Evidence of meeting #30 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was cbsa.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Toxopeus  Director General, Commercial Programs Directorate, Canada Border Services Agency
Anson  Director General, Intelligence and Investigations, Canada Border Services Agency
Hamilton  President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority
Viau  General Director, Société du Port de Valleyfield

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Intelligence and Investigations, Canada Border Services Agency

Daniel Anson

We'll have to look at how many containers were specifically examined. We do have over 52,000 seizures of illicit goods within the past year. For the number of containers, we'd have to verify the number that have been examined.

Again, part of the challenge is that there are dockside examinations, ones where they'll open up the end of a marine container, a sea container, and then there's LSI, which is another form of examination. There are also marine container examination facilities, where it will go through a full unloading, fumigation and examination, and it will also be examined on pallet scanners, etc.

There are a little over 36,000 total examinations, and that would include all the different categories across all five different ports.

Jacques Ramsay Liberal La Prairie—Atateken, QC

Would you say that the examinations we do are essentially the same as what they're doing at the U.S. ports of entry? Is it in the same order?

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Intelligence and Investigations, Canada Border Services Agency

Daniel Anson

In the same order...?

Jacques Ramsay Liberal La Prairie—Atateken, QC

The same order of magnitude. Sorry.

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Intelligence and Investigations, Canada Border Services Agency

Daniel Anson

Roughly speaking, yes, we generally have similar processes. There is compatibility in corresponding types of examination equipment and detection technology. We learn from each other, in the U.S. and Canada. We both have national targeting centres, frontline officers, commercial districts and traveller streams. We learn how to target and share lessons learned and become more efficient together.

How the U.S. does its targeting and then its enforcement examinations is something that is roughly the same model, I would say. There are variances, certainly, based on the size, the volume and the variety of different types of ports of entry that the U.S. entertains, as well as the courier facilities, but specific to the marine commercial domain, a lot of the processes are somewhat similar. Also, how we do intelligence targeting, enforcement and examinations again does roughly correspond.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Sorry to interrupt. Our time is up for this first hour.

Thank you, Mr. Anson and Ms. Toxopeus, for taking the time and effort to keep us informed. We wish you a good evening.

We'll suspend the meeting for a few moments.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you for returning for this second hour.

We'll continue this meeting with new witnesses. We're joined by Ian Hamilton, president and chief executive officer of the Hamilton‑Oshawa Port Authority, and Isabelle Viau, general director of the Société du Port de Valleyfield.

Welcome. You each have five minutes for your remarks.

Mr. Hamilton, you may begin.

Ian Hamilton President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority

Thank you very much.

Chair and members of the committee, thanks for the opportunity to appear today. My name is Ian Hamilton. I'm the president and CEO of the Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority: HOPA Ports.

We appreciate the committee’s focus on Canada’s transportation system and supply chain resilience, issues that are central to our mandate and to Canada’s economic competitiveness.

HOPA Ports represents the largest port network on the Canadian Great Lakes, with operations in Hamilton, Oshawa and Niagara. We cover more than 1,400 acres and carry more than 11 million metric tons of cargo, which represents about $4 billion in value. Each year, we serve as a catalyst to economic growth, job creation and trade-enabling infrastructure in communities across Ontario. The cargo we carry through our ports supports about 40,000 jobs in the province and in the rest of Canada.

Ports are vital economic engines for Canada. They integrate marine, rail and trucking networks and connect Canadian producers to domestic and global markets. We are pleased to see advertisements running quite regularly celebrating the St. Lawrence Seaway as a nation-building project. It truly was. That same system holds the key to what Canada needs to accomplish now: growing our trade, being our own best customer, getting Canadian goods to overseas markets more efficiently and diversifying our trading partners.

Today, this corridor has significant unused capacity, carrying roughly half of what it is capable of moving. One of the most viable opportunities to do this is to expand the Great Lakes' carrying into containerization and containers. That is why we were pleased to see budget 2025 specifically recognize Hamilton as a location for expanded container activity on the Great Lakes and to see Great Lakes ports identified as potential first ports of arrival.

Today, CBSA clears marine containers at only five Canadian ports. No Great Lakes port in Ontario or Canada has full container clearance capacity. This prevents direct overseas container imports into Canada's largest population and industrial regions and limits the role that Great Lakes ports can play in international trade.

Expanding CBSA services in the Great Lakes could deliver both economic and security benefits. Southern Ontario is Canada's population and industrial heartland. Clearing containers closer to their origins and destinations reduces congestion, shortens dwell times and improves reliability. It also strengthens resilience. We have all seen labour and rail disruptions at major gateways, particularly Montreal, create delays of up to 10 days. In some cases, containers sit at Canadian ports longer than they are at sea. This is bad for business, bad for the Canadian brand and bad for us as a trading nation. Our reliance on a small number of designated clearance ports creates bottlenecks and systemic supply chain vulnerabilities. A more distributed clearance network would reduce risk and allow container traffic to be rerouted during disruptions, disasters or security incidents, strengthening Canada's economic sovereignty.

