Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act

An Act to amend the Criminal Code and An Act to amend the Criminal Code (medical assistance in dying) and to make related amendments to other Acts

Sponsor

Sean Fraser  Liberal

Status

Second reading (House), as of Nov. 16, 2026

Subscribe to a feed (what's a feed?) of speeches and votes in the House related to Bill C-41.

Summary

This is from the published bill.

This enactment amends the Criminal Code to, among other things,
(a) clarify that a person cannot receive medical assistance in dying on the basis of a mental illness; and
(b) create exemptions from the offences of culpable homicide and administering a noxious thing, in order to permit a medical practitioner or a nurse practitioner to provide medical assistance in dying to a person who has lost the capacity to consent to the procedure if the person made an advance request to receive medical assistance in dying when they had that capacity and if
(i) the person is eligible to receive medical assistance in dying and the medical practitioner or nurse practitioner ensures that the applicable safeguards are complied with,
(ii) the person prepared their advance request in accordance with the applicable criteria, including that the person was diagnosed, before the request was signed, with a serious and incurable illness or disease that was reasonably expected to lead to an irreversible loss of the capacity to consent to receiving medical assistance in dying, and
(iii) the province in which the person would receive medical assistance in dying has in force a provincial legislative regime that identifies the repository in which advance requests are stored and that includes rules in relation to, among other things, making, storing, withdrawing and amending or replacing advance requests.
The enactment also amends An Act to amend the Criminal Code (medical assistance in dying) so that the exclusion from eligibility to receive medical assistance in dying in relation to a mental illness remains in force.
Finally, the enactment makes related amendments to other Acts.

Elsewhere

All sorts of information on this bill is available at LEGISinfo, an excellent resource from Parliament. You can also read the full text of the bill.

Bill numbers are reused for different bills each new session. Perhaps you were looking for one of these other C-41s:

C-41 (2023) Law An Act to amend the Criminal Code and to make consequential amendments to other Acts
C-41 (2017) Law Appropriation Act No. 1, 2017-18
C-41 (2014) Law Canada-Korea Economic Growth and Prosperity Act
C-41 (2012) Law Appropriation Act No. 3, 2012-13

Votes

Nov. 16, 2026 Passed Time allocation for Bill C-41, An Act to amend the Criminal Code and An Act to amend the Criminal Code (medical assistance in dying) and to make related amendments to other Acts

Debate Summary

line drawing of robot

This is a computer-generated summary of the speeches below. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Bill C-41 would maintain the exclusion of medical assistance in dying where mental illness is the sole underlying condition and establish a framework for advance requests by adults with capacity-limiting illnesses, subject to safeguards and provincial or territorial legislation.

Liberal

  • Supports Bill C-41: The Liberals support the bill’s two central changes: maintaining the exclusion for MAID when mental illness is the sole underlying condition, and permitting advance requests subject to safeguards.
  • Maintains mental illness exclusion: They argue that uncertainty about whether mental illness is irremediable, limited clinical consensus and gaps in mental health services make expansion unsafe; the exclusion should remain indefinitely.
  • Allows advance requests: They support letting capable adults with an incurable, capacity-limiting illness set out in advance when they would want MAID, preserving personal choice and respecting their expressed wishes.
  • Safeguards and provincial roles: The bill retains eligibility requirements and adds protections, including independent assessments, the ability to revoke a request and rules against proceeding where consent is unclear. Provinces and territories decide whether to implement advance requests.

Conservative

  • Split the bill: Conservatives support permanently excluding mental illness as the sole basis for MAID, but insist that provision be separated from advance requests so each issue receives its own vote and scrutiny.
  • Oppose advance requests: They argue advance requests risk ending lives without contemporaneous consent, as a person’s wishes may change and clinicians must make subjective judgments about suffering, refusal and eligibility.
  • Strengthen safeguards and care: Conservatives call for stronger national oversight, enforceable safeguards and better access to health, disability, mental-health and palliative supports, so MAID does not substitute for care.

