I did hear the testimony of the Canadian Bar Association, which is recommending that allegations of parental alienation not be allowed in cases involving violence, which, according to the Quebec bar, is consistent with the case law. There is some disagreement on that.
The judicial discretion issue comes up a lot, and people tend to think that the decision-maker should have full discretion and that no factor should be eliminated, because it makes for worse decisions. However, the Divorce Act already limits what the judge can consider.
Previously, it was within the judge's discretion to consider violence, but now that is mandatory. What's more, the Divorce Act explicitly stipulates a factor not to be considered.
Accordingly, it is the role of Parliament to tell judges how to use their discretion, not that they must use it.