Evidence of meeting #42 for Justice and Human Rights in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was child.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

S. Chuang  Professor, University of Guelph, As an Individual
A. Barkauskas  President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association
Nadeau  President, Barreau du Québec
Le Grand Alary  Lawyer, Secretariat of the Order and Legal Affairs, Barreau du Québec
Laberge  Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec
Rafii  Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families
Zaccour  Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
Trou  Head of Écho Institute, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale
Brien  Co-Lead on Political Affairs, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

Thank you, Chair.

It's good to see you again, Ms. Zaccour. Thank you so much for your advocacy on behalf of children and survivors of family violence.

In your written submission, you suggest changes to the original parental alienation provision in this bill. Could you explain why you're recommending these changes and how they would help to protect children and survivors from unintended harms?

10:05 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

NAWL has suggested different ways that provisions to curtail allegations of alienation to protect victims of violence can be introduced. One is preventing the allegations, as in the bill.

Another approach would be to prevent certain inferences—as in the “myths and stereotypes” provision—and say that courts should not be able to infer that just because a child is afraid, the mother is alienating, for example. One of the proposals we make is to do it a different way, and the committee will judge whichever way is most appropriate. There are many techniques for this, as long as the outcome is preventing these really problematic decisions.

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

We have heard that judges need more training or education on family violence, coercive control and situations where children resist contact with a parent. How much of a difference would better training or education make in addressing the concerns you have raised?

10:10 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

Very little, in my opinion, and the reason is that court of appeal decisions in provinces are finding that the mother is alienating despite a finding of family violence, including criminal convictions in some cases, or admissions of violence.

For judges, their responsibility is to follow the law. That takes precedence over training. Even if you give them training that says they should not find, for example, parental alienation if they also find domestic violence, they're just going to turn to the law. The only way to change the law is through legislation. Once the law is changed, training will be essential.

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

Are you saying that further training is not helping the situation?

10:10 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

The problem is that further training cannot change the law. Training can only explain the law. It cannot substitute a change in legislation or achieve the same things. It can achieve other things, like getting judges to apply the law or—

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

Can it change judges' perspectives?

10:10 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

That's unlikely, because judges who sit on these cases are hearing the parental alienation experts testify daily. That's extremely common. It's unlikely that an hour-long training a year ago would have changed the culture of the courts, compared with what they're seeing in the decisions rendered by a court of appeal—which they have to follow—or the arguments or expertise they hear.

No one is ever against training, but it will not accomplish what this bill seeks to accomplish. It can accomplish other things. For example, regarding relocation, some of the changes in the bill are to codify things that are already in the law that judges may misapply. In that sense, education can be helpful for things that are already in the law but that judges are misapplying. However, if the state of the law is, for example, the friendly parent rule, you can't educate judges out of applying the law as it is.

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

The Divorce Act already requires judges to consider children's views and preferences. What more do you think is required to make sure children's voices are heard fairly and safely in those cases?

10:10 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

There's jurisprudence in several provinces. Even though the Divorce Act says that they have to consider children's views and preferences, judges have decided there's an exception. If there's parental alienation, they don't have to consider their views—which is, in my view, problematic, but that's where the jurisprudence has gone.

That needs to be changed so judges always consider children's views and preferences, which is different from children deciding. They don't decide, but they are entitled to their views.

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

Thank you very much.

Mr. Rafii, when family violence is alleged, how can we make sure children are protected while allowing judges to look at the full picture of each case, rather than relying on assumptions about either parent?

10:10 a.m.

Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families

Bijan Rafii

Number one, we have to ensure that we are not relying on stereotypes. Both men and women are victims of intimate partner violence. Surprisingly, even to me, it's at about the same level, although men report intimate partner violence at about one-third the rate of women.

We have to make sure every allegation of intimate partner violence is validated. We can't say that if one person says it, it has to be true. We have to make sure there is evidence of it, and the evidence has to be overwhelming. Also, as MP Cody mentioned, people change. If something happened 10 years ago, we cannot hold that it's still true. We have to make sure the evidence is still valid.

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you very much. That concludes your time.

Finally, Monsieur Beaulieu, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Please go ahead.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Thank you.

Ms. Zaccour, my first question is for you.

Bill C‑223 eliminates the friendly parent provision and prohibits consideration of parental alienation.

How will a non-violent parent who is the victim of parental alienation still be able to protect their relationship with the child?

10:10 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

Thank you for your question.

In order to protect the relationship with the child, judges use orders that aren't required to be based on the determination that the child was brainwashed, which is what this bill captures. That means judges can issue an order imposing a schedule for parenting time. They can also order that a particular method of communication be used.

Those are some of the ways judges can still protect parenting time under this bill.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

According to both the Canadian and Quebec bar associations, the measures in Bill C‑223 unduly limit the judge's discretion.

What do you say to that?

10:15 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

I did hear the testimony of the Canadian Bar Association, which is recommending that allegations of parental alienation not be allowed in cases involving violence, which, according to the Quebec bar, is consistent with the case law. There is some disagreement on that.

The judicial discretion issue comes up a lot, and people tend to think that the decision-maker should have full discretion and that no factor should be eliminated, because it makes for worse decisions. However, the Divorce Act already limits what the judge can consider.

Previously, it was within the judge's discretion to consider violence, but now that is mandatory. What's more, the Divorce Act explicitly stipulates a factor not to be considered.

Accordingly, it is the role of Parliament to tell judges how to use their discretion, not that they must use it.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

In the Bloc Québécois, we are in favour of protecting children and victims, but we have heard from hundreds of victims of parental alienation and survivors of domestic violence. We recommend listening to all those victims, not disregarding them. Parental alienation is real. I don't think any one person is the sole possessor of the truth.

That's basically where we stand.

10:15 a.m.

Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law

Suzanne Zaccour

What's interesting is that people who tell the court that they experienced parental alienation almost always speak negatively about the courts in their accounts. They say that they weren't properly listened to, that they weren't protected, that the decisions weren't in the best interests of the child.

That tells me that there is a consensus that the way the courts handle these cases isn't working. The research also shows that.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

I'd like to know whether Mr. Rafii agrees.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

I'm so sorry. That is the conclusion of your time, sir.

As I say to all witnesses, if there's additional information you'd like to provide the committee, please do so in writing through our clerk.

With that, I want to say thank you to all witnesses for sharing their insights with us today on this very important bill.

I believe Mr. Maloney has a very quick motion to move.

James Maloney Liberal Etobicoke—Lakeshore, ON

I do, Madam Chair. Thank you.

I would like to move, pursuant to Standing Order 97.1, that this committee request an extension of 30 sitting days to consider Bill S-233, an act to amend the Criminal Code regarding assault against persons who provide health services and first responders, referred to the committee on Wednesday, May 27, and that the committee require additional time to hear from witnesses and complete the study on the bill.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Is that okay with everybody?

(Motion agreed to)

Thank you.

With that, the meeting is adjourned.