House of Commons Hansard #165 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was medical.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Youth Criminal Justice Act Third reading of Bill C-231. The bill amends the Youth Criminal Justice Act to expand opportunities for young people with problematic substance use to access treatment during police referrals, court proceedings, sentencing and supervision, supporting rehabilitation and reintegration. Members across parties support the measure, while noting that effective implementation depends on timely access to treatment services. The House adds the alternate title “For the Friends of David Law” and passes the bill. 5800 words, 40 minutes.

Bill C-41—Time Allocation Motion Members debate the government’s time-allocation motion on Bill C-41, which would address MAID for cases where mental illness is the sole condition and permit advance requests. Conservatives, Bloc and Green members call for fuller scrutiny and question safeguards, including consent at the time of administration. Justice Minister Sean Fraser argues prior studies support moving ahead to recognize patients’ agency and reduce suffering. 5200 words, 30 minutes.

Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act Second reading of Bill C-41. The bill would permanently exclude mental illness as the sole basis for MAID, establish advance requests for people with qualifying conditions who may later lose decision-making capacity, and improve reporting. Supporters emphasize autonomy and dignity, while critics question consent, safeguards and oversight, and argue the advance-request provisions need separate, fuller debate. The House also debates provincial roles and whether the bill’s consideration is being rushed. 35000 words, 4 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives criticize Liberal spending and borrowing, linking them to inflation and affordability as families struggle with food, housing and jobs. They object to funding for Brazil’s forests, question rising immigration levels, and accuse the government of misleading Stellantis workers over a plant sale. They also raise concerns about Telesat ethics and attacks on faith communities.
The Liberals promote budget 2026 as a plan for growth and affordability, highlighting expanded groceries and essentials benefits, worker and caregiver supports, and housing and homelessness investments. They defend their fiscal position, immigration policies and climate investments, while emphasizing efforts to protect Stellantis jobs and uphold ethics rules.
The Bloc condemns the Liberals’ climate record, citing COP criticism, the push to sell gas at COP and plans for Arctic oil drilling. It also challenges immigration targets, warning of inadequate capacity and threats to Quebec’s political weight.
The Greens warn Parks Canada cuts threaten ecosystem protection, migratory bird habitat, visitor safety and wildfire prevention in Gulf Islands National Park.
The NDP calls for better decorum in the House during Question Period.

Adjournment Debates

Canada Health Infoway governance Matt Strauss presses Health Minister to say whether she fired Canada Health Infoway CEO Michael Green, and asks who is conducting an audit of the organization. Wade Grant says an independent review and audit are under way, but does not answer either question directly.
Budget deficits and borrowing Jacob Mantle says Budget 2026 masks rising debt and borrowing behind declining deficit projections, and asks why the Liberals keep changing their fiscal targets. Wade Grant defends the budget, saying it maintains fiscal discipline, meets the government’s fiscal anchors and makes strategic investments. Mantle disputes the government’s accounting approach.
Pipeline cost-benefit analysis Elizabeth May presses Wade Grant for a cost-benefit analysis of the proposed Pacific link pipeline, arguing public funds should not support a project that increases emissions and undermines climate targets. Grant defends the government’s broader approach to clean energy, major projects, jobs and environmental protections. May reiterates that Canada is far off its Paris Agreement emissions commitments.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:30 p.m.

Bloc

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Madam Speaker, if tomorrow I am diagnosed with frontotemporal dementia, Alzheimer's, vascular dementia, or Korsakoff's syndrome, I will definitely draw up an advance request. I want to recognize my husband. I am a happy, cheerful, and lively person, and I do not want to end my life not recognizing the people I love and spent my life with. I do not want that.

