Vote #493 on November 7th, 2012

Vote topic

That the motion be amended by deleting all the words after the word “That” and substituting the following:

“the Seventh Report of the Standing Committee on Government Operations and Estimates, presented on Wednesday, June 20, 2012, be not now concurred in, but that it be referred back to the Standing Committee on Government Operations and Estimates for further consideration.”.

See context in the Debates.

Result

Yes 143
Conservative
No 119
Bloc NDP Liberal Green

Conservative

Yes Diane Ablonczy
Yes Eve Adams
Yes Mark Adler
Yes Leona Aglukkaq
Yes Dan Albas
Yes Harold Albrecht
Yes Chris Alexander
Yes Mike Allen
Yes Dean Allison
Yes Stella Ambler
Yes Rona Ambrose
Yes Rob Anders
Yes David Anderson
Yes Scott Armstrong
Didn't vote Keith Ashfield
Yes Jay Aspin
Yes John Baird
Yes Joyce Bateman
Didn't vote Leon Benoit
Yes Candice Bergen
Yes Maxime Bernier
Yes James Bezan
Yes Steven Blaney
Yes Kelly Block
Yes Ray Boughen
Yes Peter Braid
Yes Garry Breitkreuz
Yes Gord Brown
Yes Lois Brown
Yes Patrick Brown
Yes Rod Bruinooge
Yes Brad Butt
Yes Paul Calandra
Yes Blaine Calkins
Yes Ron Cannan
Yes John Carmichael
Yes Colin Carrie
Yes Corneliu Chisu
Yes Michael Chong
Yes Rob Clarke
Yes Tony Clement
Yes Joe Daniel
Yes Patricia Davidson
Yes Bob Dechert
Yes Dean Del Mastro
Yes Barry Devolin
Yes Earl Dreeshen
Yes John Duncan
Yes Rick Dykstra
Yes Julian Fantino
Didn't vote Ed Fast
Yes Kerry-Lynne Findlay
Yes Diane Finley
Yes Jim Flaherty
Yes Steven Fletcher
Yes Royal Galipeau
Didn't vote Cheryl Gallant
Didn't vote Parm Gill
Yes Shelly Glover
Yes Robert Goguen
Yes Gary Goodyear
Didn't vote Bal Gosal
Yes Jacques Gourde
Didn't vote Nina Grewal
Didn't vote Stephen Harper
Didn't vote Dick Harris
Yes Laurie Hawn
Yes Bryan Hayes
Yes Russ Hiebert
Yes Jim Hillyer
Yes Randy Hoback
Yes Ed Holder
Yes Roxanne James
Yes Brian Jean
Yes Randy Kamp
Yes Gerald Keddy
Yes Jason Kenney
Yes Peter Kent
Yes Greg Kerr
Yes Ed Komarnicki
Yes Daryl Kramp
Yes Mike Lake
Yes Guy Lauzon
Yes Denis Lebel
Yes Ryan Leef
Yes Kellie Leitch
Yes Pierre Lemieux
Yes Chungsen Leung
Yes Wladyslaw Lizon
Yes Ben Lobb
Yes Tom Lukiwski
Yes James Lunney
Yes Peter MacKay
Yes Dave MacKenzie
Yes Colin Mayes
Yes Phil McColeman
Yes Cathy McLeod
Yes Costas Menegakis
Yes Ted Menzies
Yes Rob Merrifield
Didn't vote Larry Miller
Yes James Moore
Yes Rob Moore
Yes Rob Nicholson
Yes Rick Norlock
Didn't vote Deepak Obhrai
Yes Gordon O'Connor
Didn't vote Joe Oliver
Didn't vote Tilly O'Neill-Gordon
Yes Ted Opitz
Yes Christian Paradis
Yes LaVar Payne
Yes Peter Penashue
Yes Pierre Poilievre
Yes Joe Preston
Yes Lisa Raitt
Yes James Rajotte
Yes Brent Rathgeber
Yes Scott Reid
Yes Michelle Rempel
Yes Blake Richards
Yes Greg Rickford
Yes Gerry Ritz
Yes Andrew Saxton
Didn't vote Andrew Scheer
Yes Gary Schellenberger
Didn't vote Kyle Seeback
Yes Gail Shea
Yes Bev Shipley
Didn't vote Devinder Shory
Yes Joy Smith
Yes Robert Sopuck
Yes Kevin Sorenson
Yes Bruce Stanton
Didn't vote Brian Storseth
Yes Mark Strahl
Yes David Sweet
Yes David Tilson
Yes Lawrence Toet
Yes Vic Toews
Yes Bradley Trost
Yes Bernard Trottier
Didn't vote Susan Truppe
Yes Merv Tweed
Didn't vote Tim Uppal
Yes Bernard Valcourt
Yes Dave Van Kesteren
Yes Peter Van Loan
Yes Maurice Vellacott
Yes Mike Wallace
Yes Mark Warawa
Yes Chris Warkentin
Yes Jeff Watson
Yes Rodney Weston
Yes John Weston
Yes David Wilks
Yes John Williamson
Yes Alice Wong
Yes Stephen Woodworth
Yes Lynne Yelich
Didn't vote Terence Young
Yes Wai Young
Yes Bob Zimmer

