Evidence of meeting #50 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was advertising.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Marty Deacon  Senator, Ontario, ISG
Desjardins  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Broadcasters
Nauta  Program Director, Work and Economics, Cardus

Renze Nauta Program Director, Work and Economics, Cardus

Thank you, Madam Chair.

My name is Renze Nauta. I'm a researcher at Cardus, a research institute that examines how society's institutions can support human dignity and the common good. I direct a research program at Cardus that looks at the role of economic institutions in supporting human flourishing. This led us to study the gambling industry and the impact of online gambling on Canadians' lives.

Our position on Bill S-211 is that it correctly identifies gambling advertisements as a serious public policy issue and that it is a good start in addressing it. At the same time, we believe this bill must be strengthened. Fundamentally, we believe that advertising for gambling should be treated in a similar way to how advertising for alcohol, tobacco and cannabis is treated, which is regulated by the federal government.

Let's start with some background. As members know, Parliament legalized single-event sports betting in 2021. The following year, Ontario became the first province to liberalize its online gambling market, opening it up to the private sector. Alberta followed suit earlier this year and Quebec is likely to follow.

The experience of Ontario is a useful indicator for where the rest of the country may be going, but the statistics on gambling in Ontario have become deeply disturbing. The latest data from iGaming Ontario show that Ontarians hold over 1.3 million player accounts across the various online gambling platforms. They wager nearly $10 billion every month. Of greatest concern, the average player account in Ontario loses over $300 per month. That's not how much they wager; it's how much they lose. Put another way, the average account in Ontario loses nearly $4,000 per year. I will flag that as a conservative estimate of how much individual people lose each month, since a person can hold multiple player accounts at once.

To put this in perspective, experts say it's not safe to lose more than 1% of your family income on gambling. Ontario is at 3.4 times that amount today.

Advertising is a significant part of the problem. Anyone who has watched sports lately is keenly aware of this. One study found that Ontarians were subject to 2.8 references to sports betting every minute during live sports broadcasts.

It wasn't supposed to be this way. When Parliament legalized single-event sports betting, it was argued that the goal was to bring the activity that was already being done on the black market into the legal market, allowing the government to regulate and tax it. That's fair enough. We can agree or disagree, but it's a fair public policy goal. The amount of advertising that we have seen since then defies that goal. The whole purpose of advertising is to increase demand. Companies wouldn't be pouring as much money into it if they didn't know it was working to do exactly that.

Parliament is strongly justified in acting in the face of this. I generally do not favour government interference in markets, but we must acknowledge that this is a market of a different type where the data show that the product is becoming dangerous, especially to young people.

This bill starts a conversation about what to do about it, but it can be strengthened to address the urgency of this issue in the following ways.

First, amend paragraph 3(2)(a) to ban sports-betting advertisements completely, or, at the very least, ban them during sports broadcasts when children are most likely to be watching, as the United Kingdom does. Ban advertising for in-game bets, a form of betting that is especially prone to addictive behaviour.

Second, add a provision to paragraph 3(2)(b) requiring gambling corporations to contribute financially to problem-gambling research, prevention and treatment. Their contributions should be at least equal to the amount they spend on advertising.

Third, add a new paragraph to subclause 3(2) to improve gambling prevention messaging. Standard tag lines, like “Know your limit, play within it”, do not convey the addictive nature of the product. This bill should require that the framework establish guidelines for gambling prevention messaging more along the lines of, “What are you prepared to lose today? Set a deposit limit.”

I believe these amendments would significantly strengthen the bill and are necessary to make this industry safe for Canadians to participate in.

Thank you, Madam Chair.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

I will turn the floor over now to Mr. Champoux.

You have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'd like to thank the witnesses for being with us for what little time remains in this meeting.

Mr. Desjardins, I'll start with you because you presented the perspective of broadcasters, who are already subject to a particularly heavy regulatory burden. My question is about advertising.

Approximately how much annual revenue does gambling advertising generate, province by province? Do you have any sense of those figures?

12:30 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Broadcasters

Kevin Desjardins

No, we don't really have an exact figure for these numbers. In fact, we're currently seeing a reduction in the number of ads. I'm not talking about the revenue they generate, but really the number of ads. There was a time when there were a lot of them. Perhaps that was because it was a new market and several companies wanted to establish themselves and were competing with one another. Now, we're seeing that the number of ads is starting to fall.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

I'll return to the example of Quebec, because, once again, even though the arguments in favour of the bill are made in good faith and are based on good intentions, I'm not convinced, as the fact remains that we're talking about something that falls—and must fall—within the exclusive jurisdiction of the provinces.

