Evidence of meeting #50 for Science and Research in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was public.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Nemer  Chief Science Advisor of Canada, Office of the Chief Science Advisor of Canada
Les Jacobs  Professor, Ontario Tech University, As an Individual
McCuaig-Johnston  Senior Fellow, Institute for Science, Society and Policy, University of Ottawa, As an Individual
Sarra-Bournet  Associate Vice-President of Infrastructure Development and Quantum Strategy, Université de Sherbrooke

4:10 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

My questions are for Ms. McCuaig-Johnston.

In the last federal budget, the Liberal government announced $1.7 billion in taxpayer money to recruit foreign researchers to come to Canada, including in AI, quantum computing, biotechnology and defence technologies. You previously served as executive VP of NSERC, so you understand how federal research funding is awarded.

Given that Canadian citizenship is not required for these foreign researcher recruits, how confident are you that the safeguards can identify applicants concealing foreign state funding, obligations or affiliations before they receive federal money and access to Canadian research facilities?

4:10 p.m.

Senior Fellow, Institute for Science, Society and Policy, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Margaret McCuaig-Johnston

If I'm not mistaken, that initiative is primarily focused on the U.S. because there are many researchers there who are interested in coming to Canada now, for various reasons. I'm not particularly concerned about trying to suss out their motivations. I think, as Dr. Nemer says, it's important that we not add additional layers but that instead there be sound practices and management of risks all along the process of identifying people.

I know that the system that's been put in place by the tri-agencies is comprehensive now, and I'm quite comfortable. In fact, as I've said before, I think it's a gold standard for the world.

Where I think we need to do some work is on the workarounds that some professors have chosen in certain sensitive technology areas, where they set up a company just off-site from the university and work there.

4:15 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

If those checks fail, could Canadian research infrastructure and Canadian taxpayers end up financing research that serves a foreign government's strategic interests by using our grants, our laboratories or our equipment?

4:15 p.m.

Senior Fellow, Institute for Science, Society and Policy, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Margaret McCuaig-Johnston

If the researcher returns to their original country, potentially, but I think the objective there is to try to get them to stay in Canada if we can. This is a very attractive program, and I think people in the U.S. are looking at it very seriously.

4:15 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

Based on your experience at NSERC, what typically needs to be verified before the funding is granted as it relates to interference? I want to make sure the government isn't inadvertently funding foreign researchers or even Canadian researchers who are tied to foreign actors or affiliated with a foreign government's interests.

4:15 p.m.

Senior Fellow, Institute for Science, Society and Policy, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Margaret McCuaig-Johnston

That's an interesting question.

Up until now, my understanding has been that, in the grant process, the screening of the grants is where you get the checks and balances of risk, whereas what the member of the committee, MP Ho, is identifying is incoming scholars and whether they have associations with DARPA or other agencies. Certainly, if they had any such connections in China, I would be raising big red flags all over the place, so to speak.

I think that's something with this program that they would want to take a special look at.

4:15 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

There is a possibility that researchers.... Let's say they're not coming from the United States. They're coming from countries that may be hostile to Canada and may get access to this funding with the current procedures we have in place.

4:15 p.m.

Senior Fellow, Institute for Science, Society and Policy, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Margaret McCuaig-Johnston

I think the screening process that the granting councils use now is pretty adept at looking for—China is the one that I know—affiliations with military universities and research institutes. Also, I think that can certainly be applied in this case in the screening of any professors from China who might come under such a program.

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

Thank you.

We will now proceed to MP Rana for five minutes.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you to all the witnesses for your valuable time.

Dr. Jacobs, not every institution has the same capacity to manage research security. This month, the government announced nearly $25 million to the research support fund for research security at 51 institutions.

Where does that kind of support make the biggest difference for Ontario Tech University?

Dr. Les Jacobs

There's been a sea change that has happened in Canadian universities. Ontario Tech has been among the smaller universities at the leading edge of research security. To address the nuts-and-bolts question about how this works, I'll say that in our particular case we have two full-time staff who work for me and review virtually all of our research programs—certainly all of our funded research programs—against standards. Dr. Nemer would know that this is quite new. Whenever we have research partners proposed, a standard thing I do is send their files to our research security team so that they can do those kinds of reviews.

It is an underfunded mandate in the sense that you can't really have a robust research enterprise without this now. I would issue a bit of caution. In the U.S., research security at universities is highly tied to the national identity of researchers. Part of the reason Canada is a gold standard is that we haven't gone down that path. I would be cautious about thinking that the birthplace or origin of a particular researcher is a reason to treat them as more suspect. That's wearing my human rights hat.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

Thank you.

