Vote topic

That, in the opinion of the House, given that the Prime Minister has promised to eliminate the fiscal imbalance and that this imbalance cannot be eliminated without the elimination of the federal spending power in areas that fall under the jurisdiction of Quebec and the provinces, the bill on federal spending power that the government will introduce should, at a minimum, provide for Quebec to have the right to opt out with no strings attached and with full financial compensation from any federal program, whether existing or not and cost-shared or not, which invades Quebec's areas of jurisdiction.

See context in the Debates.

Result

Yes 49
Bloc
No 229
Conservative NDP Liberal

Conservative

Didn't vote Stephen Harper
Didn't vote Jim Prentice
Didn't vote Myron Thompson

NDP

Bloc

Liberal

Didn't vote Colleen Beaumier
Didn't vote John Cannis
Didn't vote Brenda Chamberlain
Didn't vote Irwin Cotler
Didn't vote Sukh Dhaliwal
Didn't vote Raymonde Folco
Didn't vote Bill Graham
Didn't vote Paul Martin
Didn't vote David McGuinty
Didn't vote Joe McGuire
Didn't vote John McKay
Didn't vote Gary Merasty
Didn't vote Peter Milliken
Didn't vote Stephen Owen
Didn't vote Jim Peterson
Didn't vote Andy Scott
Didn't vote Raymond Simard
Didn't vote Belinda Stronach
Didn't vote Lui Temelkovski
Didn't vote Roger Valley
Didn't vote Tom Wappel
Didn't vote Blair Wilson

Independent