In Quebec, for example, Loto-Québec manages the gambling system, online betting and sports betting, and it reinvests a great deal of money in advertising campaigns that promote responsible gambling. Indeed, this is a very responsible way of using revenue from online gambling.

Rather than the federal government passing a bill that seeks to encroach upon the areas of jurisdiction of the National Assembly of Quebec and the provincial legislatures, rather than interfering in decisions that should be taken by them, would it not be preferable for the provinces to work together, to follow the example of those where things are going well, and to adopt the best practices that have proven successful elsewhere?

12:30 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Broadcasters

Kevin Desjardins

I would say that it is very much the provinces' responsibility to manage this. As you said, in 1985, there was an agreement between the provinces and the federal government on—

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you, Mr. Desjardins. We're out of time for this question.

I'm going to hand the floor over to Mrs. Thomas now for five minutes.

12:30 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Thank you.

Mr. Nauta, I'm going to ask you a couple of questions.

Can you clarify the jurisdiction of this legislation, Bill S-211, with regard to advertising? There is some argument to be made that this should be left with the provinces and that the federal government should not intervene. Of course, this bill calls for exactly that—a federal framework would be developed.

Can you comment on why that may be in the jurisdiction of the federal government and in our best interests as Canadians?

12:30 p.m.

Program Director, Work and Economics, Cardus

Renze Nauta

The first thing I'd point to is precedent. Like we've said, the advertising of gambling should follow that of alcohol, tobacco and cannabis. Alcohol advertising is governed by CRTC regulations. Tobacco advertising is governed by the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act, which was passed by the federal Parliament. Cannabis advertising is under the Cannabis Act, which was also passed by the federal Parliament. It's precedent.

The other thing is there are international aspects to this as well. Certainly, there are going to have to be negotiations between Canada and the United States with respect to international games, because the NHL is a North American phenomenon.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

That's fair enough. Thank you. I appreciate that.

Further to that, in your opening remarks, you referred to the impact that sports advertising is having on minors and luring them into placing bets. Then, of course, that translates into an impact on their mental health.

Do you care to comment on that a little bit more?

12:35 p.m.

Program Director, Work and Economics, Cardus

Renze Nauta

Absolutely. I think it's something that was not well prepared for in Ontario, and it is having significant impacts.

There was a study earlier this year that showed data from a mental health helpline by ConnexOntario, for example. It compared the incoming calls about mental health from before and after legalization with respect to gambling. For men aged 25 to 44, the difference was that those phone calls almost doubled. For men and boys aged 15 to 24, it had more than doubled; it increased 161%.

There have also been many stories lately about how minors are accessing this, even though there are attempts to restrict their access to it. From an advertising perspective, this is one of the greatest problems. Even if there are attempts to restrict minors from accessing the gambling sites, they are absolutely being found by the advertising. My seven-year-old son, for example, knows what online gambling is, and I don't think it's appropriate that, just because he wants to watch the World Cup, he is subject to that. That is one of the greatest concerns that I have.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

That's fair enough.

I'm curious, again, about your allusion to the dangers of in-game betting. Do you care to offer a brief comment with regard to that?

12:35 p.m.

Program Director, Work and Economics, Cardus

Renze Nauta

In-game bets are a form of betting that happens, as the name suggests, within the game.

It used to be, before online gambling came along, that you would place a bet on a game, and then you would sit back, watch the match and find out at the end whether you had won.

Nowadays, because it's in your pocket and it's accessible at any time, there's this new phenomenon of being able to place bets as things are going. Instead of just betting on who's going to win the match, you can bet on who's going to score the next goal, how many goals will be scored or which team is going to score first or second in the third period.

It leads to a much quicker rate of gambling more akin to a slot machine than anything else. That's where some of the dopamine hits really start flowing. It makes it much more addictive.

We're calling for a complete ban on advertising for sports betting, but at the very least, we should be looking at a ban on advertising for those kinds of bets.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

I appreciate that, and I also appreciate the detail with which you outlined a number of amendments that can be made to this bill. I think that's really helpful and something that I hope that we as a committee will have further discussion on as we make those decisions on Tuesday, going through the bill clause by clause.

