Go ahead, Mr. Hardy.
Evidence of meeting #50 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was advertising.
A video is available from Parliament.
Evidence of meeting #50 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was advertising.
A video is available from Parliament.
Conservative
Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC
I will just conclude on that.
Especially on student mobility, with what we see happening in Europe right now, I think every citizen in Canada and especially our youths are looking at that, and they don't want this to come into our country. We must have those discussions, because it's important at the moment that we study the impact of opening policies with this alliance and that we are able to give parliamentarians, who were elected by the people, the chance to analyze and open the discussion on this and then report to Parliament.
Thank you.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner
Since we received the notice of motion two days ago and it falls within the committee's mandate, I consider the motion to be in order.
I have Mr. Lawton, Mrs. Thomas, Mr. Al Soud, Mr. Champoux, Mr. Kuruc and then Mr. Ntumba.
We're starting with you, Mr. Lawton.
Conservative
Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON
Thank you very much, Madam Chair, and thank you sincerely to my colleague Mr. Hardy for bringing this up.
You just read the speaking list, and the number of MPs on this committee who wish to speak to this speaks to the importance of this motion.
I'm very grateful to Mr. Hardy for bringing this EU gambit by the Prime Minister into sunlight, because this is a process that has been done in a very underhanded and confusing way.
We have heard conflicting and contradictory stories. When media reporting first said that Canada was entertaining “associate membership” with the European Union, which is a category that does not exist, the Prime Minister denied it. Days later, Ursula von der Leyen extended the invitation to Canada, and Mark Carney went up on stage and gave her a big hug and expressed appreciation for it. We then heard other media reporting that it was actually Canada and the Prime Minister's Office that were pushing this in the first place.
Let me say from the outset that closer integration with the European Union through trade is entirely a positive. As a country, we need to trade with anyone we can around the world. That's why I was so proud to see the work of the former Conservative government negotiating what became CETA. It's noteworthy that even 10 or 11 years later, there are, I believe, nine European countries that have not yet ratified CETA. It should have been the priority of the Liberal government to ensure greater economic integration with Europe—not this EU associate membership idea, which, I reiterate, does not exist. This means that the wording is very important, if it's being accompanied by a suite of concessions or obligations that have not been revealed to Canadians.
It is incredibly appropriate, at a time when we are trying to assert our sovereignty and independence as a nation, to have this discussion in Parliament. I think the most suitable avenue, if it is going to be coming before a committee, is the heritage committee, which is tasked with looking at Canadian identity, culture and heritage.
We will never assert our sovereignty by being a star on someone else's flag, whether it is that of the United States or that of the European Union. To be Canada strong, which we often hear as a preferred slogan by the Liberals, we have to be Canada free and we have to be Canada independent.
I would love to hear from the Liberals exactly what it is about the EU.... They're laughing, so I guess Canadian independence is something they find amusing. I would love to hear what it is that the Liberals—
Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC
I have a point of order.
I just want to clarify. Mr. Lawton talked about an independent Canada, but I think he meant an independent Quebec.
Conservative
Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON
Anything that breaks up our country is a laughing matter, Madam Chair. Thank you for returning the floor to me.
As we talk about what this associate membership in the EU looks like, I would love to hear the Prime Minister and the Liberal government say what it is they find so fascinating about the way that the EU governs its affairs. We've been clear that Canada should never compromise our autonomy on regulations, taxation and migration. These are all things where the European Union has been a colossal failure.
You look at taxes as one example. There are parts of Europe where the sales tax is 27%. We are already dealing with a cost of living and affordability crisis here. Do we really want to cozy up to a regime where the cost of bureaucracy has driven up taxes to, in some cases, more than a quarter of the goods that are being purchased?
You look at regulations. We would be here for weeks and weeks and months and months if I were to list off all of the European regulations that have ended up making it difficult for European citizens and European businesses. I can give you just a couple of absurd examples.
The European Union caps the wattage of vacuum cleaners, so you can't even choose what vacuum cleaner you want in Europe. The European Union has insane regulations on air conditioning, which were causing people to go to the hospital and in some cases die of heat because they couldn't get air conditioning in their homes this summer. This is the consequence of European Union politics.
On migration, everyone knows the chaos that has come from European migration. One of the reasons that the United Kingdom ended up leaving the European Union was because it was so untenable for them to deal with the open borders approach that resulted in, one year about 11 years ago, well over a million people entering Germany—one country alone, one example—a country of 80 million.
When we hear about labour mobility between Canada and Europe, that means that anyone who's in Europe would potentially be able to come and work in Canada when we have already been having the discussion about whether we need to get our immigration system back in check, which we desperately do after 11 years of Liberal immigration policy.
Then there are the cultural aspects of this. It is not lost on me that less than two weeks ago, we had riots in France, where 550,000 people took to the streets; I think there were about 110,000 in Paris. Buildings were looted. They saw property vandalism, vehicles on fire and riots in Paris, Marseille, Lyon, Limoges, Bordeaux, Lille and other cities and communities up and down France.
This is not a country that we should be trying to emulate. It can't even manage unrest in its own borders, and that's just one country in Europe. The riots—and I'm not defending that at all—were coming from unrest stemming from cost of living, immigration issues and issues that people had with the education system and the way government was operating.
