Evidence of meeting #42 for Justice and Human Rights in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was child.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

S. Chuang  Professor, University of Guelph, As an Individual
A. Barkauskas  President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association
Nadeau  President, Barreau du Québec
Le Grand Alary  Lawyer, Secretariat of the Order and Legal Affairs, Barreau du Québec
Laberge  Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec
Rafii  Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families
Zaccour  Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
Trou  Head of Écho Institute, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale
Brien  Co-Lead on Political Affairs, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you very much for that, Mr. Rafii.

We're now moving to the National Association of Women and the Law.

Please go ahead, Suzanne.

Suzanne Zaccour Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Thank you, Madam Chair.

My name is Suzanne Zaccour. I am a lawyer with a Ph.D. from the University of Oxford, and I have spent nearly a decade researching issues of parental alienation, domestic violence and family law. I represent the National Association of Women and the Law, whose recent and current projects on family law and parental alienation have included interviews with lawyers, service providers and professionals in seven provinces and territories.

Several members and witnesses have expressed concerns that it is harmful to cut off a child from a safe and loving parental figure. We agree. That's why we're here echoing the voices of nearly 300 mothers—some here today with us and some watching from home—who have shared their stories with us. Many of them have had no contact with their children for 50 days, 300 days, 500 days and even up to five to seven years.

One survivor, whose children were flown to the U.S. for forced reunification therapy and who had no contact with her children for over 500 days, wrote to us after listening to this committee. She said, “The risk of losing contact with a child cannot be considered from only one side.”

Contrast these extreme no-contact orders with research documenting how reluctant the courts are to sever contact with fathers who are proven abusers. As one parenting assessor we interviewed in Nova Scotia expressed, “It would be really, really extreme for me to recommend no access at all [for an abusive father]. Like, axe murderer extreme.”

To understand these outcomes, we need to look at how alienation arguments shift the focus away from evidence of family violence. My study of 10 years of appellate jurisprudence in Quebec found that in alienation cases, domestic violence can disappear completely from the file, meaning that the judge made no mention of domestic violence allegations, evidence and even admissions.

A finding of alienation can be based on almost anything. Mothers are blamed for unconsciously transmitting their fear of the father, for breastfeeding, for being too rigid in following the court order, for hiring a babysitter, for not having a photo of their ex on display in their home or for not inviting the father, who assaulted them while pregnant, to the newborn's baptism party. These are all real examples.

Another real example is a published 2021 Ontario decision where the father had pleaded guilty to assaulting the mother, yet the judge wrote that the father had never been violent toward the mother. The judge gave no consideration to any family violence factors and reversed custody immediately. That meant the child had to have no contact whatsoever with the mother, not even to say goodbye, and no contact with anyone else who was close to the mother. The father was allowed to prevent the child from using any electronic devices. Police were allowed to physically enforce the order. The mother was ordered to pay up to $35,000 in reunification therapy costs and $175,000 in legal costs to the father, who pleaded guilty to assaulting her.

In this case—and others—what's interesting is that the judge criticized the mother for both alleging that the father was dangerous and supporting the father-child relationship, which a lot of victims of abuse do. As we've heard from many survivors, experts and shelters, the law gives victims no viable solution. If they support father-child contact, their allegations of violence are not credible, but if they don't support father-child contact, it's alienation. It's a real catch-22 in our Divorce Act that needs to be reformed.

Shelters report that many survivors are choosing to return to their abuser rather than face family courts, because at least then they can see their child and try to protect them and deflect abuse. Even in cases where the protective parent “wins”, it's after years of abuse. In a 2025 New Brunswick case, the court dismissed the father's alienation claim, but only after six years of litigation, and by that time, the child had been sexually abused by the father during the forced contact with him.

When survivors say, “I wish I'd never left” or “I wish I'd never called for help”, we know we've failed as a society, because no matter what GBV policies we put in place, they're doomed to failure if the law actively dissuades victims from speaking up. Our children deserve better. They deserve solutions. This is why NAWL has supported Bill C-223. I'll be very happy to take any questions on its measures or any proposed amendments.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you very much. I really appreciate how you timed that perfectly.

