Evidence of meeting #50 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was advertising.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Marty Deacon  Senator, Ontario, ISG
Desjardins  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Broadcasters
Nauta  Program Director, Work and Economics, Cardus

1:10 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

That's a very good point, and I'll give him that.

Essentially, my colleagues are saying that they agree with the motion as a whole, but that they do not want what is happening here in the House to be reported, even though it is the very job of an MP to represent the people and to speak about their issues so that Parliament is aware of what is going on. I believe the work we do in Parliament is important. So, by proposing to strip away the essence of the motion we are putting forward, they are seeking to undermine that. Furthermore, the first thing the chair said after reading out the motion was that it concerned the tabling of a report in the House. I believe that, quite intuitively, she understood where we were heading, but then her colleagues did not seem keen to go in that direction.

However, what I find truly troubling is the fact that it is up to others to decide the importance of motions. Whenever we propose something, it is never important enough, or it is not important right now. We are told that it might be important at some other time. The questions raised in committee by the opposition, which must be loyal to the people and the nation, are important. Our job is not to applaud the government. Our job is to take current events into account and to raise these issues in committee so that they can be debated.

We're constantly being told that we're engaging in political games and that there are more important things to do. We're told this in the House and we're told this here. Personally, I think that's a problem. If my colleagues want there to be no partisanship, they should stop deciding what is or isn't a priority based on their own opinions.

So, I believe that removing this element, as Mr. Al Soud proposes, is a problem. The Liberal MPs' initial reaction was to say they agreed with all of this. If they agree, we simply need to adopt it and everyone will be happy. What is more, when people watch the clips, they will think it is good that the members of this committee are able to agree because they think everything is fine. So, if there's no political manoeuvring, there's no problem. We just need to go ahead with it. However, people cannot help but engage in political manoeuvring by proposing to remove part of the motion. I think that's where the problem lies.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Mr. Champoux, you have the floor.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

This is quite entertaining. Personally, Mr. Hardy, I can't believe the Liberals are claiming that this debate is just for the sake of making sound bites. It really is attributing bad intentions to Conservative MPs to suggest they're just making sound bites. Frankly, I think that's in bad faith!

Some hon. members

Oh, oh!

1:10 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

That annoys me.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

I understand your indignation.

Madam Chair, I had nothing in particular to add on this subject. I think the Bloc Québécois's position is quite clear. Quebec is a secular state. Canada claims to be a secular state. I do not think these are matters for this committee to discuss, but, having said that, that is why I am not getting further involved in this discussion and am leaving it to my colleagues to debate.

However, I think it would be courteous of us, given that the debate on this subject seems to be dragging on, to release the witnesses if they wish to leave.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you, Mr. Desjardins and Mr. Nauta, for your presence here today. I'm sorry that we got a little off track, but we won't need you any longer for questions today. If you would like to leave, you are welcome to. If you would like to stay and be further entertained by this discussion, you are also welcome to do that.

Mr. Lawton.

1:15 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

It would be out of order, but I would love to ask our witness questions about this motion. I'm sure that, given his work at Cardus, he would have a lot of very strong opinions. I invite him to submit those to the committee, if he does have any. I will say that Cardus does tremendous work acknowledging the role that faith and faith institutions play in Canadian society. Back when I worked in media, they were always tremendous at adding context to the issue we have at hand here.

I want to be mindful, as always, about what we're actually debating. This is the amendment specifically on whether to remove “That this be reported to the House.” There was a very specific reason that line was in the original motion.

Often, what happens in committees can take place in a bit of an echo chamber. We do things all the time, and ultimately committees are products of the House of Commons. Committees are masters of their own domain in terms of how they run their affairs, but they are creatures of Parliament, which means that the work we do is to serve and support Parliament. We study, debate and amend legislation that comes from Parliament, then goes back to Parliament. We initiate studies that are meant not just to entertain ourselves, I speak for myself, but to support the work that the government does, which is supposed to be for Canadians. There might be some differentiation on whether that is the case.

I think it's lovely that we could all speak, and that Mr. Al Soud agreed with 97% of the motion. That's good, and I think it speaks to why this isn't a political game. Everything in here is something that people on all sides of the House should be able to recognize.

The benefit of it being reported to the House is twofold. Number one, we get to have a very serious debate at a time when it makes sense in the House of Commons, if Parliament so chooses, on matters that require a very open discussion, on the role that faith plays in Canadian society and the role that religious freedom plays, that philanthropy done by faith organization plays.

I bet it would be wonderful to have the opportunity, when there are so many attacks on faith institutions, for every member of the House of Commons who chooses to share, as Mr. Al Soud did, as Mr. Kuruc did and as I did, examples of faith communities in our own ridings that are doing tremendous work and give some of these communities that have been besieged by hate, animosity, attacks online and in some cases, sadly, attacks in person, the opportunity to recognize this important work.

