Madam Speaker, I am very pleased to rise on behalf of the Bloc Québécois to participate in the debate on Bill C‑41. This bill is particularly important to me because, like anyone who is growing older, I feel personally concerned by the issue it addresses. As members can see from my white hair, I am getting older, and I do think about how I would want my life to end if I were ever diagnosed with dementia. That is why I believe Bill C‑41 is prompting vigorous debates in the House.
As a quick reminder, Bill C‑41 has three main objectives.
First, it would permanently exclude mental illness as the sole underlying medical condition for medical assistance in dying. I must say that I do not support the idea of imposing a permanent exclusion. In Quebec, we were not ready to provide MAID in such cases, but neither were we prepared to permanently close the door on the possibility.
That makes me sad because I used to work in Quebec's health care system, and I watched people with mental illness suffer for years. I am not talking about depression here. I am talking, for example, about people with schizophrenia, who tried medication and who ended up living on the streets, rejected by many of their loved ones, after exhausting all the resources of the health care system and their family caregivers.
Perhaps if they had had the right to end their life with dignity, they might have died in a much more dignified manner. I have been thinking a lot about these people as we prepare to vote on this permanent exclusion. I am sad because I think it is discriminatory, as though people with mental illness do not fully exist as people or do not have the same rights as others. I think that is unacceptable, and I believe that my colleague from Montcalm agrees with me. I expressed this opinion at the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying. I think medical professionals may not have been ready to administer this type of care, but I believe that we should have continued to study this issue.
The reality is that people with mental illness will once again be forced to turn to the Supreme Court to defend their rights. In a few years, they may well succeed. However, it seems profoundly unfair that individuals who are already vulnerable and fragile should bear the burden of fighting for their rights.
The bill also establishes a comprehensive framework for advance requests, including eligibility criteria. In doing so, it responds in part to a request made by Quebec, where MAID has been available since 2024 to patients who have made an advance request. As members know, Quebec is currently the only province that allows advance requests for MAID. This framework addresses a very real need. At present, some physicians provide MAID to patients who have made advance requests, yet they continue to face criminal and civil legal uncertainty because the Criminal Code has not been amended. Bill C-41 therefore responds to Quebec's request. It provides protection for medical practitioners and gives eligible individuals the right to make an advance request for MAID.
Advance requests for MAID are based on principles that have been the subject of extensive public debate in Quebec in all sorts of circumstances. Our thinking has evolved considerably. As we know, self-determination is a principle, indeed a value, that is very important in Quebec. People have the right to decide. They have the right to make their own choices, whether that means receiving MAID, opting for palliative care or making an advance request.
In response to my Conservative colleagues, advance requests are imposed on no one. It is the individual who makes the request, while still capable of making decisions for themselves, in anticipation of a time when they may feel they are no longer the person they once were. No one is required to have an advance request imposed on them. A person must choose to make such a request, and even then, the fact that a request has been made does not mean it will be carried out when the person or their loved ones ask for it.
Self-determination, the right to dignity, and free and informed consent are important. These three principles guide Quebec's Act Respecting End-of-Life Care. We have made significant progress on this.
As for advance requests, some of the provisions in the bill give me pause and cause me concern. That is why we in the Bloc Québécois will give the bill our support in principle so that we can discuss it in greater depth in committee and hear from experts on certain aspects of the bill that, in my view, could call into question people's true intentions when they draft an advance request.
I often provide an example, because people talk about advance requests as though they were something done on a whim, without much thought. I believe, rather, that those who have done so gave it careful consideration. First of all, to have access to care under an advance request, the person has to receive a diagnosis. It is not like they write it into their will, forget about it, and then receive MAID when the will is executed. I sometimes hear the Conservatives say things that give me the impression their perspective is rather simplistic.
The request is made when the person is capable of making decisions, has received a diagnosis, and is making decisions about the stage reached. For example, this could be when the person no longer recognizes their husband, wife, children or grandchildren. At this stage, some people prefer that their life end with dignity, rather than die as a different person.
In its eligibility criteria clarifications, the bill implies that the request and the criteria set by the person may not always be fully met. This leads us to the whole issue of “happy” dementia. I do not know whether my colleagues have heard of it before. I am a former social worker. I worked in special care units at a local community services and long-term care facility for persons with dementia.
To be honest, happy dementia advances the idealized image of a person who wanders a little, causes little bother, smiles, sings, watches television practically all day long, who might knit a little, never makes much of a fuss, no longer recognizes their family members, but can still laugh. It is the person who does not upset the system, but who is a completely different person than they once were.
The advance request states that, if that were to happen and I am no longer the same person, I would like to leave with dignity, even if I seem happy.
This reminds me of a story. It is not a very pleasant one, but it illustrates my point. When I was a social worker in the special care unit of a long-term care facility, there was a woman who was very attracted to the men in the unit. She was looking for physical intimacy. She would take off all of her clothes. She had lost all her inhibitions. However, we looked into her life story and found out that this woman had devoted her life to Jesus Christ. She was a nun, a member of a religious community. This woman, who had chosen to be celibate and to suppress her sexual desires her entire life, had happy dementia. She was very friendly. However, if she had had the opportunity to make an advance request, would this nun, who had devoted her entire life to Jesus Christ, have wanted to end her days naked and looking for intimacy in the special care unit of a long-term care facility? I do not think that I am wrong in saying that no, she would not have wanted to live out her final days like that. Of course, for the care workers and staff, this behaviour was disturbing but ultimately not that big of a deal. In any case, she was very happy.
I would therefore caution against idealizing dementia. We must always take into account the person's wishes, their free and informed choice when they receive such a diagnosis and make a decision.
I encourage my colleagues to adopt the principle of the bill so that we can hear from experts in committee and pass Bill C-41.