At this point, I'll hand the mic over to Mr. Lawton.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Thank you. I have a motion, Madam Chair, and I would like to speak to it as well. I move:

That the committee recognize that:

1. Faith and religion are integral to Canadian history, culture, traditions and national identity;

2. Houses of worship and faith-based organizations make significant contributions to communities through charitable work, social services and the preservation of cultural heritage;

3. Historic religious buildings and faith traditions are important parts of Canada’s tangible and intangible heritage and merit preservation for future generations; and

That this be reported to the House.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

I have a speaking list starting with Mrs. Thomas, then Mr. Hardy and—

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

I said I was speaking to it too.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

I'm sorry. Go ahead.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

This is a very important motion that fits squarely within the mandate of the heritage committee, and I will say that the reason I'm moving this now is because earlier in this meeting I attempted to move another motion that dealt specifically with some of the attacks facing faith communities. I had started to mention attacks on churches, mosques and synagogues in the ridings of the members around the table here, representing a range of faiths. When that was ruled out of order, it actually raised what I am concerned is a very dangerous precedent, which is that we do not recognize the integral role that faith and faith communities play in the cultural fabric of this country.

I would note that this committee has in the past entertained motions, debates and discussions on hate crimes, on matters to do with the Criminal Code. I have a list of motions that I found just in the last 30 minutes that have been accepted, debated and sometimes adopted, from members on both sides, dealing with the Criminal Code. Oftentimes, when assaults on identity and heritage take place, these are illegal, but we have to underpin that with an acknowledgement of the role that these organizations play.

I remember when one of your colleagues, Marc Miller at the justice committee—about a year ago to the day, actually—said that people should face criminal prosecution for quoting certain verses of the Torah and the Bible. A lot of faith communities were understandably mortified by that comment from someone who's now the minister responsible for Canadian heritage and identity because it showed a lack of recognition of the positive role that faith communities and people of faith play in this country.

A few weeks ago, the St. Thomas Islamic Centre, a Muslim mosque, hosted an interfaith gathering that I was very honoured to attend. We had representatives of Christian groups, Sikh groups and Hindu groups sitting in a mosque talking about the way that faith communities can work together to support the betterment of society. We also have, of course, opportunities all the time as members to go to various celebrations. We need to understand that, but we also need to understand the attacks that take place against faith communities.

I mentioned the Afzaal family's murder in London. I mentioned the attack at the Quebec Islamic centre. I also mentioned the 133 churches that have been burned and vandalized, including, as I was starting to say earlier, in Madame Auguste's riding.

I believe that in Hamilton we've seen Hindu temples subjected to break-ins and thefts. The Beth Jacob Synagogue was defaced with hate graffiti. The Hamilton Downtown Mosque...and arson as well at the First Unitarian Church. As well, at St. John the Baptist Catholic Church, there was a break-in. Altars were burned. There was about $75,000 in damage.

All of us on this committee have examples of this in our ridings. I've noted that there seems to be an imbalance in when political leaders speak out about these. I think we need to stand up for hate against all faith communities. I would have argued to have a study on this. Now, that was not the prerogative for the chair, but we do need to, at a minimum, recognize the role that faith communities play.

This is incredibly timely now because we have seen the finance committee in the last Parliament recommend that faith organizations not be allowed to have charitable status.

Fortunately, with the prorogation and dissolution of Parliament, that recommendation died. I will note, however, that the finance committee's pre-budget consultation in this Parliament did have a provision that organizations that have a particular view on matters of life should be denied charitable status. If we start making the determination that charitable status should be dependent on the views of an organization in matters of conscience, we are de-legitimizing the role that faith and religion play in Canadian society.

This does not mean that everyone needs to adhere to a faith or a religion, not at all, but we need to recognize the tremendous work that faith-based organizations do, whether it's Indwell on housing, The Salvation Army or the individual mosques, synagogues and temples that are running food programs to deal with the food affordability crisis that has been allowed, sadly, to blossom on the Liberal government's watch.

All of this is why I think that, at a minimum, this committee needs to recognize the role that faith institutions play in our country, and that is a positive role.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you, Mr. Lawton.

I will note that, unlike the last motion you submitted, this one does not call for changes to the Criminal Code. Therefore, it does fall within the mandate of this committee and is in order.

I will turn the floor over to Mrs. Thomas, who is next on my list.

12:40 p.m.

Conservative

Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB

Thank you, Chair.

