, he was not breathing and he was in the ICU. My aunt said that God brought him in and God would take him out. Thankfully she said that, because he was alive for 12 years after that. He just passed away in August. He got to see his children's wedding, and he got to play with his grandkids. Those are moments with him that we will never forget. Had we taken the doctor's advice back then, he would not have been with us for them.
I was in the emergency room of another hospital, where people go to get help, and on the wall was a massive TV that asked, “Have you considered MAID?” Patients go to hospitals to get help and support, yet the hospital was pushing MAID.
This is a very touchy topic for everyone. I understand that the Liberals are now having conversations on this topic, and that is fine, but in this bill, there are two main components. One is the mental illness side and the other is advance requests. All parliamentarians have said that mental illness should not be the sole illness when it comes to MAID. We all agreed to it, yet the Liberals decided to vote that down a few weeks ago. They had the opportunity to have a bill that would satisfy the Supreme Court's requirements and meet the deadline for 2027, but they voted it down.
We all agree on the mental illness component in this bill. The Conservatives are united on that. That is why we have asked the government to work with us. We should work together and pass the bill. We should also split the bill. We all agree on the mental illness side, which would take care of the time constraint being put on us and would save lives, but the Liberals said, no, they would not do that. They have added the advance request to the equation. They are two separate issues that require two separate discussions.
I understand that the Liberals want to rush this bill through, but Canadians want an open, honest discussion. We want to bring in medical experts, provincial leaders, researchers, families, veterans and folks from indigenous communities to share opinions. The member opposite said that we have to get this right. Absolutely, we do. Let us put the mental illness side to rest. We all support it, and we would pass it tomorrow if the Liberals had a desire to do that. We would pass it at all stages tomorrow so we could focus on the issues that are still outstanding on advance requests. That seems like a common-sense idea. That seems like the right thing to do.
The statistics on MAID are insane. In Canada, 5% of all deaths are by MAID. Over 5% is one in 20. One in 10 people has said they know someone who has been offered MAID for a treatable condition. Safeguards have to be in place. We need to make sure there are safeguards protecting the most vulnerable.
I have talked to provincial leaders and spoken to doctors about the bill who are saying to hold on and are asking what the rush is. They ask, “Why are they combining these two issues into one vote?” They are confused. I understand that my colleague was talking about the studies the Liberals have done, so they should not be afraid to get back to the table and have a lengthy debate about this and call in the experts. There are two separate issues, and there are provincial jurisdictional concerns as well.
When I have conversations with members of the party opposite, they tell me that there might be some patchwork. Some provinces might buy into it and some might not, and that is a problem as well. We want to have a unified approach when it comes to these issues.
The other challenge we have is that MAID cannot be a substitute for bad health care. I understand that it is a provincial responsibility, but we have to make sure that any legislation we put forward can handle the current system. Sixty-three per cent of Canadians believe we are in a state of crisis when it comes to our health care. Canada has one of the worst wait times in the world for surgeries. We do not want people to feel so pressured and burdened when looking at the state of health care that they decide to end their lives. We have heard stories of that already, and it is a huge concern for us. MAID cannot be a substitute for bad health care.
I also believe that the language being used in this legislation could be tightened up. There is lots of room for amendments, but it has to go back to the drawing board. We have to have these conversations. We have to have these discussions. Again, we have offered the Liberals that solution. We have told them we will work with them. We made it very clear that this is not about party politics. Let us not make it about party politics. Let us make it about the lives of people, the innocent and vulnerable, who need that support. That will be my request going forward in this debate.
Conservatives are united on this: please, split the bill. Give us the time we need to study it. If we get this wrong, lives will be lost. This is a matter of life and death. I know my colleagues across the aisle agree that we have to get this right. They have the opportunity to do what is right to get this bill done. We have a responsibility as parliamentarians to protect the most vulnerable. It is our responsibility. We have to look at all options on this.
If someone needs help, we should have a health care system that supports them. We should be giving them care. We should be giving them the tools they need to get their lives back. If those do not exist, people will be pushed toward something they do not want to do. We do not want to be in a situation where we are taking away lives.
I always say that a person's worth should never be measured by their illness, their disability, their age or their need for care. I generally believe in that. I believe in the sanctity of human life. I believe that when someone is struggling, we should be there for them. We should be a country that is united in providing that care.
As we progress, as we have conversations and debates, my only ask, again, of the Liberal government is to split the bill. Lives are at stake. Let us slow down. Irrespective of what side someone is on, whether they support advance requests or not, there are legitimate concerns with this bill the way it is written. We need the time and the expertise from across the board to analyze this so we do not lose any lives. Every single day that I stand in this House, that I have the honour of serving our country, I will fight for that.