Thank you.
My next question is for Mr. Rafii.
How does Bill C‑223 undermine judicial discretion?
Evidence of meeting #42 for Justice and Human Rights in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was child.
A recording is available from Parliament.
Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families
In multiple provisions, in all four of the provisions I mentioned, the fact that they don't have discretion on parental alienation is real. It affects both men and women. They need to have discretion to assess on an individual basis.
On the issue of claims of intimate partner violence, a very significant percentage of claims of child abuse and intimate partner violence are in fact false, to get an upper hand in child custody cases. I'm not saying that's a majority, but it's a very significant percentage. Judges need that assessment. On the issue of having maximum contact, it's absolutely critical that judges are able to assess that.
As I mentioned, we know about the rate of intimate partner violence in jurisdictions that have a rebuttable presumption of equal share co-parenting. They have reduced intimate partner violence by 50% to 70%, and domestic homicide by 8%. That's not a surprise, because we're reducing conflict. By limiting a judge's discretion, you're in fact increasing conflict, and conflict increases intimate partner violence. That's the reason that jurisdictions with better equal parenting have reduced conflict and reduced intimate partner violence. It affects everything.
Bloc
Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC
Thank you.
My next question is again for Mr. Rafii.
What are the dangers of this bill, specifically for children?
Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families
Well, there are the dangers we just mentioned. I really appreciated honourable member Cody sharing what she did. The fact that children commit suicide when they lose a father is very common. Children who lose a father are four times more likely to attempt suicide and have a whole bunch of other outcomes. The example that the MP mentioned is very common for children who lose a father. The examples are absolutely horrible.
My suggestion is to not go by anecdotes and stories only. Basically, all the peer-reviewed data says that if somebody loses a father unnecessarily, there is a huge impact on those children.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid
Thank you, Mr. Beaulieu. That concludes your time.
Moving to our second round, we will begin Ms. Kirkland.
You have five minutes. Please go ahead.
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
Thank you, Chair.
Ms. Zaccour, did your association have a large part to play in helping to draft this bill?
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
My association launched a campaign, supported by 300 women's organizations across Canada, that advocated for this reform—
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
I'm sorry. I have such a short time.
Did your organization help with this bill?
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
We made recommendations that are reflected in some of the provisions.
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
You said earlier that a lot of things being said about the bill are not actually in the bill. I'd like to read a section directly from the bill on factors not to be considered. It says very clearly:
Factor not to be considered
(3.1) In determining what is in the best interests of the child, the court shall not take into consideration any allegation that a spouse has, or is likely to, through deliberate manipulation, persuade or encourage a child to become estranged from or resist contact with the other spouse.
You gave some examples in your testimony that were extremely heart-wrenching and horrible. It is my opinion that those are examples of bad decisions made by bad judges. That does happen, absolutely. Of the examples you gave, did any of them occur after 2021?
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
Yes, absolutely. Both the New Brunswick and the Ontario examples I gave were after 2021.
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
Is it possible that if we change the law the way this bill would, it could force good judges to make bad decisions, based on the part I just read from the bill?
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
I believe this will lead to better decisions because it doesn't prevent the admissibility of evidence of concrete behaviours, but does prevent the focus on brainwashing.
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
But it does prevent that. It says very clearly in what I read that those factors must not be considered.
We know that sometimes there's no founded family violence when there is, in fact, family violence. This happens especially with narcissistic abusers. They can make it seem like the woman is the problem. My conclusion is that this could harm more women and children unintentionally through these portions of this bill.
The Alberta Family Lawyers Association, other family lawyers, professional researchers and researchers have said that they believe this bill would result in the opposite intention of the bill, which would increase violence against women and children. How do you square that circle?
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
I'm here to present my opinion based on my expertise of nearly 10 years of research.
We see—as we've also heard from the Regroupement and so many other associations—how the litigation tactic of alienation leads to unsafe outcomes. The systematic studies show that it's not just a few bad decisions or a few bad judges. It's very common.
We believe this would improve outcomes.
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
I'm a family law researcher. I've testified before the Supreme Court, but I haven't represented family law clients.
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
On the idea of not considering parental alienation, which is absolutely part of the bill and is one of the harshest criticisms of the bill, could it not also harm victims of intimate partner violence? As I said previously in the first hour, an abuser, especially a narcissistic one, can also alienate a child from a victim. Could they not?
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
I was looking forward to that question. We've often been asked what a victim of abuse is going to argue if she can't argue parental alienation. The answer is abuse. We believe that in cases of family violence, we should focus on the “family violence” factor that Parliament adopted in 2021—
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
I'm sorry. Thank you. I appreciate that. That's the answer I was thinking you would give, but parental alienation is sometimes an example of abuse. It can be part of psychological abuse.
Sometimes when we're talking about that, parental alienation will come up. As soon as that comes up, if this bill bars judges from considering it, how does that work for an arbitrator?
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
Once again, this section says that the inference of manipulation, the claim of manipulation, cannot be considered, but it says nothing of particular behaviours, and of course, any behaviours can be put into evidence to argue other things. For example, if a parent is disrespecting a court order or denigrating in any form, that is family violence. It doesn't affect the behaviours that courts will have discretion to consider.
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
Essentially, then, it will have no effect at all. That's how I'm seeing this.
Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
It will have the effect of preventing judges from inferring that a child has been brainwashed and then disregarding their perspective and the evidence of family violence.
Conservative
Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON
How can a judge make an appropriate decision if they're not allowed to consider all pieces of information? That's really the concern I have. A judge, an arbitrator or a mediator has to consider every nuance of what is happening. We have to leave some things to their discretion.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid
Thank you very much. That concludes your time.
We're now moving to Mr. Chang for five minutes.
Please go ahead.