From a security perspective, container movements through the Great Lakes benefit from a shorter, more controlled inland supply chain. Reduced congestion at inland ports allows for more deliberate and effective inspections than are sometimes possible at overburdened coastal gateways. HOPA already maintains strong security governance. We coordinate closely with tenants and maintain active working relationships with municipal, provincial and federal law enforcement. We collaborate regularly with Transport Canada, the Canadian Coast Guard and CBSA. Our harbourmaster, Vicki Gruber, also chairs the national port security committees through the Association of Canadian Port Authorities.

Looking forward, expanded CBSA services can be paired with practical risk-based measures to further strengthen security. You heard from Cathy earlier—it will be announced on Wednesday—that Canada will get an AR service to allow us to bring in uncleared containers. That's a big step forward in this journey. This includes formalized information sharing that recognizes ports as trusted partners and secure-by-design infrastructure for new and expanded container yards. In specific circumstances, CBSA could also authorize designated port security officers to inspect containers in coordination with law enforcement, and that's discussing a potential for delegated authority to increase the overall productivity and capacity of CBSA.

If Canada is serious about increasing trade and diversifying supply chains, we need to think differently about how we plan infrastructure. Traditionally, we have looked backwards, measuring historical demand and responding incrementally. That approach will not get us to where we want and need to go. To achieve our trade expansion goals, our infrastructure must be built for future demand. We need to skate to where the puck is going.

Both Transport Canada and Global Affairs Canada have identified that if we want to shift our trade diversification from where it sits today, which is at 72% of exports going to the United States, to the goal of 55%, we're short by about 50% in terms of the capacity we need at our container ports to deal with that demand.

Strategic infrastructure investment is essential to building prosperous waterfronts and unlocking trade opportunities. Inland container clearance improves export competitiveness, reduces highway congestion, lowers emissions and enhances resilience during supply chain disruptions. With expanded CBSA support, tailored service models and strategic investment, Canada can unlock the full economic and security potential of the Great Lakes marine system.

The Great Lakes-St. Lawrence Seaway is not just a nation-building project of our past; it remains a cornerstone of Canada's prosperous future.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Mr. Hamilton.

Ms. Viau, you have the floor for five minutes.

Isabelle Viau General Director, Société du Port de Valleyfield

Mr. Chair, committee members, thank you for the opportunity to contribute to this study.

The Port of Valleyfield is a municipal port located in the heart of Valleyfield's main industrial park and in a strategic logistical corridor connecting Quebec, Ontario and the United States. The port authority manages, maintains and develops the infrastructure, while three specialized operators carry out its operations: Valleytank, McAsphalt and Desgagnés Logistik Valport.

The Port of Valleyfield is a multi-purpose port specializing in solid and liquid bulk, general cargo and special projects. For decades, it has played a strategic role in the Arctic supply chain by consolidating cargo for northern communities and mining projects.

In 2015, the Port of Valleyfield began receiving containers from Europe, for which customs clearance was provided on request by the Canada Border Services Agency. In 2023, following a change of operator at the port and a request for a licence transfer, the agency reassessed its service offer and, without notice, put an end to customs clearance in Valleyfield.

This decision was made without consideration for the supply chains in place, without action to ensure continuity of service, without consideration of the impacts on stakeholders and the economy, forcing customers to redirect to other terminals. At the time service was ended, the port was handling approximately 1,000 containers a year in a growing market. However, these volumes reflect only a portion of the impacts.

In Valleyfield, ships frequently carry mixed cargo, meaning containers and general cargo. The port's inability to process these containers forces ships to unload their entire cargo at other ports, resulting in a direct loss of economic activity for our region, increased supply chain inefficiency, increased costs, delays and increased pressure on ground infrastructure and a loss of opportunity for the port.

In some cases, customers have to use two separate ships, one that stops in Valleyfield for main freighter transportation, and a second carrying only one or two containers of parts needed for project assembly, which stops at another port. This results in a significant level of inefficiency for the entire supply chain.

Over the past five years, many businesses have set up close to the Port of Valleyfield, banking on the presence of this strategic infrastructure and the possibility of using it for their current or future logistical needs, particularly for container imports. The agency's decision undermines this value proposition as well as the port's attractiveness.

The reasons cited by the agency have evolved over time, without any solutions tailored to our reality. Furthermore, all of the options we proposed, including the implementation of a pilot project or a partnership with the Montreal Port Authority, were rejected.

Our request was simple. We were not asking for exceptional treatment or to transform the Port of Valleyfield into a large container port. We were just asking that the agency restore the container clearance service in a proactive, agile, innovative and adapted approach to our reality of approximately 1,000 containers a year, a service that we have benefited from for several years and that has proven its worth.

The Société du Port de Valleyfield remains fully committed to a collaborative approach aimed at finding a solution that meets the government's security needs while preserving the port's business model and competitiveness. We are convinced that these imperatives can be reconciled by focusing on solutions aligned with the reality of ports, rather than the agency imposing a one-size-fits-all model that hinders their development.