We're now moving to our last organization, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale.

Please go ahead. Collectively, you have five minutes.

Mathilde Trou Head of Écho Institute, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you for inviting me to participate in this meeting.

The Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale comprises 47 shelters located across 16 regions of Quebec. Every day, our members take in women and children who are victims of domestic violence and help them navigate the process. Our workers have key knowledge of how the systems responsible for providing protection operate, particularly the family courts.

The Institut Écho operates under the umbrella of the Regroupement. It supports professionals, particularly in the socio‑judicial field, who work with victims of domestic violence. It provides training and tools to help them better identify and document coercive control, as well as opportunities for collaboration in order to strengthen the safety net around victims. We're in close contact with these socio‑judicial stakeholders.

We would like to point out that, in Canada, exposure to domestic violence accounts for 34% of cases handled by child protection services. International studies also show that children exposed to domestic violence face an increased risk of physical abuse or neglect by the abusive parent, as well as sexual violence, particularly incest.

Bill C‑223 is pursuing essential goals with regard to child safety.

First, when legal counsel screens for domestic violence risks, they can make informed decisions that protect the rights of mothers and children who are victims. However, these legal experts must be properly trained to identify and document coercive control and its impact on victims. Only through proper screening can legal counsel request appropriate protective measures for women and children. These measures include safe temporary arrangements, protection orders, supervised contact and exemption from mediation.

Second, the courts must carry out a more thorough assessment of the effects of coercive control on the parent‑child relationship in order to better protect the child.

The abusive parent's coercive control undermines the mother‑child relationship. The roles of spouse and mother within a family are inseparable in daily life. Why should it be any different in the eyes of the law? Behaviours that seek to control, belittle and isolate the mother undermine her ability to parent and thereby harm her relationship with her child.

Elise Brien Co-Lead on Political Affairs, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

Mothers are having to contend with impossible orders from an institution that is supposed to protect them. If these women don't say something about the violence they and their children are experiencing, their behaviour is seen as neglect, and if they do say something, their behaviour is seen as alienation. Recently, a woman receiving support from one of our member shelters sought legal help to initiate divorce and custody proceedings. When she told her lawyer she was seeking a divorce because her partner was abusive towards her, the lawyer advised her not to talk about the partner's behaviour, because she could be accused of parental alienation.

Countless studies have shown that, in domestic violence cases, the abuser alleges parental alienation as a way to conceal the violence and keep the victims, the mother and children, quiet.

When one parent is dangerous and one parent is protective, it is essential to prevent the dangerous parent from doing harm and to ensure the safety of the protective parent in order to keep the child safe. That means allowing contact to be cut off and providing for that possibility, so the child can live without being afraid all the time, so they can be a child and focus on growing up, learning and playing, instead of dealing with the anguish caused by the contact with the violent parent. That means doing away with the presumption that parenting time and decision-making responsibility should be shared equally by both parents.

Third, the bill gives children the right to express their views freely and to be heard in all legal proceedings that affect them, by requiring that the information be obtained directly from them.

Bill C‑223 compels us to take a long, hard look at how the justice system treats children. What if it recognized the right of the child instead of the right to the child? Bill C‑223 compels us to move beyond the “childist”, or ageist, mindset, where the child is viewed as the possession or extension of the adult. The best interests of the child should be based on the needs of the child, not of the adult. Those working at our member shelters, as well as other professionals, bear witness daily to the fact that abusive spouses are men who put their needs first, not their children's. Most of them are incapable of putting their children's basic needs first.

To the outside world, when a child appears in court, it's just a hearing, but to the child, it's their whole life hanging in the balance, being decided by someone else. It is essential to talk to them at their level, to listen to them and, above all, to hear what they have to say. I repeat, that means accepting that parenting time and decision-making authority should not always be shared equally by both parents.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you so very much. I really appreciate that.

We'll go into our first round of questions for six minutes, starting with MP Cody.

Please go ahead.