The motion that my colleague has moved here today has to do with public concern that has grown in this country around the increase in censorship that is happening at the hands of the current government and the encroachment on freedom of expression within Canada. In particular, he is drawing special attention to religious freedom and the conversation around that.

Here's why it's so important. When speech is restricted, when Canadians are not able to hold a variety of viewpoints and express those viewpoints freely, it then actually restricts the flow of ideas, and it puts instead a dangerous amount of power in the hands of government. It puts a concentration of power in the hands of government.

I'll give you an example.

Bill C-11 was put in place by the Liberals. It requires that certain online content be given preference over other content. This government would argue that, even though certain preference is given, it's not taking the speech away altogether. For example, certain content will have to be bumped up in a person's search, and it will be given preference on the very first page of your search. However, other content will fall to page 53. Now, we all know that we don't read to page 53 when we do a quick Google search. As a result, this actually is censoring speech because it's giving preference to some over others.

It's akin to saying that, in a library, all books can exist. We believe in a myriad of viewpoints. They can be here. However, there are certain books that will be allowed on the first floor, and certain that will be allowed on the second, and certain allowed on the third. Then there will be this other category of books that will be tucked away in a storage room somewhere in a back corner. If you dare search for it, you'll find it. Then we claim that all books are treated with equal value, that all people who would use this library would be given equal access to these different ideas.

In fact, is that the protection of free speech? Is that protection of all ideas and viewpoints? I would argue no. I believe most Canadians would agree with that.

It's like saying to someone that they have free speech, the ability to share an idea with the general population. However, the only place from which they can speak is in some basement room with a locked door. Do they have the ability to speak? Absolutely, they have the ability to speak. This government would contend that free speech is protected.

There's another side to be considered, however. Within our charter, we not only have the right to express an idea; we have the right to be heard. By locking that person in a basement room with a locked door, yes, they had the ability to speak, but they did not have the ability to be heard. Bill C-11 does exactly that within the online space. It's a direct infringement on our rights and freedoms as Canadians.

Now, we are looking at other bills that potentially do the same. We'll have an opportunity to talk about those more at this committee. Our concern on this side of the table is this. When legislation is put in place that slowly but surely erodes the rights and freedoms of Canadians and their ability to hold a true belief and express that belief publicly, we enter into a very dangerous space.

The public square should be an area where we are able to join as a community, as a country, etc. and exchange ideas. Maybe we disagree, and that's great. Let's have the debate. To shut down that debate is altogether wrong. In fact, it can actually cause the problem to fester even more. The search for truth should be done in the public square. It should be done in that robust place rather than pushing people to the fringes where potentially harm and violence can fester and come forward.

Further to that, when infringement on free speech takes place, or when government overreaches, it causes people to censor their own voice. It causes them to go small. It causes them to go quiet. In many cases, it causes certain religious groups or certain faith groups to shrink back. Bill C-9 is a great example of this. It was put forward by this government in the name of wanting to protect faith groups, but in fact it actually causes many faith groups to shrink back, because the provisions within that bill allow for the potential prosecution of holding certain beliefs and of those beliefs reaching public airwaves.

This is a problem in our country. If we cannot agree to protect one another's right to believe certain things, to engage in certain faiths, of our choice as the Canadian people, if we do not respect that freedom, then we enter into a very dangerous place as a nation. It very quickly takes us towards countries like North Korea, Iran, Turkey and China. We do not want to go there.

The motion that my colleague Mr. Lawton has moved here today with regard to a study on this issue is very important. We must make sure that we are in fact protecting Canadians and their ability to believe what they want to believe, to speak what they want to speak, to exist within the rights and freedoms that are granted to them in the charter. Let's take the time. Let's look at that and make sure that our country is doing well.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Mr. Hardy, you have the floor.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

I will read through the motion point by point, very briefly, to give my views on it, but it is very important that we adopt it today, for several reasons. Firstly, it states:

1. Faith and religion are integral to Canadian history, culture, traditions, and national identity;

I would even go so far as to say that they are an integral part of the national identity of both Canada and Quebec. Indeed, if there is one thing we know for certain, it is that the Christian faith and the values that have been upheld within that faith in Quebec since the very beginning—such as equality, respect, mutual support and love for others, and the common good—are, ultimately, part of the very foundation of our communities. This is what led people to work together and help one another to build monuments. Churches are at the heart of almost every town in Quebec. It all began around a church.

