Evidence of meeting #42 for Justice and Human Rights in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was child.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

S. Chuang  Professor, University of Guelph, As an Individual
A. Barkauskas  President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association
Nadeau  President, Barreau du Québec
Le Grand Alary  Lawyer, Secretariat of the Order and Legal Affairs, Barreau du Québec
Laberge  Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec
Rafii  Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families
Zaccour  Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
Trou  Head of Écho Institute, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale
Brien  Co-Lead on Political Affairs, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

My question is addressed to the representatives of the Barreau du Québec.

You are proposing to adopt the criteria set out by the Quebec Court of Appeal in the Droit de la famille—24915 decision.

Could you explain to us the criteria used by the Quebec courts for a judge to conclude that parental alienation has taken place?

8:55 a.m.

President, Barreau du Québec

Marcel-Olivier Nadeau

Thank you for your question, Mr. Beaulieu.

I'll let Ms. Laberge answer the question.

8:55 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

With regard to findings of parental alienation, it is important to note that allegations of parental alienation often arise in legal proceedings, whether or not violence is involved. It is very important to mention this. It is, however, quite difficult for judges, and even for lawyers, to determine who is telling the truth in such cases.

The Quebec Court of Appeal's judgment in Droit de la famille—24915 provides a definition of parental alienation. The context was somewhat different, as this judgment was handed down in the context of a civil liability claim where the aim was to establish the concept of fault. At the very least, it clarified certain points, even though case law did not necessarily always agree on the same definition of parental alienation or on the standard required to conclude that parental alienation was present. It should be noted that this concept is also the subject of some controversy within the field of psychology.

In any case, what we observe is that, in every definition we come across, it really requires behaviour that is inappropriate given the family dynamics, that is systematic, and whose aim is to exclude the other parent.

That said, these are still just labels. It is good to be aware of the issue, and I believe it is a priority to raise awareness among judges and solicitors through fairly in-depth training to help them distinguish fact from fiction. The fact remains that, in every case—whether or not parental alienation is present, whether or not there is domestic violence—we must ask ourselves what is in the child's best interests. In every instance, it is worthwhile, and indeed necessary, to examine all the circumstances.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Thank you.

The court of appeal says that there can't be parental alienation if the parent making the complaint has engaged in inappropriate behaviour, such as violence.

Can an abusive father successfully claim parental alienation in Quebec?

8:55 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

The court of appeal says that, in order to make a finding of parental alienation, there must be no legitimate reason for the child to distance themselves from their parent. For example, in a case of abuse, a child might sometimes have a perfectly legitimate reason for wanting to distance themselves from the abusive parent. In that case, of course, there wouldn't be a finding of parental alienation. Parental alienation basically means one parent brainwashing the child in order to turn them against the other parent, but without a valid or sufficient reason.

We're seeing something on the ground that raises concerns. I think that the bill is trying to address this issue, but I'm not sure whether it's taking the correct approach. We're seeing that, in cases involving allegations of domestic violence, the parent—the mother—who is the victim of the violence will naturally want to protect the children and certainly limit contact with the other parent as much as possible. The other parent, using parental alienation, will often claim that the mother is making up allegations of abuse and that she wants to keep the children from seeing him. In these cases, we must determine whether alienation or abuse is taking place.

Each time, we need to step back a bit from these labels and from the urge to assign blame. We should look at the situation as a whole and ask what solution serves the child's best interests. Of course, these two concepts often come up as a defence whenever someone refers to these types of situations. I think that we should let the judges hear the evidence so that they can make a decision.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Why should alienation be regulated by criteria rather than banned entirely?

9 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

I think that, if we ban evidence of parental alienation, we'll be harming certain children who are genuine victims of parental alienation and who aren't experiencing other forms of abuse from the parent.

If parental alienation claims are prohibited, some children will be exposed to this type of brainwashing by one parent regarding the other parent. They will have no say in the matter, and their interests won't be protected.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

If the judge can no longer recognize manipulation, what happens to a parent whose child has truly been turned against them, including a mother who is a victim?

9 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

If the judge can no longer recognize alienation, and if a parent—for example, a mother who is a victim of abuse—can't argue that the other parent is engaging in parental alienation, we can indeed wonder what would happen.

