Evidence of meeting #42 for Justice and Human Rights in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was child.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

S. Chuang  Professor, University of Guelph, As an Individual
A. Barkauskas  President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association
Nadeau  President, Barreau du Québec
Le Grand Alary  Lawyer, Secretariat of the Order and Legal Affairs, Barreau du Québec
Laberge  Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec
Rafii  Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families
Zaccour  Director, Legal Affairs, National Association of Women and the Law
Trou  Head of Écho Institute, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale
Brien  Co-Lead on Political Affairs, Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

That concludes your time. I appreciate the enthusiasm, though. Thank you.

We are moving on to Ms. Gladu for five minutes.

Please go ahead.

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

Thank you, Chair, and thank you to all the witnesses for being here today.

I'm going to start with Professor Chuang.

I am very interested in the research you were talking about. You didn't get time to finish talking about the results and how they might inform us on this bill, so please go ahead with that.

9:05 a.m.

Professor, University of Guelph, As an Individual

Susan S. Chuang

I appreciate that. I should have spoken faster.

I was saying that when we coded for who made the first report and when, it turned out that the majority—more than half—of the mothers made the allegations first in court and 76% of the fathers mentioned the allegation of abuse in court. Mothers were also more likely to formally report to child services or to the police than were fathers, but the majority of the formal reports were not verified. After the investigation, no evidence was found.

In terms of the credibility of the evidence provided in court, judges, in the end.... That's the big thing: Did judges believe these allegations? Fewer than half of the allegations made were actually believed by judges. Out of all those allegations, the most credible allegation was only gatekeeping—restricting one parent from seeing the children, or breaches—so that became an issue.

Also, when there are allegations of abuse, in the court documents we've seen, the other parent is also claiming extreme gatekeeping or breaches of parenting time, or one parent is requesting supervised visits, which is also a barrier for a lot of people because they cost money and take time. There might be a relocation, which is another way of creating distance from the other parent.

There are many forms of parental alienation; there are other ways of doing it. Judges did not believe more than half of these claims, these allegations, so that's an issue.

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

Thank you.

We've heard a lot of witness testimony that the parental alienation measures in this bill are problematic. Are there measures in this bill that you think are worth retaining?

I'll ask that question of Wayne, first of all, and then we'll go to Valérie Laberge.

9:10 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

I believe that judges need to be educated on some of the unique characteristics of victims of family violence when it comes to being witnesses. In fact, Dr. Rachel Birnbaum and I wrote a paper on that, and you've already heard from her. There are unique characteristics. I don't think the language in the bill addresses it in the way I would address it. Raising the issue for the consideration of judges so that they're aware of it, but without limiting their discretion on how to deal with it, I think makes sense.

A lot of the aspects of this bill to raise the issue...like family violence. The current Divorce Act lists the type of family violence for consideration by the judge, but without limiting their discretion. That has gone a long way to improving justice, and I think that might be a good way of getting some of these things in front of the courts and front of mind.

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

Ms. Laberge, does the bill have any good aspects?

9:10 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

Yes. I think that Mr. Barkauskas summed it up quite well. We share exactly the same concerns in this area and we see things the same way.

That said, one section of our brief focuses on myths and stereotypes. In my opinion, this is the best improvement in this bill. However, one exception stands out. In the clause on myths and stereotypes, paragraph (e) of the bill prohibits the introduction of evidence regarding “inconsistent statements or conflicting evidence in relation to incidents of violence.” We find that this runs contrary to the rules of evidence. Once again, we strongly support the idea that the judge should hear as much evidence as possible in order to render a decision.

We believe that shedding light on these myths and stereotypes in the Divorce Act isn't a bad idea at all.

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

Thank you.

Wayne, the relocation provisions in this bill changed what was put in place in 2021. What do you think about them?

9:10 a.m.

President, Alberta Family Lawyers Association

Wayne A. Barkauskas

I can tell you, from sitting in the room while we came up with the relocation provisions in the current Divorce Act, that there was a lot of debate going back and forth. Eventually a consensus was reached after a lot of work creating the provisions that we have now.

The problem you have is that if you change it to 51%, as I understand the bill is suggesting, so that a parent has 51% time, the other parent has to prove that it would be a negative event for the child to move. You reverse the onus. Well, 51% can occur when people have fifty-fifty shared parenting but decide that on Wednesday evenings, the child is going to stay with one parent because there's an extracurricular activity. Suddenly, the entire field has shifted. That parent, because they're doing the Wednesday evenings, can now move. You've upset the balance.

That is not logical. It doesn't make sense. It's not good for the child.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you so very much.

That was almost a minute over. Come on, folks. Let's make it tighter.

Last but not least, we'll go to Monsieur Beaulieu, please, for two and a half minutes. Then we will conclude this hour.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

I'm still speaking to the Barreau du Québec representatives.

Is counsel trained to assess the risks of violence and to develop a safety plan?

9:10 a.m.

President, Barreau du Québec

Marcel-Olivier Nadeau

I can answer part of your question, Mr. Beaulieu.

Obviously, counsel must remain vigilant as part of their job. However, do they have all the skills needed to develop a plan, recognize the signs, and so on? We don't think so. We believe that this could create a false sense of safety.

A number of people, such as psychosocial workers, should be able to look at this issue. As Mr. Barkauskas said, people who specialize in this type of assessment should be able to step in. The burden shouldn't fall entirely on counsel.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Is there any risk in entrusting this task to counsel rather than to a specialized worker?

9:15 a.m.