NDP

  • A free vote on conscience: The NDP caucus treats Bill C-41 as a matter of conscience, recognizing profound differences while balancing autonomy, dignity, equality and protection of vulnerable people.
  • Unequal access to advance requests: Kwan notes that advance requests would be available only where provinces or territories enact the required framework, raising concerns that Canadians’ rights could depend on where they live.
  • Mental illness eligibility remains contested: The bill maintains the exclusion for people whose sole underlying condition is mental illness; Kwan outlines equality concerns alongside expert and disability-rights concerns about irremediability, treatment access and safeguards.
  • Care must make choice meaningful: The government must ensure timely, affordable access to health care, housing, disability supports, mental health treatment and palliative care so assisted dying is not a substitute for unavailable support.
  • Thorough, inclusive review: Kwan urges the committee not to rush the bill and to hear people with lived experience, Indigenous organizations, families, advocates and experts through a transparent, human-rights-based process.

Bloc

  • Mental illness exclusion: The Bloc opposes indefinitely excluding people with serious, incurable mental illnesses from MAID, arguing that a blanket ban is discriminatory and likely unconstitutional. It calls for rigorous safeguards and says eligible people should not be left to pursue costly legal challenges.
  • Respect Quebec’s jurisdiction: The Bloc wants the Criminal Code to avoid restricting Quebec’s MAID laws and supports allowing provinces to develop care procedures. It warns that federal criteria, especially the test of relief through “reasonable means,” may be more restrictive than Quebec’s intolerability standard.
  • Advance requests and choice: The Bloc supports advance requests and emphasizes that a capable person should define in advance the conditions they find intolerable. It opposes others’ values overriding those wishes and wants Quebec’s approach accommodated.
  • Careful, non-partisan study: The Bloc criticizes the government for rushing the bill and urges thorough, evidence-based debate that hears from affected people and experts. Members suggest splitting the bill so advance requests can proceed while the mental-illness issue is resolved.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 6:55 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, I want to quote Stefanie Green, who is a practitioner, on the issue of MAID. This goes back to the case of Ms. Rodriguez, which dates back to 1991, when the debate was ongoing in Canada. “After learning what lay ahead for her, she wanted a doctor to be able to give her medication to end her life when she felt the time was right, so that her death could be quick and certain.” She then goes on to quote Ms. Rodriguez: “If I cannot give consent to my own death, whose body is this? Who owns my life?”

I note that because it is important that we recognize that the debate on this in Canada has been going on since the early 1990s.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 6:55 p.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Mr. Speaker, I did not hear a question, but I can say that doctors have reached out who are sharing legitimate concerns about this bill. Again, we as Conservatives agree on the mental illness stuff. We have been leading the charge on that. My colleague sitting right beside me, with Bill C-218, has led the charge on that, so there is no debate regarding that. The debate is regarding the safeguards that are needed. Irrespective of what members' beliefs are and what side they are on, it is our duty as parliamentarians to make sure that safeguards are in place to protect the most vulnerable. That is where we stand.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 6:55 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Mr. Speaker, as my colleague has pointed out well, the bill is fundamentally about the idea of advance directives for MAID. We could fix the mental health issue in 48 hours. We have already proposed splitting the bill and expediting the mental health section. It could move forward very quickly, so that is not the issue in tonight's debate. The issue is that the government is proposing a radical change to our MAID laws to allow a person today to sign a document that would allow someone to kill them at some point in the future. The law would not even require that they be told at that future point in time. Someone could be killed without even being told what is about to happen to them, simply on the basis of a document that they signed years ago before they even had any lived experience with their illness. They might receive a diagnosis, be terrified about what that means, sign a document based on what somebody tells them and then years later have someone take their life as a result of that document. This is gravely concerning, and it is something that I strongly oppose and that we should strongly oppose.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 6:55 p.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Mr. Speaker, as I said in my speech, the Liberal government needs to slow down on advance requests. They have to slow down. There is deep concern among medical professionals, provincial leaders, community organizations, advocacy groups, hospices and others raising concerns.

It is in the best interests of Canadians that we pass the mental illness component as soon as possible. We could pass it tomorrow. We are ready to support the Liberals' initiatives. That would take care of the time crunch that they claim they are under. We would support that, but let us take the time to find a solution for vulnerable Canadians who may end up losing their lives without proper safeguards. Let us study this, let us spend time on it and let us get it right, because this is a matter of life and death.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7 p.m.