I am grateful that we are able to hold a debate on this issue, and I respect everyone who does not share my opinion. I support the bill and hope that it can be improved and further clarified in committee.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:35 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker (Alexandra Mendès) Alexandra Mendes

It is my duty, pursuant to Standing Order 38, to inform the House that the questions to be raised tonight at the time of adjournment are as follows: the hon. member for Kitchener South—Hespeler, Health; the hon. member for York—Durham, The Economy; the hon. member for Saanich—Gulf Islands, Climate Change.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:35 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act, brought forward by the Liberals. MAID is an issue that people in my constituency of Lethbridge very much care about. I have certainly read many emails, had many conversations and engaged in many phone calls. I have heard from countless constituents who have serious concerns about what the Liberals are attempting here. This level of public concern is exactly why Parliament must carefully examine legislation of this magnitude. Unfortunately, however, earlier today the Liberals used their majority to shut down debate and move this bill forward at a quick pace.

When it comes to an issue literally of life and death, playing political games is extremely cold-hearted and altogether inappropriate. Canadians expect us to listen to experts. They expect us to examine the evidence and consider the consequences before making decisions with irreversible effects. Instead, the government is limiting debate on legislation that raises profound questions about consent, medical safeguards and the protection of vulnerable Canadians. This is not a minor legislative adjustment. It concerns human life, which is something very sacred.

Bill C-41 combines two very different issues. First, it proposes to permanently exclude individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness from accessing medical assistance in dying. This is a positive shift. Second, it would establish a framework for advance requests, allowing someone to request medical assistance in dying today, which would be carried out in the future. This is alarming because there is inadequate research to suggest this would be done effectively or that it would take into account the individual's capacity at the time of their death. These issues raise very different ethical, medical and legal questions, and they deserve independent study and debate.

The current exclusion of mental illness expires March 17, 2027, meaning Parliament must act before that deadline. However, there is no comparable deadline for the advance directives that are being included in this legislation. The government has tied the two together, one urgent and one not, in order to get this through quickly. Conservatives have been clear from the beginning that these issues should be separated. There is no reason to put them together, except, of course, for political gamesmanship. We are prepared to pass the permanent mental illness exclusion through all stages of the House today and send it to the Senate without any further delay.

Advance requests, meanwhile, deserve their own thorough parliamentary study, meaningful consultation and thorough debate. Religious organizations, including the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, and disability advocates have raised serious concerns. Their voices should not be dismissed from the conversation. Parliament should never operate under artificial political pressure when considering legislation that could result in the loss of human life. Canadians deserve better than having debate limited on an issue this consequential.

At the heart of advance requests is a fundamental question: What are the fundamental requirements of consent? Consent is the question. Under this proposal, someone could request MAID while they have decision-making capacity, with that request carried out years later, after they have lost that capacity, but how can someone know with certainty what they will want years into the future, particularly before experiencing the circumstances they are making a decision about? Someone may believe today that they could never want to live with dementia or significant cognitive decline, but imagining that experience and living that experience are two very different things. People adapt. Their perspectives change and their priorities evolve. Someone who once feared a particular condition may still find meaning, comfort and joy in life after developing that said condition. How can we know that a decision made years earlier still reflects what that person truly wants?

There are also serious questions about interpreting behaviour when someone can no longer communicate verbally. The legislation would address words, sounds or gestures that may indicate refusal or resistance to MAID, but how does a practitioner distinguish an involuntary reflex or expression of distress from a genuine indication that someone does not wish to proceed? The consequences of getting that wrong, of course, are irreversible. The person will die.

Similarly, how can practitioners determine whether someone is experiencing enduring and intolerable suffering when that person can no longer communicate? It is based on the judgment of another. How can they distinguish irremediable suffering from fear, distress or confusion that may be treatable? These clinical judgments deserve much more examination than what this government is currently allowing for by rushing the bill through.

There is another concern, which is people feeling pressured to seek medical assistance in dying, because they fear they will become a burden to their families or to society. People with disabilities, seniors and those experiencing serious illness should never feel that their lives are worth less because they have need for assistance. They should never feel that their families or society would be better off without them.