President, Barreau du Québec

Marcel-Olivier Nadeau

I think so, for the reasons that I just provided. Counsel doesn't have all the skills. Counsel does have some. Counsel can identify certain issues and can make disclosures and referrals. Yet to go from there to thinking that counsel should be the key player—or even the only player—no, that isn't appropriate.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Is there a presumption of shared custody under Canadian law?

9:15 a.m.

President, Barreau du Québec

Marcel-Olivier Nadeau

I'll let Ms. Laberge answer that question. Her response will be more comprehensive than the one that I could provide.

9:15 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

The response is quite short. No, there isn't any presumption of shared custody under Canadian or Quebec law.

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

Okay.

What are the risks posed by the new wording when it comes to the best interests of the child and shared custody?

9:15 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

Do you have the clause on hand?

Mario Beaulieu Bloc La Pointe-de-l'Île, QC

No.

Perhaps I'll move on to another question.

9:15 a.m.

Member, Expert Group on Family Law, Barreau du Québec

Valérie Laberge

You can ask me the other question. However, as far as I recall, the clause states that there isn't any presumption of shared parenting time. That said, we know this fact. It could remain in the bill, but the matter shouldn't be taken any further.

9:15 a.m.

Lawyer, Secretariat of the Order and Legal Affairs, Barreau du Québec

Nicolas Le Grand Alary

I think that there may be some confusion regarding the proposed wording and the fact that there actually isn't any presumption. Perhaps including in the legislation that there isn't any such presumption—that it doesn't exist—serves an educational purpose. It could reassure people who mistakenly believe that the presumption does exist. However, there's something to consider regarding the wording to ensure this.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Thank you very much.

I really want to thank all of the witnesses for your testimony today. If there are any additional facts, figures or opinions that you would like to provide, please don't hesitate to send in your written submissions via our phenomenal clerk.

I'm going to suspend while we switch witnesses. Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Iqra Khalid

Welcome back, everyone.

We have with us, in this second hour of the meeting, the Canadian Centre for Men and Families, represented by Bijan Rafii, who is appearing by video conference. We also have the National Association of Women and the Law, represented by Suzanne Zaccour, director of legal affairs. Lastly, we have Regroupement des maisons pour femmes victimes de violence conjugale, represented by Elise Brien, co-lead on political affairs, and Mathilde Trou, head of the Institut Écho, both of whom are appearing by video conference.

Thank you to all of the witnesses for being here today.

We'll start with Mr. Rafii for five minutes.

Please go ahead, sir.

Bijan Rafii Executive Director, Canadian Centre for Men and Families

Madam Chair and committee members, thank you for inviting me to speak to you today.

As a child and family advocate and the executive director of the Canadian Centre for Men and Families, York region, I support families navigating high-conflict divorce, where people may often employ every tool possible to hurt their partner. We support clients and their children who are victims of all types of intimate partner violence, including parental alienation and false allegations.

I'm here to provide my insight and deep concern regarding Bill C-223, especially regarding four specific provisions of this bill.

Proposed subsection 16(3.1) of the bill intends to remove judicial discretion regarding parental alienating behaviour, assuming it is merely a manipulative tool used to deceive the courts. However, alienating behaviours are real and they harm victims and their children. This assertion is supported by a large body of peer-reviewed research, including a very recent publication by Drs. Hines and Lysova, who appeared recently. It showed that 6.3% of Canadians report their father was a victim of a mother's alienating behaviour, while 4.5% report that their mother was a victim of a father's alienating behaviour. This demonstrates that parental alienation is real, that it affects both fathers and mothers at similar rates in Canada and that this bill will hurt women as well if passed.

Proposed subsection 16(5) limits judicial discretion to evaluate intimate partner violence claims, even when evidence is lacking or victim behaviour strongly suggests otherwise. This is predicated on the assumption that intimate partner violence victims are mainly women. In reality, the 2025 survey of safety in public and private spaces by Statistics Canada indicated that men comprised exactly 50% of physical intimate partner violence victims in the past year and 48% of emotional abuse victims during the same period. Furthermore, a study by Drs. Lysova and Hines, which is currently submitted for publication, found that 11% of Canadians knew a man who was falsely accused of spousal abuse, compared to 1% for women, and 9% knew a man who was falsely accused of child abuse, compared to 3% for women. Not only will stripping judges of the ability to properly evaluate these allegations be unjust to these victims; it will only increase conflict between divorcing parents.

Proposed subsection 16.93(1) makes it too easy for a custodial parent to relocate, which can have devastating consequences for children by severing the bond with a loving parent. Children who unnecessarily lose meaningful contact with a parent—that usually means a father—are four times more likely to attempt suicide, two to eight times more likely to commit a crime and be incarcerated, five times more likely to commit rape, three times more likely to have drug addictions, eight times more likely to become pregnant as a teen and twice as likely to drop out of high school.

We must ensure that abuse allegations are real to prevent the justice system from becoming an instrument of revenge and, ultimately, hurting our children.

Proposed subsection 16(6) limits the presumption of equal parenting time and responsibility, contradicting the latest trend in international family law and best practices. In fact, implementing a rebuttable presumption of equal shared co-parenting in the absence of abuse and neglect is the only proven method to reduce intimate partner violence. It lowered intimate partner violence incidence by 45% in Spain and 70% in Kentucky—there is a chart below my notes—after the introduction of equal parenting legislation in these jurisdictions. Equal parenting legislation also reduced intimate partner homicide in Spain by 8% in a very short period. This subsection takes us backward.

This bill will neither make children safe, nor reduce rates of intimate partner violence. It will instead increase conflict. In the best interests of our children, my request to the committee is to please focus on data and peer-reviewed research, not stories, emotions or outdated stereotypes. The stakes are too high.

Thank you.