Good morning, everybody.
I would like to first thank Chairperson Khalid and the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights for critically reviewing the proposed amendments to the Divorce Act in Bill C-223.
As we all can agree, when parents separate, all those involved, including parents themselves, professionals such as family mediators, lawyers and especially our family courts, should and must prioritize the best interests of children. The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, in article 3, as its key principle, says the following:
The child shall enjoy special protection, and shall be given opportunities and facilities, by law and by other means, to enable [them] to develop...in a healthy and normal manner and in conditions of freedom and dignity.... [T]he best interests of the child shall be the paramount consideration.
This is Canada's only criterion in the Divorce Act, and rightly so.
Thus, upholding these basic rights to have supportive and loving relationships with their families, including extended families, is paramount to their healthy development.
I would like to mention that I'm neither a therapist nor a counsellor, but I have had decades of research experience and expertise in parenting, fathering and parent-child relationships in various socio-cultural contexts. When families are in crisis, individuals, families, social workers and principals reach out me as a last resort to step into the family and help them move positively forward and make positive changes.
In my experience with hundreds of families, regardless of their education, income or social status, many parents do not realize that they, as parents, influence and impact their children's lives. Knowledge is power, and with a bit of information, parents can change 180°. If parents, while co-parenting together, do not fully realize their influence and impact on their children's lives and how their relationship with each other indirectly impacts their relationships with their children, what can we do when families separate and conflicts escalate? A key factor that has transformed families dramatically and may be the most far-reaching in its implications is separation and divorce.
Based on Canada's general social survey in 2011, more than half of parents, 55%, did not have written agreements on their scheduled time with their children. This means that they had to rely on the family courts to intercede and finalize parenting times and decision-making.
Consequently, when conflicts or differences of opinion arise on what really constitutes the best interests of the children and keeping them safe from physical and emotional harm, children are caught in the middle. Moreover, many children and adolescents live their developmental years in litigation, which in turn may significantly impact their lives for many years to come.
According to the 2019 Canadian health survey on children and youth, almost one in five children had experienced separation or divorce. Shockingly, only 21% of the families had equal shared parenting time. More than four in 10 children had irregular visits, remote visits or no contact at all, which is almost one in five children, with the majority of children, 87%, living with their mothers only. The non-custodial parents are most likely fathers.
However, are fathers important? For many decades since the late 1960s, scholars have consistently found that fathers, or the second parent, have a unique contribution to their children's lives. As my report stated, there are numerous studies, hundreds of thousands, that have evidenced the various ways in which fathers directly and indirectly impact children's development.
Focusing on keeping children safe from abuse is a human issue. Children and individuals in general should be protected by abusers and perpetrators, whether or not their motives are intentional or malicious. However, we all know that family violence and abuse have many faces and show themselves in many forms.
The question, and the reason we're talking today, is this: How can abuse be determined in family courts when time and resources are limited? In the last few minutes, I would like to talk about my family court case project, which is ongoing. It may shed some light on our discussions today.
My family court case project uniquely examined Ontario family court cases from 2018 to 2019. The criteria were that the cases occurred between 2018 and 2019, pre-COVID; that they took place in Ontario; that the reason for the court case was related to the children, whether it was parenting time or decision-making; and that a parent had made an allegation against the other parent.
This resulted in 288 cases, which involved 471 minor children. There were 13 forms of abuse that were coded, including coercive control and parental gatekeeping or parental alienation. There were almost 1,500 allegations or events that were coded.
Mothers accounted for 70% of those allegations. The mothers' top allegation was psychological abuse, primarily to her, whereas the fathers' top allegation was gatekeeping, at 31%. We also coded—