Bloc

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

Mr. Speaker, I heard my colleague say that, when it comes to mental illness, moving forward while the health care system is not equipped to treat people would be catastrophic. However, I did not hear my colleague call for a 35% increase in health transfers, as the Bloc Québécois has done. Not wanting people to face discrimination indefinitely because they have been resistant to treatment for decades, and wanting to wait until our system is effective, while also not transferring the funds needed to make it so, seems rather illogical to me.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7 p.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Mr. Speaker, I strongly believe that health care in Canada should be better than what it is right now. I believe the current government should stop its reckless spending on other pet projects outside of the country, bring that money home and invest it in health care services. For example, the debt the government has increased in this country is from interest payments. We are paying more for interest payments than we are for health care transfers. Let us bring that money back home, and let us fix our health care system.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7 p.m.

Conservative

Tamara Jansen Conservative Cloverdale—Langley City, BC

Mr. Speaker, there is a cruel kind of thief that enters a home without breaking a window or turning a lock. It does not steal the family's silver or the money tucked away for a rainy day. The thief takes something far more precious. It steals memories, familiar faces and little pieces of a lifetime lovingly built together. About 10 years ago, that thief came for my auntie Grace.

She arrived in Canada from Holland in her early twenties, stepping off a ship in Halifax with a whole new life ahead of her. She found work as a maid at 24 Sussex Drive for Prime Minister John Diefenbaker, where she even served tea to President Kennedy. Each morning, as she brought Mr. Diefenbaker his tea, he would hand her the newspaper and ask her to read aloud. She was in Canada now, he told her, and learning English was important, and learn she did. She married my uncle John, raised a family and together they built a successful pest control business. When they were not working, they would hitch up their little tent trailer and explore the beautiful country they had made their home. It was a good life, filled with hard work, adventure and love, but Alzheimer's has a terrible way of unravelling even the most beautiful stories.

My uncle cared for her at home until about five years ago, when her needs became more than he could manage alone. Today, at 92, he drives from Langley to Surrey every single day to sit beside his wife, make sure she is eating and see that she is being cared for. I remember him sending me a little video. There she was, happily sorting a tray of mismatched socks into pairs, only to mix them up and begin again. My uncle was so excited to show me how happy she was.

These days, she does not recognize the man who has loved her for a lifetime or the children they raised together, but sometimes, when the family sings old, familiar hymns, she quietly hums along. Every once in a while, the faintest glimmer of recognition sparkles in her eyes. How precious those moments are to a husband who has devoted his life to loving his wife. Imagine another scenario.

Imagine that, years ago, while my aunt was still the capable woman who had built the business, raised her children and travelled across Canada, she had written down a simple instruction, that if the day ever came when she no longer recognized her husband or children, she did not want to go on living. Perhaps she could not imagine there might still be happiness in a familiar song or contentment in sorting mismatched socks or love in the quiet presence of a husband she could no longer name. Imagine that day has come and someone must decide whether the time has come to act upon her words.

There is something deeply troubling about asking someone to predict years in advance what will make their life worth living. When we are healthy and independent, we imagine all things we could not possibly bear. We tell ourselves we could never live without our memories and our independence, but something remarkable happens when people actually live through circumstances they once feared. Researchers call it the disability paradox.

In a study of people with disabilities, more than half of those with moderate to serious disabilities described their quality of life as good or excellent. Lives that others might look upon with pity were lives the people living them still very much enjoyed. Researchers in the Netherlands studying advance euthanasia requests among people with Huntington's disease also found that people making those requests recognized that their wishes might change as their illness progressed. The person writing an advance request is imagining a future they have never lived, but the person living that future may have discovered reasons to treasure it. When the decision is irreversible, that difference matters.

I think about my aunt sitting contentedly with her mismatched socks and my uncle watching her, grateful for every smile. What if she had signed an advance request? Who would speak for the woman she is today? Who would notice that she was happy? Who would ask whether the suffering she once feared had actually become the suffering she was experiencing? Who would stop it if someone got that decision terribly wrong? When I turn to Bill C-41, I do not find the protections that would give me confidence that those questions have been answered. There is no requirement to tell a person their life is about to be ended or consult the family who knows them best, or have a dementia specialist examine them when that final decision is made. When the family disagrees, there is no independent court or tribunal required to review the decision before it proceeds.

Then, there is the question of intolerable suffering. How can we be certain someone is suffering intolerably when they can no longer tell us what they are feeling? Researchers have spent years developing ways to recognize pain in advanced dementia, yet there is no gold standard assessment tool. A grimace might mean pain. Agitation might mean infection or an unfamiliar environment. These are things we should be trying to understand and treat, yet Bill C-41 would ask practitioners to determine not simply whether someone is suffering, but whether someone is suffering intolerably. How can we ask someone who cannot tell us what they are feeling to bear the consequences of another person's judgment about whether their life is still worth living?