Thank you for your attention.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you very much, Ms. Viau.

We now go to the members for questions.

Ms. Kirkland, you have the floor for six minutes.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Madame Viau and Mr. Hamilton, for being here. I think you can probably appreciate that my questions will be directed to Mr. Hamilton, of course, since he is here with us from the Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority.

Mr. Hamilton, you and I have met a couple of times. We've had brief conversations, but that was before I became a member of Parliament. It's nice to be able to have these conversations here, at this committee. I really appreciated your introduction. You touched on a few things that I'm going to touch on here as well.

The port of Oshawa is a critical gateway for jobs, manufacturing and trade in the entire Durham region. I've had the privilege of touring the port of Oshawa and meeting the employees there. Can you walk us through just how important the Oshawa port is to the local economy and the supply chains?

4:50 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority

Ian Hamilton

As it stands today, Oshawa deals in a few key bulk commodities. We've invested about $35 million into the development of agricultural facilities for the export of Durham region farmers' produce.

Oshawa is one of the unfortunate communities that have been hit particularly hard by the trade tariffs, particularly around the automotive industry. We believe that, going forward, Oshawa's strategy around the development of defence, moving into those areas and taking advantage of the educational institutions there, as well as the manufacturing capacity and skilled workforce, gives it the opportunity to grow into new markets. Those markets won't necessarily be moved by bulk or break-bulk ships; they'll be moved much more in containers.

On the backbone, there's an LCBO distribution facility in Oshawa, which I think would benefit a great deal, from a sustainability side, from containers coming directly into the port of Oshawa, but also from the development of new export opportunities and bringing Oshawa products to international markets. It would reduce the complexity and the cost of the supply chains if you were able to load containers directly in Oshawa and move them out.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

That would be absolutely fantastic.

In terms of operational challenges, can you describe how the limited, inconsistent or completely unavailable CBSA presence can impact the port of Oshawa's ability to move goods efficiently?

March 26th, 2026 / 4:50 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority

Ian Hamilton

The lack of a CBSA-bonded licence or customs licence.... It's impossible to move forward without it, but that's not the only challenge. We also need to make sure that we bring in the right marine infrastructure and that we have the right model for loading and unloading containers, just so that we can create a sustainable, cost-effective model. CBSA is the biggest roadblock. Nothing moves without a CBSA-bonded facility, but that's not a silver bullet where as soon as that's done, everything is just going to start to flow. We have lots of other work.

We're delighted to see the trade diversification corridors fund in place now, and some potential for investment that will help us build that infrastructure.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Do you think that if we had the CBSA presence there, it would be the beginning, that it would open the door completely for all those other things that you suggested we need to grow and build there?

4:50 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority

Ian Hamilton

Yes. We're sure of that.

We also have a very good relationship with the LCBO. They have a big commitment toward sustainability. They'd very much like to experiment with bringing containers directly into Oshawa, if we can find the right operational model. However, without CBSA, it all makes it a challenge.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Are there any instances that you have seen of lack of coordination? Has a lack of coordination among CBSA, HOPA and maybe even the Durham Regional Police Service led to any delays, confusion or significant errors at the port of Oshawa? Are you aware of any?

4:50 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority

Ian Hamilton

No.

Again, we deal with bulk and break-bulk commodities. We're aware of no material problems that have occurred as a result of a lack of coordination, but recognizing there is no.... CBSA there can work on clearance of bulk and break-bulk goods, but it cannot work on clearance of containers.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Mr. Hamilton, we've heard from the president of the Customs and Immigration Union. He talked about how scanning equipment is important—and it is—but of course it can't replace trained officers on the ground, so that presence would be wonderful. From your perspective at the port of Oshawa, how critical is that human element, both in security and in keeping that trade moving—if in security at all, and if not, please let me know. Is there anything the federal government can do or needs to do to provide that, or are they falling short? What can they do?

4:55 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority

Ian Hamilton

The human element is critically important. Right now, based on how the cargo moves, I believe the CBSA is a relatively siloed organization in terms of, “I can clear containers”; “I can clear air cargo”; “I can clear something else.” Having the approach of how to increase the productivity of CBSA by cross-training officers.... I talked a bit in my presentation about how I think there are some opportunities to explore delegated authority. How can we use existing manpower?

As I mentioned, Vicki Gruber, our harbourmaster, has a team of about 12 people. How can we start to use these qualified people to support the CBSA—not replace it—to increase its productivity?

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Have you made requests of the federal government to have the CBSA present at the Oshawa port?

4:55 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Hamilton-Oshawa Port Authority

Ian Hamilton

We haven't made specific requests for containers. We made one in Hamilton. We backed away from our request around marine and focused on rail, which, again, as I mentioned, will be announced on April 1. We're quite delighted.

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Okay.

How much time do I have left?

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

None.