On the NATO DIANA test centres, our allies' work in innovation is being done on the same campuses as regular academic research. From what you have seen, how does a university keep that work properly protected without walling it off from the rest of the research community?

Dr. Les Jacobs

In our particular case, we have a couple of research facilities, including a huge research facility that does a lot of defence work. It is a highly secure facility that controls entrance access. People enter it and sign NDAs, all of those kinds of measures, which are quite new. The central point is that it actually involves an investment, and it's a bit of a pay-to-play situation.

We understand that if we are working closely with leading defence industry partners, then having a high level of security is important. Indeed, part of the initiative behind the first round of DISHs was to really bring facilities like ours up to secret standards.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

What does the security clearance process entail for researchers and personnel at the DIANA test centre?

Dr. Les Jacobs

That's a little bit trickier. If they're among the PIs or collaborators on the funded projects, they will go through the security review. All of our industry partners will go through that kind of review. That tends to be how it operates in practice.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

What measures has Ontario Tech implemented to ensure research security?

Dr. Les Jacobs

First and foremost is complying with the tri-council requirements, which we apply not just to the tri-council research but also to all of our research activity. Keep in mind that a significant amount of research activity in Canadian universities is now tied directly to industry-funded research as opposed to tri-council research.

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

Thank you. The time is up for MP Rana.

We will proceed to MP Blanchette-Joncas for two and a half minutes.

Please go ahead.

Maxime Blanchette-Joncas Bloc Rimouski-Neigette—Mitis—Matapédia—Les Basques, QC

Ms. Nemer, I want to come back to a very important current issue: Bill C‑31, which, among other things, would eliminate the re-evaluation of pesticides. Normally, every 15 years, Health Canada conducts an independent scientific review to determine whether any pesticides have become hazardous and should be prohibited or completely banned. This follows Bill C‑30, which, among other things, allows for the reintroduction of certain pesticides for food security or economic reasons.

I would like to know if you were consulted about these legislative changes.

4:25 p.m.

Chief Science Advisor of Canada, Office of the Chief Science Advisor of Canada

Mona Nemer

No, I wasn't consulted, because this is really a matter for Environment and Climate Change Canada and Health Canada. You know, there are advisers in those departments. Not every issue comes across my desk. However, I believe it's very important to continue using science and scientific data to make changes, whether that means banning things that are currently allowed or reintroducing things that were allowed before.

Maxime Blanchette-Joncas Bloc Rimouski-Neigette—Mitis—Matapédia—Les Basques, QC

There does seem to be some public opposition, however. A recent poll conducted for Équiterre found that 69% of Quebeckers oppose a measure to reintroduce pesticides that were banned because they were deemed hazardous.

As you are no doubt aware, the federal government wants to build closer ties with the European Union. However, Canada currently uses 121 pesticides that are banned in the European Union. From a scientific standpoint, I'm trying to benefit from your expertise. How can we build closer ties with them? We want to increase trade with them, but they won't even accept the agricultural products we produce here because we don't meet their standards, especially when it comes to the production of certain foods.

4:25 p.m.

Chief Science Advisor of Canada, Office of the Chief Science Advisor of Canada

Mona Nemer

I'm aware that some pesticides are banned there. In fact, some food additives that we use are banned there. I think we might need to ask ourselves: Why is it not acceptable there, but is it acceptable here?

I would like to say a few words about agriculture and food security. We might think that we don't have to change and that this is the only way to continue producing the same amounts of food, but this is where, once again, research, science, and technology are truly remarkable, especially in agriculture. There are ways to practise precision agriculture and know exactly how to manage things without having to use chemicals, even if they're harmless. Therefore—

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

Thank you. The time is up.

We will now proceed to MP Cody for five minutes.

Please, go ahead, MP Cody.

Connie Cody Conservative Cambridge, ON

Thank you.

Through you, Chair, I want to thank the witnesses for coming today.

I'd like to direct my first question to Dr. Nemer.

Thank you for coming. You told the committee you consulted with the government on its national security strategy. Specifically, who did you consult with?

4:25 p.m.

Chief Science Advisor of Canada, Office of the Chief Science Advisor of Canada

Mona Nemer

I've been consulted extensively for, I would say, the past at least two years, if not more, on health security, biosecurity. These have been conversations with the Minister of ISED, with the Minister of Health, with the Office of the Prime Minister and with senior public servants as well. There are many different decision-makers in the apparatus.