Vote #159 on February 7th, 2011

C-46 An Act to implement the Free Trade Agreement between Canada and the Republic of Panama, the Agreement on the Environment between Canada and the Republic of Panama and the Agreement on Labour Cooperation between Canada and the Republic of Panama

That Bill C-46 be amended by deleting Clause 12.

See context in the Debates.

• Yes 52
• No 189
• Paired 22
• Bloc NDP
• Liberal Conservative

• Yes Guy André
• Didn't vote Gérard Asselin
• Yes Claude Bachand
• Paired Josée Beaudin
• Paired André Bellavance
• Paired Bernard Bigras
• Paired Raynald Blais
• Paired France Bonsant
• Yes Robert Bouchard
• Paired Diane Bourgeois
• Yes Paule Brunelle
• Didn't vote Serge Cardin
• Didn't vote Robert Carrier
• Yes Claude DeBellefeuille
• Didn't vote Nicole Demers
• Yes Johanne Deschamps
• Didn't vote Luc Desnoyers
• Yes Jean Dorion
• Yes Gilles Duceppe
• Didn't vote Nicolas Dufour
• Didn't vote Meili Faille
• Yes Carole Freeman
• Yes Christiane Gagnon
• Yes Roger Gaudet
• Paired Monique Guay
• Paired Claude Guimond
• Yes Michel Guimond
• Yes Jean-Yves Laforest
• Yes Mario Laframboise
• Didn't vote Francine Lalonde
• Yes Carole Lavallée
• Paired Marc Lemay
• Yes Yves Lessard
• Yes Yvon Lévesque
• Didn't vote Luc Malo
• Yes Serge Ménard
• Yes Maria Mourani
• Didn't vote Richard Nadeau
• Didn't vote Christian Ouellet
• Yes Pascal-Pierre Paillé
• Yes Daniel Paillé
• Paired Pierre Paquette
• Yes Louis Plamondon
• Yes Roger Pomerleau
• Yes Thierry St-Cyr
• Yes Ève-Mary Thaï Thi Lac
• Yes Robert Vincent

• No Jim Abbott
• No Diane Ablonczy
• No Leona Aglukkaq
• No Harold Albrecht
• No Mike Allen
• No Dean Allison
• No Rona Ambrose
• No Rob Anders
• No David Anderson
• No Scott Armstrong
• No Keith Ashfield
• No John Baird
• No Leon Benoit
• No Candice Bergen
• No Maxime Bernier
• No James Bezan
• No Jean-Pierre Blackburn
• Paired Steven Blaney
• No Kelly Block
• Paired Sylvie Boucher
• No Ray Boughen
• No Peter Braid
• No Garry Breitkreuz
• No Gord Brown
• No Patrick Brown
• No Lois Brown
• No Rod Bruinooge
• No Dona Cadman
• No Paul Calandra
• No Blaine Calkins
• No Ron Cannan
• No Lawrence Cannon
• No Colin Carrie
• No Rick Casson
• No Michael Chong
• No Rob Clarke
• No Tony Clement
• No John Cummins
• No Patricia Davidson
• No Stockwell Day
• No Bob Dechert
• No Dean Del Mastro
• No Barry Devolin
• No Earl Dreeshen
• No John Duncan
• No Rick Dykstra
• No Julian Fantino
• No Ed Fast
• No Diane Finley
• No Jim Flaherty
• No Steven Fletcher
• Paired Royal Galipeau
• No Cheryl Gallant
• Paired Bernard Généreux
• No Shelly Glover
• No Peter Goldring
• No Gary Goodyear
• No Jacques Gourde
• No Nina Grewal
• No Stephen Harper
• No Dick Harris
• No Laurie Hawn
• No Russ Hiebert
• Paired Randy Hoback
• No Ed Holder
• No Brian Jean
• No Randy Kamp
• No Gerald Keddy
• No Jason Kenney
• No Peter Kent
• No Greg Kerr
• No Ed Komarnicki
• No Daryl Kramp
• No Mike Lake
• Paired Guy Lauzon
• No Denis Lebel
• Paired Pierre Lemieux
• No Ben Lobb
• No Tom Lukiwski
• No Gary Lunn
• No James Lunney
• No Peter MacKay
• No Dave MacKenzie
• No Colin Mayes
• No Phil McColeman
• No Cathy McLeod
• No Ted Menzies
• No Rob Merrifield
• Paired Larry Miller
• No Rob Moore
• No James Moore
• No Rob Nicholson
• No Rick Norlock
• No Deepak Obhrai
• No Gordon O'Connor
• Paired Bev Oda
• No Tilly O'Neill-Gordon
• No Christian Paradis
• No LaVar Payne
• No Daniel Petit
• No Pierre Poilievre
• No Joe Preston
• No Lisa Raitt
• No James Rajotte
• No Brent Rathgeber
• No Scott Reid
• No Blake Richards
• No Lee Richardson
• No Greg Rickford
• No Gerry Ritz
• No Andrew Saxton
• Paired Andrew Scheer
• No Gary Schellenberger
• No Gail Shea
• No Bev Shipley
• No Devinder Shory
• Paired Joy Smith
• No Robert Sopuck
• No Kevin Sorenson
• No Bruce Stanton
• No Brian Storseth
• No Chuck Strahl
• No David Sweet
• Didn't vote Greg Thompson
• No David Tilson
• No Vic Toews
• No Bradley Trost
• No Merv Tweed
• No Tim Uppal
• No Dave Van Kesteren
• No Peter Van Loan
• No Maurice Vellacott
• No Josée Verner
• No Mike Wallace
• No Mark Warawa
• No Chris Warkentin
• No Jeff Watson
• No Rodney Weston
• No John Weston
• No Alice Wong
• No Stephen Woodworth
• No Lynne Yelich
• No Terence Young

