Vote #33 on December 3rd, 2013

Bill

C-4 A second act to implement certain provisions of the budget tabled in Parliament on March 21, 2013 and other measures

Vote topic

That Bill C-4 be amended by deleting Clause 471.

See context in the Debates.

Result

Yes 122
Bloc NDP Liberal Green
No 143
Conservative

Conservative

No Diane Ablonczy
No Eve Adams
No Mark Adler
Didn't vote Leona Aglukkaq
No Dan Albas
No Harold Albrecht
No Chris Alexander
No Mike Allen
No Dean Allison
No Stella Ambler
No Rona Ambrose
No Rob Anders
Didn't vote David Anderson
No Scott Armstrong
No Keith Ashfield
No Jay Aspin
Didn't vote John Baird
No Joyce Bateman
No Leon Benoit
No Candice Bergen
No Maxime Bernier
No James Bezan
No Steven Blaney
No Kelly Block
No Ray Boughen
No Peter Braid
No Garry Breitkreuz
Didn't vote Lois Brown
No Patrick Brown
No Gord Brown
No Rod Bruinooge
No Brad Butt
No Paul Calandra
No Blaine Calkins
No Ron Cannan
No John Carmichael
No Colin Carrie
Didn't vote Corneliu Chisu
No Michael Chong
No Rob Clarke
No Tony Clement
No Joan Crockatt
No Joe Daniel
No Patricia Davidson
No Bob Dechert
No Barry Devolin
No Earl Dreeshen
No John Duncan
No Rick Dykstra
Didn't vote Ted Falk
No Julian Fantino
Didn't vote Ed Fast
No Kerry-Lynne Findlay
No Diane Finley
Didn't vote Jim Flaherty
No Steven Fletcher
No Royal Galipeau
No Cheryl Gallant
No Parm Gill
No Shelly Glover
No Robert Goguen
No Peter Goldring
No Gary Goodyear
No Bal Gosal
No Jacques Gourde
No Nina Grewal
Didn't vote Stephen Harper
No Dick Harris
No Laurie Hawn
No Bryan Hayes
No Russ Hiebert
No Jim Hillyer
Didn't vote Randy Hoback
No Ed Holder
No Roxanne James
No Brian Jean
No Randy Kamp
No Gerald Keddy
No Jason Kenney
No Peter Kent
No Greg Kerr
No Ed Komarnicki
No Daryl Kramp
No Mike Lake
No Guy Lauzon
Didn't vote Denis Lebel
No Ryan Leef
No Kellie Leitch
No Pierre Lemieux
No Chungsen Leung
No Wladyslaw Lizon
No Ben Lobb
No Tom Lukiwski
No James Lunney
No Peter MacKay
No Dave MacKenzie
Didn't vote Larry Maguire
No Colin Mayes
No Phil McColeman
No Cathy McLeod
No Costas Menegakis
No Rob Merrifield
No Larry Miller
No James Moore
No Rob Moore
No Rob Nicholson
No Rick Norlock
No Deepak Obhrai
No Gordon O'Connor
Didn't vote Joe Oliver
No Tilly O'Neill-Gordon
No Ted Opitz
No Erin O'Toole
No Christian Paradis
Didn't vote LaVar Payne
No Pierre Poilievre
No Joe Preston
Didn't vote Lisa Raitt
No James Rajotte
No Scott Reid
No Michelle Rempel
No Blake Richards
No Greg Rickford
Didn't vote Gerry Ritz
No Andrew Saxton
Didn't vote Andrew Scheer
No Gary Schellenberger
No Kyle Seeback
No Gail Shea
No Bev Shipley
No Devinder Shory
No Joy Smith
No Robert Sopuck
No Kevin Sorenson
No Bruce Stanton
No Brian Storseth
No Mark Strahl
No David Sweet
No David Tilson
No Lawrence Toet
No Bradley Trost
No Bernard Trottier
No Susan Truppe
No Tim Uppal
No Bernard Valcourt
No Dave Van Kesteren
No Peter Van Loan
No Maurice Vellacott
No Mike Wallace
No Mark Warawa
No Chris Warkentin
No Jeff Watson
No Rodney Weston
No John Weston
No David Wilks
No John Williamson
No Alice Wong
No Stephen Woodworth
Didn't vote Lynne Yelich
No Wai Young
No Terence Young
Didn't vote Bob Zimmer