I have heard directly from a woman in my riding who lives with a disability. She regularly reaches out to the medical system for help, yet has repeatedly found herself being offered medical assistance in dying rather than the support and services she truly requires. Let us think about that: Someone asks the health care system for help to improve their circumstances and live, and instead they are offered death. That should give the House reason to pause. People with disabilities deserve appropriate care, they deserve a treatment and they deserve support. Death should never be presented as an alternative to the services they cannot access. We must do better. We must not create a society where dependency is seen as a loss of dignity and where people feel they should end their lives before becoming dependent on others.

There are also concerns about implementation. Bill C-41 would permit advance requests only in provinces and territories that establish their own regulatory frameworks. This could result in inconsistent oversight and different levels of protection across Canada. Canadians deserve consistent safeguards regardless of where they live. This is concerning and deserves careful consideration, which is not being granted by the government as the bill before us, once again, is being rushed through the House of Commons.

Conservatives have been fighting to make the exclusion for mental illness permanent, which is the second component of the bill. We very much support that. My colleague, the member for Cloverdale—Langley City, championed this protection through her private member's bill, Bill C-218, which would have permanently excluded individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from MAID. The Liberals voted that bill down, knowing that they were going to play a political game and couple that provision with the advance medical directive. It is absolutely shameful: playing with the lives of people and rushing a piece of legislation of this magnitude through the House of Commons. It is unspeakable.

At the end of the day, this debate comes down to a simple principle. Parliament has a responsibility to protect the most vulnerable. That is our job. That is the will of the Canadian people. That is what they have sent us here for, and that means listening to Canadians. It means examining the evidence and carefully considering the consequences of legislation that we pass in this place.

I will close by sharing an email I received today from a constituent. It reads, "I am very concerned about how MAID impacts vulnerable Canadians and how it will impact our loved ones with dementia and other capacity-limiting illnesses. Thank you for taking the time to hear my concerns on this."

As members can imagine, there was much more to that email, but the bottom line is that this is just one of dozens of emails, another several dozen phone calls and in-person meetings that I have taken with regards to this issue. It matters to Canadians.

We owe it to the Canadian public to take this seriously and give it careful consideration. We must hear from physicians, psychiatrists, legal experts, families, veterans, disability advocates, faith-based organizations and provincial governments. We must examine consent, safeguards and the realities of our health care system. Most importantly, we must ensure that vulnerable Canadians are protected.

Conservatives are prepared today to separate the bill into two parts and pass the protection for those with a mental illness while having robust discussions and debates, and hearing from witnesses, with regards to the advance directive piece.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:45 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Madam Speaker, I want those following the debate to reflect on the word hypocrisy. When we think about that word, let us think of how the Conservative Party tried to pass MAID legislation in two hours. We are going well beyond the two hours. Then I want us to think of how, when I posed the question to the member opposite, he said the legislation is on advance, that we never had the debate on advance requests.

Back in 2023, there was a joint committee of the House of Commons and the Senate where there was a Conservative member today whose recommendation was:

Recommendation 21

Amend the Criminal Code to allow for advance requests [after] a diagnosis of a serious and incurable medical condition, disease, or disorder leading to incapacity.

That is from an active Conservative member. It has been part of the debate for years, and the Conservative Party knows that. The issue is that the Conservative Party as a whole, the far right, opposes advance requests, and that is the reason they want to filibuster.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:45 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Madam Speaker, wow, I wish the member opposite was honourable. I would love to be able to use that term, but unfortunately, that was an attack on Canadians. It was an attack on their concerns. It was an attack on their desire to be heard, to have a voice. It is this desire that the Liberal Party has to shut down debate, to prevent any form of discourse from taking place. The members act as if something in the past, pointing to 2023, is somehow ironclad, as if it is done, as if there is no reason to reconsider it. Ironically, the other part of the bill is in fact a reconsideration of mental illness being a sole reason for requesting medical assistance in dying. They are willing to reconsider one part, but they are not willing to reconsider another part. That is the definition of hypocrisy.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

