Thank you, Madam Chair.
My name is Renze Nauta. I'm a researcher at Cardus, a research institute that examines how society's institutions can support human dignity and the common good. I direct a research program at Cardus that looks at the role of economic institutions in supporting human flourishing. This led us to study the gambling industry and the impact of online gambling on Canadians' lives.
Our position on Bill S-211 is that it correctly identifies gambling advertisements as a serious public policy issue and that it is a good start in addressing it. At the same time, we believe this bill must be strengthened. Fundamentally, we believe that advertising for gambling should be treated in a similar way to how advertising for alcohol, tobacco and cannabis is treated, which is regulated by the federal government.
Let's start with some background. As members know, Parliament legalized single-event sports betting in 2021. The following year, Ontario became the first province to liberalize its online gambling market, opening it up to the private sector. Alberta followed suit earlier this year and Quebec is likely to follow.
The experience of Ontario is a useful indicator for where the rest of the country may be going, but the statistics on gambling in Ontario have become deeply disturbing. The latest data from iGaming Ontario show that Ontarians hold over 1.3 million player accounts across the various online gambling platforms. They wager nearly $10 billion every month. Of greatest concern, the average player account in Ontario loses over $300 per month. That's not how much they wager; it's how much they lose. Put another way, the average account in Ontario loses nearly $4,000 per year. I will flag that as a conservative estimate of how much individual people lose each month, since a person can hold multiple player accounts at once.
To put this in perspective, experts say it's not safe to lose more than 1% of your family income on gambling. Ontario is at 3.4 times that amount today.
Advertising is a significant part of the problem. Anyone who has watched sports lately is keenly aware of this. One study found that Ontarians were subject to 2.8 references to sports betting every minute during live sports broadcasts.
It wasn't supposed to be this way. When Parliament legalized single-event sports betting, it was argued that the goal was to bring the activity that was already being done on the black market into the legal market, allowing the government to regulate and tax it. That's fair enough. We can agree or disagree, but it's a fair public policy goal. The amount of advertising that we have seen since then defies that goal. The whole purpose of advertising is to increase demand. Companies wouldn't be pouring as much money into it if they didn't know it was working to do exactly that.
Parliament is strongly justified in acting in the face of this. I generally do not favour government interference in markets, but we must acknowledge that this is a market of a different type where the data show that the product is becoming dangerous, especially to young people.
This bill starts a conversation about what to do about it, but it can be strengthened to address the urgency of this issue in the following ways.
First, amend paragraph 3(2)(a) to ban sports-betting advertisements completely, or, at the very least, ban them during sports broadcasts when children are most likely to be watching, as the United Kingdom does. Ban advertising for in-game bets, a form of betting that is especially prone to addictive behaviour.
Second, add a provision to paragraph 3(2)(b) requiring gambling corporations to contribute financially to problem-gambling research, prevention and treatment. Their contributions should be at least equal to the amount they spend on advertising.
Third, add a new paragraph to subclause 3(2) to improve gambling prevention messaging. Standard tag lines, like “Know your limit, play within it”, do not convey the addictive nature of the product. This bill should require that the framework establish guidelines for gambling prevention messaging more along the lines of, “What are you prepared to lose today? Set a deposit limit.”
I believe these amendments would significantly strengthen the bill and are necessary to make this industry safe for Canadians to participate in.
Thank you, Madam Chair.