Connie Cody Conservative Cambridge, ON

Thank you, and through you, Chair, thank you to the witnesses for being here today.

I believe everyone shares the same goal—protecting children and ensuring their safety and well-being.

Before I ask my question, I would like to share something very personal. My husband and I spent a long time discussing whether we should tell this story. It is not easy to revisit, and even today it remains painful, but we ultimately decided that if sharing our family's experience could help another child, then it was a story worth being told.

When we discuss family law, court processes and legislation, it can be easy to lose sight of the child at the centre of those decisions. My husband had a son from a previous relationship. I came into his life when he was very young, and I loved him as my own. In our home, he was simply our son. A relationship between adults can end. A loving and non-violent parent-child relationship should not.

When I read Bill C-223 and saw the section that recommended parental alienation be inadmissible in family court proceedings, I immediately thought of our son and our family's experience. Our story did not happen all at once. It happened slowly over many years.

At first, we believed that if we followed the court's directions, respected the process and continued doing everything we were supposed to do, our son would be able to have a healthy relationship with both parents. That's not what happened. Visits were deliberately missed. Court-ordered access was denied. Communication became increasingly difficult. We found ourselves returning to court over and over again, simply trying to preserve the relationship between a father, his son and a second family. What made it so difficult was that nothing ever seemed to change. We would go back to court, obtain another order and hope things would get better. Before long, we would find ourselves right back where we started.

Meanwhile, our son was the one caught in the middle. One of the only ways to stay connected was through phone calls. The court had ordered that we could speak with our son once a week at a specific time. We looked forward to those calls all week. Sometimes hearing his voice for a few minutes was all we hoped for, but there was never an answer. Our son told us that he could hear the phone ringing. He could see our names on the display. He knew we were calling, but he was not allowed to pick up the phone.

As parents, that was heartbreaking to hear. We knew he wanted contact. He knew we were trying, yet even something as simple as answering the phone became a source of stress and conflict for him.

There eventually came a point where we struggled with whether continuing to make those calls was helping him or hurting him. We wanted him to know that we loved him and that we would never stop trying to be part of his life. At the same time, we could see the emotional toll this was taking on him. He was the one living with the conflict. He was the one carrying feelings of guilt and responsibility that no child should ever have to carry.

As the years passed, we watched the relationship between our son and his father become weaker and weaker, not because the love was gone but because barrier after barrier kept being placed between them. There was a point when our son's mother wanted to relocate to Alberta. After reviewing the history, a judge determined that it was in our son's best interest to remain in Ontario with us. For the first time in a long time, it felt as though someone had finally understood what was happening and recognized how important it was to protect that father-son relationship.

Not long afterward, the judge who had reversed custody retired. The matter was then brought before a new judge, and everything changed. The years of history, the repeated interference with the father-son relationship, the manipulation and even the fact that our son had previously been abducted and hidden in another country carried no weight with this new judge. She decided these were not matters to be considered and never even looked at the file.

The previous decision was reversed. Permission was granted for our son to live with his mother in Alberta. The reality was that once relocated, there was very little we could do. The Ontario order existed, but it was meaningless in another province.

We took him to the airport because that was what the court required from us. I can still see that moment as clearly as if it happened yesterday. When it was time for him to leave us, he wrapped his arms around my neck and started to cry. He told me he did not want to go. He told me he had only said he wanted to because if he didn't, it would hurt his mother's feelings. As adults, we understood what those words meant. As parents, they broke our hearts.

We stood there, knowing what he was telling us yet powerless to change what was about to happen. All we could do was hug him, tell him we loved him and watch him walk toward the plane. As he disappeared from sight, I could never have imagined that it would be the last time we would see him.

It was a few years later we received a phone call from a friend. He asked if we had heard the news. We did not know what he was talking about. He told us that someone had said that our son had died. We couldn't believe it. We thought surely someone would have called us. Surely someone would have told his father that his son was gone. We began making calls, trying to find out whether it was true.

Eventually, the police had to contact his mother and advise her that she had to answer the phone and tell us what had happened. That is how we learned how our son had died.