So, this reality—which is our past, for better or for worse, although I am not saying everything was perfect—led people from elsewhere to settle on another continent and build a nation. I truly believe we must not forget this, because without those values, there would be no schools or hospitals. A person's right to be recognized not by what they have in their bank account, but by their worth as a human being, stems from that. If we do not recognize this right and are unable to protect it, we are putting our history and our identity at serious risk. It is the committee's job here to ensure that we never forget this.

People often ask where secularism fits into all this. Once again, there have been many dogmas and many things done in the name of the bible or the Church. However, if we go back to the actual facts of the bible, there is a man called Jesus who said: “Render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and unto God the things that are God's”. That is a secular statement. It means that we must separate the state from religion.

Often, people are afraid and say that religion must be removed from everything and that we should no longer talk about it. On the contrary, it is our history. That is where we come from. When we do not know what is written in these books, we are sometimes afraid of them, even though there are very simple principles regarding the separation of church and state within the bible itself.

Secondly, it is written:

2. Houses of worship and faith-based organizations make significant contributions to communities through charitable work, social services, and the preservation of cultural heritage;

As I said, our schools, our hospitals and all the organizations that help the needy are often based on the values upon which our country was founded.

Thirdly, it states:

3. Historic religious buildings and faith traditions are important parts of Canada's tangible and intangible heritage and merit preservation for future generations;

As I said earlier, and as we are seeing happen in many countries, when people want to erase history, they start by erasing all the monuments of the past. In this way, young people will grow up without seeing these monuments and without wondering who was there before them. For example, in Iran, which was once a free country, what was the first thing they did? They destroyed the monuments. I'm talking about Iran, but all the great conquerors in human history have done the same. They arrive in a country, they don't agree with what they see, and they want to destroy the monuments. We remember Napoleon, who fired cannonballs at the Sphinx at Giza. The idea is to erase history to ensure that future generations will not see it.

I believe that our buildings which, at some point in their history, were linked to a faith—I mentioned the cross at L'Isle-aux-Coudres, in particular—just like our churches, must never be sacrificed in the name of the prevailing popular sentiment of the moment regarding how we would like history to have been written. The facts are important. We do not want to rewrite history; we want to live through it, learn from it, acknowledge it and protect it, and then move forward as a society.

So, I believe this is a motion that is entirely appropriate for the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage. It is directly linked to the history of Quebec, which subsequently founded the rest of the country. So, I believe we should adopt this motion.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

Mr. Kuruc, you have the floor next. Then I have Mr. Al Soud, and that's the end of my list.

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'd like to touch on my colleague's point number three:

Historic religious buildings and faith traditions are important parts of Canada's tangible and intangible heritage and merit preservation for future generations;

I want to touch on that because Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, Hamilton in general, has not been exempt from acts of violence on its religious institutions. I want to list some of those.

First, we have the Hindu Samaj Temple. Then we also have the Hamilton Mountain Mosque, which is in my riding. We also have the mosque on Stone Church Road, the Ibrahim Jame Mosque on King Street East and the Hamilton Downtown Mosque. We have the Beth Jacob Synagogue. We have the Immanuel Christian Reformed Church and St. Paul's Presbyterian Church. We also have The First Unitarian Church, St. John the Baptist Catholic Church, St. Mary's Catholic Church, Meadowlands Fellowship Church and Hamilton Christian Fellowship.

These are all religious institutions that have not escaped attacks or vandalism. One of them, the very first one, the Hindu Samaj Temple, was burned. These are unthinkable acts that we're speaking of in a country like Canada, where a major part of its population are immigrants, and we have a vast and widely accepted and loved religious framework. Canada accepts all religions. It loves all religions, and they are celebrated, and rightly so. I do believe that this is a very important part of this heritage committee.

I support this non-partisan study so that we can reinforce to Canadians that government supports all religious freedoms. That's something that I personally believe, along with many of my colleagues, was lost in Bill C-9.

For the community that I represent, Bill C-9 caused fear, confusion and trauma, and I believe it caused those three things to many Canadians. We need, and actually owe it to Canadians, to set the record straight, that freedom of religion is important and is a fundamental building block of Canadian society.

I support my colleague Andrew Lawton's motion on this, and I believe it's exactly where it belongs—in this heritage committee. I hope, then, that we get the support of our Liberal colleagues and our Bloc colleagues along the way because I truly believe this is a non-partisan motion.

Thank you.