I want to take us now into an Ontario care home on a summer morning this past July. An 83-year-old grandmother named Brigitte Stegemann was lying in her bed. She was someone's mother and grandmother, and a woman whose family had loved her for a lifetime, but this was the morning she had scheduled to die. According to her granddaughter, just two days earlier, Brigitte had broken down in tears when she learned the date had been set. She said she had made a mistake, but now the day had arrived. Her granddaughter describes a nurse struggling to insert an IV, leaving blood on Brigitte's nightgown and bedding.

When the doctor arrived, Brigitte lay quietly with her eyes closed and her hands clasped tightly together, almost as though she was praying. Perhaps she was praying. Her family does not know. When the doctor asked whether they could proceed, Brigitte gave no answer. She did not open her eyes. She did not nod. She did not speak. Her granddaughter says she felt a wave of relief, believing the procedure would stop without confirmation of her grandmother's wishes, but it did not, and within minutes, Brigitte was gone.

This happened under existing MAID laws, before Parliament had even authorized this new expansion. A granddaughter is left wondering whether their grandmother's wishes were respected and whether the safeguards meant to protect her worked at all. Now, Parliament is being asked to allow advance requests to be carried out when someone cannot consent nor confirm that they still want to die. If we cannot be certain that consent is being properly respected under today's system, how can we be confident we will recognize a change of heart in someone who can no longer tell us what they want?

The government has chosen to call Bill C-41 the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. What a remarkable name for a bill that purports to protect one group of vulnerable Canadians while opening the door to an entirely new expansion for people who can no longer consent.

What troubles me most is what the government chose not to include. When I introduced Bill C-218 to protect Canadians suffering from mental illness, people asked why I had not included more mental health supports. I would have loved to, but as a private member, I was limited to what I could do in my bill. The government has no excuse. Instead of including the treatment, counselling and compassionate care vulnerable Canadians desperately need, the Liberals chose to attach an entirely different expansion of assisted dying. The only reason these two decisions are tied together is for political spite. The government could protect Canadians struggling with mental illness right now by splitting the bill and passing the mental illness exclusion today and then give Parliament the time to properly scrutinize the rest of the bill. With the looming March deadline, the Liberals have made the protection of one vulnerable group conditional on expanding assisted dying to another.

As I stand here today, I keep thinking about my uncle John. Tomorrow morning, at 92 years old, he will get into his car and make that familiar drive from Langley to Surrey. He will find his wife and sit beside the woman he has loved for a lifetime. Perhaps she will recognize him. More likely, she will not. Perhaps they will sing an old hymn and she will happily sort her little pile of mismatched socks. My uncle will treasure every minute, because while Alzheimer's has stolen so much from my aunt, it has not stolen her ability to experience happiness and it has not stolen my uncle's love for her. Who among us has the wisdom to decide that those moments no longer matter? The thief has already taken her memories. Let us be careful that the law does not take away her tomorrows.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:10 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, as I tried to allude to earlier, the discussions and debates on this issue have been around for decades, starting in the early nineties. It is good that we have personal opinions and we want to share those personal opinions.

Does the member have any sense of whether the constituents she represents reflect her opinion? Does she have any indication of what her constituents would have to say on this legislation?

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:10 p.m.

Conservative

Tamara Jansen Conservative Cloverdale—Langley City, BC

Mr. Speaker, the political gamesmanship here is absolutely shameful. The government knows full well that Parliament has to act before March 17 to prevent MAID from expanding to mental illness alone.

However, instead of introducing a straightforward bill to do exactly that, the Liberals have tied it to an entirely separate expansion of assisted dying. They are using an approaching deadline to pressure Parliament into accepting something it has not properly studied. They are holding the protection of one vulnerable group hostage against the expansion of MAID for another.

If the government genuinely wants to protect Canadians struggling with mental illness, there is a very simple solution: split the bill and pass that protection immediately.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:10 p.m.

Bloc

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

Mr. Speaker, I have a question for my colleague. The bill stipulates that the matter of how to administer advance requests falls under provincial legislation. Quebec has its own law.

I listened to the example she gave. What makes her think that the Quebec law would have done to her aunt what she claims?