• No André Arthur
• No Helena Guergis

• No Scott Andrews
• No Larry Bagnell
• No Navdeep Bains
• Didn't vote Mauril Bélanger
• No Carolyn Bennett
• No Scott Brison
• Didn't vote Gerry Byrne
• No John Cannis
• No Siobhan Coady
• Didn't vote Denis Coderre
• Didn't vote Irwin Cotler
• No Bonnie Crombie
• No Rodger Cuzner
• No Jean-Claude D'Amours
• Didn't vote Sukh Dhaliwal
• Didn't vote Ruby Dhalla
• No Stéphane Dion
• No Ujjal Dosanjh
• Didn't vote Ken Dryden
• No Kirsty Duncan
• Didn't vote Wayne Easter
• No Mark Eyking
• No Martha Hall Findlay
• No Raymonde Folco
• No Judy Foote
• No Hedy Fry
• No Marc Garneau
• No Ralph Goodale
• Didn't vote Albina Guarnieri
• No Mark Holland
• Didn't vote Michael Ignatieff
• No Marlene Jennings
• No Andrew Kania
• No Jim Karygiannis
• Didn't vote Gerard Kennedy
• No Kevin Lamoureux
• No Dominic LeBlanc
• No Derek Lee
• No Lawrence MacAulay
• Didn't vote Gurbax Malhi
• Didn't vote Keith Martin
• No John McCallum
• No David McGuinty
• No John McKay
• Didn't vote Dan McTeague
• No Alexandra Mendes
• Didn't vote Peter Milliken
• No Maria Minna
• Didn't vote Brian Murphy
• No Shawn Murphy
• No Joyce Murray
• No Anita Neville
• No Rob Oliphant
• Didn't vote Massimo Pacetti
• No Bernard Patry
• No Glen Pearson
• No Marcel Proulx
• Didn't vote Bob Rae
• No Yasmin Ratansi
• No Geoff Regan
• No Pablo Rodriguez
• No Anthony Rota
• No Todd Russell
• No Michael Savage
• No Francis Scarpaleggia
• No Judy Sgro
• No Mario Silva
• No Scott Simms
• No Michelle Simson
• No Paul Szabo
• No Alan Tonks
• No Justin Trudeau
• Didn't vote Frank Valeriote
• Didn't vote Joe Volpe
• No Bryon Wilfert
• No Borys Wrzesnewskyj
• Didn't vote Lise Zarac

• Yes Malcolm Allen
• Yes Charlie Angus
• Yes Niki Ashton
• Yes Alex Atamanenko
• Yes Dennis Bevington
• Yes Chris Charlton
• Yes Olivia Chow
• Yes David Christopherson
• Yes Joe Comartin
• Yes Jean Crowder
• Didn't vote Nathan Cullen
• Yes Don Davies
• Yes Libby Davies
• Yes Paul Dewar
• Yes Fin Donnelly
• Yes Linda Duncan
• Didn't vote Yvon Godin
• Yes Claude Gravelle
• Yes Jack Harris
• Yes Carol Hughes
• Didn't vote Bruce Hyer
• Didn't vote Peter Julian
• Didn't vote Jack Layton
• Yes Megan Leslie
• Yes Jim Maloway
• Yes Wayne Marston
• Didn't vote Pat Martin
• Didn't vote Tony Martin
• Didn't vote Brian Masse
• Yes Irene Mathyssen
• Yes Thomas Mulcair
• Didn't vote John Rafferty
• Didn't vote Denise Savoie
• Yes Bill Siksay
• Yes Peter Stoffer
• Yes Glenn Thibeault