I mentioned a few of the examples. About a block from my office, Indwell, which is a Christian charity that serves and supports everyone, is taking over an old school to turn it into transitional housing for people who need it. They are motivated by their faith beliefs to serve. Last week on Parliament Hill, we had representatives from the Canadian Foodgrains Bank, an organization I know members from all sides have had relationships with. They have two growing projects in my riding. Again, it's a Christian organization that is serving people around the world, regardless of faith, ensuring they can eat. They do this because they are motivated by their faith.

There are so many opportunities to look around in our country and see people who have all sorts of negative things to say about people of faith. I've seen it on my own social media page. We post a picture with this religious group at this religious institution, and we have to turn off the comments because of the hostility and bigotry that exists towards people of pretty much all faith groups. Some deal with it more acutely than others, but everyone is dealing with it.

This is not an issue that is so small as to be confined to the heritage committee. This is, further to your point earlier, Madam Chair, an issue that, if you really brought it out, touches on the criminal justice system. It touches on women and gender issues. It touches on issues that actually affect other committees. Rather than having every committee introduce its own motion that deals with their own strain of it, it would be far more suitable for us to have this motion, lead the charge as the heritage committee, report it to the House, so that if and when an opportunity arises in the House where members want to discuss this, that option is there.

This is not something that hijacks the government's agenda. It's not something that trumps legislation before the House. As we've seen, the Liberal government has had no shortage of opportunities to flex its new-found majority to push its agenda forward. I suspect if they ever want to do that again, they can and will, so this is not taking away anything from Parliament. It's adding an option for all members.

I am mindful of the time here. I think we have a good-faith agreement on the essence of the motion. If our issue is just on this line, I'm hoping that's something that we can work towards.

Understanding that question period is approaching, I move to suspend the meeting.

(Motion negatived: nays 6; yeas 5)

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

We will continue. I have Mr. Kuruc next on the list.

1:20 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'd like to recognize that Mr. Al Soud did acknowledge that, principally, the motion is widely accepted. I was happy to hear that, but he lost me when he used the term “political game”. I found that very interesting because his recommendation to cut out the part where it says “report to the House” becomes a very big political game.

I understand that he's very experienced in committees. We had two points of order that weren't points of order, which he knows weren't, and now we're further down the path of more political games when it shouldn't be that. I hope with his acknowledgement that this is a good motion....

I think, if the faith-based groups in his riding and my riding were asked about this, they would want it to be reported to the House. That's the essence of what this is. We want this reported to the House. This is not a political game by any means. It is the meat and potatoes of the motion. Saying that you want it out is getting into political games.

His colleague talked about clips and that we're here to clip. I know in a Liberal-perfect world, Canadians wouldn't see this, but that's not the case. The case is that, yes, I will maybe report this to my constituents and Canadians.

I do not like and I do not appreciate the authoritarian approach and vibe that I'm feeling from these Liberals. I will clip. I will send these videos, and I will let the Canadian public know what is going on in this committee, because that's exactly what our duty is as parliamentarians. I will not have anyone on that side suppress me with an idea that we should not be sharing videos with Canadians or reporting to Canadians what happens in Parliament. This is Canada. It is the land of the free. We are not a dictatorship. We're not a communist regime, so we will continue doing what we do.

I do not appreciate the tone. We are now getting way off the topic.

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

My tone was perfectly respectful.

1:20 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

I think the actual part of the motion is wholesome. I think the Liberals understand that. I think everyone at this table can acknowledge that we all support the faith-based groups in all of our communities. We respect them heavily. We just ask that this report be brought to the House.

I hope that Mr. Al Soud can understand that. I hope we can all pass this motion, because that's what it's intended to do, report it to the House.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

Mr. Ntumba, you have the floor.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

I had prepared three good questions, but, in the end, I shall not be asking them.

I will conclude by addressing my colleagues here today.

We have fully understood your approach, but we have also set out our own. We shall be happy to revisit this a little later, as it seems clear that we do not see eye to eye, due to your approach, which prevents us from aligning our positions today.

1:25 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

I have a point of order. We're not getting translation.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Mr. Ntumba, please carry on speaking so that we can check if it's working.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I had prepared three good questions for the witness, who is no longer here.

We understand our colleagues' request. It would be better if we discussed this next time, as time is almost up.

I move that the debate be adjourned.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

This is a motion to adjourn. That is a dilatory motion.

A voice

Is it to adjourn the debate or adjourn the meeting?

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

It is a motion to adjourn the meeting.

(Motion agreed to [See Minutes of Proceedings])

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

The meeting is adjourned.