November 16th, 2026 / 4:45 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Madam Speaker, my colleague spoke very well on the issue. I think what is happening here is that we are again seeing that the Liberals want to just wrap multiple things up into one bill. They have a chance to put one thing in a bill that the House, I think, would have unanimous, if not pretty near unanimous, agreement on, which would be to remove mental illness as a sole reason for MAID. I sat on the committee and there was no consensus on irremediability. That became abundantly clear. The issue of advance directives was not actually part of the scope of the study of the committee, so for the Liberals to add that into this bill is ridiculous and, I would say, an overstep in what they should be doing with this bill.

They have already screwed up MAID legislation multiple times. Why are they trying to screw it up again?

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:45 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Madam Speaker, I cannot put myself into the frame of reference or mindset of a Liberal member. I value the voices of Canadians too much. I understand the need to hear from experts on this issue. I understand the need to have robust discussion, to hold proper meetings, but unfortunately, the government does not. Why the Liberals are sweeping that under the rug and pretending there is nothing to see here and that we can just push this through as if it is some frivolous piece of legislation is beyond my ability to comprehend, but it is incredibly dangerous and it is a massive disservice to the Canadian public.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:45 p.m.

Bloc

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Madam Speaker, as my colleague mentioned earlier, advance requests for MAID have been in place in Quebec for the past two years. They have not caused any problems and the rules are very clear. I have experienced this personally with my parents. An advance request may, for example, specify that MAID should be provided when a person no longer recognizes their loved ones, can no longer have meaningful or enjoyable interactions with others, or has become incontinent and is no longer able to care for themselves.

These are very specific criteria, and they must be established while the person still has the capacity to make such decisions. It is as though my colleague is suggesting that, once a person has lost that capacity or their memory, they might feel differently. However, that would be completely contradictory.

As I understand it, my colleague opposes advance requests altogether. In Quebec, advance requests already exist, and we do not want the practice to be criminalized. My colleague appears to believe that the debate that took place in Quebec over many years is not valid and that advance requests should be rejected.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Madam Speaker, today the government has presented us with a piece of legislation that is of two minds: one, it would take away medical assistance in dying from those who would request it because of mental illness as their sole reason; and, two, the other part of this legislation would allow for an individual to request medical assistance in dying as an advance directive.

To put these two together is a disservice to the Canadian public, because the second component—

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:50 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker (Alexandra Mendès) Alexandra Mendes

We must resume debate. We are way past time.

The hon. member for Airdrie—Cochrane.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Blake Richards Conservative Airdrie—Cochrane, AB

Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak about Bill C-41, the government's latest piece of legislation related to medical assistance in dying.

Now, my Conservative colleagues and I welcome the overdue admission in this bill that expanding MAID to individuals suffering solely from mental illness is a dangerous step. We know that people living with mental illness can experience tremendous suffering, but we also know that recovery is possible, that circumstances can change, and that people deserve access to the treatment and support that can help them rebuild their lives.

For years, Conservatives have been arguing that Canadians struggling with mental illness deserve treatment, support and hope, not the government telling them that MAID is the best option for them. The responsibility of government should be to ensure that these options are available, not to create a system where someone who is struggling may come to see MAID as their best or only option.

The other part of this piece of legislation is a separate issue altogether, the idea of advance requests. I really struggle to understand why the Liberals feel the need to tie these two issues together. I think I do understand why, but I really struggle to understand why they are doing this, taking two different issues, one where there seems to be pretty broad agreement, and another one where there is certainly a need for more study. Advance requests raise serious questions about consent, safeguards, provincial jurisdiction and a whole host of things that need to be considered. They deserve to have a thorough study, not to just be rushed through in a piece of legislation because they are being tied together with the other concept that there is obviously a need to rush but also where there seems to be a lot more broad consent.