At this time of all, what exactly is it that's on the table in this agreement between Canada and Europe? This is a question the government should be answering, but they're not, so I'm proud to be supporting my colleague Mr. Hardy's motion to bring some sunlight onto this here.
Thank you.
Liberal
Conservative
Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB
Thank you.
I think I'll just add to both of my colleagues' really good remarks in regard to this motion and pursuing a further relationship with the EU. As you know, since 2025 Prime Minister Carney has come to the table, promising Canadians that he would have his elbows up, that he would pursue greater independence for Canada. Right now we're in a bit of a trade dispute or spat with the United States of America and, of course, Carney wants to move us away from that relationship toward having closer ties to the EU, it would seem.
However, there is something to be considered here with regard to our national independence. This potential agreement with the EU would not only be about the relationship between governments, Canada and, then, EU countries or the EU Parliament itself; rather, there's something to be considered here in terms of the conversation among Canadians themselves. My concern is that, if we're not careful in pursuing this, the voices of Canadians could be ignored.
For example, as we pursue this, what happens to indigenous rights? What happens to those treaties? What happens to the way that we govern ourselves, as a country, in that regard? What happens to our respect for French and English as the two official languages in this country? What happens in terms of our respect with regard to Quebec's being an independent nation within a nation? What happens to those things?
Do we retain our autonomy as a country? Do we retain our independence, our ability to make these decisions, or does the EU begin to dictate to us the terms that exist right here within our own borders? These are big questions with regard to our national identity and our way forward.
Then, of course, yes, there are big questions with regard to our economy and trade, regulatory frameworks, the environment, technology and digital policy, and energy and natural resources. Alberta remains a superpower in this country as regards to those things. Will that continue to be the case? Will they continue to develop? Furthermore, there is our labour and social policy, our immigration policy.
We can look at defence and national security. A country depends on those things to protect its sovereignty and its people. In fact, a government's foremost responsibility is to make sure that its citizens are kept safe and secure. How will that work in terms of Canada's relationship with the EU? Do we cede some of that sovereignty? Do we cede some of those decisions with regard to defence, with regard to our border defence and with regard to the safety and security of citizens, or does the Government of Canada retain that power? These are big questions, and the answers to these questions will forever impact every single Canadian citizen, not only of this generation but of future generations.
While my colleagues across the way have turned their noses up at us a bit in regard to this motion, and have laughed at times, this is serious. These questions are real, and they are in the minds of Canadians, as Prime Minister Carney has been somewhat elusive about the relationship that he is pursuing with the EU. You'll recall that it came out in the news that this relationship was being pursued, and Carney denied it, only for us to find out a couple of days later, from the president of the EU, from Ursula herself, that, in fact, it was true that an associate membership was being extended to Canada. Unfortunately, this Prime Minister, I believe, has broken trust with the Canadian people because he has not been completely honest.
We have big questions. Canadians have big questions with regard to what is going on in the conversations that are taking place right now in Montreal. Those questions deserve serious consideration, and this place, as the heritage committee, is the place to have those conversations.
I'm thankful for the motion that my colleague Mr. Hardy has brought forward. I do believe that it's incumbent upon us to give it our time and attention.
Liberal
Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON
Thank you, Madam Chair.
There's a lot that's been said tied to the Prime Minister's commitment to the French language, to Canadian culture. My simple response would be that he has thus far been absolutely unequivocal in his commitment to both. He has been unequivocal as it pertains to Canadian sovereignty, directly as it pertains to our conversations with the United States and the trade war currently taking place. There is no reason to believe that he would relent on that commitment as it would pertain to conversations tied to the EU.
Ms. Thomas has indicated that there are conversations that are vital, that should be taking place in relation to this conversation. I don't disagree: There is a time and place for conversations like this.
She made mention of the impact on Canadians. At the same time, we have a conversation taking place today tied to sports gambling, which also has an impact on young Canadians. Out of respect for our sponsors, who have dedicated countless hours to put forward this kind of work.... Perhaps the Conservatives care very little for young Canadians' safety within the online spaces as it pertains to gambling online. We certainly do.
Conservative
Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB
On a point of order, let's refrain from insinuating things.
Conservative
Rachael Thomas Conservative Lethbridge, AB
Chair, excuse me. There is a point of order there, because personal attacks are not fair game at a committee like this.
Conservative
Conservative
Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON
In terms of the procedure around this, and I believe it's under chapter 22 of the green book, we've seen this before, where this is going. Every time this comes up, the Liberals have a motion to adjourn. I would invite the members to vote on the motion and not try to get away from it, like they do every single time.
Liberal
Liberal
Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON
Chair, quite frankly, it's frustrating that the Conservatives would try to take the rules we have in these institutions, the good faith with which we've operated at this committee, the constant note and tone of collaboration we've engaged with, and try to turn this into a political démarche.
With that note, Madam Chair, I move to adjourn debate.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner
That is a dilatory motion. The clerk will call the vote.
(Motion agreed to: yeas 6; nays 5)
I am going to turn the floor over to Mr. Coteau now.
Welcome back to the heritage committee. You have six minutes.