Evidence of meeting #50 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was advertising.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Marty Deacon  Senator, Ontario, ISG
Desjardins  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Broadcasters
Nauta  Program Director, Work and Economics, Cardus

Noon

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Okay. I'm—

Noon

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

I don't want to challenge your ruling right away. I believe it would be appropriate to hear submissions on this.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

You can challenge the chair's ruling.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

No, you can't debate this. You do not have the floor.

Noon

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Madam Chair, you're saying that faith is not part of Canadian culture. That is the precedent you are setting.

Voices

Oh, oh!

Noon

Liberal

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

I have a point of order, Chair.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

That is not what I said, and you do not have the floor.

Noon

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

That is the precedent you are setting. It is an incredibly dangerous precedent.

I challenge the ruling.

Noon

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

[Technical difficulty—Editor] have a historic attribution given to them by the heritage department.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

We're calling the vote. Please stop debating.

(Ruling of the chair sustained: yeas 7; nays 4)

We're at noon, but I hope the sponsors of the bill can stay for an extra few minutes so we can get some more questions in. I'm sorry that you haven't had as much time to talk about your legislation as normal. If you have some extra time, we'll continue with your testimony.

I'm going to turn the floor over to Ms. Royer for five minutes.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you, Senator Deacon and MP Chagger. I have deep respect for the work you've been doing on this.

Ads are everywhere. We have a public health crisis and a societal crisis. A member of my riding wrote, “Our family has been devastated by online sports betting.” The industry targets the vulnerable. In particular, a generation of young men are exposed to the dangers of gambling and gambling addiction. Lives are being ruined on smart phones.

I have three questions. If you don't have enough time, please follow up with answers later.

Number one, if restrictions on advertising or responsible gambling requirements become stricter in Canada, is there a risk that bettors will shift to international sites?

Number two, do you believe gambling operators should bear greater financial responsibility for the costs associated with problem gambling—including prevention, research and treatment—and, if so, what role should legislation play?

Number three, the volume of sports-betting advertisements during sporting events and on social media may normalize gambling for young Canadians. How does Bill S-211 address that concern, and what additional measures, if any, are needed to protect youth?

I'll go to both of you.

Thank you.

12:05 p.m.

Senator, Ontario, ISG

Marty Deacon

Thank you for the questions. I may come back and ask for some clarification.

I'm going to start off by saying that the intent of the bill has several tentacles. If we get a framework or some common understanding established, there are a couple of things that could happen. It could be whistle-to-whistle bans, meaning that from 10 minutes before competition starts to 10 minutes after competition stops, there is no advertising permitted. It could be time of day. It could be the use or non-use of celebrities. There are different things we could do to make these less appealing. I want to be clear on those as some of the possibilities, based on your last question about normalization and how we could get at this.

I think your first question was around international seepage. If we tighten things up—you're absolutely right—we cannot control the international imperative. We can't control what happens. It probably happens right now. What we're hopeful we can control is our own story. That could happen. There could be blocks. There could be no way to get on these sites. There could be ways that enhance.... We don't know that international piece. It's something we are aware of and monitor, but I can't respond as to what that would look like.

What I'm hoping is that we can do better work where we are.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

Got it.

Senator Deacon, I'm going to interrupt, and you can follow up later with written details.

I'd also like to understand how it is that each of you decided to tackle this particular issue. Why did you ultimately decide to go the route of a Senate public bill as the mechanism? What are the limitations to what you can tackle through a Senate public bill or a private member's bill?

Thank you.

12:05 p.m.

Senator, Ontario, ISG

Marty Deacon

Post the single sport event betting bill, we saw a problem very quickly. We voted for that bill, so we wondered what we could do.

It took a lot of work—months—before we came to the floor of the Senate to say, “What can we do? What is the history of tobacco, cannabis and alcohol? What threshold can we set?” Working with the clerks, the law and previous rulings, we decided on a partial ban and we decided to set up a bill in the Senate. We wanted to get going and do the very best we could to minimize this problem.

The framework group could ask for a full ban. That's beyond my purview. However, that's where it started and why it started in the Senate.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

Is the framework the ideal mechanism, or is it just a starting point?

12:05 p.m.

Senator, Ontario, ISG

Marty Deacon

You're right on both accounts. The framework is important because we want a minimum standard across this country. Once those folks and the stakeholders get together to develop a framework, they may find, through the expertise in that group, that it may look different, based on consultation.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

Please follow up with some written information, because I know we have limited time. Our time together has been reduced quite a bit.

Lastly, if you had all the power of the federal and provincial governments behind you, what would you truly want to see done about sports betting and related ads?

12:10 p.m.