I believe that alienation must remain an argument for consideration. Otherwise, all the circumstances that the judge must consider in order to render a decision in the best interests of the child would be obscured.

A case‑by‑case approach is the cornerstone of the system, the Divorce Act and the Civil Code of Quebec when it comes to determining the best interests of the child. I think that this is essential.

We can only ensure that decision‑makers and counsel have the tools needed to receive specialized training and to recognize this type of situation or trend. They must be able to make the best possible decisions.

Of course, in light of all the evidence, I don't think that anything should be prevented.

9 a.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you. That concludes your time.

Moving to our second round of questions, we'll start with Mr. Khanna.

You have five minutes. Please go ahead.

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair, and a big thank you to the witnesses for coming today.

My questioning will be for Wayne.

How many members do you represent?

9 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

There are 1,000.

9 a.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Are they all in family law?

9 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

I believe that almost all of them are family law lawyers. Other counsel support our organization even though they're not family lawyers, I believe.

9 a.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Has your organization been part of consultations on this bill?

9 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

Yes. As far as I know, we're the only organization that polled its members on this bill before writing submissions. We've provided the detailed results of that poll. The overwhelming majority of them are opposed to this bill.

I need to point out that our members and I are proponents of protecting victims of family violence. We're not opposed to that. We're simply saying that this bill is not the right way to do it.

The right way to do it is the way they made the last changes to the Divorce Act. You start from the bottom up. You bring together a whole group of people with diverse backgrounds and as a group build legislation from the bottom up. That will work. Doing it from a single perspective is bound to fail if you don't get everyone onside at the front end.

9 a.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Since you work with provincial counterparts closely, do you have any idea what the provinces think on this? Do you know what the Alberta government thinks on this? Do you have any thoughts on their perspectives?

9 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

I am not aware of any position taken by any province with respect to this legislation. In my communications with our justice minister, it's never been brought up.

9 a.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Look, lawyers do a lot of challenging work. Obviously, they're faced with pressures—time pressures and deadlines. Even some of the best lawyers sometimes can make mistakes. In adding that extra scope of developing a family plan, do you think mistakes could happen?

9 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

People are human. Families make mistakes. Parents make mistakes. Lawyers make mistakes. I'm sure everyone sitting in this room will admit that they've made mistakes. The way to avoid mistakes is through education and understanding.

As I said, since 2021, as a result of the changes to the Divorce Act, the amount of education going on within the profession on this particular issue has been enormous.

9:05 a.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

With the way this bill is written today, do you think your members, if asked, could sufficiently do a family plan today that would assess the risks and dangers to the child?

9:05 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

If you're talking about safety planning, no, absolutely not.

I've had decades of training. I might be able to create a safety plan, but I would never do it. There are organizations—community organizations—and that's their specialty. They will know the local resources. They will be able to determine the specific needs of an individual client and tailor the safety plan for the client. Not only that, but a safety plan shouldn't be done once. It should be done on an ongoing basis.

For a lawyer like me who does only family law.... I won't touch it. What do you do about the lawyers that practise in Hanna, Alberta, or Flin Flon, Manitoba, and do three divorces a year? You cannot expect them to have the level of knowledge to create a safety plan or even to properly screen clients. The screening probably should be done by an outside organization. That's my belief.

9:05 a.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

Indirectly, do you think that by giving lawyers that extra responsibility, more children could be at risk?

9:05 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

Not only would more children be at risk, but the victims.... It's not just children. The spouse is most likely to be at significant risk.

You're also limiting access to justice, because as I said, lawyers in Flin Flon or Hanna may not have the capability of doing it, which means that people won't have a lawyer at all because a lawyer is not going to take training to do this if they only do three divorces a year.

9:05 a.m.

Conservative

Arpan Khanna Conservative Oxford, ON

That's the concern we have. Again, the intentions are good. We want to protect children and protect partners from violence, yet the practicality of it, putting responsibility on lawyers to assess something that's outside their scope, is obviously a concern for us. I think it will lead to the unintended consequence of potentially more children and more partners being put in a position where there is some violence.

Are there any major—