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:10 p.m.

Conservative

Tamara Jansen Conservative Cloverdale—Langley City, BC

Mr. Speaker, the translation was a bit cut off, so I am not totally sure I understood his question.

The challenge, as my other colleague spoke about, is we are going to have a patchwork of law. Every province can have its own bill. People will be able to travel from province to province. It is an absolute dog's breakfast. We need to say no to this bill.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:10 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her excellent speech tonight. My friend across the way pointed out that this debate has been going on for a very long time. He said since the 1990s. I would say versions of this debate have been going on since the dawn of time, actually.

It is notable that in 10 years, and through multiple phases of expansion, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau chose not to bring in advance directives. There were people in this House and elsewhere pushing for it at the time, but there were also grave concerns about how advance directives would lead to somebody in the future choosing to kill someone based on a document they signed in the past that may be ambiguous, may not be clear, or may not relate to their present lived experience or present preferences. Justin Trudeau thought that was a bridge too far.

Now we have a Prime Minister who actually wants to go further in the expansion than Justin Trudeau did. Further, he is trying to deviously tie it to another issue. The core point on advance directives is this was considered for 10 years by a previous Liberal government, and Justin Trudeau was not exactly a moderate on these issues. It was too far, yet the Prime Minister has chosen to go even further.

Why is that?

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:15 p.m.

Conservative

Tamara Jansen Conservative Cloverdale—Langley City, BC

Mr. Speaker, let us talk about the government's record here. Bill C-218 would have permanently prevented MAID from expanding to people whose sole underlying condition is mental illness. The Liberals voted it down on October 7. Twenty days later, they introduced their own legislation containing the same protection, but attached an entirely different expansion of MAID.

The parliamentary committee had already recommended the permanent exclusion in June. The Liberals cannot pretend this is some new sudden revelation that requires an entirely new legislative package. They had the evidence. They had the recommendation. They had the bill before them. We could have addressed all the issues. They chose to defeat it and now they want to dictate the terms of protecting the very people they refused to protect three weeks ago.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:15 p.m.

Bloc

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

Mr. Speaker, in this debate, which can get quite emotional, I am going to try to live up to my riding's name, and I will remain calm.

The bill before us today is really two bills in one. The government proposed that the vote at second reading be split. In fact, I expected the Conservatives to support that proposal, but that does not appear to be the case. Later, at third reading, we can discuss whether it is appropriate to split the vote or even split the bill. However, for now, it seems to me that it would have been wise for everyone to agree to hold separate votes at second reading. The reason is that mental illness raises a distinct set of issues, while advance requests raise a different set of issues altogether. In my opinion, there should have been two separate bills.

As I have said many times, when it comes to a human being determining the conditions of their end of life and determining what they consider to be the threshold of what is tolerable in this process, the law recognizes the principle of self-determination. The Baudouin ruling, which is an interpretation of the Carter decision, makes it clear that, in matters relating to mental illness, a blanket prohibition is discriminatory. What bothers me a great deal today is that, from the very first Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying, the question was not whether we should move forward on the issue of mental illness. On the contrary, we said that we would wait and see whether the network, the providers and the system were capable of proceeding safely. That was the issue. It was not about whether we should move forward with it or not. Why were we so convinced of that as soon as we saw the first report from the late Marc Garneau, who was the chair of the committee? It was precisely because a blanket prohibition is discriminatory in nature.

I heard all sorts of things about mental illness: astonishing intellectual shortcuts, horror stories and anecdotes. People are basing their positions on absolutely nothing. If what some are describing is actually happening today in the context of mental illness, that is, if people are being encouraged under the current law to choose medical assistance in dying, or if it is being suggested to people with mental illness, that is a criminal offence. It is that simple. One calls the police and reports it, because the Criminal Code already governs such situations. When witnesses come before committee and tell us anecdotal stories of that nature, I ask them whether they reported the matter to the police, because those cases are already covered by the Criminal Code.

However, if we have legislation that sets out all the safeguards needed to ensure that things are done properly, that is quite a different matter. I heard all sorts of claims. The point, here, is not to suddenly allow a suicidal or depressed minor access to MAID. Such a person would not even be assessed for that purpose. Simply making a request does not make someone eligible. Some witnesses came and told us that if the bill had been passed, they would not have been there, in front of us. What basis do these people have for making such claims, given that the assessment process is precise and rigorous?