I think it is even more important to note that in the context of the government's track record, in terms of ensuring that there are proper safeguards, ensuring that getting this legislation right when it comes to the topic of medical assistance in dying, the government's track record is not exactly good.

There is no doubt that this piece of legislation needed to be split into two pieces of legislation to be voted on separately, so that one could pass with the speed that is needed, and the other one could be studied properly. Not only did the Liberals ignore our legitimate pleas to split the bill, but now they are shutting down debate, and ramming it through without allowing for that proper study or for that scrutiny to take place that needs to happen.

This is literally a matter of life or death. The Liberals are relegating this legislation to limited debate based on, frankly, what seems to be just petty politics. The Liberals have to stop playing games with people's lives. Let us pass the mental illness provisions, and let us give the advance request the study and scrutiny it is due.

I want to speak a little, while I have the floor, about the impact of medical assistance in dying on the veteran community. That is a community that is near and dear to my heart, and one that I spend a lot of time thinking about and working for. It is an issue that I hear about quite consistently when I speak with veterans across Canada. There are far too many heartbreaking stories from veterans out there who were seeking help from the government to access benefits that they are entitled to, but instead of getting that help that they were asking for to live their lives, they were being offered, and in some cases even pressured, to consider medical assistance in dying.

Can members imagine the impact that has on someone, when they go to the government looking for help to live their lives and are asked if they would consider death instead? Can members imagine the impact that must have on someone, especially when they may already be in a state of suicidality, PTSD or mental health issues? They are already dealing with sanctuary trauma from the organization that is supposed to help them not being there for them, and then they get that.

We need to understand what is happening here. When we are talking about these cases, we are talking about heroes who stepped up and served this country. When those veterans returned to Canada, they did not ask for handouts, but asked for the care they earned through their service. They asked for treatment and assistance in their transition back into civilian life. What did they get from the government? They were met with a mountain of delays and denials. Worst of all, in some cases, they were offered medical assistance in dying. In some cases, they were even pressured to consider it.

I really want people to think about that. A veteran calls Veterans Affairs for help and the person on the other end of the line instead offers them death. The system is so overwhelmed and backlogged that, for whatever reason, in some cases, death is being considered a more efficient option than support. If that is the case, that is a deeply broken system.

These stories should concern every single Canadian, no matter what their stance on medical assistance in dying is otherwise. Our veterans made a commitment to Canada. They accepted difficult assignments, away from their families. In many cases, they returned home carrying physical or psychological injuries that came from their service. When they came back after fighting those battles, they found themselves fighting another battle, this time with their own government. They are forced to navigate complicated application processes; wait months, and in many cases, even years, for decisions on their benefits; and then are often forced to repeatedly demonstrate that those injuries were sustained while serving.

Consider what that means for someone who has already sacrificed so much for Canada. They may be dealing with physical and psychological injuries that affect their daily lives. They are not asking for special treatment. They are just asking for the government to honour the commitments it made to them when they signed up to serve. The government has a responsibility to ensure that every veteran who reaches out for help is treated with dignity and compassion. That means ensuring that VAC employees are well-trained and are ensuring that veterans are connected with the appropriate health care and support services.

That brings me to the question of safeguards and accountability. When it comes to medical assistance in dying, the government must be able to demonstrate that medical practitioners are properly trained, that eligibility requirements are being respected and that concerns raised by patients, families and health care professionals are being taken seriously. That means ensuring that individuals are making decisions freely, that they understand the options available to them and that they are not being influenced by outside pressure, by inadequate access to care or a feeling that they have become a burden on their families or society.

Bill C-41 must get this right. While we welcome the decision to maintain the exclusion for individuals suffering solely from mental illness, finally, serious questions certainly remain about the safeguards, the oversight and the government's ability to protect vulnerable Canadians.

Canada should be a country where someone struggling with their mental health knows that help is available, where someone living with a disability knows they will be supported and where someone facing a serious illness knows they and their family will not be left to navigate those challenges alone. It should certainly be a country where the men and women who put their lives on the line in service to Canada can return home knowing that their government will stand behind them.