The tragedy had had happened two weeks earlier—two weeks. Not only had we lost our son, but we had been denied the opportunity to attend his funeral. We did not get to see him one last time. We did not get to say goodbye. After years of fighting to remain part of his life, we were excluded in death as well.

We lost the battle, and we lost our son to suicide. That is why I'm sharing the story today. It's not because I can change what happened to our family. I'm sharing it because I hope that our story does not become someone else's story. Parental alienation is real. I hope that another child does not lose a loving parent because important information was never considered in court. I hope that another family does not spend years watching a parent-child relationship slowly disappear while court orders go unenforced. I hope that no parent ever experiences the heartbreak of wondering whether more could have been done to save their child.

Mr. Rafii, here is my question: What needs to be done to ensure that our story doesn't become someone else's story?

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Ms. Cody, my sincerest apologies, but that concluded your six minutes. I really want to say thank you for sharing your very empowering story.

We are going to Mr. Housefather for six minutes.

Go ahead.

Anthony Housefather Liberal Mount Royal, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I think that was absolutely a heartbreaking story.

Ms. Cody, thank you for sharing that with us. Thank you for letting everybody understand why the best interests of the child need to be at the heart of the Divorce Act and all things related to the breakup of a relationship. That being said, I want to turn to Ms. Zaccour.

Ms. Zaccour, when we first met about this bill—you and I and Ms. Hepfner—one of the things I told you was that I didn't agree with the relocation provisions in the bill. However, whether I agree with them or not, I don't want them to be misrepresented. I think in the first panel there was some discussion of the fact that a child could be abducted and brought to another province and that nothing could be done about that, even if the other parent didn't give consent and the court never approved it.

Can you talk to me about whether the bill actually says that? I don't think it does.

9:50 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

Unfortunately, sometimes some of the criticism of the bill is about things that have been said about the bill rather than what is in the bill.

The bill does not change the notice requirements for relocation. It changes the burden of proof, which takes place if all else is equal. That's what a burden of proof or presumption does. It clarifies that courts cannot tell parents where to live; they can only tell the child where to live.

The section that was referred to is about inferences that courts may or may not make from certain circumstances. It does not prevent any evidence from being admitted, as was said about evidence of prior inconsistent statements. There is nothing like that in the bill.

The notice requirement for relocation stays the same. The bill only says that, in and of itself, taking a child out of a home where there is violence is not against the child's best interests. It doesn't say that the court can't order the return of the child. It doesn't say that a parent doesn't have to give notice if they want to actually, in law, relocate the child.

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to clarify.

Anthony Housefather Liberal Mount Royal, QC

I want to give you another opportunity.

A lot of hypotheticals have been tossed out over the days of hearings. I know you've been listening to them attentively. Are there any hypotheticals that have been answered—or, in your view, incorrectly answered—that you want to clarify in terms of how they would play out?

9:50 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

A few witnesses and comments have said that if we don't allow judges to infer that a child is being brainwashed, courts won't be able to do anything about parents withholding contact or denigrating. This is incorrect. Courts commonly give orders to parents that will say, “You're not allowed to denigrate” or “You can only communicate through these means” or “You have to give contact in this way.” The orders are not optional. Parenting orders are mandatory. If someone does not respect them, they can be fined, and they can even go to jail.

It's not true that the only way to address problematic behaviours is through custody reversals, assuming a child is brainwashed, and reunification camps. There are many other tools that courts have for addressing them.

Anthony Housefather Liberal Mount Royal, QC

My colleague Ms. Hepfner advised that she's brought a number of amendments to this bill to clarify various provisions and to deal with certain concerns that have been addressed. Two of the provisions that have received tons of attention are the parental alienation provision and the question of relocation.

Can you talk to us, though, about other provisions of the bill that are simple, common-sense provisions adopted by provinces like British Columbia and are not controversial or are much less controversial and much more agreed upon by virtually the entire family law membership of people working in this area?