The unfortunate thing about this debate is that very few lawmakers here have carefully read the experts' report laying out all of the safeguards that would be needed to safely provide medical assistance in dying for people with mental disorders.

Some will tell me that psychiatrists cannot assess irremediability. Fine, but they assess people's decision-making capacity every day. There are people with mental disorders who also have cancer, and their capacity to consent, or not consent, to MAID based on their cancer can be assessed. Everyone is capable of doing that. Psychiatrists do this regularly, but if a mental disorder is the sole condition, suddenly opponents say they cannot do that. They say that psychiatrists cannot accurately determine a prognosis or a diagnosis and that this justifies a blanket prohibition for all individuals who are unresponsive to all the available treatments for their mental disorder. These are individuals who have never refused a treatment that could improve their condition and who, after several decades, sometimes 25 or 30 years, have come to the conclusion that they would like to end their lives with dignity, following a proper assessment, and certainly not when they are in distress or experiencing a suicidal crisis.

A suicidal crisis is actually sometimes part of the expression of a mental illness or disorder. The fact remains that irremediability is a chronic condition established over time. That is a far cry from the scenario of a young man suffering from a broken heart who decides to put up his hand and say that he wants MAID. If the law were to pass, what would happen? By raising his hand, he would be raising a red flag, and instead of attempting suicide, thinking he is entitled to access MAID, he could be treated. He could be taken care of. However, right now, with a blanket prohibition, there is no preventive aspect in terms of there being a law to deal with the issue of mental disorders. As I said, this is unconstitutional.

Going back to my first point, the government had five years, since the first Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying, to ask the Supreme Court for an opinion. The government could have clarified whether the blanket prohibition imposed in the Carter decision unconstitutionally infringes on the rights of patients with a mental disorder and is therefore unconstitutional discrimination. However, it did not do that. It did not summon the courage to do so, and right now, if we decide to uphold the indefinite exclusion, it means there will be no more debate on this matter here. No future government would reopen the debate on this.

What is happening? The burden is being placed on vulnerable patients. The government says it wants to protect vulnerable patients, yet there is a contradiction there. The government says that these patients are vulnerable and lack the capacity to make decisions about their own end of life in the circumstances I have described, even after a comprehensive and rigorous assessment. However, the government expects them to navigate the legal system and take their case all the way to the Supreme Court to defend their rights. To me, that shows disregard for human dignity. To me, that shows cowardice, parliamentary cowardice. It is cowardice because Parliament has never been proactive throughout this entire debate on MAID. Now, suddenly, when it comes to mental illness and advance requests, Parliament has decided to be proactive. I will come back to that, but colleagues can surely understand why I find this somewhat surprising.

All the regulatory bodies told us that they were ready. The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying refused to hear from the Canadian Psychiatric Association, which had established standards of practice. The government paid a committee to set standards of practice. All the practitioners told us that everyone was ready to move forward. In the end, the answer is no because there are some who oppose all forms of medical assistance in dying and who will seize on any anecdote to say that it will become a horror show, that it will be awful, that it will cause harm, and that the system is unable to deliver proper care.

There are indeed mental health challenges. However, when someone has been dealing with a mental disorder for 30 years, in keeping with the definition, I do not want to hear anyone claim that the system is incapable of treating that person and that this is why we have to wait for the system to be able to treat or cure them, especially when some psychiatrists say that no cure is even possible. People are effectively being told to continue suffering within reason. If this constitutes discrimination, does the first clause save the blanket prohibition? Absolutely not. What is really happening is that people are being told to continue suffering until a treatment is found that will finally cure them. These people are being told to be patient, after a lifetime of stigma and discrimination.

Only a small minority of people are likely to request MAID, and the assessment would ensure that they meet the criteria. On top of that, there was an additional safeguard in place for people with mental disorders. Prospective monitoring was advised. During the assessment, when it was time to intervene, a panel would be asked to review the process to see whether it had been properly implemented, which is not currently the case for other scenarios involving MAID. The bill has continued to move forward with regard to advance requests. This was a key recommendation of the first special joint committee. We agreed that while we should delay the decision to see whether the necessary provisions for mental disorders could eventually be implemented in practice, there were no reservations about advance requests five years ago.