We have a responsibility to protect those who are most vulnerable. That responsibility must be reflected in our laws, our policies and, most importantly, the services we deliver to Canadians. The answer here is straightforward. Canadians struggling with a mental illness deserve treatment, individuals living with disabilities deserve support and those facing serious illnesses deserve access to quality care. Our veterans deserve the benefits and assistance they earned through their service to this country.

The government must ensure that MAID is never presented as a substitute for the care and treatment that Canadians deserve. When someone reaches out to the government for help, they should be met with compassion and solutions, not the suggestion that death is their best option.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Madam Speaker, I truly value all life. To address this legislation, I have done significant background work to be able to share with the House what has taken place with MAID since the mid-1990s.

When a parliamentary committee has actually recommended, and this goes back to 2023, to have advance requests and then I see the Conservatives prepared to pass MAID legislation after only two hours of debate, it seems to me that there is a faction within the Conservative Party that just does not want the legislation to ultimately pass.

Does the member support, in principle, what the legislation is proposing, including advance requests? These are the very same advance requests that the Province of Saskatchewan, for example, wants to put into place.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5 p.m.

Conservative

Blake Richards Conservative Airdrie—Cochrane, AB

Madam Speaker, there is a saying that when someone is explaining, they are losing. That is exactly what we are hearing over there. The suggestion has been clearly made here that there is a need to split this piece of legislation because one piece has broad agreement. On the other piece, there is a need for further study.

Why could that not happen? Why could we not do that? We could split the legislation so we could ensure proper study and the proper safeguards on the one piece. On the other piece, the government has finally come around on that one. Frankly, it could have just voted for the piece of Conservative legislation and that would have been dealt with.

This seems to me like one of those examples where if someone is explaining, they are losing. The Liberals are losing.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5 p.m.

Bloc

Sébastien Lemire Bloc Abitibi—Témiscamingue, QC

Madam Speaker, section 1 of the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms grants every human being the right to life and to personal security, inviolability and freedom.

Quebec society believes that the right to life implies the right to die. In this context, medical assistance in dying must be established as a right that gives individuals the opportunity to avoid terminal suffering and medical paternalism, thereby ensuring their dignity. Allowing MAID means allowing people to choose how, when and where they wish to die, giving them the right to dignity.

I would like to hear my colleague's thoughts on that. Is that not a reason to support the bill?

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5 p.m.

Conservative

Blake Richards Conservative Airdrie—Cochrane, AB

Madam Speaker, let me start by making it quite clear that I support wholeheartedly the portion of the bill dealing with ensuring we have the safeguards in place for those with mental illness. I struggle with the other parts more, mostly because I do not really trust the Liberals to get the safeguards right. They have proven time and time again that they do not seem to be able to do that. That is why the study is needed.

Having said that, I recognize there is a range of different opinions out there in terms of what those safeguards should be. It is not a matter of legislation passing or not passing. It is a matter of making sure it gets the proper study and scrutiny that it deserves.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5 p.m.

Conservative

Alex Ruff Conservative Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound, ON

Madam Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for his unrelenting advocacy for our veterans over the last number of years, and in particular for shining a light on this issue where, unfortunately, employees of Veterans Affairs Canada were offering MAID to our veterans. That is point one.

Point two is the member for Winnipeg North keeps asking if we support this in principle. That is fine, he can ask that question. I actually think there is going to be a split feeling on that, even among all parties in this House. However, I am concerned that, and the ship has sailed, the Liberals have used time allocation on this bill here at second reading. As the member highlighted in his speech, it is so important that we get this right going forward.

Does the member share the same concerns I have that the Liberal government is now going to likely use time allocation even during debate at committee and take away the opportunity for all the stakeholders and experts to testify at committee so that we can make sure we get this bill right?

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:05 p.m.