NDP

Didn't vote Malcolm Allen
Yes Charlie Angus
Yes Niki Ashton
Didn't vote Alex Atamanenko
Yes Robert Aubin
Yes Paulina Ayala
Yes Tyrone Benskin
Yes Dennis Bevington
Yes Denis Blanchette
Yes Lysane Blanchette-Lamothe
Yes Françoise Boivin
Yes Charmaine Borg
Yes Alexandre Boulerice
Yes Marjolaine Boutin-Sweet
Didn't vote Tarik Brahmi
Didn't vote Ruth Ellen Brosseau
Yes Guy Caron
Yes Andrew Cash
Yes Chris Charlton
Yes Sylvain Chicoine
Yes Robert Chisholm
Yes François Choquette
Yes Olivia Chow
Yes David Christopherson
Yes Ryan Cleary
Didn't vote Joe Comartin
Yes Raymond Côté
Didn't vote Jean Crowder
Yes Nathan Cullen
Yes Libby Davies
Yes Don Davies
Yes Anne-Marie Day
Yes Paul Dewar
Yes Pierre Dionne Labelle
Yes Fin Donnelly
Yes Rosane Doré Lefebvre
Yes Matthew Dubé
Yes Linda Duncan
Yes Pierre-Luc Dusseault
Yes Mylène Freeman
Yes Randall Garrison
Yes Réjean Genest
Yes Jonathan Genest-Jourdain
Yes Alain Giguère
Yes Yvon Godin
Didn't vote Claude Gravelle
Yes Sadia Groguhé
Didn't vote Jack Harris
Yes Dan Harris
Didn't vote Sana Hassainia
Didn't vote Carol Hughes
Yes Pierre Jacob
Yes Peter Julian
Yes Matthew Kellway
Yes François Lapointe
Yes Jean-François Larose
Didn't vote Alexandrine Latendresse
Yes Hélène Laverdière
Didn't vote Hélène LeBlanc
Yes Megan Leslie
Yes Laurin Liu
Yes Hoang Mai
Yes Wayne Marston
Yes Pat Martin
Yes Brian Masse
Yes Irene Mathyssen
Yes Élaine Michaud
Yes Christine Moore
Yes Marie-Claude Morin
Yes Isabelle Morin
Yes Dany Morin
Yes Marc-André Morin
Yes Thomas Mulcair
Yes Pierre Nantel
Yes Peggy Nash
Didn't vote Jamie Nicholls
Yes José Nunez-Melo
Yes Annick Papillon
Yes Ève Péclet
Yes Manon Perreault
Yes François Pilon
Yes Anne Minh-Thu Quach
Didn't vote John Rafferty
Yes Murray Rankin
Yes Mathieu Ravignat
Yes Francine Raynault
Yes Jean Rousseau
Yes Romeo Saganash
Yes Jasbir Sandhu
Yes Craig Scott
Yes Djaouida Sellah
Yes Jinny Sims
Yes Rathika Sitsabaiesan
Yes Kennedy Stewart
Yes Peter Stoffer
Yes Mike Sullivan
Yes Glenn Thibeault
Yes Philip Toone
Yes Jonathan Tremblay
Yes Nycole Turmel

Bloc

Yes André Bellavance
Yes Jean-François Fortin
Yes Claude Patry
Yes Louis Plamondon

Liberal

Yes Scott Andrews
Yes Mauril Bélanger
Yes Carolyn Bennett
Didn't vote Scott Brison
Yes Gerry Byrne
Yes Sean Casey
Didn't vote Irwin Cotler
Yes Rodger Cuzner
Didn't vote Stéphane Dion
Didn't vote Emmanuel Dubourg
Yes Kirsty Duncan
Yes Wayne Easter
Didn't vote Mark Eyking
Yes Judy Foote
Didn't vote Chrystia Freeland
Yes Hedy Fry
Didn't vote Marc Garneau
Yes Ralph Goodale
Yes Ted Hsu
Yes Yvonne Jones
Yes Jim Karygiannis
Yes Kevin Lamoureux
Yes Dominic LeBlanc
Yes Lawrence MacAulay
Yes John McCallum
Yes David McGuinty
Yes John McKay
Yes Joyce Murray
Yes Massimo Pacetti
Yes Geoff Regan
Yes Francis Scarpaleggia
Yes Judy Sgro
Yes Scott Simms
Yes Lise St-Denis
Yes Justin Trudeau
Yes Frank Valeriote

Independent

Didn't vote Dean Del Mastro
Yes Bruce Hyer
Didn't vote Maria Mourani
Yes Brent Rathgeber

Green

Yes Elizabeth May