Senator, Ontario, ISG

Marty Deacon

That's a good question.

If I had all the power and if all the stars aligned, I would love a full ban on advertising, end of story.

Bardish Chagger Liberal Waterloo, ON

I would just add that I think there is actually a lot of power in the federal and provincial governments. There are certain jurisdictions that are maybe the outliers.

The concern is this: Will the model in Ontario, which is now being followed by Alberta, be the norm? Based on conversations I've had with stakeholders, there are other provinces considering it. If we think there's an abundance of online advertising at the current time, what will that look like when more provinces are entering that space? I can't foresee it being better; I think it would be worse. That's where there is a responsibility.

We are the government. We legalized sports betting less than a decade ago. We legalized cannabis, and I don't see any advertising enticing vulnerable communities to dabble in that space. What's happening with sports betting is the complete opposite. There are people who would call themselves responsible gamblers. There are people who recognize that addiction is a reality. When it's causing harm to individuals, families and communities, the federal government has a responsibility. This framework or this conversation is saying to bring the experts and the provinces to the table and to figure out the best way. A number of provinces are complaining about getting Ontario ads in their provinces. Perhaps tomorrow other provinces will be complaining about other provinces' ads coming in.

Clearly, something needs to be done.

Zoe Royer Liberal Port Moody—Coquitlam, BC

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Our next questioner will be Mr. Champoux. However, I think we are ready to move on to our next witnesses.

I want to thank the sponsors very much for their time today and for bringing this legislation forward.

I will suspend for a couple of minutes while we get ready for our next panel of witnesses.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

I mentioned before we rose for the break that it will be Mr. Champoux's turn for two and a half minutes. Then we'll move on to Mrs. Thomas and Mr. Ntumba for five minutes each.

First, we will have opening statements from our new witnesses.

Online, we have with us Kevin Desjardins from the Canadian Association of Broadcasters.

Here in the room with us is Renze Nauta from Cardus.

We'll start with you, Mr. Desjardins. You have five minutes for an opening statement. The floor is yours.

Kevin Desjardins President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Broadcasters

Thank you and good afternoon, Madam Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to appear today. I am Kevin Desjardins. I'm the president and CEO of the Canadian Association of Broadcasters, representing Canada's private radio and television broadcasters.

Let me begin by emphasizing that our members recognize the importance of responsible sports-betting advertising, particularly when it comes to protecting minors and vulnerable Canadians. Our concern is that the bill before you appears to assume that there is a significant regulatory gap that needs to be addressed without first establishing whether such a gap actually exists.

Sports-betting advertising in Canada is already subject to substantial regulation. In provinces such as Ontario and Alberta, licensed gaming operators must comply with detailed advertising requirements. These are supplemented by the Canadian Gaming Association's national code for responsible gaming advertising, which is independently administered by Ad Standards. These include restrictions on ads directed at minors, the use of athletes or celebrities, misleading representations, inducements and requirements relating to responsible gambling.

Broadcasters are also subject to established advertising standards and compliance mechanisms. Before Parliament creates another layer of regulation, we believe it should first ask what specific problem we are trying to solve that isn't already addressed by these mechanisms.

This brings me to our second concern, which is that additional restrictions on Canadian broadcasters could inadvertently push advertising to less regulated offshore and digital platforms. Canadian broadcasters are identifiable, accountable businesses operating under Canadian law. By contrast, enforcement is far harder with offshore gambling operators and global social media platforms. If restrictions fall mainly on Canadian broadcasters, ad dollars are likely to flow to those less accountable platforms, and ultimately that won't reduce exposure. It could actually make it worse. The goal should be a more accountable advertising ecosystem, not the opposite.

Our third concern is that licensed operators use advertising to identify themselves to Canadians and communicate safeguards like age checks and responsible gambling measures. Canadians already have access to offshore gambling services that may not be subject to Canadian consumer protections. Restricting visibility of licensed operators could make it harder for Canadians to distinguish legitimate services from illegal or unregulated ones.

Finally, the bill is written as though more restrictions on advertising are a given, rather than first assessing whether current regulations work. Our recommendation is that the federal government work with provincial regulators and industry stakeholders before establishing any additional requirements. The objective should be meaningful protection for Canadians and not simply additional restrictions on the Canadian media organizations that are easiest to regulate. Any new framework must also account for the reality that Canadian broadcasters compete with global platforms that don't face the same oversight.

In short, we support responsible advertising and meaningful consumer protection, but duplication and unintended harm should be avoided.

Thank you. I look forward to any questions.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you very much. We'll turn the floor over now to Mr. Nauta from Cardus.

You have five minutes, sir.