Conservative

Blake Richards Conservative Airdrie—Cochrane, AB

Madam Speaker, on the first part of his question, the only thing that I would disagree with is that member used the past tense when he referred to veterans being offered medical assistance in dying. I have heard many stories and I do not believe it is in the past, unfortunately, though I wish that were the case.

I also want to thank the member for his service because that is always something that deserves mentioning.

In terms of the second part of his question, the reality here is that the government has repeatedly failed to ensure proper safeguards in the legislation around the topic of medical assistance in dying. I do not have much faith that the government has it right in this instance. It certainly needs that proper scrutiny and study, and it is not receiving that. It is ramming this bill through, and I think it is doing it for a very—

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:05 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker (Alexandra Mendès) Alexandra Mendes

We are already over the member's time.

The hon. member for King—Vaughan.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:05 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the residents of King—Vaughan, especially on a topic as important as this one.

The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying heard considerable concerns about safeguards and oversights in the MAID process. There are serious moral and legal considerations when we discuss MAID for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. We are asking whether it is possible to know with enough certainty to make an irreversible decision that a person's condition would never improve.

After hearing from experts and the people directly affected, it recommended keeping the exclusion in place indefinitely. I support that recommendation. The most important thing we need to keep front and centre in this debate is that MAID must never become a cheaper or easier alternative to providing real and effective support to Canadians who are suffering. We cannot tell Canadians in a vulnerable state that the help they need is many months or even years away and then turn around and tell them that MAID is the option.

When someone finally works up the courage to ask for help and is told they will have to wait six months, what are they supposed to do tonight? What are they supposed to do tomorrow? We have a responsibility to make sure that Canadians have access to those supports when they need them most.

Bill C-41 would keep the exclusion in place for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. The government should instead bring forward a separate bill to maintain this exclusion, so that the House can debate and vote on that question on its own. The committee has given Parliament a clear recommendation, and the House should act on it, but questions that were raised when the government first introduced MAID are still being raised today: How do we make sure that consent is freely given when someone feels they have run out of options? What guidance do doctors have when they are uncertain about eligibility? How do we know whether a person has had a genuine opportunity to access the care that might have helped them? Being told that a treatment exists is one thing. Being able to find a doctor who provides it, affording it, getting it and receiving that treatment when one needs it is another.

Canadian seniors are concerned about safeguards. They want to know that when they go to the hospital for treatment, they will get the care they came for. A senior recently told me that a family member brought her to the hospital because she had a bad flu. They told me that during that visit, they were offered MAID without asking about it. They are now afraid to go back to the hospital. The next time this senior falls ill and their family tells them they need to go to the hospital, they may hesitate. They may stay home longer than they should. Many seniors in this country are already in a vulnerable situation. They should be able to go to the hospital, tell the doctor exactly what they are going through and feel confident that they will get the care they need.

There is one thing I am crystal clear on. Canadians who are suffering from mental illness and who can get better must have the opportunity to get better. They should never feel pushed toward an irreversible decision because they could not get the help they needed. Someone may have already tried several treatments. They may have been referred to a specialist and spent months waiting to be seen. They may be relying on a family member who is doing everything they can to help and has run out of places to call. Those Canadians are asking for something very practical. They need an appointment they can get to, treatment they can afford and someone they can call when things get worse.

We are in no position to make MAID available to people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. It would also be profoundly unfair to this country's medical professionals to put them in such a difficult moral and legal position. A doctor may know that another treatment is worth trying and also know that their patient cannot afford it or cannot get an appointment. We need to take seriously what that means for the patients and the doctors as well.

We cannot tell veterans who have fought and suffered for this country that the care they need, the treatment they need and the medication they need are months away and then turn around and raise MAID in the meantime. It is an insult to their service, their courage and their love of this great country. A veteran who calls for help should be able to say how difficult things have become and know that the person on the other end of that call will help them get care. They should be able to ask when they will see a specialist, what help is available while they wait, and who they can call if things get worse. After all we have asked of them, they should never have to wonder whether asking for that help was a mistake.