It took the government five years to show some courage and do what had been proposed. If it felt that advance requests were a more delicate process, given that the person is assessed when they are incapacitated, all it had to do was set up an additional safeguard, an additional requirement. It was told that since the provinces are responsible for health care, it should require them to develop a “how to” procedure so that this is done by the book, and, that way, debates will take place in each provincial legislature. This could even become an election issue. If, for example, a province decides not to go ahead at all, someone will surely go to the Supreme Court and have the ban struck down or change the government so that the legislature passes a law.

Quebec has implemented a process based on a very interesting approach. First of all, a person is not told that MAID is an option before first undergoing an evaluation. An advance request is made based on a diagnosis, and once care begins following that diagnosis, the patient is given an explanation of the stages of the disease's progression. At some point during these stages, when the person is of sound mind, they sit down with the care team and establish the criteria that correspond to their personal threshold of what is tolerable.

A person might say that they would like to receive MAID when they become doubly incontinent, when they start playing with their own feces, when they resist being fed, when they are no longer able to recognize their own family or even interact with other human beings. There is no automatic threshold. In fact, at a certain point in the progression of the illness, in other words, when the patient has reached a certain level of incapacity, a third person is responsible for informing the care team that they believe the patient should be evaluated. The care team will evaluate the patient and may inform the third party that the patient in question has not yet reached that stage. The process would then continue.

This process is based on the clinical judgment of physicians or other professionals. The Quebec law states that, at the time medical assistance in dying is administered, the person must be “incapable of giving consent to care due to their illness”, they must be “exhibiting, on a recurring basis, the clinical manifestations related to their illness” and they must be in a medical state “of advanced, irreversible decline in capability...that gives a competent professional cause to believe, based on the information at their disposal and according to their clinical judgment, that the patient is experiencing enduring and unbearable physical or psychological suffering that cannot be relieved under conditions considered tolerable.” There is no mention of reasonable means.

My colleague, who was a social worker, told me about a lady who had what is known as “quiet dementia” or “happy dementia”. Incidentally, this is a transitional phase that leads the person towards the end of their life. It is a transitory state. It is not permanent. People with Alzheimer's often die from a secondary condition, because they are no longer mobile, because they are bedridden or because they are confined to a wheelchair. That is why the concept of what is considered tolerable is important. However, in the government's bill, instead of trusting provincial legislatures, it proposes a whole bunch of criteria and the aim is to set aside the criteria that the individual may have put in place, on the pretext that it would lead to MAID being granted in cases of happy dementia.

Let us imagine a woman with an illness who reaches a point where she is no longer aware of her actions and is no longer in her right mind. Let us imagine that she repeatedly undresses in public and smiles while throwing herself at men. She appears happy. Who was this woman? It is very important to understand that someone who reaches that stage of the disease and that stage of cognitive decline is not the same person anymore. This woman was a nun who had spent her entire life observing the strictest standards of modesty. Does anyone think that if this woman had set out her wishes in advance, she would have put up with this situation simply because she seems relatively bothered and even seems happy? The Supreme Court has been very clear. The whole question of dementia, whether or not the person appears happy, should be discussed at the formal meeting where the patient establishes their personal criteria.

A person could very well say at that meeting that if they reach that stage and wish to continue living in that condition, they should be allowed to do so.

I will end here. No one would be forced to make an advance request if they have a degenerative disease such as Alzheimer's or dementia. The Conservatives always make it seem as though it would be mandatory for everyone. It is not a requirement, but merely an option.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 4th, 2026 / 7:35 p.m.

Liberal

Élisabeth Brière Liberal Sherbrooke, QC

Madam Speaker, I really want to thank our colleague from Montcalm, who has championed this issue and advanced it with great rigour. He has done a lot of work. I had the great pleasure of serving on the special committee, and I really want to point out how passionate the member is about this subject. We heard it in his speech.

Advance requests are already a big step forward. We hear about the need for advance requests in our communities, although our Conservative colleague was unable to tell us what she was hearing from her constituents on the matter. I can speak to this from my own experience. I worked as a notary for nearly 30 years at a time when MAID did not exist, and people would ask me to include something about it in their living will. They said that, if MAID ever became legal, then they wanted to have something in writing.

Since this bill directly addresses a need that has been expressed by our loved ones, our seniors and people who are suffering, as our colleague so rightly pointed out, why is the Bloc Québécois opposed to Bill C-41 as it now stands? Does the Bloc not believe that it would be a good idea to pass this step forward and continue the debate on certain aspects of the bill?