9:50 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

There are a lot of provisions in the bill beyond the specific alienation provisions, including the removal of what has been called the maximum contact provision, which the Supreme Court has recognized that judges mis-characterize as a presumption of shared custody, and the removal of the friendly parent rule, which doesn't exist in B.C.

That is what I was referring to when I talked about a court that receives allegations of violence from a parent who says that she is prepared to support the relationship with the father. The court will say, “She thinks it's only bad for her if I don't believe her, but it's also bad for her if I believe her that the father was abusive, because then why is she supporting a relationship?” This provision is highly problematic, as was noted by the Senate in 2019, when the amendments passed.

I think it's really important to focus on what the bill does and not what is said about the bill. For example, the bill does not prevent evidence of any behaviour from being put forward to the judge, including withholding behaviours and denigration. It only talks to the inferences or the allegations that can be made.

I want to reassure the committee that this bill would in no way prevent parents from providing evidence that visits were missed or that there's denigration. The idea is that children are their own people. The argument shouldn't be that they have been brainwashed so we shouldn't listen to them, but rather that we should listen to what the child says and evaluate the allegations based on the normal credibility assessments that judges do.

Anthony Housefather Liberal Mount Royal, QC

Do I have any time left, Madam Chair?

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

You have 30 seconds.

Anthony Housefather Liberal Mount Royal, QC

In some of the studies that have been raised, a very limited number of children have been interviewed for the study. For one, in Ontario, I think there were six children.

Can you talk to us a little about whether or not it's possible to retain a relationship with both parents in the event that...? You know what I'm talking about, so quickly jump in.

9:55 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

Unfortunately, the orders that are made in situations of alleged parental alienation do not typically result in the children having a good relationship with both parents. Even the witnesses who have brought the contrary perspective by saying that they believe they were alienated have said themselves that the system did not work for them.

Unfortunately, the law cannot mandate love. The research also shows that sometimes what is best for children is to give them space to repair relationships rather than keeping children in court for five years, 10 years or 11 years, forcing a child to have a relationship with one parent to the detriment of the relationship with the other parent.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you.

Ms. Zaccour, I recommend slowing down a bit so that the interpreters are not chasing after you to interpret.

Mr. Beaulieu, please go ahead for six minutes.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

My first question is for the representatives of Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale.

You write that an abusive father can turn the child against their mother. Under this bill, the judge would no longer be able to recognize that. How, then, will the mother be able to defend herself?

9:55 a.m.

Co-Lead on Political Affairs, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

Elise Brien

Thank you for your question.

Actually, the bill says that, instead of working from the assumption that the child is being manipulated, the judge has to look at the actual behaviours in question. Therefore, any behaviour that seeks to disparage, humiliate or isolate the other parent warrants consideration under Bill C‑223.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Under the bill, a parent will be allowed to leave with the child without notifying the other parent, if they claim it is to flee violence. An abusive father could do the same.

What's stopping him from posing as the victim in order to take the child?

9:55 a.m.

Head of Écho Institute, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

Mathilde Trou

Again, as other witnesses have said, training on intimate partner and family violence is really the most important thing. The ability to document and identify coercive control is paramount, and that applies to all the actors in the legal system, from legal advisers and lawyers to judges. That knowledge is necessary to properly differentiate between false allegations and domestic violence. That's really the best way to protect women and children.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

The bill applies only to parents who are married. Therefore, two children staying at the same shelter in Quebec would not be entitled to the same protection, simply because their parents were or weren't married.

Do you think that's okay?

9:55 a.m.

Co-Lead on Political Affairs, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

Elise Brien

In the past, judges have applied the best interests of the child principle in a consistent way, such that the children of both married and common-law parents enjoyed the same rights. You're right that children really have no control over their parents' marital status, so why should they have different rights?

The rights available to children whose parents are married could organically be extended to those whose parents are not, and vice versa. Provincial laws could follow suit if the federal government took the first step, obviously.

Furthermore, protecting one-third of children is still protecting a lot of children, so it's a positive step forward. If that creates the momentum to protect the remaining two-thirds of children, we would of course welcome that. It would be a good thing.