We need to see how the existing safeguards work in practice, especially in the most difficult cases. If a patient or a family member raises a concern, who hears it? Who reviews what happens? How does Parliament find out whether the safeguards we put in place are being followed? These questions matter to the Canadians who depend on us right now.

The special joint committee has heard serious concerns about the safeguards and oversights. It is up to us as parliamentarians to take those concerns seriously. We need to listen to doctors, nurses and legal experts. We need to hear from veterans and veterans groups, Canadians living with mental illness, Canadians with disabilities, and seniors and their families, who are often the first to see when someone is struggling. They can tell us whether the system worked for them and where they were left trying to find out on their own.

When we ask a committee to listen to those Canadians and bring forward recommendations, we have a responsibility to act on what we heard. Conservatives will continue to work in the House to make sure those voices are heard. We will fight to keep the exclusion in place for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. We will keep pressing for safeguards that work in practice and for Canadians who reach for mental health support to get the help they ask for.

When a senior goes to the hospital, when a veteran calls for treatment or when a Canadian who has been struggling for months finally asks for help, they should be able to count on us to make that help available. No Canadian should ever feel that MAID is their only option because the help they asked for never came.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:15 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Madam Speaker, the Conservatives are trying to give this narrative that advance requests have not been debated, when in fact that is not the case. I will go back to a committee that in 2023 made a recommendation that we incorporate advance requests. In fact, the Conservative member of Parliament who chairs the status of women committee wanted to see advance requests. I am wondering if the member could give a clear indication: Does she believe that her colleague who chairs the status of women committee is wrong in her belief that we should have advance requests?

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:15 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Madam Speaker, I am going to answer that question, because I respect my colleague, and I respect her decision. It is not her decision I am worried about. It is the decision of the Liberal government that I cannot trust. I cannot trust it to make these decisions on behalf of individuals who have issues of mental health and need the help that they wanted. For that individual, my colleague across the way who made those comments, I have sat with seniors on their last dying breath, and they have always hoped that there would be an opportunity to live another day.

I think maybe what you should do is look into your heart and soul and start realizing that life is something that we all cherish, and we all want to live it to the fullest extent.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:15 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker (Alexandra Mendès) Alexandra Mendes

As a reminder to the hon. member, the “you” is me.

The hon. member for Laurentides—Labelle.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:15 p.m.

Bloc

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Madam Speaker, I want to revisit some of the mechanisms at play. I get the sense that having more choices about our own life has led some people here to conclude that a dementia diagnosis automatically means that the person must request MAID, even when the person does not want to die, as if they are being told that this is how it is and that they have to die. However, that is not the case.

Does a person have the right to make an advance request if they wish? There are mechanisms and requirements in place to make sure that nobody is being forced. We want the choice to be made by the person themselves, not by those who are left behind. Nobody wants their loved one to die, that is for sure.

I hope that we will be able to make a distinction between the wishes of the individual and the fears of those who will be losing a loved one.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:15 p.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Madam Speaker, my concern here is very simple.

I recently spent some time with a mother whose daughter was coerced into human trafficking. She was a young child when she was recruited. After many surgeries, that daughter is now suffering from mental health, and the mother has tried everything within her power to save this child. I will tell members something: The appointments to get her help are months and years away.

I think we need to look at this bill, and we need to decipher if it meets the circumstances for that particular individual. I think the other issue we have in this country is that if money was not sent abroad and was sent to the provinces for medical help, so that the doctors are available to help individuals with their mental health, this would solve a lot of the problems.

Bill C-41 Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards ActGovernment Orders

5:15 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

Madam Speaker, very quickly, I would like to ask my colleague how important it would be to split this bill, debate the second part and get some more insight into the second part of this bill. We could look at it, talk to more experts, and put more time on the second part.

I think the first part is something we can agree on and that it should move forward. I hope the members across the way will see it that way too.