NDP

No Malcolm Allen
No Charlie Angus
No Niki Ashton
No Alex Atamanenko
No Robert Aubin
No Paulina Ayala
No Tyrone Benskin
No Dennis Bevington
No Denis Blanchette
No Lysane Blanchette-Lamothe
No Françoise Boivin
Didn't vote Charmaine Borg
No Alexandre Boulerice
No Marjolaine Boutin-Sweet
No Tarik Brahmi
No Ruth Ellen Brosseau
No Guy Caron
No Andrew Cash
No Chris Charlton
No Sylvain Chicoine
No Robert Chisholm
No François Choquette
Didn't vote Olivia Chow
No David Christopherson
No Ryan Cleary
Didn't vote Joe Comartin
No Raymond Côté
No Jean Crowder
No Nathan Cullen
Didn't vote Libby Davies
No Don Davies
No Anne-Marie Day
Didn't vote Paul Dewar
No Pierre Dionne Labelle
No Fin Donnelly
No Rosane Doré Lefebvre
No Matthew Dubé
No Linda Duncan
No Pierre-Luc Dusseault
No Mylène Freeman
No Randall Garrison
No Réjean Genest
No Jonathan Genest-Jourdain
No Alain Giguère
No Yvon Godin
No Claude Gravelle
No Sadia Groguhé
No Dan Harris
Didn't vote Jack Harris
No Sana Hassainia
No Carol Hughes
No Pierre Jacob
No Peter Julian
No Matthew Kellway
No François Lapointe
No Jean-François Larose
No Alexandrine Latendresse
No Hélène Laverdière
No Hélène LeBlanc
No Megan Leslie
Didn't vote Laurin Liu
No Hoang Mai
No Wayne Marston
Didn't vote Pat Martin
Didn't vote Brian Masse
No Irene Mathyssen
No Élaine Michaud
Didn't vote Christine Moore
No Dany Morin
No Marie-Claude Morin
No Marc-André Morin
No Isabelle Morin
No Thomas Mulcair
No Pierre Nantel
No Peggy Nash
No Jamie Nicholls
No José Nunez-Melo
No Annick Papillon
No Claude Patry
No Ève Péclet
Didn't vote Manon Perreault
No François Pilon
No Anne Minh-Thu Quach
No John Rafferty
No Mathieu Ravignat
No Francine Raynault
No Jean Rousseau
Didn't vote Romeo Saganash
No Jasbir Sandhu
No Craig Scott
No Djaouida Sellah
No Jinny Sims
No Rathika Sitsabaiesan
Didn't vote Kennedy Stewart
No Peter Stoffer
Didn't vote Mike Sullivan
No Glenn Thibeault
No Philip Toone
No Jonathan Tremblay
No Nycole Turmel

Bloc

No André Bellavance
Didn't vote Jean-François Fortin
Didn't vote Maria Mourani
No Louis Plamondon

Liberal

No Scott Andrews
No Mauril Bélanger
No Carolyn Bennett
No Scott Brison
Didn't vote Gerry Byrne
No Sean Casey
No Denis Coderre
No Irwin Cotler
No Rodger Cuzner
No Stéphane Dion
No Kirsty Duncan
No Wayne Easter
No Mark Eyking
No Judy Foote
Didn't vote Hedy Fry
Didn't vote Marc Garneau
No Ralph Goodale
No Ted Hsu
No Jim Karygiannis
No Kevin Lamoureux
No Dominic LeBlanc
No Lawrence MacAulay
No John McCallum
No David McGuinty
No John McKay
Didn't vote Joyce Murray
Didn't vote Massimo Pacetti
No Bob Rae
No Geoff Regan
No Francis Scarpaleggia
Didn't vote Judy Sgro
No Scott Simms
No Lise St-Denis
No Justin Trudeau
No Frank Valeriote

Independent

Didn't vote Peter Goldring
No Bruce Hyer

Green

No Elizabeth May